U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.

Https

Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock () or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Plan: Rhode Island PYs 2016-2017
Combined Plan C

Section: WIOA State Plan Common Elements

Narrative: III. a. 2. A.

Published
Located in:
  • III. Operational Planning Elements
    The Unified or Combined State Plan must include an Operational Planning Elements section that support the State’s strategy and the system-wide vision described in Section II.(c) above. Unless otherwise noted, all Operational Planning Elements apply to Combined State Plan partner programs included in the plan as well as to core programs. This section must include—
    • a. State Strategy Implementation
      The Unified or Combined State Plan must include—
      • 2. Implementation of State Strategy
        Describe how the lead State agency with responsibility for the administration of each core program or a Combined Plan partner program included in this plan will implement the State’s Strategies identified in Section II(c). above. This must include a description of—

III. a. 2. A. Core Program Activities to Implement the State’s Strategy

Describe the activities the entities carrying out the respective core programs will fund to implement the State’s strategies. Also describe how such activities will be aligned across the core programs and Combined State Plan partner programs included in this plan and among the entities administering the programs, including using co-enrollment and other strategies.

Current Narrative:

Network government replaces the historic top–down, centralized strategy of government decision making. In Rhode Island, the strategy of embracing the network government approach allows past successful collaborations to be formally recognized and expanded, but also requires new collaborations to be fostered. While WIOA requires the collaboration of numerous partners, Rhode Island is taking such collaboration to the next level, integrating inter–agency and community partner collaboration into the official policy making and program design processes. Such collaborations not only generate policy recommendations, but solutions to day–to–day operational challenges that hinder service delivery to both clients and employers. This foundational strategy of networked government supports the three workforce strategies identified above.

While such cooperative service delivery may be substantially more difficult to establish and coordinate than a centralized bureaucracy, a network government strategy to service design and delivery provides unique service combinations more effectively to individuals and employers. Recognizing the need for a network government strategy and requiring agencies to solve problems through a network government approach allows the combined planning described in this document to take place and for practical implementation challenges to be addressed. The network government approach also provides workforce entities a more complete understanding of a client or employer and the ability to provide services in tandem to maximize the effectiveness of those services.

For this reason Rhode Island has included, in addition to the core program partners, the following combined program partners in this state plan: Temporary Assistance for Needing Families, Trade Adjustment Assistance for Workers program; Jobs for Veterans State Grants program; Unemployment Insurance and Senior Community Service Employment Program. Workforce development partners shall include other community based job training and placement agencies. By coordinating the planning activities of these programs, Rhode Island seeks to create a common vision for meeting the career needs of all Rhode Islanders served under these programs.

WIOA allows networked government to be achieved by providing the flexibility needed to let its one stops play a role that is natural for them within the fabric of our states workforce development network. We want to reimagine the One Stops to be a network connections facilitator. While workforce intermediaries will have the job of working with the demand end of the market, one stops gain the latitude to reimagine the role they play in our state specific and unique network. By spending the appropriate amount of time with job seekers, rather than attempting to be the entire network for the individual, the one stop can help connect job seekers to the services or industry partnerships based on the job seeker’s specific needs. Some of the important aspects of re–aligning the one stops include focusing on training career coaches, case managers and guidance counselors on how to navigate the workforce development network, aligning coaching with industry needs and providing more clear and more refined guidance for job seekers.

Four major factors of network government collaboration must be addressed between all partners included in this plan before the most effective service delivery can be provided. These factors include: clarifying partner roles and implementing an integrated response team model, braiding resources across programs to maximize investments, establishing common standards around client intake and service referrals, and developing an IT infrastructure to support intelligence sharing and effective case management among partner entities, both government and non–government.

Clarifying partner roles and implementing an integrated resource team model is critical in developing a coordinated and collaborative service delivery system. The integrated resource team model started as a pilot model under the Rhode Island Disability Employment Initiative grant. In the pilot participating agencies committed to participating in ad–hoc teams developed around meeting the needs of individual clients. If one agency determined a client needed to be referred to additional services, the agency receiving the referral would commit to participating in a joint case management team with staff from other programs serving the same client. As a result, coordination and collaboration among employment and training programs fundamentally improved through a blending and braiding of resources at a customer level. This was achieved by developing better communication processes between multiple service systems for more integrated service delivery. By giving a goal specific explanation of available resources, the Resource Plan helps the customer, One–Stop staff, and community partners to coordinate and maximize available resources.

Bringing the integrated resource team model to scale for all programs included in this plan requires the implementation of formal mechanisms to create response teams. For frontline service employees state agencies responsible for administering a program shall assign points of contacts between frontline staff members to provide as close to immediate feedback as possible on the eligibility of a client for additional services. Frontline staff should be directed to view their caseload as a shared caseload with partnering agencies and that referrals requiring attention do not constitute a competing caseload. A client in need of TANF or a similar service is not more or less in need based on how the need was identified. Frontline staff connections between agencies does mean each agency will designate a single point of contact for all staff from a partner agencies. Such lop sided points of contacts often result in the single point of contact becoming overwhelmed with referrals and a lack of responsiveness all together if the individual is unavailable to process referrals. In addition, directing frontline staff to work collaboratively across agencies and to view their work as extensions of each other will also promote a greater knowledge and competency among frontline staff about available programs and resources that may benefit the client. Such work increases client access to programs and the efficiency of inter–program referral, making inter–program collaboration at the frontline level routine business practice.

In addition to directing frontline staff to share caseloads, taking the integrated resource team model to scale also requires a government and non–government continuous improvement team structure to develop solutions around practical challenges hindering collaborative efforts throughout the workforce network. Continuous improvement teams are ad–hoc teams comprised of subject matter experts from both government agencies and non–government organizations convened to solve practical challenges facing the workforce network. The members of the team are identified in response to the level of practical challenge presented. Teams will be ad–hoc in nature and therefore will not be standing committees. Teams are topic centered not membership centered. When a team resolves a challenge the team will be dissolved even if the team members may serve on a new team. While a subtle difference, having topic–based teams rather than member–based teams ensures only the relative members are participating in a team for a given topic and that the topic at hand is addressed before a new topic is introduced.

The continuous improvement teams will be responsible for determining the cause of the challenge and will amend any internal policies or processes contributing to the cause of the challenge. If the team identifies more formal policies, such as regulations or statute, as being the cause of the challenge, the team shall make recommendations for amending the official policy to the appropriate agency executive or workforce board for consideration. Similar to the problem solving work of the workforce intermediary, the continuous improvement teams will be topic centered and responsible for implementing identified necessary changes. The stakeholder process for this plan resulted in a recommendation that the following five topics be addressed by the continuous improvement teams first. Please refer to Appendix A for a copy of the official memorandum documenting the recommendations of the stakeholder groups to the leading state agencies. This memorandum was presented to the state board on February 18th 2016.

First, it was recommended to convene a continuous improvement team to study the issue of common assessments and to provide recommendations to the departments for establishing a statewide common assessment policy. Different assessments of a similar competency are required by separate programs, which in some cases requires a client to take multiple assessments for the same competency before a service can be provided. Such duplication delays service provision to the client and consumes program resources that could be put towards other needs of the client.

It was also recommended to convene a team to develop solutions around collecting and sharing client information among one–stop network partners. The stakeholder group articulated the need for basic client data collection standards that all service providers could collect as part of an intake process. This team would be tasked with determining which data elements about a client should be shared among one–stop partners to increase the quality and efficiency of services provided. However, although stakeholders agreed on the need for better data sharing practices, concerns over the sharing of confidential data between entities was also expressed.

A third factor of partner coordination that must be addressed to provide better service delivery is the need to establish common standards around client intake and service referrals. This factor does not only pertain to the work conducted at the American Job Centers, but all partners providing services or connecting clients to services. Such partners may be government agencies, community providers, education institutions, and non–profit organizations. As clients receive services from multiple programs and as program staff seek to refer clients successfully to other services, the need for common data collection and sharing standards that can be adopted by all workforce partners. During the stakeholder meeting held January 13th, 2016, both community and government partners identified the need to establish a client profile that each partner can access, eliminating the duplication of data collection, and the need to establish information sharing standards around program eligibility.

The client profile should contain a record of the individual’s demographic information, resume elements, assessment results, and other data that is commonly used by service providers. The Rhode Island Departments of Education, Human Services, and Labor & Training will convene a work group comprised of program administrators and community providers to identify the common data elements of the client profile and the format in which those elements should be presented. Included in this work will be an analysis of all applicable privacy statutes of these elements and recommendations for establishing data sharing policies that fully comply with these statutes. The recommendations of this work group will be presented to the agency directors and the Governor’s Workforce Board so a statewide, multiple agency, data sharing policy can be adopted.

Standards for sharing program information help create uniformity among partners for how program information is communicated. For programs receiving referrals from other partner agencies, standard information should be provided to the referring program. For example, program eligibility requirements or program contact information should be provided to the referring program to ensure the referral is appropriate for the client and to maximize the opportunity for a client to successfully enter the new program. Creating information standards does not mean creating another form for program staff to complete, instead the standard provides programs with guidance on what information referring programs need in order to make a quality referral. The work group described above will also recommend such information sharing standards for programs receiving referrals.

Both government and non–government partners rely on provided program information to make informed decisions about referring a client to an education program, training, employer recruitment, or other service. However, the information regarding the eligibility requirements of different opportunities may not provide enough detail for a quality referral to be made. For some organizations the volume of referrals made on a daily basis makes following up on each potential referral unfeasible. Establishing basic standards for eligibility data elements would create a uniform format to provide organizations making referrals the information necessary to prevent referring a client to an opportunity for which they are ineligible. Such standards may include education level required, documents required, and any other application requirements.

Stakeholders recommended establishing a team comprised of government and non–government partners to evaluate customer focus within the one–stop network and provide an action plan for increasing the customer centeredness inside the one–stop network in collaboration with the two local Workforce Development Boards. The issue of accessibility ranged from ensuring the hours of operation of career centers met the needs of clients to offering services in more geographic areas using technology, other partner organizations, and a mobile unit. These recommendations also included increasing individualized attention and case management services to one–stop clients, ensuring resources are provided to meet the language, education, physical, and technological needs of clients, and improving one–stop partner collaboration around delivering services to a shared client.

Additionally, it was recommended to the state to establish an evaluation committee to develop performance measures to gauge the effectiveness of the one–stop network beyond the requirements of federal program reporting and track those measures on a continuous basis in collaboration with the two Local Workforce Development Board. With recommendations and goals brought forth creating a more client centered one–stop network, performance measures should be developed to track indicators of client centeredness.

Executive management coordination is the final aspect of the integrated response team model to be discussed. Executive managers in all program agencies are responsible for ensuring the new model is implemented throughout all levels of the program, committing mid–level administrators to participating in the continuous improvement teams, and ensuring changes resulting from continuous improvement teams are implemented. Executive management is also responsible for handling any formal policy recommendations resulting from the continuous improvement teams. These policy recommendations and other executive management coordination will take place through the Governor’s Skill Cabinet and Children’s Cabinet. The Governor’s Children’s Cabinet aims to improve the health, education, and wellbeing of the state’s children, increase efficiency in coordination of service delivery, and improve data and evidence based decision making through strengthened data sharing capacities. The Cabinet is composed of directors from six agencies, representatives of child advocacy groups, and the Secretary of the Office of Health and Human Services. Similarly, the Governor is proposing to create a skills cabinet to align skills initiatives at the executive level with other programs. This cabinet will be comprised similarly to the Children’s Cabinet with director level representatives. Both cabinets will include the agency leadership necessary to deliver high–level policy decisions and to make any formal policy changes. These cabinet meetings also allow such policy issues to be elevated to the Governor for consideration.

Formalizing such collaborative efforts at each management level and including both government and non–government participants will clarify the roles of network partners. Because most workforce related programs have similar goals for their clients, program design and requirements are also similar. As a result, programs have created numerous microcosms that perform similar functions yet remain unrelated from each other and often serving clients based on a specific set of client characteristics, such as having a disability or being a veteran. Examples of overlapping functions include, but are not limited to, employer outreach, subsidized employment programs, client counseling, and client assessment. Such duplication limits the resources of all programs, and creates confusion among both individual clients and businesses about what services exist, how to access services, and what combination of services will best suit an existing need.

Employer relations is one of the most important areas where role clarity is vital to program success and provides an illustrative example of how role clarity can improve program performance. With so many client–focused programs, there is very little inherent support for a coordinated employer engagement strategy. As a result employers may develop a strong relationship with one program and not gain access to other resources that may assist their workforce development efforts, or may experience the opposite challenge of government fatigue, which occurs when an employer is approached by too many programs seeking their advice and participation. In a state the size of Rhode Island government fatigue can happen quickly if a coordinated employer engagement strategy is not in place.

All programs struggle to develop enough employer connections to generate enough employment opportunities for their clients. The inadvertent competition among programs for the same employer pool further reduces this capacity at the program level. By designating a lead agency to manage employer engagement for workforce purposes and ensuring that agency is aligned with the economic development strategy of the state will allow programs to combine resources to support this consolidated approach, which will allow freed funding to be used on other key program priorities. This does not mean programs will no longer interact with employers, on the contrary, program relationships with employers will be strengthened as a quality, coordinated approach will be used across programs resulting in more meaningful and numerous employer relationships for all partners.

To address this issue, and others like it, the Rhode Island Executive Office of Commerce will be responsible for setting and communicating the economic development strategy for the state. This office is required by Rhode Island state law to coordinate with the Department of Labor and Training to align the state workforce development efforts to the wider economic development efforts underway. With this relationship in place and with the state department of labor leading the statewide effort to create and scale up sector–based partnerships in line with the industries identified by the Executive Office of Commerce as targeted economic development industries, the department of labor will have the lead responsibility of coordinating employer engagement for partner programs included in this plan. The Department of Labor and Training will convene program administrators to identify current employer engagement with existing programs and develop joint employer engagement strategies.

Once programs are able to collaborate around shared functions, then program resources can be more effectively braided to support common goals. Because most program funding is participant based, programs have often struggled to leverage funding in a meaningful way since pooling funds has not been an option. Recognizing these past failings, Rhode Island seeks to develop real–time braiding practices that capitalize on pursuing the shared goals of separate programs and developing customized funding plans for each participant in a jointly supported activity. For example, the Real Jobs Rhode Island grant program is a sector–based program that uses several funding streams to support workforce solutions proposed by industry–based partnerships. Because Real Jobs Rhode Island is sector–based, the identity and characteristics of individual training participants is unknown at the time the grant proposal is submitted and even when participants are identified future cohorts may include a completely different combination of participants. As a result, the multiple funding sources supporting the program must be managed in such a way as to respond to the specific training plans and participants selected by the partnership in real–time. As Rhode Island implements its demand driven sector strategy and career pathway strategy, the ability to braid funding in real–time to address the unique needs of clients and employers becomes a critical function of all partner programs.

The fourth factor of developing an IT infrastructure able to support intelligence sharing and case management across programs provides workforce partners the technology necessary to access client information as needed and to keep all service providers working with a client up–to–date on the services received by the client. The IT infrastructure solution will include an umbrella data system that is able to mine existing agency MIS systems to generate client data without requiring agencies to directly access those MIS systems. Such a system will also have the capability to generate referrals, allowing all partner programs to track client referrals in the same system and to allow staff from each program to connect quickly if additional information is required to serve the client. This data system can also serve as the electronic version of the client profile described above.