Located in:
- II. Strategic Elements
The Unified or Combined State Plan must include a Strategic Planning Elements section that analyzes the State’s current economic environment and identifies the State’s overall vision for its workforce development system. The required elements in this section allow the State to develop data-driven goals for preparing an educated and skilled workforce and to identify successful strategies for aligning workforce development programs. Unless otherwise noted, all Strategic Planning Elements apply to Combined State Plan partner programs included in the plan as well as to core programs.
- c. State Strategy
The Unified or Combined State Plan must include the State's strategies to achieve its strategic vision and goals. These strategies must take into account the State’s economic, workforce, and workforce development, education and training activities and analysis provided in Section (a) above. Include discussion of specific strategies to address the needs of populations provided in Section (a).
- c. State Strategy
II. c. 1. Describe the Strategies the State Will Implement, Including Industry or Sector Partnerships Related to In-demand Industry Sectors and Occupations and Career Pathways, as Required by WIOA Section 101(d)(3)(b), (d). “career Pathway” is Defined at WIOA Section 3(7). “in-demand Industry Sector or Occupation” is Defined at WIOA Section 3(23).
Current Narrative:
Identifying and aggregating the workforce demands of employers and developing comprehensive solutions to meet those demands is the core of a sector strategy. In Rhode Island, the sector strategy is applied through the use of industry–based partnerships, also known as workforce intermediaries. As defined by Robert Giloth in Workforce Intermediaries for the Twenty–First Century, workforce intermediaries are “homegrown, local partnerships that bring together employers and workers, private and public funding streams, and relevant partners to fashion and implement pathways to career advancement and family–supporting employment for low–skilled workers.” Giloth goes on to explain workforce intermediaries complement the work of the public workforce system by focusing on the development of specific workforce solutions and implementing those solutions by integrating services and funding from a variety of sources both public and private. Public workforce program administrators and public boards complement the work of the intermediaries through the setting of policy, providing insight on larger economic trends, and improving access to public programs and funds.
Rhode Island’s state workforce board recognized the need to develop the capacity of workforce intermediaries and used state funding to support industry partnership grants. Building on the success of this initiative, Rhode Island under WIOA seeks to bring the workforce intermediary strategy to scale in all target industry clusters and to use all programs included in this plan to support this effort. This sectoral approach, the most ambitious according to Giloth, will develop workforce solutions that address connecting the labor supply to the workforce demand across employers in an industry cluster. By taking a sector approach to growing workforce intermediaries, Rhode Island will be able to align cross industry, demand–based workforce solutions to the statewide economic development initiatives in the same industry clusters. In addition, sectoral workforce intermediaries will be able to provide higher quality actionable intelligence that policymakers can use to better leverage public resources for the success of Rhode Island’s workforce members and employers.
The purpose of the sector based strategy and the use of workforce intermediaries is twofold. First, this strategy provides a structured way for employers within the same sector to collaborate to generate solutions for shared problems. Finding enough workers with the skills needed to supply the labor necessary to produce goods and services is one of the most critical issues facing employers and the reason why a sector strategy is needed to promote workforce development. The use of intermediaries allows employers the ability to collaborate through a third party so that the natural competition of employers doesn’t hinder the industry’s ability to develop solutions to common challenges that, if met, would benefit all employers in an industry. In addition, the structured collaboration managed through the intermediary helps employers to think critically about their workforce needs and then helps employers articulate those needs in a way that the workforce network can respond to.
The second purpose of a sector based strategy is to provide actionable intelligence to and from those programs serving clients who need to compete for employment, or who need to improve their current employment status. The sector based strategy leverages intermediaries to provide real–time information about current labor needs and future needs. Using intermediaries to take the guess–work out of anticipating where employment is available will help programs working with clients to spend more resources serving clients than trying to perform the role of the workforce intermediary of determining what employers are looking for in the workforce. In addition, by leveraging intermediaries, workforce development partners will have better information around what RI employers actually need in terms of their workforce and how individuals can connect to those opportunities. This intelligence has often been to the missing link between industry projections for workforce needs and the individuals seeking to connect to those projected opportunities. The construction industry provides a good example of this missing link. For many years the construction industry has projected a shortage of workers as existing workers begin to reach retirement age. Due to the long periods of time to train for certain trades, the number of younger workers available to replace retiring workers does not match the number of workers projected to retire. However, despite having this information many workforce programs struggle to find ways to connect their clients to this sector. By building upon the roles of workforce intermediaries in sectors such as construction, information about employer led training and recruitment activities can be provided in real–time to help connect existing clients to existing opportunities that represent the larger industry projections supported by labor market research and trends.
The scaling up of workforce intermediaries has started under the Real Jobs Rhode Island program. This grant program combines several federal and state funding sources to officially recognize workforce intermediaries and to fund workforce solutions developed by the intermediaries and their participating employers. These partnerships are comprised of at least five employers and at least two diverse entities. Employers in the partnership work collaboratively to identify shared workforce challenges, existing positions to be filled and the qualifications necessary to perform the tasks associated with the positions. In addition, near future labor needs are also identified and analyzed for the skills needed by future workers. Once this analysis of the labor needs of the employers is complete, the employers work with the non–employer partners to develop a strategy for obtaining the workers needed to fill the current or near future open positions. Such strategies primarily include developing industry “boot–camps”, on the job training programs, registered apprenticeships or other educational and occupational training programs.
Industry–based partnerships provide the mechanism for employers to convene around common workforce challenges and to enter into a formal partnership with government or community providers of their choice to develop customized solutions to the present labor shortage in their industry. Typically these partnerships are convened by an entity that is trusted in the employer community, such as an employer association, labor union, or other industry intermediary. The partnership develops the training modules, selects or develops the training curriculum, develops a recruitment strategy, and sets the application criteria for entering training. Each partnership is provided a grant advisor from the Department of Labor and Training who is responsible for assisting the partnership refine its planned solution and resolving any challenges the partnership may face implementing their proposed solutions, including obstacles such as connecting to other needed partners, overcoming bureaucratic processes and red tape, and ensuing public funding is received in a timely manner.
The role of the grant advisor and the other program staff involved in the partnership is critical to supporting the capacity building of the workforce intermediary by connecting the intermediary to new potential partners and providing the partnership information about other existing resources that may help the partnership’s effort. For example, one Real Jobs Rhode Island workforce intermediary developed a workforce solution that requires the development of a registered apprenticeship program for Biomedical Equipment Technicians and Data Scientists. The grant advisor connected the partnership to ApprenticeshipRI, an apprenticeship intermediary developed under the American Apprenticeship Initiative, to receive technical assistance in developing program standards and registering the new apprenticeship programs. The services of ApprenticeshipRI are provided at no cost to the partnership and will expedite the registration process. Such connections help workforce intermediaries leverage existing resources and maximize existing workforce investments.
In addition to connecting the workforce intermediaries to other resources, the advisor becomes an advocate for the work of the partnership inside of state government. Typically, the workforce intermediary will encounter a government process that creates an undue burden or hinders the very work of the partnership public investments are trying to support. The grant advisor has the authority to bring such issues to program administrators and work with the administrators on developing solutions that resolve the conflict between a partnership’s work and a government process.
A prime example of how workforce intermediaries through networked government work through undue burden brought on by governmental processes was apparent in a local school who attempted to acquire used manufacturing equipment to expand school based training for CNC machining. The proposal of a local manufacturing company to sell used equipment to the school that had a CTE program designed to provide students with manufacturing training seemed to be a cut and dry idea that served both the needs of the school and the employer simultaneously. However, as the request moved through the procurement process at the local and state level the response to the school became a purchase document for buying new equipment which would eliminate the employer relationship and limit the number of machines the school could purchase. Through networked government, the employer intermediary for the manufacturers brought this problem to the Department of Labor and Training. The department then facilitated a meeting with the purchasing agencies and the local school. The issue was resolved and the original proposal progressed as planned. In this instance the immediate need to improve the state’s workforce was resolved and the agencies involved gained valuable knowledge about how internal procedures could be amended to prevent similar situations from occurring in the future.
Industry–based partnerships with employers as the primary participants invert the common method of employer engagement. Rather than have employers participate in a service provider developed program, service providers are invited to participate in an employer led workforce development program. Employers determine what level of intervention they are willing to support when it comes to preparing future employees. In addition, employers choose which service providers they want to collaborate with in delivering the workforce solution developed. The freedom of partnerships to control their own membership allows existing collaborations to be supported and creates a healthy competition for those organizations, both employer and non–employer, looking to join the partnership. Employers looking to join the partnership must be willing to collaborate with the other employers and commit to the workforce solution developed. Service providers seeking to become partnership members directly must demonstrate their value to the employers and must provide services that fit the proposed solution strategy. Depending on the level of intervention included in the workforce solution, some service providers may provide services as part of the industry–based training program, whereas other service providers may not be directly involved in the partnership but may align their pre–industry training services to the partnership’s program.
The ability of service providers to participate in the partnership provides a unique opportunity for providers to work with employers directly to create or customize education or service programs and creates more opportunities for such programs to be delivered within the context of an occupational skills training program. Contextualized program delivery coupled with the direct input from employers will generate opportunities for services provided [Title I and II of WIOA and title IV of Vocational Rehabilitation] by each of the combined partner programs to be provided in tandem to a client participating in a contextualized learning program that also supports the attainment of a secondary education degree or its equivalent, or a post–secondary education credential. By providing services in tandem, workforce partners participating in the partnership will be more responsive to the employer demand for workers, while simultaneously providing more effective services to clients.
The more efficient delivery of services allows employers to connect with workers quicker while ensuring workers are adequately prepared for the training or placement. With the elimination of the sequence of services mandated under WIA, partner programs may now provide more services concurrently and may expedite the client’s progress in achieving their career goals. An illustrative example, Title I Youth services can be used to provide tutoring and other academic supports for an older youth to compliment Title II education services provided to a client. In addition to complementary academic services, Title I funds for paid or unpaid work experience can be used to support occupational training for the same client. Further, the older youth may be co–enrolled as an Adult to receive additional training services when transitioning to a permanent position. Using funding in such a way allows participants to succeed in completing the employer–based training in a timely way and provides the employer with a trainee or employee that is achieving both academic and occupational skills attainment.
Diverse entities, regardless of type, participating in workforce intermediary partnerships have the ability to work directly with employers to develop workforce solutions that blend the occupational factors an employer group needs to see addressed with the services and education individual workers need to be successful. The workforce intermediary model builds diverse entitles into the intermediary structure because the entire reason employers need a workforce intermediary is that their recruitment methods alone are unable to supply the workforce they need. Therefore, because employers cannot solve this workforce shortage alone, diverse entities and the people they serve are critical to the success of any workforce solution developed.
In addition to having direct access to employers, the workforce intermediary strategy provides diverse entities the opportunity to develop customized programs and service delivery methods for the intermediary’s workforce plan. This ability gives the diverse entities a way to develop solutions that do not need to be system–wide changes. Many divers entities have experienced pressure to make system–wide changes is response to employer needs. Such large scale projects, such as developing CTE curriculum or drafting elements of an adult education provider contract, hinder the entity’s ability to engage in customized solutions development. A sector–based training program may not require education reform or to different statewide regulations changes around service delivery and the demand captured by the partnership may not represent a large enough or long–term type of employer demand to justify legacy system changes. Yet just because employer needs for workforce talent may not warrant a system–wide change, the demand for those workers is real and diverse entities are needed by employers to find and retain those workers. The recognition of the need for diverse entities to participate in the workforce intermediary helps those entities connect client serving programs to the workforce solutions. The new workers required by employers must come from the client pools served by diverse entities, however, by working through workforce intermediaries the expertise of employers and diverse entities are brought together in an official capacity to solve workforce shortages and connect clients to open positions.
As partnerships form and the results of workforce solution plans are generated, best practices will emerge. While each partnership responds to the unique demands of its employer members, a community of learning will develop among partnerships, helping employers to better articulate their needs and match those needs to the appropriate service provider, helping service providers to better respond to the needs of employers in a meaningful way and more effectively serve their clients. In addition, grant advisors and other government staff can begin to solve practical challenges facing partnerships and can refine workforce, economic, and education policy to further support the efforts of the partnerships.
Another benefit of bringing employers and service providers together in industry–based partnerships is employers will learn how to better signal their workforce needs to trigger the appropriate response from the government and non–government workforce organizations. Translating the real time talent needs of an employer into a recruitment or application qualifications often results in a misalignment of the skills of potential candidates to the skills required at the production level or a shortage of qualified candidates responding to a recruitment. For example, education credentials are often required by employers more as a means to measure an individual’s reliability rather than their academic skills. However, if a six week “boot camp” or similar program can demonstrate to an employer in real–time the reliability of a candidate than the employer may hire the individual with more confidence in the long–term success of the individual while the individual is spared having to overcome the barrier of having an academic credential before being qualified to gain employment. By working together, employers and service providers can produce a more accurate descriptions of what skills employers are looking for and how to find or develop those skills in the pool of available workers.
As the capacity of the workforce intermediaries within the targeted sectors of the economy grows, the intermediaries will provide industry employers even greater assistance in identifying and meeting employer workforce development needs. For many employers across the industry sectors, internal human resources capacity has been reduced. Companies have shed many of the internal human resources functions and analysis capability, limiting the available internal succession or expansion programs to ensure workforce continuity. Sectoral workforce intermediaries are positioned to fill this need. In earlier sector based partnerships, intermediaries were able to resolve single workforce challenges and to pilot best practice models. However, by taking the workforce intermediary strategy to scale, workforce intermediaries will be able to provide more comprehensive plans to address employer needs that are both immediate and long–term. Such efforts will include topics such as succession planning, reducing turnover, and developing post–employment training for continuing staff development. The workforce development network offers several tools to help employers address their workforce challenges. Educational programs, internships, on–the–job training, registered apprenticeship, and other programs can be used in the workforce intermediary’s plan unifying workforce efforts across the industry and within individual employer.
As workforce intermediaries begin to work with employers in a more comprehensive way, the government programs and the diverse entities participating in the intermediary will be able to develop investment strategies that braid multiple resources and funding sources together to support the planned workforce solution. Participating programs can add resources to aspects of the workforce plan that align with the program mission and goals. By looking to create a comprehensive strategy and investment plan, the intermediary will be able to attract more resources for its employer partners and their future workers. Participating programs receive better placement and retention of clients within the employer community and receive a more transparent account of how funds are used to support activities. This transparency not only allows for more effective investment, but will help prevent programs duplicating efforts and funding.
As partnerships begin to develop comprehensive workforce strategies and use the investments supporting the strategy, the larger workforce related programs, including all programs contained in this plan, will be able to analyze the trend of these workforce solutions and create more informed policy and investment decisions to improve the function and collaboration of workforce network entities. As the workforce intermediaries grow in capacity and organize more of the employer demand for workforce, the larger workforce related programs will align with each other to ensure greater connections to industry partners and to scale up existing efforts to complement the increased capacity of the intermediaries. This relationship creates a sustainable cycle of improving program alignment with aggregated demand where employer participation in intermediary partnerships increases the information available regarding employer demand to diverse entities, who are able to respond more effectively to employer demand.
Sector partnerships are now the primary mechanism for delivering workforce funding to employers, but will not be the sole mechanism. Businesses who wish to utilize subsidized services can be helped regardless of whether they belong in a sector partnership or not. Also, the grant program Real Jobs Rhode Island is not the only program that supports the sector strategy. The sector based approach helps build the capacity of many intermediaries including the work underway in our core programs. These include the Business Leadership Network operating under the Vocational Rehabilitation program, the workforce councils that are apart of Job Corps, and other existing grant work performed by the GWB such as the Workforce Innovation Grant. Workforce intermediaries will be prioritized for all available funding and services.
All programs should encourage employers to engage in industry collaboration to foster strong relationships between businesses, governments, and individuals. These new sector strategies are in no way exclusionary, the new standard of partnerships is meant to bring all parties responsible for the growth of the state’s economy together. While not required, the participation in a partnership should be the primary way employers engage with the workforce network. The ability to aggregate demand and develop effective solutions depends on the use of this sector strategy. The ability for businesses that wish to utilize already established tools such as job listings through EmployRI without working with their industry peers will remain, however as employers seek more comprehensive workforce development solutions the mechanism of sector partnership will be used to assist employers in the development of these solutions