Located in:
- Unemployment Insurance (UI)
The Jobs for Veterans’ State Grants (JVSG) are mandatory, formula-based staffing grants to (including DC, PR, VI and Guam). The JVSG is funded annually in accordance with a funding formula defined in the statute (38 U.S.C. 4102A (c) (2) (B) and regulation and operates on a fiscal year (not program year) basis, however, performance metrics are collected and reported (VETS-200 Series Reports) quarterly (using four “rolling quarters”) on a Program Year basis (as with the ETA- 9002 Series). Currently, VETS JVSG operates on a five-year (FY 2015-2019), multi-year grant approval cycle modified and funded annually.
In accordance with 38 U.S.C. § 4102A(b)(5) and § 4102A(c), the Assistant Secretary for Veterans' Employment and Training (ASVET) makes grant funds available for use in each State to support Disabled Veterans' Outreach Program (DVOP) specialists and Local Veterans' Employment Representatives (LVER) staff. As a condition to receive funding, 38 U.S.C. § 4102A(c)(2) requires States to submit an application for a grant that contains a State Plan narrative, which includes:
- a. Contents of a Complete Ui Sqsp Package
A complete UI SQSP package includes the following documents, as described in Chapter 1, ETA Handbook 336, 18th Edition:
- a. Contents of a Complete Ui Sqsp Package
a. 3. The State Plan Narrative
The State Plan Narrative is a vital element of the SQSP that provides a vehicle for sharing with the Federal partner State-specific efforts that affect the administration of the UI Program. The State Plan Narrative allows the State to describe in a single narrative: a) State performance in comparison to the Government Performance Review Act goals; b) actions planned to correct deficiencies regarding UI programs, UI program reviews and reporting requirements; and c) results of customer satisfaction surveys (optional).
Current Narrative:
In FY2016, agency–wide focus will be on the improvement of performance metrics. Across all levels, staff performance is being measured against state scores for the UI Core Measures and the Secretary’s Standards. Every manager is managing to and being measured against a group of measures that are consolidated into our Customer Service Metrics. The measures included are First Payment Promptness, Nonmonetary Determination Timeliness, Nonmonetary Determination Quality and Lower and Higher Appeals Aging. They are also managing to and being measured against our Employer Service Metrics that include: New Employer Time Lapse, Tax Quality and Effective Audit Measures. Both the Customer Service Metrics and the Employer Service Metrics are in line with the DOL priorities for FY2016. In all of our “at risk” areas, we are focusing on process improvements, system fixes and staff training that will directly impact our ability to meet the acceptable levels of performance.
Already, we have seen significant improvement in our backlog of ready to work issues due to system improvements that consolidate issues into singular fact–finding and enhancements that ease the online filing process for claimants. These changes significantly improved our Timely First Payment metric along with our Lower Authority Appeals Timeliness. In FY2016, we hope to meet the acceptable levels of performance for both of these standards. National Priorities: Improving State Capacity to Administer and Operate the UI Program Effectively:
Administering and operating the UI program effectively is a main concern for Massachusetts. Since April of 2010, MA has been rated at risk by the US Department of Labor due to its consistent and significant failure to meet first payment timeliness standards. The fact that this designation was the result of many years of declining performance along with beginning the process of implementing a new and automated UI system forms the basis for future program enhancement. Although only being in the position for four months, unemployment insurance director Rob Cunningham is committed to returning Massachusetts to a national top performer.
In recent years our inability to effectively process UI claims in a timely manner has been the result of circumstances relating to the great recession, staff turnover and training capabilities, decreased funding opportunities, and implementation of a new UI system. In effect, since 2008 MA has administered the program using a 30–year–old legacy system while trying to implement new technologies that rise to the level of required performance and expectations. In the past MDUA has used many strategies to correct our lack of performance in this area. These efforts include an independent business analysis by Coffey Associates, internal program workgroups, engaging stakeholders, and partnering with other state UI Agencies. Moving forward in the FY16 SQSP cycle, MA would like to take the results of these experiences and the retirement of the legacy system to turn it into actionable program goals.
The first and most important change for the upcoming year will result in MDUA realigning its resources to ensure program goals are achieved. The first step was to develop a matrix of performance standards and assigning responsibility to the individual business units. The matrix will be monitored at the highest level in the organization to ensure that it consistently is a top priority. To date the matrix includes all USDOL secretary standards and UI Core measures. To drive success, DUA has realigned staff to focus on these measures. In addition, MDUA will be centralizing the monitoring of the matrix while keeping the responsibility of performance within the individual business units.
Improving Prevention, Detection and Recovery of UI Improper Payments
Massachusetts has embarked on an aggressive plan to lower the states improper payment rate for the UI program. This plan includes bringing in new experienced leadership at the highest level to coordinate our systems approach to improving prevention, detection, and recovery of improper payments. According to our analysis, the top three reasons of improper payments in MA are benefit year earnings at 43%, worksearch 25%, and separation issues are 10% of total overpayments. 78% of all improper payments are attributable to these three causes. Massachusetts continues to investigate any area that potentially creates an improper payment; however, keeping in mind that a large percentage of the improper payments are from three causes, analysis has focused on making system and business process enhancements that will drive our improper payment rate down. For example, our analysis of benefit year earnings shows that enhancements to the continued claims process can simplify the process for claimants to self–certify that they worked and earned wages. This enhancement will dramatically increase a claimant’s ability to self–report earnings accurately. The Benefit Payment Accuracy unit has taken an aggressive action in use of the NDNH cross match program. MDUA has also been working on the implementation of the treasury offset program which will start on 8–03–2015. MA will continue to engage stakeholders, USDOL, partner states, and the UI Center for Excellence in its endeavors to reduce, detect, and recover improper payments. The NDNH cross–match is being improved in FY16 to make it more efficient and a more effective tool to reduce BYE improper payments. The current process, while an improvement over prior years, remains highly manual and less effective than initially intended.
Improving Program Performance
Since the implementation of UI Online two years ago DUA has delivered ongoing staff development to promote the familiarization of the new system for system users. Some of the newest training strategies implemented include:
• Expanding the initial claims process to include a full day of hands on system training where staff file and adjudicate claims in a test environment, in addition to another day of classroom training. This expanded training was delivered to approximately 100 staff in 10 sessions with an additional 11 days spent delivering individualized training to 9 staff • Provided Initial Adjudication Training to 120 managers, adjudicators and review examiners in four three week training sessions • Provided Refresher Training to over 300 staff in 12 sessions for adjudicators and adjudication managers, in multiple office locations • Provided UI Online User Training to over 300 DUA/DCS personnel • Provided Customer Service Training to over 300 DUA personnel in 84 half day sessions covering 6 targeted topics designed to assist customers with navigation of the new system • Secured BTQ Certification Training that was delivered to 25 adjudication staff by regional DOL staff
DUA continues to identify system inefficiencies in its UI Online system, which is a web–based, self–service system that allows claimants to file an initial, continued or additional claim online. The system was designed to send fact finding and other requests for information to claimants and employers to streamline and allow more automation to the UI process. At the request of DOL we have modified the use of fact finding questionnaires so only questionnaires pertaining to interested party employers are sent to claimants; all base period employers continue to receive fact finding questionnaires to ensure proper charging and to reduce improper payment of benefits. We have also implemented a system enhancement to bundle all ready to work issues for individual claimants to insure the prompt resolution of outstanding issues by one adjudicator.
DUA has contracted with a readability vendor to review and revise over 500 fact finding questionnaires to improve user comprehension. Prior to vendor submission, we solicited feedback from employers, claimant advocates and DUA staff to ensure a comprehensive review process. Currently, over 100 of the revised questionnaires have been put into production. In FY16 we will complete this project, although DUA expects ongoing review of readability throughout the system.
DUA has made great strides in improving accessibility to UI Online for the Limited English Proficiency customers. We have provided designated customer service lines in Spanish and Portuguese, translated non–monetary determinations for Spanish speaking claimants, developed fact finding coversheets which direct LEP customers to service in 11 languages if needed in the completion of fact finding questionnaires and provide assistance in the completion of fact finding questionnaires in 11 different languages.
Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act (WIOA)
Under the WIOA Act, the Unemployment Insurance (UI) program and the related other federal workforce functions are expanded and enhanced. The integration of programs that provide services to those likely to exhaust unemployment insurance and return them to suitable employment mandate changes in roles of the DUA.
Working under the leadership and direction of the Executive Office of Labor and Workforce Development (EOLWD) in conjunction with other secretariats and their agencies, DUA will develop and build the wage matching systems that require the use of confidential UI employment and wage information to supply ETA with the WIOA reporting requirements on the full range of reemployment programs. To identify those receiving a first payment for UI and likely to exhaust during FY2016, DUA will utilize a model that incorporates historical and current information on those who received UI and related services. The outcomes and characteristics of those who participated in Profiling, Reemployment Assistance, and other mandatory employment and training referral services will be evaluated to better identify demographic information that is now available from the UI Online system. We will utilize information related to coordinated programs that provide employment and training services to better identify the likelihood of reemployment than the current screening mechanism.
DUA has partnered with the department of Career Services (DCS) to implement the Reemployment Services and Eligibility Assessment (RESEA) program. Step one of this expanded services program was implemented this year and step two will occur in January 2016. By developing and using a re–employment model that closely monitors program outcomes, changes in demographics, and industry structures, DUA will improve the referral rates of UI claimants. Our goal is to develop a more streamlined delivery of services and information to employers, training providers and those seeking work in Massachusetts.
DUA continues to partner with the DCS Rapid Response team on WorkShare (DUA’s short term compensation program) education to employers. DUA will further develop this partnership through training sessions for Rapid Response staff who, in turn, will provide one on one and group WorkShare training sessions with Massachusetts employers. DUA will emphasize WorkShare as a way to keep skilled workers employed by companies during slow periods as well as a potential temporary increase to cash flow. To streamline the application process employers have the ability to submit their WorkShare application through the UI Online system.
Massachusetts is unique in that there is still a strong UI presence in the Career Centers and walk–in sites. Customers are provided with direct access to UI customer assistance as DUA provides funding to DCS for staff in most of the state’s twenty seven Career Centers.
Reemployment of UI Claimants
Massachusetts transitioned from a REA to a RESEA state beginning in April 2015. DCS will continue to implement our program model for UI claimants which has always leveraged RES with Reemployment Eligibility Assessment (REA) components as part of the mandatory program requirements.
The MA Workforce System comprises 16 Workforce Investment Areas with 27 One–Stop Career Center (American Job Center – AJC) locations. DCS will continue to implement the Reemployment Services and Eligibility Assessment (RESEA) Grant (formerly Reemployment Eligibility Assessment – REA) as a statewide program. Operating the grant as a statewide effort reinforces the ETA’s vision of a fully integrated and interconnected workforce system. DUA and DCS will continue to partner on the operation and management of this program. We have elected to transition to a multiple RESEA model and changes have been made with respect to the selection of the participant and comparison groups, sanctions for non–participation, and mandatory activities for RESEA participants.
DUA management and staff have been fully engaged in the development, planning, administration, and oversight of the RESEA Program since its inception. Periodic meetings have been held with DCS and DUA staff to plan, adjust and address issues through the year. Some of the major changes agreed to in this year’s grant include:
• inclusion of UCX claimants, • the elimination of the RESEA control and WPRS group from the sampling process, • those selected for WPRS will be absorbed into the RESEA enrollment group, • broader use of technology to induce program participation, • and the strengthening of participation requirements. DCS continues to work on two on–going projects to enhance resources and support staff and claimants participating in RESEA. The first project is a real–time triage process for new UI claimants and the second is strengthening skills for job matching through the effective use of Labor Market Information (LMI).
The use of Labor Market Information is geared towards identifying and targeting demand driven job opportunities, which is consistent with the direction outlined in the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act (WIOA). In fact, starting on August 24, 2015, Assistant Secretary for Policy and Planning, Greg Bunn, will be charged with the responsibility of building the best LMI system in the country. LMI specialists continue to work with Career Center staff through training and use of projected and real–time LMI data. Staff incorporates this information when assisting UI claimants in their job search efforts. Continued emphasis will be placed on the use of LMI for resume preparation and review of work search logs to ensure that RESEA participants are conducting a focused work search informed by labor market information.
The RESEA grant is an integral part of Massachusetts reemployment services strategy for UI claimants. By continuing to integrate RES with activities such as UI eligibility assessments and work search reviews, DCS ensures that each RESEA participant has access to the full menu of individualized services offered by the One–Stop Career Centers. This decreases the amount of time it takes for the RESEA customer to return to work.
It is the goal of DCS to complete 59,500 on–site, one–on–one Reemployment Services and Eligibility Assessments on a nine (9) month basis. All RESEA customers will receive specific mandated reemployment services, which are to be provided by Career Center staff (funded through this RESEA grant) in addition to an initial one–on–one reemployment and UI eligibility assessment. During this meeting, the RESEA customer will be scheduled for a subsequent RESEA one–on–one reemployment and UI eligibility status review. This status review will also be conducted by a Career Center (RESEA funded) RESEA Specialist.
If either review uncovers a potential UI eligibility issue such as failure to report or to fully participate in all components of RESEA the customer will be referred to a UI RESEA Specialist to complete additional fact finding. The UI RESEA specialist will conduct the follow–up fact–finding interview and if necessary refer to UI adjudication for a final determination.
Addressing Worker Misclassification
The Massachusetts Department of Unemployment Assistance (DUA) has taken worker misclassification very seriously. A majority of DUA audits are based on employers in which we expect to find misclassification. From 2012 to 2014 DUA has averaged a total of 5,100 newly discovered workers per year; which is an average of 5.34 misclassified workers per audit. DUA uses a fraud detection database, AWARE, (Aggregate Workforce Analytics Reporting Engine) which allows us to perform cross–matches against other participating state or federal agencies information including the IRS’ 1099 information. DUA also gets direct referrals from the IRS regarding employer misclassification (SS–8’s.) These referrals are reviewed by audit management and assigned to staff for follow up audits if they believe there is a reasonable chance misclassification will be uncovered. DUA also reviews outside agency information outside of AWARE, including liquor license transfers, Lottery winners and, hopefully soon, Registry of Motor Vehicle renewals.
DUA regularly attends monthly meetings as a member of the Council on the Underground Economy (CUE). The group’s sole purpose is to uncover and address employee misclassification throughout the state. During these meetings DUA gets referrals of possible misclassification from other agencies including the Alcohol Beverage and Control Commission (ABCC), Insurance Fraud Bureau, OSHA, and Labor Standards. As part of these monthly meetings, the DUA participates in surprise site visits, usually to new construction projects, to uncover and educate employers and general contractors regarding misclassification. DUA continues to audit cases where businesses have claimants who file unemployment claims with 1099 wages. DUA keeps tabs on past employer audits for noticeable changes in their Employment and Wage filing for possible follow–up audits.
In FY16, we expect to continue the good work DUA has done, and become more efficient in uncovering these misclassifications.
B. FEDERAL EMPHASIS (GPRA GOALS)
Make timely benefit payments (Strategic Goal 4)
Target: 87.5 percent of intrastate first payments for full weeks of unemployment compensation will be made within 21 days from the week ending date of the first compensable week.
The high claims volume from a protracted winter resulted in the redeployment of Call Center Adjudication staff in order to provide acceptable service levels to customers filing claims through the end of the first calendar Quarter of 2015. This procedure was minimized during the second quarter when the clear realization that the continued deployment of Adjudication staff severely impacted the timely first payment of claims. In April we were able to begin to reduce the backlog and work with a focus on minimizing call volume. Backlog of ready to work issues was over 50,000 in March and plummeted to 4,778 during the last week of June. The first week in July saw a slight increase and, currently (7/16/2015) the ready to work count is at 6857. We are now focusing on the improvement of timely first payments and hope to be current (under 4,000 consistently) by the end of the current quarter of the September 30, 2015. This should enable us to achieve our CAP projection for the period ending September 30, 2015. Recent weeks have seen nearly two thirds of our customers filing new claims using the web–based application. Two years into the new system, ease of filing for claimants, employers and TPA’s has begun to take hold and positively impact our ability to improve in the area of first payments, and multiple surveys of users demonstrate both claimants and employers are largely satisfied with UI Online. DUA remains committed to ensuring adjudication staff spends their time addressing fact finding questions and adjudicating issues, rather than answering claims filing calls except in unusual circumstances.
DUA has embarked upon a Call Volume Reduction Project to further enhance the usability of the web–based system and identify those areas where the customer service aspects of UI Online need enhancement. This project, with a completion goal of early 2016, is focusing on some updates including a better online FAQ section, an enhanced monetary screen, simplified User password setup and an overall homepage review to further depress call volume by ensuring the best service possible online.
Expansion of access to assistance for fact–finding for Limited English Proficiency is intended to avoid delays in first payments for those claimants. Coupling this service in 11 languages with the readability project reviewing and updating hundreds of questionnaires, DUA continues to remain committed to achieving our timely first payment goals.
While the 21 Day Timely First Payment report for the current quarter ending was finalized at 62.37% , significant gains have been made with aforementioned backlog reduction effort as evidenced by the last four weekly TFP rates at 84.7 (w–e 7–11), 81.4% (w–e 7–4), 77.57% (w–e 6–27) and 76.24% (w–e 6–20). These weekly rates are clearly 20 percentage points higher than one year ago at this time. This is related to the dramatic reduction of ready to work issues during the past quarter. Ready–to–work issue backlog stood at 4778 for COB on 6–26–15. This was the culmination of the issue reduction effort which kept adjudicators off the phones for 90% of the preceding workweeks. The chart below demonstrates the reduction in our total number of issues (workload credit and non–workload credit issues):
Ready–to Work Queue Trending Date All Ready Workflow Queue 5/28/2014 81,923 7/3/2014 80,028 7/14/2014 41,691 2/27/2015 47,486 3/3/2015 50,452 3/20/2015 43,154 4/4/2015 35,874 4/18/2015 30,122 5/13/2015 21,598 5/30/2015 15,704 6/11/2015 9,755 6/19/2015 6,180 7/9/2015 7,130 7/16/2015 6,857
Significant gains have been made within the last the last four months relative to Issue Time Lapse. Current Time Lapse (resolved within 21 days of detection) for the final week reported for the quarter (6–27–15) was 42.55 % for Separation Determinations and 67.17% for Non–Separation Determinations. This is a major improvement over the quarter where these rates began at 5.18% for Separations and 21.73% for Non–Separation time Lapse. This is a 300% + improvement in these rates over the quarter.
a. SHORT–TERM MEASURES (45 to 90 days)
As staff develop more familiarity with UI Online due to usage and training, the productivity data becomes more relevant. As such, DUA continues to monitor adjudication productivity to leverage in staffing standards. We expect the productivity to continue to improve as we continue to enhance the system and business processes, focused on achieving our timeliness and accuracy goals.
? Adjudication staff have been instructed to immediately make phone calls on all additional/rebuttal fact–finding in order to expedite the issue resolution process. This will be coupled with additional refresher training for staff in the area of rebuttals in order to improve both quality and timeliness.
? DUA is reviewing the current predate process from both a customer and staff viewpoint with a clear focus on policy adherence and the identification of system/process modifications that will positively impact our ability to improve timely first payments for predated claims, as well as minimize Customer Assistance calls.
? DUA has made the Fact–Finding queue an option from the main telephone menu so claimants can access adjudication staff to assist them in the completion of outstanding fact finding. In addition, accessibility has been further enhanced for Limited English Proficiency customers with Fact–finding cover sheets which direct LEP customers to Fact–Finding assistance in11 languages if needed in the completion of the questionnaires. This process was implemented for the current quarter (July 2015) and potential enhancements will be analyzed. Issues with completed fact finding will then be assigned for resolution in a more timely manner.
Detect Benefit Overpayments (Strategic Goal 4)
Target: Overpayments established will be at least 55.3 percent of the estimated detectable, recoverable overpayments.
Massachusetts currently falls below acceptable levels of performance in the percentage of detectable/recoverable overpayments established for recovery. UI Online has been very helpful in improving the detection and prevention of overpayments. Some of our business processes that are showing equal improvement are:
• the OnPoint Technology AWARE system to prevent and detect fraud claims and fraud schemes. Some of the cross matches DUA uses through AWARE include: Out–of–country cross–match to identify online weekly certifications from IP addresses outside of the U.S and its territories, and • the Identification of Commonalities cross–match that checks bank accounts, home addresses, email addresses and security questions and answers, and • known fraudulent banking methods
DUA has used SBR funding to supplement our existing cross–match menu with new fraud preventative cross–matches, including cross–matches for deceased claimants and business owners/officers who receive UI benefits while the corporate entity is still in operation. We have also added scripts designed specifically to prevent fraud schemes, based on identifying characteristics we have gleaned from prior fraud attempts. This has proven to be very effective and we continue to evaluate for more potential prevention efforts.
As part of the DUA–wide realignment, Program Integrity has recently been moved to report to the Chief of Staff to increase its visibility within the agency, and ensure a renewed focus on PI for DUA. The unit continues to take a proactive role in the Massachusetts Joint Task Force in the Underground Economy which identifies improperly classified workers and unregistered employers conducting business on a cash basis. The Task Force allows Program Integrity staff to work in conjunction with other state agencies on possible fraudulent unemployment claims. A recent SBR request resulted in additional funding to increase staffing and our ability to run queries to detect overpaid benefits, review cases and prosecute fraudsters.
We have gained access to the CJIS system (Criminal Justice Information System) which has allowed DUA Program Integrity Investigators the ability to crosscheck identification documents provided by criminals to establish fraudulent claims. We also access the data base at the Massachusetts Registry of Motor Vehicles but the CJIS system has provided DUA faster access to identity information, allowing for more effective investigations.
After skipping a year due to the implementation of UI Online, DUA resumed state tax intercept in 2015, which brought in more than $3M to the DUA UI Trust Fund in the first quarter of 2015.
Massachusetts is scheduled to launch the Treasury Offset Program (TOP) August 3, 2015. By expanding our overpayment recovery capacity to include the intercept of federal tax returns, we anticipate increasing the recovery of overpayments via tax offset by 300%.
Establish Tax Accounts Promptly (Strategic Goal 4)
Target: 89.0 percent of status determinations for new employers will be made within 90 days of the end of the first quarter in which liability occurred.
Massachusetts has failed to reach the target of 89% of new employer status determinations resolved within 90 days of the first quarter in which liability occurred largely due to employers failing to register in a timely manner. We have implemented several strategies designed to prompt employers to register with DUA and begin paying contributions when they are due. DUA is currently at 84%, and passed the recent TPS review for “New Employers” for the first time since 2009. DUA has begun assessing penalties on employers who fail to file timely quarterly contributions. These penalties range from $25 dollars to $2,500 dollars depending on the number of employees:
Year – Quarter Number of Employers Penalty Amount 2015–1 22,282 $740,852.37 2014–4 20,739 $666,112.39 2014–3 22,960 $705,906.88
In addition DUA utilizes the following cross–matches with other state agencies to obtain information on possible employers subject to registration:
• Newly registered corporations (and LLC’s) from the Secretary of State’s office • All new and transferred liquor licenses issued by the Alcoholic Beverage Control Commission • Corporations with active licenses from the Department of Licensure • Quarterly reviews to identify employers that have filed withholding tax with the Department of Revenue, but are not registered with DUA • DUA has an agreement with the Massachusetts Lottery Commission to cross reference the list of current lottery vendors to verify registration as an active employer if subjectivity applies DUA is currently in the final steps of an agreement with the Massachusetts Registry of Motor Vehicles to begin cross–referencing the list of current businesses holding commercial license plates to verify registration of an active employer if subjectivity applies. A new law in Massachusetts effective in 2016 requires businesses to present a certificate of good standing from DUA if an employer who wants to engage in business with any other MA state entity for goods or services over $5,000 which we believe with increase employer registration. We continue to work with the business community to raise employer awareness of the obligation to register with DUA as subject employer through mailing campaigns to area Chambers of Commerce, Workforce Investment Boards and employer union groups. We believe these efforts will increase employer awareness and prompt employer registrations.
i. FACILITATE CLAIMANT REEMPLOYMENT (STRATEGIC GOAL 4) Target: TBD
Massachusetts transitioned from a REA to a RESEA state beginning in April 2015. DCS will continue to implement our program model for UI claimants which has always leveraged RES with Reemployment Eligibility Assessment (REA) components as part of the mandatory program requirements.
The MA Workforce System comprises 16 Workforce Investment Areas with 27 One–Stop Career Center (American Job Center – AJC) locations. DCS will continue to implement the Reemployment Services and Eligibility Assessment (RESEA) Grant (formerly Reemployment Eligibility Assessment – REA) as a statewide program. Operating the grant as a statewide effort reinforces the ETA’s vision of a fully integrated and interconnected workforce system. DUA and DCS will continue to partner on the operation and management of this program. We have elected to transition to a multiple RESEA model and changes have been made with respect to the selection of the participant and comparison groups, sanctions for non–participation, and mandatory activities for RESEA participants.
The Career Center Seminar (CCS) is a comprehensive introduction to the services available at the Commonwealth’s 27 Career Centers and is mandatory for all REA and Profiled UI claimants. UI claimants not selected for enrollment in REA or Profiling are still required to attend a Career Center Seminar. All REA customers receive specific mandated reemployment services including a skills assessment and completion of a Career Action Plan (CAP), participation in workshops on resume preparation and interviewing, and introduction to on–line resources for job search. Job counselors at the Career Centers review work search logs to guide UI claimants and to ensure compliance with benefit requirements.
As you know, no target goals have been set for FY 2016. The Department suspended the GPRA target for FY 2015 to develop a measure that integrates UI more closely with the larger workforce system. Under WIOA, MA follows common measures, which includes common exit for WIOA Title I, Wagner–Peyser and TAA participants. This means customers are exited from all programs 90 days after their last reportable service. RESEA follows the same action. This differs from the programmatic processes that track individualized services while enrolled in a specific program.
C. Program Deficiencies
i. EFFECTIVE AUDIT MEASURES
One of the major reasons that the effective audit measure did not pass in 2013 was due to inadequate staffing. DUA failed the Effective Audit Measure by not reaching the 1% penetration rate as required by DOL, completing 867 of the required 1,900 audits. In addition, DUA also failed to meet the overall amount of wages required for audit purposes, this is a direct correlation to failing to complete the required amount of audits. Due to aggressive measures to increase staffing levels since 2013, audit staff levels have gone from 13 field auditors in August of 2013 to 22 full time auditors. Management of the unit also has had excessive turnover in the past, but has now had the same management team in place for over a year.
In addition to having an expanded Performs unit DUA recently requested and was approved additional funding to begin the process of streamlining the audit package which would allow audit staff to close cases quicker and would help drive the effort to meet the 1% penetration rate. Staff has had to complete manual duplicative processes to ensure the integrity of the data in our system. Streamlining this package will allow staff to complete audits in less time, and should increase their overall production to help DUA meet the required penetration rate.
For 2015 DUA will be required to complete 2,010 audits for the entire year. Through June of 2015, DUA has already completed 50.2% of that goal (1,010 audits) which is approximately the total number of audits completed for the entire year of 2014. With the increased audits DUA is still finding 3.5 misclassified workers per audit. DUA is on pace to pass all Effective Audit Measures as required by the DOL for 2015 and will likely continue to pass in FY2016 also.
ii. DETECTION DATE AND DETERMINATION DATE ACCURACY
Invalid Recording of Issue Detection Date and Determination Date In the last four completed BTQ quarters MDUA reported average valid detection dates for 90.83 percent of separations and 85.12 percent of non–separation issues Massachusetts remains committed to achieving a 95 percent accuracy rate in establishing correct issue detection dates. Initial analysis showed that the system was the cause of incorrect recording of a significant number of detection dates. Enhancements were made to the system to resolve these issues; however, it has had minimal impact in increasing the Agency’s accuracy. DUA will engage in additional analysis to determine cause, responsibility, and additional trends that affect the Agency’s ability to meet correct issue detection date goal in order to take additional action remedying errors. In the last four completed BTQ quarters, MDUA reported average valid determination dates for 90.83 percent of non–separation determinations and 85.12 percent for separation determinations. This is slightly higher than a 20 percent increase in accuracy of determination dates. This increase is attributable to enhancements to the system to ensure accuracy of the data. As with issue detection dates, MA is committed to achieving a determination date accuracy rate of at least 95 percent of the evaluated nonmonetary determinations in each quarterly review. To work to this goal, MDUA will begin additional analysis of determination date errors to identify cause, responsibility, and additional trends that affect the Agency’s ability to meet the correct the issue determination date goal and to take additional action remedying errors.
iii. BENEFIT ACCURACY MEASUREMENT (BAM) DEFICIENCIES
The Benefits Accuracy Measurement deficiencies identified by the Regional Office include wide variances between the sum of Monetary Denied Claims Accuracy (DCA) weekly universe counts and reporting of Monetary Denied claims on ETA reports. BAM also was deficient in meeting the ninety–day Paid Claims Accuracy (PCA) federal requirement of ninety–five percent. Federal BAM program guidance requires the sample universes to be selected from the same data that is later reported through monthly and quarterly ETA reports. Comparison of the BAM Universe and ETA report is expected to result in a discrepancy of no more than ±15 %; however, comparison of Massachusetts CY2014 data shows a discrepancy rate of 45.1%. Investigation into the discrepancy showed there were systemic and synchronicity issues in the processing of UI claims for EUC extension eligibility that resulted in monetary denials for new claims to be included in the BAM universe but excluded from the UIRR report(s). The discrepancy was further impacted by programming necessary to accommodate Massachusetts policy that allows a set of claimants to elect to move back and forth from regular UI to EUC Tiers and to decline a new monetarily eligible claim and return to the extension on a prior claim. Investigation as to other causes that may have affected the discrepancy percentage continues; however, it is expected more recent data will reflect a decline in the discrepancy. The Benefits Accuracy Measurement (BAM) program was placed on a CAP for the 2014 SQSP year due to the failure to complete 95% of Paid Claim Accuracy (PCA) cases within the 90–day threshold; the Massachusetts 90– day completion rate was 93.4%. Because the 2015 SQSP was written prior to completion of the 2014 SQSP year, this goal was continued on the 2015 SQSP. BAM actually met the goal for the 2014 SQSP year with a 96.03% completion rate and the 2014 BAM year with a 95.98% completion rate. The BAM unit has complied with the 95% completion rate, beginning third quarter 2013 and has maintained this rate in all but one subsequent quarter. To achieve this, the Massachusetts BAM Operational Handbook was rewritten and continues to be updated to reflect MA legislative and Agency policy change, form changes, and new protocols for working with business units, claimants, and employers. Staff receives continuous training on best practices and computer skills that will add to their success in meeting timely completions. Staff is encouraged to self–monitor the timeliness of their casework. Management stays attentive of BAM cases considered at risk for not meeting the 90–day completion date in order to take action in a timely manner and work with investigators to meet their goals. Management reviews the status of PCA timeliness for all core measures three times per week and will meet with individual investigators to aid in completion. iv. DATA VALIDATION DEFICIENCIES The Benefits Data Validation (BDV) deficiency identified by the Regional Office was a failure to implement the BDV program and failure to submit populations and modules as required of the program into the SUN system. DUA failed to complete required reporting for Benefits Data Validation while transitioning into the new UI Online system. Further delay occurred due to the MA DUA initiative to build a Data Warehouse for reporting purposes. The two–year SQSP milestones for BDV were to develop Module 3, develop the files necessary to perform DV of populations and modules, and analysis of data to ensure error resolution within the files. File development was completed for all modules and populations. Analysis was completed; however, this is an iterative process. It requires analysis to identify file errors, loading files into SUN to identify additional errors, and coding fixes to the files in the Data Warehouse repetitively until all errors are identified and removed.
In FFY15 Benefits Module 3 was rewritten and published in the SUN; however, MADUA staff failed to return to the SUN to certify the module during the window of opportunity that ETA makes the certification screen available. Milestones for the development of population and module files were accomplished. The population and module files were created and analyzed for accuracy as well as loaded into the SUN for the system to identify file errors. MA DUA was able to successfully develop files, test files, test files in the SUN, resolve file errors, and complete Data Validation for modules and 14 out of 16 populations. Populations 14 and 15 were not submitted due to the significant number of errors within the population files that caused the SUN to reject the files. These population files will be addressed during the continuation of analysis of all population files for error identification and error resolution.
MA DUA failed a significant number of populations. This is indicative of errors within the population files and potentially ETA reports. In FFY16 MA DUA will devote resources to the continuation of analyzing file errors and file fixes to ensure accuracy of population and module files. The outcome of file accuracy should be representative in BDV 2016 through an increase in passing populations.
It has been known that the check marks on the milestone grid are placed erroneously, as well as the fact there is a typing error in identification of populations. MA DUA submitted a document with milestones correctly placed for this CAP. Upon return to DUA, the checkmarks were not in the same array. It is unclear how or when this occurred. It was determined that no changes would be made to ensure the integrity of the document but understood that DUA would work towards the milestone deadlines as prescribed originally. Inasmuch as MA DUA made progress in resolving this CAP on a quarterly basis and in fact, has met or exceeded milestones, MA DUA has modified the milestone checkmarks in the CAP. In addition, it was understood that population “31” represented population “3a” and was a typographical error. This has been corrected.
TAX DATA VALIDATION DEFICIENCIES All Tax Data Validation (TDV) populations and required modules were submitted in the 2015 DV year. To make this happen, a staff member with strong technical skills was utilized to assist with the process of manually manipulating the Tax DV extract files to allow submission into the system. Tax DV substantially failed in the 2015 TDV year. Defects in UI Online have been identified that when corrected, will reduce the failure rate in populations. Errors within the population and module files, while identified, will not be fixed. Instead, TDV population and module files are being rebuilt inside the MA DUA Data Warehouse that drives the source for all MADUA reporting. TDV Data Warehouse development began in August 2015 and is expected to be ready for implementation in May 2016. Because the DV year ends June 10th each year it will not be possible to implement files generated from the Data Warehouse for the 2016 TDV year. MA DUA will address UI Online defects and enhancements and manually modify module and population files for SUN usability to ensure 2016 TDV submission.
D. Reporting Requirements
i. REPORTING DEFICIENCIES MA DUA’s timely reporting of UI required weekly, monthly and quarterly reports has improved significantly and the Agency continues to work toward 100% timely submission. In FFY14, the Agency maintained an average of 19 late report filings per month. The average has now been reduced to 2 late filings per month. The Massachusetts Data Warehouse has greatly improved the Agency’s ability to report in a timely fashion; data is now compiled through queries that are run on a prescribed schedule and data is accessible to business owners for validation prior to transmission. This accessibility grants business owners greater knowledge of their units(s) performance levels and the ability to manage from valid statistical information. DUA has continued its internal procedure of reviewing requests for changes and additions to reports through its Change Control Board to work towards 100% timely submission of UIRR. It is expected that the Agency will meet 100% timeliness submission before the end of this biennial SQSP. The following graphs illustrate the number of “Late Sent” reports on a monthly basis and demonstrate the drastic improvements that have been made in the agency’s timely reporting during the last two years.
F. ASSURANCES
The State Administrator, by signing the SQSP Signature Page, certifies that the state will comply with assurances as outlined in ET Handbook 336, 18th Edition: Unemployment Insurance (UI) State Quality Service Plan (SQSP) Planning and Reporting Guidelines, Chapter 1, Part VII: Assurances.
i. Assurance of Contingency Planning In 2012 an independent consultant was engaged to modify the IT Contingency Plan. This modification took into account the changes to contingency planning with the new system architecture. This work was completed in June of 2012. This plan is reviewed and updated to reflect system modifications and personnel changes; the most recent update was in July 2015.
ii. Assurance of Automated Information Systems Security
In 2011, an independent consultant was engaged by DUA to perform a risk assessment. This assessment was completed in July 2012 and consisted of an assessment of the UI Benefits system, an assessment of the UI Online Revenue system, an assessment of the EOWLD Telephony system, and an assessment of the UI Fraud Prevention and Detection System involving National Directory of New Hires.
DUA also reviews and updates as necessary the SSP annually. The review and plan were updated in 2014 and remain current.
F. CUSTOMER SERVICES
N/A
G. OTHER N/A
INTEGRITY ACTION PLAN Massachusetts Federal Fiscal Year: 2016
Accountable Agency Official(s): David Martin DUA Director of Program Integrity
Summary: DUA has specific plans to make the Program Integrity Unit even more robust in the upcoming years. DUA has four key strategies in its Integrity Action Plan: cross–matches, new staff, new collection strategies and technology. After UI Online went live July 1, 2013, DUA launched AWARE (Aggregate Workforce Analytics Reporting Engine) in November 2013. DUA has put this software to full use and will continue to analyze new ways to prevent fraud through this software tool. The Program Integrity Unit has seen a shift in leadership which DUA hopes will revamp, create and strengthen how the Unit pursues and recovers fraud. DUA is in the process of developing new processes to collect debt and make claimants aware of an existing overpayment. DUA is also reviewing its current technology to pursue and identify fraud before it occurs; we plan on targeting some improvements in our access in FY 2016.
AWARE and Cross–matches: DUA has used data from AWARE to develop cross–matches which were not available prior to the implementation of UI Online and AWARE. Since AWARE has been put into place, DUA has been able to prevent the payment of more than $25m of fraudulent benefits in one scheme alone. DUA continues to work with other State and Federal Agencies to have new data from other sources loaded into the AWARE package to create additional cross–matches. Below are new cross–matches DUA has started in AWARE.
• Out of Country Claims: DUA runs a weekly cross–match to determine which claimants are certifying their weekly benefits from outside the United States; bringing their availability into question. AWARE provides a list of all IP addresses and those claims are reviewed weekly within Program Integrity. • Multiple Bank Accounts: DUA runs a weekly cross–match to look for bank accounts used for more than one claimant. This has been helpful in finding possible fraud cases. • Suspicious Bank Accounts: DUA has been able to identify certain criteria high in fraud pertaining to specific banks. DUA uses this query to review for possible fraud. • Multiple Claims to One Address: This cross–match shows when multiple checks for different claimants are being sent to a one address. This query has also been helpful in identifying fraud, often before it occurs. • Multiple Email Addresses: This query looks for different claimants using a common email address. • Secret Question and Answer: DUA has also found a commonality pertaining to fraud in which similar secret questions and passwords are used. This report is also run weekly. • Owner/Officer: This will give DUA the ability to cross–match to ensure that business owners and/or officers are not fraudulently filing unemployment benefits. • Timed Cross–match: DUA has identified that fraudsters have developed computer programs that run a script to try and set up bogus DUA claims using stolen ID’s. DUA has recognized that these initial claims are filed much faster than if someone had to manually enter an initial claim themselves. We currently work with our IT department to get this list, but believe it would be better housed in the AWARE program. • Fraudulent Employers: DUA has found an influx of fraudulent employers that are set up with the sole intention to file fraudulent unemployment benefits. DUA has found that these fraudulent employers are set up with subject dates older than a year and immediately start to have unemployment claims filed against them. • NDNH (National Directory of New Hires) Cross–match: The DUA is reviewing its process to detect and set up overpayments based upon NDNH cross matching as the current process has a lower than expected overpayment set–up rate. It is anticipated that when complete this cross match will be more effective in detecting and preventing current fraudulent benefit year earnings collectors from obtaining future benefits. • Similarly, DUA Program Integrity is beginning a review of all of its current cross matches to determine their effectiveness and to search for potential improvements and/or automation. This review of all Program Integrity cross matches will take some time but should result in a more effective use of Program Integrity staff and resources and reduce benefit year earnings overpayments.
New Staff: DUA has made several staff changes within the Program Integrity Unit. In May 2015 the Program Integrity Unit was shifted under the Chief of Staff. This shift allows BAM and Program Integrity to work together more closely. These are DUA’s units focused on combating claimant fraud and the determining of the agency’s success in combatting claimant fraud. Program Integrity continues to share fraud referrals with Revenue Audit and have worked together on multiple investigations. When Audit discovers employee misclassification, a referral is made to the Program Integrity Unit to make sure that the individuals are not collecting unemployment benefits. The Program Integrity Unit will also refer cases of working and collecting directly to Revenue Audit to ensure employers pay delinquent unemployment taxes. Program Integrity has become more involved in the Massachusetts Joint Task Force on Underground Economy, allowing Program Integrity to work with other Massachusetts Agencies to discuss, discover and report new or current fraud schemes seen throughout the State.
DUA hired a new Program Integrity Director in January 2015 and moved the unit in June from the Revenue Department to the Office of the Chief of Staff. We believe this change in leadership and operational escalation of the unit will lead to improved pursuit and detection of fraud and recovery of overpayments.
DUA also used SBR funds to hire new staff. Five Compliance Officer II’s were hired to pursue fraud both internally through cross matches and externally through business site visits. A Program Coordinator III was added to assist with the collecting of data through various cross–matches, analyzing trends and new fraud queries.
New Collection Strategies: DUA has sought to bolster collection activities for claimants who have been overpaid. The DUA made robo calls through funds granted by an SBR to thousands of claimants with past due overpayments. DUA is considering using this platform going forward.
DUA also began participating in IRORA (Interstate Reciprocal Overpayment Recovery Arrangement) in 2013. IRORA is an agreement among states to collect overpayments of unemployment benefits for each other. States can enter into separate agreements among themselves, but the IRORA gives states a standardized approach to recovering overpayments for each other on a cooperative basis. This program has been live since May 2014 and fully operational since June 2014. More than $100,000 has been recovered in total between dollars collected by other states for DUA and dollars collected by DUA and sent to other states to satisfy the other states’ overpayment.
DUA is also ready to participate in the Treasury Offset Program (TOP) for IRS tax intercept. Recent changes to Massachusetts law allow the Agency to participate in this program. So far in 2015 DUA has intercepted more than $4.5M in state tax intercepts. DUA believes that the TOP intercept should at a minimum double that amount for the next full tax year and will generate some tax intercepts for the DUA Trust Fund in 2016 as well.
DUA has also begun an open and ongoing dialogue and regular meetings with Special Agents from the US Department of Labor, Office of the Inspector General (OIG). DUA has stepped up its prosecution of cases both through the Attorney General’s office as well as the OIG and expects an increase in restitution agreements as a result.
DUA is also exploring the possibility of garnishing wages in order to pay off aging UI debts. Wage garnishment would bring a substantial amount of money into the DUA UI Trust Fund.
Technology: DUA has identified certain technology based areas in need of improvement. DUA has gained access to CJIS (Criminal Justice Information System). DUA recently detected a large volume of falsified claims using a refined query. By identifying these at the initial claim stage, DUA successfully avoided making payments. The fraudsters have begun to respond to identity verification fact–finding with falsified documents (driver’s licenses, passports, social security cards) in an attempt to have the identity verification issue overturned. CJIS has allowed Program Integrity investigators the ability to crosscheck driver’s licenses to ensure the claimant is whom they claim. Program Integrity management also has access to Accurint, a data mining tool offered by Lexis Nexis. Accurint provides access to a significant amount of identity information and is sometimes necessary when dealing with questionable claimant identity information.
DUA has also worked with our IT department to track and block phone numbers coming into the weekly certification line from outside the country. Program Integrity is also setting up availability issues for claims which are later determined to have been generated for or by an out of country claimant. This has allowed DUA to identify possible claimants whom are not available or not looking for work. DUA has also started working with the Registry of Motor Vehicles to start a cross match against claimants addresses to look for inconsistencies.
DUA has also implemented a new Investigations phone line for all CO II’s. Previously if a fraud tipster contacted a unit other than the investigators in Program Integrity, they would have been told to hang up and call the Fraud Hotline, an (800) number. With the new phone line internal callers can transfer these calls to investigations without any problem.
Despite these successes, DUA recognizes that we still have improvements to make related to BYE issues/overpayments. DUA is working with OnPoint and their AWARE technology to detect and prevent more benefit year earning overpayments by improving and expanding use of the National Directory of New Hires (NDNH) and our State Directory of New Hires. The NDNH cross match system has less than a 20% success rate in detecting potential overpayments. To address this issue, DUA requested and received SBR funding to contract with OnPoint to refine the parameters and incorporate NDNH into the existing AWARE process. DUA expects that this effort will result in increased detection and prevent more benefit year earning overpayments.
Program Integrity Milestones Target Dates 3rd qtr. 2015 4th qtr. 2015 1rst qtr. 2016 2nd qtr. 2016
Cross Match Evaluation • NDNH • Report of Hire • Prisoner Cross Match X X
X
X X X Collections Process • Civil Actions • Treasury Offset • IRORA (fixing small defects)
X X X
SQSP STATE PLAN NARRATIVE
MASSACHUSETTS STATE QUALITY SERVICE PLAN OCTOBER 1, 2015 – SEPTEMBER 30, 2016
A. OVERVIEW
In July of 2013, Massachusetts launched the benefits portion of UI Online, our web–based, self–service system. Claimants can now file an initial, continued, or additional claim online, complete fact finding and other requests for information, update contact information, review payment history, file an appeal, and much more. For the first time, our tax, benefits, and appeals systems are fully integrated. DUA had been operating with a 29 year old COBOL based system that was inflexible and unable to keep up with significant law and policy changes. DUA greatly struggled with its workload during the recession, as evidenced by our “At Risk” status and substandard performance measures. A dramatic change was not optional.
Therefore, 2013 was DUA’s year for change. Staff, claimants, employers, and TPAs all had to become accustomed to a new system and a new way of conducting business. As with any large system implementation, there were many challenges: user familiarity was a large one, and in addition, design shortcomings and conversion complications resulting from the conversion of over 2 million claims. The DUA team rallied together, and customers worked with us to identify issues. Claimants responded overwhelmingly well to the ability to use self–service options that were not available to them before.
DUA’s goal for 2014 was to stabilize. The massive changes were over, but the Agency was still recovering from the extensive backlog from the legacy system and settling into the new business processes. In addition, we restructured some departments and hired new staff where needed. We focused on reducing the backlog, fixing any outstanding defects, and stabilizing the infrastructure. We focused on the performance standards and are driving business decisions to meet these goals. As expected, due to the excessive backlog and the fact that the system is designed to work oldest claims and issues first, we saw a downturn in many of our metrics initially. However, we saw some positive trajectory in timely first payment and issue timeliness numbers. This occurred as we continued to improve our business processes, staff became more accustomed to the new system, and calls coming into the call center drastically declined.
Our theme for 2015 was to optimize. In 2015, we continued to improve the system by enhancing the customer service experience and implementing required law and policy changes. As in the past few years, we focused on Program Integrity to stay abreast of new fraud schemes to protect the trust fund. Although staff has adjusted to the new system, there was a continued need for significant training, as a large majority of our adjusters were new. Lastly, agency–wide, there was a renewed focus on internal auditing and quality control in order to catch issues early and tailor training where it was needed most.
In FY2016, agency–wide focus will be on the improvement of performance metrics. Across all levels, staff performance is being measured against state scores for the UI Core Measures and the Secretary’s Standards. Every manager is managing to and being measured against a group of measures that are consolidated into our Customer Service Metrics. The measures included are First Payment Promptness, Nonmonetary Determination Timeliness, Nonmonetary Determination Quality and Lower and Higher Appeals Aging. They are also managing to and being measured against our Employer Service Metrics that include: New Employer Time Lapse, Tax Quality and Effective Audit Measures. Both the Customer Service Metrics and the Employer Service Metrics are in line with the DOL priorities for FY2016. In all of our “at risk” areas, we are focusing on process improvements, system fixes and staff training that will directly impact our ability to meet the acceptable levels of performance.
Already, we have seen significant improvement in our backlog of ready to work issues due to system improvements that consolidate issues into singular fact–finding and enhancements that ease the online filing process for claimants. These changes significantly improved our Timely First Payment metric along with our Lower Authority Appeals Timeliness. In FY2016, we hope to meet the acceptable levels of performance for both of these standards. National Priorities: Improving State Capacity to Administer and Operate the UI Program Effectively: