U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.

Https

Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock () or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Plan: Massachusetts PYs 2016-2017
Combined Plan C

Section: WIOA State Plan Common Elements

Narrative: II. b. 1.

Published
Located in:
  • II. Strategic Elements

    The Unified or Combined State Plan must include a Strategic Planning Elements section that analyzes the State’s current economic environment and identifies the State’s overall vision for its workforce development system. The required elements in this section allow the State to develop data-driven goals for preparing an educated and skilled workforce and to identify successful strategies for aligning workforce development programs. Unless otherwise noted, all Strategic Planning Elements apply to Combined State Plan partner programs included in the plan as well as to core programs.

    • b. State Strategic Vision and Goals

      The Unified or Combined State Plan must include the State’s strategic vision and goals for developing its workforce and meeting employer needs in order to support economic growth and economic self-sufficiency. This must include—

II. b. 1. Vision

Describe the State’s strategic vision for its workforce development system.

Current Narrative:

Context for Vision and Goals

Governor Charles D. Baker took office in January 2015 and quickly tasked the Executive Office of Labor and Workforce Development’s (EOLWD) Secretary, Ronald L. Walker, II, with the charge of building upon our successes in creating jobs and assisting residents in finding employment opportunities in every community within the Commonwealth. Working with EOLWD, the Governor signed an Executive Order early on in his administration establishing a Workforce Skills Cabinet (WSC) to create a formal structure within the Administration to set up guiding principles and policies to align economic, workforce, and education systems in order to better address the workforce skills gap in Massachusetts. The Workforce Skills Cabinet is chaired by the Secretary of Labor and Workforce Development and comprised of the Secretaries of Education, Housing and Economic Development and others as required. The cabinet is charged with creating and implementing a strategy to align systems and develop workforce skills to meet the varying needs of employers in the Commonwealth’s regions, now and in the future. The WSC provided a direction to organize various state and federal processes impacting these systems. The research and stakeholder processes were developed to provide context for three major planning products for the Commonwealth:

  • Statewide Economic Development Plan (State Required, State Driven)
  • Statewide Workforce Development Plan (WIOA Required, State Driven)
  • Statewide Strategic Plan for Higher Education Campuses (State Driven)

The amendment of the Workforce Investment Act (WIA) by the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act (WIOA) serves as a vehicle for ensuring Governor Baker’s vision that all Massachusetts residents benefit from a seamless system of education and workforce services that leads to a more informed, educated, and skilled workforce, which meets the Commonwealth’s businesses’ demands and sustains a thriving economy.

Organizing Lens: Workforce Skills Cabinet (WSC)

The WSC Secretaries agreed to analyze the landscape and key economic conditions that would affect alignment of systems and the ultimate outcomes for business and individuals. Ultimately the work of the WSC would impact the development of the required plans listed above. The WSC used the framework of looking at the economy (the macro view), the systems (state services), and the customers (businesses, workers, students) to brief the Secretaries on major assets and challenges.

See the MA State Plan posted at www.mass.gov/massworkforce/state–plan GRAPHIC: CHART 19, WORKFORCE SKILLS CABINET, depicting this WSC framework.

The federal portal does not provide the ability to include this chart/graphic in the State Plan submission. Please review the missing information by viewing the copy of Massachusetts State Plan posted on www.mass.gov/massworkforce/state–plan/ The analysis includes a series of research briefings, interviews and meetings with stakeholders, internal briefings by staff on operations of the three major systems and input from external stakeholders on how to align systems and reduce skill gaps in the economy. The key findings are represented in the charts below. This information set an agenda for the WSC agencies that will influence the development of policies, operations and funding priorities and guide the work of the Administration.

The list below shows the high–level insights from the “macro” level briefings on the labor market and the potential for new workforce supply to meet skill need in Massachusetts. Coupled with the specific labor market analysis in Section I, it supports the focus on developing middle–to high–skilled talent pipelines in technical occupations (often called “middle” skills) within vocational/technical education, on–the–job training efforts or sector initiatives and community college credentials along with a strong demand for STEM credentials across the post–secondary spectrum.

GRAPHIC: CHART 20, INSIGHTS FROM BRIEFINGS – The federal portal does not provide the ability to include this chart/graphic in the State Plan submission. Please review the missing information by viewing the copy of Massachusetts State Plan posted on www.mass.gov/massworkforce/state–plan/ Insights from the WSC briefings:

Economy (Macro)

  • Business Needs:Growing need for “Middle Skills” Workers with Certificates/Two–Year degrees
  • Lack of credentialed workers in high growth areas (Healthcare, Education, Professional Tech, Advanced Manufacturing, STEM)

Workforce Demographics

  • Highest concentration of 4–year degreed workers in nation
  • Outflow of middle– to high–skilled labor (Baby Boomers retiring)
  • Inflow of immigrants accounts for 100% of population growth (ESOL, credentialing needed)
  • 50% of UI claimants have a HS diploma or less

New Workforce Pipeline

  • High high school graduation rates
  • Persistent achievement gaps in low–income communities
  • Low on–time completion rates for 2 and 4–yr degrees at public higher education institutions
  • Shortage of middle skill credentials in high growth areas
  • Strong pipeline from private sector universities (4 year+ degrees)

In addition, the WSC reviewed the “system” level of state and regional government structures and the roles each Secretariat is asked to play in the overall design and support for economic, education and workforce development.

System (State Services)

Executive Office of Education (EOE)

Developing supply of new workforce through coordination of:

  • 4 State Governance Boards (Board of Early Education & Care, Board of Elementary and Secondary Education, Board of Higher Education, UMass)
  • 3 State education agencies (Early Education & Care, Elementary and Secondary Education, Department of Higher Education)
  • 15 Community Colleges
  • 9 State Universities
  • 5 UMass Campuses
  • 26 Vocational Technical Schools
  • 408 School Districts
  • 10,000 Early Education Providers
  • 125 Adult Education Programs

Executive Office of Housing and Economic Development

Setting conditions for business growth through:

  • Housing
  • Mass. Office of Business Development
  • MassDevelopment
  • Mass Life Sciences Center
  • MA Tech Collaborative
  • MOITI
  • Clean Energy Center
  • NA Growth Capital Corp.

Executive Office of Labor and Workforce Development

  • Connecting/reconnecting workers to jobs through:
  • DUA (Unemployment Insurance)
  • DCS (Career Centers)
  • Commonwealth Corporation
  • 16 Workforce Development Boards
  • 32 One–Stop Career Centers
  • Job seeker services
  • Job seeker access to education and training programs
  • Business support (talent recruitment, retention, training and labor market info)

Customers (Business, Workers, Students)

Finally, while the organization of agencies can be sorted and mapped at a state level by agency or program, the “user” or customer – individuals and business – have a different perspective on alignment or lack thereof. There are excellent examples where economic, education, human service, and workforce operators connect and align within a region, yet many times individuals and businesses feel like they are required to talk to several disconnected systems to package a set of services to meet their needs.

Federal and State Planning Processes

The Workforce Skills Cabinet developed an agenda to influence the creation of the specific, state required planning processes to align the policies, operations and resources governed by these efforts through a customer perspective. The goal is to build out an integrated, customer–facing system that connects and coordinates across education, workforce and economic development to achieve the best outcomes for individuals and business. The full agenda is in Attachment A. Through the Workforce Investment and Opportunity Act, the “workforce” system is expanded to include the other key federal partners captured under WIOA and housed under the Executive Office of Health and Human Services (EOHHS). The funding and services captured under these partners will therefore be aligned and includes in Step 2 (Chart 20) through the development of the State Workforce Development Plan.

Below is the overview of the intention and design of aligning our federal and state planning processes. Each step informs the next, bringing in the information and analysis acquired from the prior Plans. Ultimately, statewide planning across the three Secretariats will inform the design of regional planning for our key regional partners.

The following sections describe each of the steps below in terms of expected process and initial context points.

STEP 1: Business Lens / Economic Development Planning Process

The Administration will utilize the state required economic development planning process to set the stage for our Statewide Workforce Development WIOA Plan to ensure the vision and goals for the workforce system are aligned with the economic development strategies identified.

The Governor and the Secretary of Housing and Economic Development (EOHED), with the assistance of an Economic Development Planning Council, must develop and implement (1) a written comprehensive economic development policy for the Commonwealth and (2) a strategic plan for implementing the policy.

In addition to gathering input and information through the Workforce Skills Cabinet, the Executive Office of Housing and Economic Development created a formal process to shepherd the development of the Economic Development Plan based on internal and external research and input from a wider audience of stakeholders that took place during the summer and fall of 2015. The research included:

Internal Research

  • Baker–Polito platform, transition documents, current program, and funding streams, along with a review of national best practices from the National Governors Association and National Conference of State Legislatures
  • Academics (Michael Porter (Harvard), Barry Bluestone (Northeastern), Alicia Sasser Modestino (Northeastern), Michael Goodman (UMass), Elisabeth Reynolds (MIT), Rappaport Center)
  • Key industry groups (AIM, Mass. High Tech Council, Mass. Taxpayers Foundation, NAIOP, CNU, Mass. Competitive Partnership, Jobs for Massachusetts)
  • Regional Listening Sessions: Six teams, led by EOHED senior staff, conducted deep dives on the secretariat’s economic development policy areas, identifying opportunities, policy goals, resources, key partners, key questions, and success metrics

Legislative and Municipal Engagement

  • EOHED met with 62 lawmakers individually since January
  • The Secretary of EOHED visited 85 cities and towns since January, including 24 of 26 Gateway Cities
  • EOHED altogether visited 105 unique communities, with a collective population of nearly 4.3 million residents (64% of the state’s population), from Great Barrington and Williamstown, to Chatham and Salisbury
  • Focus of discussions is on local opportunities, priorities and concerns, EOHED perspectives on local opportunities, and resources to help advance the local agenda

Public Engagement

  • Six statewide public listening sessions were held in June
  • Eight more were added in response to popular demand to participate
  • Sessions provided EOHED staff with direct engagement with over 1,000 stakeholders – residents, elected and municipal officials, business owners, regional agencies, and trade groups
  • Feedback from listening sessions has helped shape key priorities and strategy decisions

Themes from the fourteen economic development listening sessions included the following areas, which span across all areas of federal, state, and local government.

DRAFTSTRENGTHSINHIBITORS FOR GROWTH
INNOVATIONNationally leading research and development base – per capita and as a share of GDP, more R&D expenditures, and federal funding for R&D, than any other state 2nd in tech patents per capitaSlower–than–average rate of new business formation • Need for systems that bring companies to scale • Need for business mentorship, and small business technical assistance
INNOVATIONDiverse cluster base of employment/ business growth– education, financial services, biopharma, health care delivery, medical devices, technology, insurance, and marketing
INFRA–STRUCTURESite readiness and infrastructure concerns
INFRA–STRUCTUREA lack of capacity in local governments and municipal boards
BUSINESS ENVIRONMENTPolitical and fiscal stabilityHigh and growing prosperity statewide – • 5th highest GDP per capita, fifth highest rate of growth in the USHigh levels of regional inequality • All regions outside the Boston metro lag US averages in measures of prosperity, private employment, and wages • Berkshire, Bristol, Hampden, Franklin and Worcester Counties have each seen negative job growth since 1998
BUSINESS ENVIRONMENTBusiness and land use regulations – volume, complexity, lack of predictability
CAPITAL AND COSTSNational leader in venture capital investment as a share of GDP Second in VC under managementBusinesses struggling to accessearly–stage capital
BUSINESS ENVIRONMENTCompetitive overall tax position – 27th in state and local taxes as a share of GDPReputation as high cost state
HOUSING• Housing affordability: Around Boston, there’s limited housing workers can afford, and outside Boston, incomes aren’t high enough • A slow and dysfunctional housing production market
WORKFORCEThe nation’s best–educated workforceDemographic challenges: • An older–than–average workforce, and aging more quickly than the US affecting job creation and municipal financial health • Regional demographic trends – in particular in the western counties and on the Cape • Talent retention is a struggle for communities outside Boston
WORKFORCEAn unmatched knowledge economy––40% of workers employed in the innovation sectorSkill Mismatch • Employers struggling to find skilled workers, in middle–skills positions and in the STEM fields • Demographic churn will exacerbate middle skills mismatch
WORKFORCE3rd highest average wages statewide in the US, with greater–than–average wage growthHigh levels of overall economic inequality – 7th highest Gini coefficient in the US
WORKFORCEHigh and growing labor force productivity – 5th highest GDP per

The analysis and strategies of the Task Force align with WIOA’s principal mission to engage and support individual job seekers with barriers by coordinating services across WIOA funding streams. The recommendations include implications for all of the WIOA Core Program Partners and are therefore integrated into the vision, goals and strategies of the statewide Workforce Development Plan.

The Massachusetts Combined WIOA State Plan will impact the overall systems for the partners included in the Plan. The Commonwealth developed the Combined State Plan to include the following partners:

  • The Adult Program (Title I of WIOA), as part of the Department of Career Services (DCS), Executive Office of Labor and Workforce Development (EOLWD);
  • The Dislocated Worker Program (Title I), as part of the Department of Career Services (DCS), EOLWD;
  • Trade Adjustment Assistance for Workers Programs (Activities authorized under chapter 2 of Title II of the Trade Act of 1974 (19 U.S.C. 2271 et seq.)), as part of DCS, EOLWD;
  • Jobs for Veterans State Grants Program (Programs authorized under 38, U.S.C. 4100 et. seq.) as part of DCS, EOLWD;
  • The Wagner–Peyser Act Program (Wagner–Peyser Act, as amended by Title III), as part of DCS, EOLWD; and
  • The Youth Program (Title I), as part of the Department of Career Services (DCS), EOLWD;
  • The Adult Education and Family Literacy Act Program (Title II), as part of Adult Community Learning Services (ACLS), Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE) Executive Office of Education (EOE);
  • The Vocational Rehabilitation Program (Title I of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, as amended by Title IV), as part of the Massachusetts Rehabilitation Commission (MRC) and Massachusetts Commission for the Blind (MCB), Executive Office of Health and Human Services (EOHHS).
  • Federal–state unemployment compensation program, as part of the Department of Unemployment Assistance (DUA), EOLWD;
  • Temporary Assistance for Needy Families Program (42 U.S.C. 601 et seq.) as part of Department of Transitional Assistance (DTA), EOHHS;
  • Employment and Training Programs under the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, (Programs authorized under section 6(d)(4) of the Food and Nutrition Act of 2008 (7 U.S.C.2015(d)(4))), as part of DTA, EOHHS and
  • Senior Community Service Employment Program (Programs authorized under title V of the Older Americans Act of 1965 (42 U.S.C. 3056 et seq.)), as part of the Executive Office of Elder Affairs (EOEA).

Step 3: Executive Office of Education (EOE) Higher Education Strategic Planning

The Executive Office of Education, in partnership with the Board of Higher Education, will kick off a new strategic planning process for the 15 community colleges, state universities and UMass system in 2016. The Executive Office intends to build the strategic planning requirements to include key priorities developed through the Workforce Skills Cabinet. Institutions will be expected to utilize the information developed in the State Economic Development Plan and Statewide Workforce Development Plan (required by WIOA) on key industries and high–demand career pathways as a building block for developing curriculum, programming, and capital planning. In addition, EOE will set an expectation to be part of regional planning efforts designed under the Workforce Skills Cabinet (leveraging the WIOA planning requirements).

Step 4: Create and Launch an Integrated Regional Planning Process

The Administration will utilize the required WIOA Regional Planning process to create a new, Integrated Regional Planning Process across the economic, education and workforce Secretariats.

On a regional basis, this process will seek out and scale up regional workforce development models that provide workers with the skills employers demand. The process will ensure that regional employers, educators, and workforce training officials are coordinated in a way that creates strong talent pipelines, for both middle–skilled and highly skilled jobs. Additional detail is described in further sections.

Workforce Development Plan Vision

Vision: All Massachusetts residents will benefit from a seamless system of education and workforce services that supports career pathways for individuals and leads to a more informed, educated, and skilled workforce, which meets the Commonwealth’s businesses’ demands and sustains a thriving economy.

To achieve this vision, Massachusetts will engage businesses to understand their needs and develop an integrated education and workforce system that supports career pathways to prepare residents with foundation, technical, professional skills and information and connections to postsecondary education and training. WIOA partners will work to:

  • Design career pathways across partners aligned with business demand
  • Improve foundation skills and transition to postsecondary education and training for individuals with barriers to employment
  • Assist low–income individuals and families to achieve economic self–sufficiency through support services, labor–market driven credentialing, and employment
  • Meet the needs of job seekers and businesses who engage in the public workforce system (including partner programs)

The concept for the Vision is a departure over prior workforce development planning frameworks for federal programs in Massachusetts. Over the span of the Workforce Investment Act (WIA), the Commonwealth continued to oversee and operate federal programs separately within the agency most directly tied to the federal funding partner. The WIOA partners are embarking on a new concept to organize resources (staff, supports etc.) around key job seeker populations and business development using a “pathways” models that will encourage separate agencies to wrap resources, staff and supports around the customer base.

The term “pathway” is utilized in many policy debates and program operations. Through the WIOA Planning Process, stakeholders worked through the idea of creating pathways to organize services (not just sector initiatives) similar to the generalized model in Chart 25 developed by CLASP. The Steering Committee has worked with stakeholders to create “service flow charts” for specific populations (including but NOT limited to youth, low–skilled (including Title II), low–income (including TANF and SNAP), individuals with disabilities (including Vocational Rehabilitation), older workers (including SCSEP), homeless, veterans, etc.). As described under further sections and in the draft statewide Memorandum of Understanding (MOU), state partners will work with representatives in local areas to define and build out similar pathways appropriate to regions.

See the MA State Plan posted at www.mass.gov/massworkforce/state–plan for CLASP graphic depicting the "Three Core Features of a Career Pathway"

The concept of organizing public services along a pathway continuum requires a new level of communication, referrals, staff cross–training, information technology tools to improve coordination, and overall focus on using data and information to track an individual’s progress into other programs not administered by the organization that was the first point of contact for a participant (student, consumer, job seeker, client etc.). In addition, the ability to ensure that an individual moves into a next step implies that while individuals are engaged more strategically to produce stronger education/job/wage outcomes, less individuals will be served collectively.

Aligning services for individuals to ensure access to career pathway supports limits the concept of “universal access” or open enrollment to ensure that resources are prioritized or reserved for individuals referred in from other support services. For example, students who achieve a high school equivalency credential through Title II and need to transition to skill training and certification to achieve employment may be prioritized for an ITA through a Career Center thus limiting the pool of ITAs for the general OSCC population. Or, job seekers working with the OSCC who are focused on employment and develop a Career Action Plan that identifies a need for Title II adult basic education’s ESOL support may be prioritized for enrollment in programs (currently faced with existing wait lists) based on the agreement between programs to prioritize career pathway development and employment in their region.