Please note, the information below reflects progress to close–out the indicators that are being replaced by WIOA common performance measures. Section 106 of the Rehabilitation Act, as amended in 1998, requires the Rehabilitation Services Administration (RSA) to evaluate State vocational rehabilitation (VR) agencies based on their performance on evaluation standards and indicators. Performance on these standards is used to determine whether a State VR agency is complying substantially with the provisions of its State Plan.
ACCES–VR, together with the SRC, had established additional measures related to the priorities, goals, strategies and performance measures that are consistent with Section 106 of the Rehabilitation Act and with regulations found in 34 CFR 361. The baseline and target performance measures for each indicator below was initially established using Federal Fiscal Year (FFY) 2010 data, with the expectation that ACCES–VR would start to report the results after FFY 2012, the year in which the agency could gather a full year of complete data. The following evaluative results are based on the most recent data available on the federal performance indicators and the priorities and goals.
RSA Performance Indicator 1.1: The number of individuals exiting the VR program who have achieved an employment outcome must equal or exceed performance in the previous period.
Baseline FFY 2010: 12,092 individuals achieved an employment outcome
Performance FFY 2014: 12,059 individuals achieved an employment outcome
Performance FFY 2015: 11,284 individuals achieved an employment outcome
Performance Target: ACCES–VR will exceed the final FFY 2010 result for RSA Performance Indicator 1.1.
Results: The number of individuals exiting the VR program with an employment outcome does not meet the performance standard. The employment outcome numbers are influenced by many factors, including the overall economic climate. A key factor that may explain the current lower number is the number of youth in the ACCES–VR caseload population that are preparing for work, rather than being immediately ready to enter employment.
Priority 1: Increase the employment rate and earnings for individuals with disabilities served by ACCES–VR. Goal 1.1: Increase the percentage of individuals exiting the VR program after receiving services that achieve an employment outcome and exceed the national standard of 55.8 percent.
RSA Performance Indicator 1.2: At least 55.8 percent of all cases closed after receiving VR services, will have achieved an employment outcome. Baseline FFY 2010: 45.9 percent achieved an employment outcome Performance FFY 2014: 58.6 percent achieved an employment outcome Performance FFY 2015: 59.4 percent achieved an employment outcome Performance Target: Meet or exceed the RSA performance standard of 55.8 percent Results: Although there was a decrease in the number of individuals that achieved employment after receiving VR services, the percent that achieved employment increased slightly from FFY 2014 to FFY 2015. The 59.4 percent of individuals who obtained employment exceeds RSA’s performance standard.
ACCES–VR established the following additional goals that did not meet the national standard in FFY 2010: Youth: Increase the percentage of youth with disabilities (applicants prior to age 22) exiting the VR program after receiving services that achieve an employment outcome and exceed the national standard of 55.8 percent. The baseline in FFY 2010 was 42.5%. In FFY 2015, 60.6 percent of youth achieved employment after receiving VR services, which exceeds the national standard.
Supported Employment: Increase the percentage of individuals that achieve an employment outcome after receiving supported employment services. The baseline in FFY 2010 was 45.2 percent. This has increased over the years. In FFY 2015, 72.2 percent achieved an employment outcome, which exceeds the RSA performance standard of 55.8 percent.
Social Security Participants: Increase the percentage of individuals that are recipients of Supplemental Security Income (SSI), Social Security Disability Income (SSDI) or SSI/SSDI and achieve an employment outcome that exceeds the national standard of 55.8 percent. The baseline in FFY 2010 was 39.4 percent.
In FFY 2015, 52.6 percent achieved an employment outcome, which is just below RSA’s performance standard.
RSA Performance Indicator 1.4: The percentage of individuals who have significant disabilities that achieve an employment outcome with earnings of at least minimum wage will be 62.4 percent or greater.
Baseline FFY 2010: 98.2 percent earned at least minimum wage Performance FFY 2014: 98.6 percent earned at least minimum wage Performance FFY 2015: 98.9 percent earned at least minimum wage Performance Target: Meet or exceed the RSA performance standard of 62.4 percent
Results: ACCES–VR has exceeded the RSA performance standard each year since the baseline data was established. Individuals are considered to have a significant disability when they have a physical or mental impairment which seriously limits one or two functional capacities, such as mobility, communication, self–care, self–direction, interpersonal skills, cognition, work tolerance, or work skills, and whose vocational rehabilitation will require multiple supported employment services over an extended period of time. ACCES–VR assisted a substantially greater percentage of individuals with significant disabilities to achieve competitive employment compared with to the national standard.
In FFY 2015, 98.9 percent of individuals with significant disabilities that obtained employment through ACCES–VR earned at least minimum wage.
Goal 1.2: Improve earnings of individuals achieving an employment outcome by increasing the percentage that earn at least 200 percent of the federal poverty level at closure.
Baseline FFY 2010: 23 percent (2,710 individuals) of all individuals achieving an employment outcome earned above 200 percent of the federal poverty level ($416/week)
Performance FFY 2014: 22 percent (2,578 individuals) of all individuals achieving an employment outcome earned above 200 percent of the federal poverty level ($442/week)
Performance FFY 2015: 23 percent (2,576) of all individuals achieving an employment outcome earned above 200 percent of the federal poverty level ($449/week)
Performance Target: 28 percent of all individuals achieving an employment outcome will earn above 200 percent of the federal poverty level
Results: In FFY 2015, the percentage of individuals that earned at least 200 percent of the federal poverty level was 23 percent, the same as in 2010, and a very slight increase from 2014.
Related Measures: RSA Performance Indicator 1.3: The percentage of individuals that achieve an employment outcome with earnings equivalent to at least minimum wage will be 72.6 percent or greater. Baseline FFY 2010: 95.4 percent of individuals achieved this employment outcome
Performance FFY 2014: 96.9 percent of individuals achieved this employment outcome
Performance FFY 2015: 97.6 percent of individuals achieved this employment outcome
Performance Target: 97.5 percent of individuals will achieve this employment outcome
Results: ACCES–VR’s performance on this measure exceeds the RSA performance measure, and in 2015 also met the targeted 97.5 percent. RSA Performance Indicator 1.6: Increase the percentage of individuals that report earned income as the largest single source of economic support at the time they exit the VR program; the national standard is 53 percent or greater.
Baseline FFY 2010: 59.8 percent
Performance FFY 2014: 59.6 percent; exceeds the RSA performance standard
Performance FFY 2015: 57.9 percent; exceeds the RSA performance standard Performance Target: 64.8 percent
Results: ACCES–VR’s performance on this measure exceeds the RSA performance measure. ACCES–VR strives to increase the number of individuals who report earned income as the largest single source of economic support at the time they exit the VR program.
Goal 1.3: Increase the average hourly earnings of individuals employed after participating in postsecondary training when compared to the average hourly earnings of all employed individuals in the State and approach the national benchmark ratio of .52 (variation on RSA Performance Indicator 1.5 – see Related Measures below).
Baseline FFY 2010: Average wage of individuals with postsecondary training is $11.42 per hour; .40 of the State Average Wage
Performance FFY 2014: Average wage of individuals with postsecondary training is $12.56 per hour; .41 of the State Average Wage
Performance FFY 2015: Average wage of individuals with postsecondary training is $12.65; .40 of the State Average Wage Performance Target: The long term target is to meet the national benchmark of .52. The short term target is to increase the level of earnings closer to the national benchmark of .52
Results: Performance on this indicator has improved slightly. In NYS the average hourly wage is $31.91. In FFY 2015 the average wage for all ACCES–VR consumers was $11.47. As would be expected, individuals who participate in postsecondary training are earning higher wages ($12.65) on average when compared to all ACCES–VR participants. Although the average wage for ACCES–VR consumers who participate in postsecondary training has improved slightly each year since the baseline FFY 2010 was established, these individuals are still securing jobs, on average, at wages below the .52 threshold established by RSA. ACCES–VR will continue to use the strategy of supporting higher education and workforce credentials as a means to higher wage employment and careers by developing strategies to address postsecondary work experiences. ACCES–VR increased its level of funding for postsecondary training programs, and increased the economic need threshold to 500 percent of federal poverty level. These increases allow ACCES–VR to contribute more money to the costs of training program (lessening the burden on consumers) and allow more individuals to meet economic need for services dependent on economic need, such as college training, that can lead to increased earnings. Related Measures: RSA Performance Indicator 1.5: Average hourly earnings of individuals employed after receiving VR services will be equivalent to at least the minimum wage as a ratio to the State’s average hourly earnings for all individuals in NYS who are employed; ratio equals .52 or more.
Baseline FFY 2010: The average VR wage of $10.70 per hour is .37 of the State Average Wage ($28.84).
Performance FFY 2014: The average VR wage of $11.10 per hour is .35 of the State Average Wage ($31.35).
Performance FFY 2015: The average VR wage of $11.47 per hour is .36 of the State Average Wage ($31.91). Performance Target: $16.59 per hour would equal .52 of the State Average Wage. Results: Although the FFY 2015 average wage increased from the FFY 2010 baseline of $10.70 to $11.47, the average VR wage in FFY 2015 would need to be $16.59 in order for NYS to meet the standard for this indicator. ACCES–VR results for this standard remain below the national benchmark. This ratio reflects the relationship of hourly wages earned by individuals at the time of closure (typically 90 days after attaining employment) to the average hourly wage for all workers in the State. The benchmark ratio of .52 is set at just above half of the overall State hourly wage. There are many structural forces in the NYS economy that make it challenging for individuals participating in VR to earn a livable wage. Many of the individuals served by ACCES–VR, given the economic need criteria for many VR services, are low–income individuals. A high percentage of individuals served by the VR program are determined to have significant and most significant disabilities. The wide gap in wage distribution in NYS also makes this performance measure particularly problematic for low–income individuals participating in VR services. The wage gap in NYS is influenced or skewed by the earnings in Manhattan, particularly on Wall Street. ACCES–VR remains committed to improving its performance on this indicator and assisting VR participants in obtaining higher wage outcomes.
Priority 2: Increase services to unserved and underserved groups.
Goal 2.1: The service rate for identified unserved and underserved populations will be commensurate with the NYS population rates for those populations based on race, ethnicity and disability. RSA Performance Indicator 2.1: The ratio of the percent of individuals with a minority background to the percent of individuals without a minority background exiting the program that received VR services; RSA performance standard > or = .80.
Baseline FFY 2010: .87; exceeds the standard Performance FFY 2014: .85; exceeds the standard
Performance FFY 2015: .82; exceeds the standard Performance Target: Continue to meet or exceed the RSA performance standard. Results: ACCES–VR has continually exceeded RSA’s performance standard of >=.80.
Priority 3: Improve the quality of ACCES–VR services.
Goal 3.1: Consumer satisfaction with ACCES–VR services will increase annually toward the target of 90 percent of respondents expressing satisfaction on key questions contained in ACCES–VR consumer satisfaction surveys.
Baseline FFY 2010: 76 percent indicated satisfaction with ACCES–VR services
Performance FFY 2012: 76 percent indicated satisfaction with ACCES–VR services
Performance FFY 2013: 86 percent indicated satisfaction with ACCES–VR services
Performance FFY 2014: not available
Performance FFY 2015: 82 percent indicated satisfaction with ACCES–VR services Performance Target: Meet or exceed 90 percent of respondents to consumer satisfaction surveys expressing satisfaction with VR services. Results: In FFY 2014, ACCES–VR contracted with the Potsdam Institute for Applied Research (PIAR) at SUNY Potsdam to conduct a survey of 5,105 youth ages 18–22 years in a closed status to inquire about their VR services and employment, but not specifically about their satisfaction with VR services. The survey conducted by PIAR in FFY 2015 was focused on individuals who attained an employment outcome at the time of exit from the ACCES–VR program. The survey purpose was to look at job retention and potential need for additional services. Those that were working at the time of the survey had a satisfaction rate of 88%, whereas those no longer working had a satisfaction rate of 76%.
Goal 3.2: Increase collaboration with community partners, particularly the State agency partners who share responsibility for achieving employment outcomes for individuals with disabilities.
Baseline 2010: ACCES–VR is in the process of developing a Memorandum of Understanding with the NYS Department of Labor (DOL) for a cooperative effort through its Disability Employment Initiative to improve service options and results for individuals with disabilities served through the One–Stop centers. Performance Target: NYS DOL and ACCES–VR will implement promising practices that improve service results for individuals with disabilities. Results: ACCES–VR and Office of Special Education worked closely the NYS DOL to qualify as a demonstration site for youth skills training that could lead to increased youth employment. The U.S. DOL Office of Disability Employment Policy (ODEP) and the National Collaborative on Workforce and Disability for Youth (NCWD/Youth) selected NYS as one of the partners to have staff participate in four free full–day trainings in the core competencies that professionals need to have when working with youth. The training includes content–rich materials, resources and pre/post training technical assistance from experts in youth and workforce development, and disability information. New York State received an award from the U.S. Department of Education to establish and operate model demonstration projects designed to improve the education and employment outcomes of child Supplemental Security Income (SSI) recipients and their families. The Promoting the Readiness of Minors in Supplemental Security Income (PROMISE) initiative is intended to improve the provision and coordination of services for these children and their families. The services will help child recipients achieve better outcomes, including graduating from high school ready for college and a career, completing postsecondary education and job training, and obtaining competitive employment in an integrated setting. ACCES–VR is an active partner in this initiative and joins other NYS agencies, non–profit organizations and Cornell University to improve the education and employment outcomes for children with disabilities receiving SSI in Western New York, Capital Region and New York City. ACCES–VR is a partner in the NYS Partnerships in Employment Systems Change, a five year project to develop and sustain activities that improve opportunities for integrated, competitive employment. ACCES–VR is also an active partner collaborating with the Office for People with Developmental Disabilities and NYS DOL to ensure access to integrated employment opportunities.
Goal 3.3: Increase collaboration with businesses that may lead to employment outcomes.
Baseline 2011: The ACCES–VR Business Relations Unit is continuing to establish business relationships and develop business accounts. Collaborative projects with the National Employment Team (NET) and other national, State and regional resources, including local One–Stops that have yielded quality employment outcomes. Performance Target: ACCES–VR will continue to develop collaborative business relationships to increase employment outcomes. Results: ACCES–VR continues to develop and maintain several business partnerships at the federal, State, and regional levels, such as Net partnerships with United Health Group, with MandT Bank, Lowe’s, Walgreens, JLodge, etc., and Ernst and Young that provides access to job opportunities at several retailers including Macy’s, CVS Caremark, Best Buy, and TJX Companies, Inc. (includes TJ Maxx, Marshalls, HomeGoods, and more). Regionally, ACCES–VR’s Manhattan District Office enhanced the liaison relationship with City University of New York (CUNY) college offices to facilitate the preparation and referral of professional–level applicants to area businesses. The ACCES–VR District Offices located in the Central New York region have partnered with the National Disability Institute and the NYS Credit Union Association to facilitate training and employment for consumers with middle to professional level skills. Work continues with the Long Island Working Partnership members (a consortium of business and service provider agencies) to enhance important initiatives for the 2013–2014 Summer Internship Program for high school graduates. ACCES–VR is in the process of branding itself to be more easily recognizable, and has started a marketing campaign with signage on public transportation in key metropolitan areas of the State, including NYC and Buffalo. As part of its Strategic Planning process, ACCES–VR surveyed a sampling of businesses from across the state to ascertain their current knowledge of ACCES–VR. The results of this survey helped direct the development of more compelling marketing and outreach materials targeted for business, including brochures on Hiring Good People is Good Business, Worker Retention Services, On the Job Training Program and Work Try–Out Program. This past year ACCES–VR participated in a joint presentation with NYS Department of Labor to discuss financial incentives credits available to business. ACCES–VR is also working to identify federal contractors/subcontractors, and to obtain the most current information regarding the changes in the Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs (OFCCP) rules, which advance the recruitment of qualified candidates with disabilities. ACCES–VR ensures that key staffs across the state are prepared to provide customized training to the business community on the benefits of hiring individuals with disabilities, through their participation in the American Disabilities Act (ADA) Trainer Network. This no–cost service is a valuable resource to businesses as they strive to diversify their workforces with qualified candidates with disabilities.