Located in:
- II. Strategic Elements
The Unified or Combined State Plan must include a Strategic Planning Elements section that analyzes the State’s current economic environment and identifies the State’s overall vision for its workforce development system. The required elements in this section allow the State to develop data-driven goals for preparing an educated and skilled workforce and to identify successful strategies for aligning workforce development programs. Unless otherwise noted, all Strategic Planning Elements apply to Combined State Plan partner programs included in the plan as well as to core programs.
- a. Economic, Workforce, and Workforce Development Activities Analysis
The Unified or Combined State Plan must include an analysis of the economic conditions, economic development strategies, and labor market in which the State’s workforce system and programs will operate.
- a. Economic, Workforce, and Workforce Development Activities Analysis
II. a. 1. B. Workforce Analysis (B.I - B.IV)
The Unified or Combined State Plan must include an analysis of the current workforce, including individuals with barriers to employment, as defined in section 3 of WIOA.* This population must include individuals with disabilities among other groups** in the State and across regions identified by the State. This includes: Individuals with barriers to employment include displaced homemakers; low-income individuals; Indians, Alaska Natives, and Native Hawaiians; individuals with disabilities, including youth who are individuals with disabilities; older individuals; ex-offenders; homeless individuals, or homeless children and youths; youth who are in or have aged out of the foster care system; individuals who are English language learners, individuals who have low levels of literacy, and individuals facing substantial cultural barriers; farmworkers (as defined at section 167(i) of WIOA and Training and Employment Guidance Letter No. 35-14); individuals within 2 years of exhausting lifetime eligibility under the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program; single parents (including single pregnant women); and long-term unemployed individuals. ** Veterans, unemployed workers, and youth, and others that the State may identify.
i. Employment and Unemployment
Provide an analysis of current employment and unemployment data, including labor force participation rates, and trends in the State.
ii. Labor Market Trends
Provide an analysis of key labor market trends, including across existing industries and occupations.iii. Education and Skill Levels of the Workforce
Provide an analysis of the educational and skill levels of the workforce.
iv. Skill Gaps
Describe apparent ‘skill gaps’.
Current Narrative:
Unemployment and Labor Force
Unemployment in Massachusetts has declined steadily from a high of 8.8 percent at the end of 2009. As of December 2015, the Massachusetts unemployment rate stood at 4.9 percent with an estimated 174,600 residents unemployed and actively seeking work.
Chart 10– Massachusetts Unemployment Rate 2010 through 2015
This chart/graphic could not be included in the State Plan submission the federal portal. Please review the missing information by viewing the copy of Massachusetts State Plan posted on: mass.gov/massworkforce/state–plan.
The estimates for the numbers of residents unemployed have declined while the estimates for employed residents were increasing. At the same time the shares of the working age population participating in the labor force, the sum of employed and unemployed, were gradually increasing. However, since July 2015 estimates indicate participation in the labor force has been declining, with some increases in the number of residents who are not seeking a job, but would like a job. The share of employed residents also includes some “hidden unemployment” that is, residents who are involuntarily employed part–time but want full–time work. Those who are not in the labor force but want a job along with those unemployed and actively seeking work represent just over 300,000 residents, many of whom may have barriers to employment for current jobs. In December 2015, the labor force participation rate was at 64.5, the lowest level in the data series that goes back to 1976.
View of the working Age Population
The estimated number of Massachusetts residents employed reached an all–time high of 3.47 million in May of 2015. By November the number had dropped to 3.39 million. However, a percentage of this population includes individuals who are working part–time but are seeking full time work. In looking at BLS’s alternative measures of unemployment, the U–6 measure captures the estimates for total number of unemployed, all marginally attached workers and individuals employed part–time for economic reasons. These roughly 175,000 involuntary part time workers may have a gap in skills, be missing a credential or have some other barrier preventing them from gaining full–time employment. Also from the chart below we see that while the labor force has grown, there remains a sizable amount of the working age population who are not currently looking for work. The BLS indicates that on a national level the primary reasons people report for leaving the labor force, aside from those who have simply stopped working, are attendance in school, illness or disability and retirement.
Chart 11: Estimates of Residents Labor Force Status
This chart/graphic could not be included in the State Plan submission the federal portal. Please review the missing information by viewing the copy of Massachusetts State Plan posted on: mass.gov/massworkforce/state–plan.
Regional Differences in the Workforce & Labor Force across the Commonwealth
The Greater Boston region is a major factor in the state’s overall unemployment rate. Chart 12 indicates that this region not only has the lowest unemployment rate but also the largest labor force, almost double that of the next largest region in terms of labor force, the Southeast Region.
The Cape and Islands region exhibits a higher unemployment rate than other regions due to the seasonal variations in employment. Immigration and increases in seasonal jobs to the region in summer months result in lower unemployment than indicated by the annual average unemployment rate.
Chart 12: Workforce Area Regions: 2015 Annual Average
| Workforce Area Region | LaborForce | Employment | Unemployment | Rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Berkshire | 65,608 | 61,950 | 3,658 | 5.6 |
| Cape and the Islands | 127,607 | 119,574 | 8,034 | 6.3 |
| Central MA | 438,793 | 415,758 | 23,035 | 5.2 |
| Greater Boston Metropolitan | 1,308,895 | 1,255,748 | 53,147 | 4.1 |
| Northeast Region | 555,353 | 526,681 | 28,672 | 5.2 |
| Pioneer Valley | 355,229 | 334,144 | 21,085 | 5.9 |
| Southeast Region | 718,469 | 678,254 | 40,215 | 5.6 |
Source: DCS/BLS Local Area Unemployment Statistics
Education Levels
Massachusetts benefits from being the most well educated state in the nation. The twelve month average labor force education attainment by residents age 25 plus from 2012 to 2014 demonstrates that both the majority of the working age population and the labor force possess a bachelor’s degree or higher (i.e., 43% and 50%, respectively). This education segment grew by 45,800 residents since 2012, more than any other educational group. High school graduates are the second most prevalent education level among the Commonwealth’s working age population, but the segment’s population growth has remained relatively flat. This group is the only educational segment to decline in labor force members over the two–year period.
Chart 13– Educational Attainment Level of the Massachusetts Age 25+ Labor Force
Employment Status Pop. 25+ Years by Education Attainment
| 2012 vs 2015 Change & Growth_ | Less than High School | High School Graduate | Some College or Associate’s | Bachelor or Higher |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Labor Force | 157,700 | 683,100 | 627,200 | 1,635,900 |
| Change in Labor Force | 22,200 | –42,500 | –12,200 | 127,500 |
| % Growth Rate LF | 16.40% | –5.90% | –1.90% | 8.50% |
| Share of Labor Force | 5.10% | 22.00% | 20.20% | 52.70% |
| Underlying Data | ||||
| 2012 Annual Average | 135,500 | 725,600 | 639,400 | 1,508,400 |
| 2015 Annual Average | 157,700 | 683,100 | 627,200 | 1,635,900 |
Source: BLS Current Population Statistics
MassINC & The UMass Donahue Institute predict that for the first time since data have been collected, “Massachusetts will end a decade with fewer prime working age college–educated residents than it [started] with.” With projections indicating a diminishing population of bachelor’s level educated individuals seen in Chart 14, addressing labor demand for all industries could be impacted, not just those associated with STEM–related occupations.
Chart 14 Massachusetts Projected Rate of Change in Population with Bachelor’s Degree 1990 – 2030
This chart/graphic could not be included in the State Plan submission the federal portal. Please review the missing information by viewing the copy of Massachusetts State Plan posted on: mass.gov/massworkforce/state–plan.
Individuals with Barriers to Employment
Certain groups of job seekers continue to see higher than average annual unemployment rates, between 7 and 12 percent, despite a December 2015 unemployment rate of 4.9 percent. The Baker Administration created a task force on Economic Opportunity for Populations Facing Chronically High Rates of Unemployment to lay out a strategic plan that addresses chronic unemployment among specific target populations including African Americans, Hispanic or Latino Americans, certain groups of veterans, and persons with disabilities and Native Americans. The Task Force summarized a list of barriers that individuals often face in the employment process which can be found in attachment B at the end of this document.
Chart 15: Unemployment rates by Massachusetts Target Populations
Massachusetts 2014 Target Populations Unemployment Rates
Gulf–era II Veterans 9.0%
Black African American 10.7%
Hispanic / Latino 11.0%
Person with a Disability 15.1%
Native American 19.7%
Source: Governor Baker’s Task Force on Persons Facing Chronically High Rates of Unemployment, BLS
Individuals with Disabilities
The most recent information specific to individuals with disabilities from the American Community Survey shows that for Massachusetts in 2014 the number of working–age people with disabilities was 399,206. Of those, 35.5 percent were employed and 19.4 percent were employed full time. At the same time, the number of those who were not working but actively looking for work was 7.3 percent. An estimated 57.2 percent were not in the labor force.
As can be seen in Chart 16 individuals with cognitive disabilities make up the majority of all three groups. It is even more predominant for those actively looking for work, with over 1/3 of this group is estimated to have a cognitive disability. The term Cognitive Disability is a broad category that encompasses intellectual and development disabilities, and can include diagnoses such as Downs Syndrome, Dyslexia and Traumatic Brian Injury.
Chart 16 – Disability Category by Labor Force Cohort
| _ | Employed | Unemployed | Not in the Laborforce |
|---|---|---|---|
| With a hearing difficulty | 40,879 | 5,401 | 32,498 |
| With a vision difficulty | 26,972 | 4,362 | 35,302 |
| With a cognitive difficulty | 51,295 | 15,751 | 126,885 |
| With an ambulatory difficulty | 45,787 | 8,836 | 122,462 |
| With a self–care difficulty | 13,107 | 3,375 | 57,100 |
| With an independent living difficulty | 26,577 | 7,885 | 109,501 |
| _ | 204,617 | 45,610 | 483,748 |
Source: U.S. Census American Community Survey 2014
Age Demographics of the Labor force
When viewed by age cohorts, the working age population and labor force exhibit distinct patterns. As indicated in Chart 17, looking at labor force participation rates by age groups, the rates are highest among 25 to 54 year–olds. This age group which represents the largest share of the labor force also has the strongest attachment to the labor market with labor force participation rates above 80 percent. Looking back to 2005, those aged 25 to 34 had a participation rate of 82.2 percent and now have a rate of 85.2 percent in 2015. This age group has the largest number of residents in the labor force. Those 35 to 44 years old also have a slightly higher labor force participation rate in 2015, 83.9 percent compared to 83.1 percent in 2005. At the same time, the rates for those ages 45 to 54, middle age workers, who make up one of the larger labor pools of the working age population, have declined across the board in all labor market measures since 2005. The group is much smaller in both population and labor force than in 2005.
Teens, young adults and seniors all exhibit lower labor force participation rates compared to other cohorts, most likely to due to educational pursuits or retirement. Both the teen population and the labor force participation have been declining since 2005. At the same time the population for 20 to 24 year olds has increased with a slight drop in participation by 2015.
Older workers (55–64) make up the third largest population share. This population’s labor force participation rate is comparatively high amongst the other cohorts percentages suggesting older workers are delaying retirement. However since this category makes up such a large part of the overall population, when this group does transition out of the labor force, it may exacerbate the current tightness in the Massachusetts labor market.
Chart 17: Working Age Population and Labor Force by Age Group, December 2015
| Age Group | Population | Labor Force | LFPR | Out of LF |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Age 16–19 | 329,100 | 118,200 | 35.9% | 210,900 |
| Age 20–24 | 526,200 | 364,000 | 69.2% | 162,200 |
| Age 25–34 | 979,700 | 834,500 | 85.2% | 145,200 |
| Age 35–44 | 779,200 | 653,700 | 83.9% | 125,500 |
| Age 45–54 | 909,500 | 739,500 | 81.3% | 170,000 |
| Age 55–64 | 922,300 | 644,600 | 69.9% | 277,700 |
| Age 65+ | 1,046,700 | 231,700 | 22.1% | 815,000 |
| Total: Age 16+ | 5,492,700 | 3,586,200 | 65.3% | 1,906,500 |
Skills Gap
With a tightening labor market, the importance of addressing skill gaps in our workforce becomes greater. A month into his term, Governor Baker created the Workforce Skills Cabinet, composed of the secretaries for Labor and Workforce Development, Education, and Housing and Economic Development, to gather ideas to strengthen the pipeline to employment. This cabinet is charged with finding a way to help people who are looking for work get the skills they need to fill the jobs that exist in the Commonwealth, and to help employers find qualified workers. Since early March 2015, the Workforce Skills Cabinet has met with business leaders and educators around the state to find ways to create partnerships between the employer community, the state workforce system and education.
To provide some indicators of which occupations may be experiencing a potential skill gap, Massachusetts conducted an analysis of demand for jobs versus the potential supply of workers with the skills needed to meet that demand.
Methodology
Using a six month period from February to July 2015, data from the Massachusetts Department of Unemployment Assistance’s monthly survey of Unemployment Insurance (UI) claimants were compared to The Conference Board Help Wanted Online Data Series® real–time job vacancies by occupation. The six digit Standard Occupational Code (SOC) title associated with the UI Claimant’s last occupation of employment was compared to advertised job openings with the same SOC.
Wage levels from the most recent Occupational Employment Statistics (OES) are included. To gauge the level of experience and training required for each occupation, the SOC was matched to O*NET Job Zones. These zones are clusters of similar occupations based on the education, related experience and on–the–job training typically needed to perform the job. They are categorized as follows:
Job Zone 5: Occupations that need extensive preparation Examples: Lawyers, Industrial Engineers and Physical Therapists
Job Zone 4: Occupations that need considerable preparation Examples: Computer System Analysts, Teachers and Accountants
Job Zone 3: Occupations that need medium preparation Examples: Medical Assistants, Registered Nurses and Computer Support Specialists
Job Zone 2: Occupations that need some preparation Example: Truck Driver, Receptionists and Retail Salespersons
Job Zone 1: Occupations that little to no preparation Examples: Waiters/Waitresses, Cashiers and Short Order Cooks
More information on O*NET Job Zones: https://www.onetonline.org/help/online/zones
Occupations that did not have a threshold of at least 50 posted vacancies from February to July 2015 had median wages below $25,000 annually and were in Job Zones 1 or 2 were excluded from the analysis.
For Job Zones 3, 4 and 5, the top 20 occupations in terms of posted vacancies were listed. Each occupation listed has a ratio calculated of the number of UI Claimants for every 100 job vacancies posted. This ratio serves as an approximation of a potential skills gap, with a lower figure indicating a higher gap.
A second metric used compares the volume of posted job vacancies to the count of current employment in an occupation from OES data in an attempt to gauge the urgency of relative demand. By adding these two figures, we estimate what a possible “full employment” number would be for an occupation if all the posted vacancies were actually filled. The number of posted job vacancies was divided by the “full employment” figure to generate a percentage that illustrates possible demand relative to current employment levels.
These two indices, job demand relative to current employment levels and the ratio of available claimants to job vacancies, serve as indicators of possible occupationally associated skill gaps and their level of demand.
Chart 18 –Potential Skill Gaps in Extensive Preparation Occupations
| Occupation | Feb–July 2015 Claims | Feb–July 2015 Job Postings | Job Count | Job Count as % of full employment | Claimant per 100 posting | Entry Wage | Median Wage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Medical Scientists, Except Epidemiologists | 309 | 5,327 | 10,000 | 35% | 6 | $47,900 | $87,000 |
| Medical and Health Services Managers | 831 | 4,001 | 10,600 | 27% | 21 | $67,250 | $96,950 |
| Physical Therapists | 47 | 2,429 | 7,300 | 25% | 2 | $64,860 | $82,540 |
| Speech–Language Pathologists | 44 | 1,875 | 3,660 | 34% | 2 | $56,270 | $76,910 |
| Mental Health and Substance Abuse Social Workers | 188 | 1,783 | 5,170 | 26% | 11 | $27,030 | $42,730 |
| Occupational Therapists | 34 | 1,314 | 4,490 | 23% | 3 | $57,840 | $80,420 |
| Lawyers | 401 | 1,592 | 17,180 | 8% | 25 | $69,420 | $124,780 |
| Educational, Guidance, School, and Vocational Counselors | 204 | 1,168 | 6,910 | 14% | 17 | $38,230 | $60,920 |
| Education Administrators, Elementary and Secondary School | 139 | 1,080 | 6,810 | 14% | 13 | $72,240 | $98,450 |
| Education Administrators, Postsecondary | 234 | 1,044 | 9,950 | 9% | 22 | $58,790 | $85,060 |
| Operations Research Analysts | 113 | 784 | 3,180 | 20% | 14 | $45,650 | $78,000 |
| Community and Social Service Specialists, All Other | 141 | 738 | 1,710 | 30% | 19 | $24,800 | $34,560 |
| Architectural and Engineering Managers | 227 | 777 | 6,440 | 11% | 29 | $95,260 | $135,940 |
| Physician Assistants | 35 | 536 | 2,610 | 17% | 7 | $72,810 | $101,040 |
| Computer and Information Research Scientists | 26 | 518 | 820 | 39% | 5 | $67,420 | $100,020 |
| Mental Health Counselors | 251 | 697 | 7,900 | 8% | 36 | $27,520 | $36,640 |
| Nurse Practitioners | 55 | 500 | 5,080 | 9% | 11 | $80,470 | $103,070 |
| Natural Sciences Managers | 113 | 522 | 3,050 | 15% | 22 | $107,030 | $163,810 |
| Healthcare Social Workers | 94 | 466 | 11,090 | 4% | 20 | $39,820 | $58,000 |
| Health Specialties Teachers, Postsecondary | 41 | 370 | 5,000 | 7% | 11 | $57,440 | $102,230 |
Source: DUA Unemployment Insurance Claimant Data, Conference Board Help Wanted Online Data Series® real–time job vacancies
Specialized healthcare professions make up the most difficult to find and highest relative demand occupations in Job Zone Five, and as expected, pay a higher than average wage. Speech Language Pathologists, Physical Therapists and Occupational Therapists in particular only have 2–3 available claimants for every 100 posted vacancies and OES data indicates slightly higher than average median annual wages at $76,910, $82,540 and $80,420 respectively. Computer and Information Research Scientists have the highest relative demand and a current employment count is lower than other occupations, which may indicate difficulty finding individuals skilled in this type of work.
Chart 19 Potential Skill Gaps in Considerable Preparation Occupations
| Occupation | Feb–July 2015 Claims | Feb–July 2015 Job Postings | Job Count | Job Count as % of full employment | Claimants per 100 postings | Entry Wage | Median Wage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Software Developers, Applications | 734 | 13,169 | 26,900 | 33% | 6 | $71,770 | $104,460 |
| Marketing Managers | 1,330 | 9,505 | 9,470 | 50% | 14 | $81,060 | $127,940 |
| Network and Computer Systems Administrators | 393 | 6,781 | 9,730 | 41% | 6 | $58,950 | $81,390 |
| Social and Human Service Assistants | 678 | 6,856 | 17,790 | 28% | 10 | $23,350 | $31,110 |
| Computer Systems Analysts | 453 | 6,597 | 15,850 | 29% | 7 | $59,550 | $85,180 |
| Management Analysts | 273 | 5,757 | 21,000 | 22% | 5 | $57,840 | $88,500 |
| Industrial Engineers | 117 | 4,951 | 7,150 | 41% | 2 | $64,310 | $90,160 |
| Market Research Analysts and Marketing Specialists | 333 | 4,311 | 17,220 | 20% | 8 | $41,120 | $66,070 |
| Sales Representatives, Wholesale and Manufacturing, Except Technical and Scientific Products | 1,173 | 4,708 | 26,680 | 15% | 25 | $41,420 | $66,920 |
| Human Resources Specialists | 403 | 3,534 | 13,140 | 21% | 11 | $41,560 | $61,810 |
| Managers, All Other | 1,190 | 4,160 | 5,600 | 43% | 29 | $65,920 | $110,320 |
| Public Relations Specialists | 133 | 3,097 | 7,000 | 31% | 4 | $38,380 | $57,170 |
| Sales Representatives, Services, All Other | 905 | 3,501 | 19,990 | 15% | 26 | $37,270 | $68,090 |
| First–Line Supervisors of Non–Retail Sales Workers | 112 | 2,620 | 5,740 | 31% | 4 | $51,900 | $86,240 |
| Sales Representatives, Wholesale and Manufacturing, Technical and Scientific Products | 562 | 3,034 | 14,680 | 17% | 19 | $53,970 | $84,180 |
| Financial Analysts | 312 | 2,740 | 16,640 | 14% | 11 | $54,950 | $84,220 |
| Computer Programmers | 194 | 2,575 | 8,440 | 23% | 8 | $57,490 | $85,870 |
| Elementary School Teachers, Except Special Education | 392 | 2,371 | 26,770 | 8% | 17 | $49,140 | $69,810 |
| Secondary School Teachers, Except Special and Career/Technical Education | 502 | 2,413 | 24,000 | 9% | 21 | $50,640 | $70,290 |
| Human Resources Managers | 497 | 2,301 | 4,220 | 35% | 22 | $70,660 | $110,100 |
Source: DUA Unemployment Insurance Claimant Data, Conference Board Help Wanted Online Data Series® real–time job vacancies
In Job Zone Four we again see stem–related occupations constituting the majority of the Higher Demand and Higher Gap quadrant. Included are Industrial Engineers, Network Administrators, Software Developers and Computer Systems Analysts on the cusp, providing a range of median wages from $81,390 to $104,460. Management and Supervisory occupations also figure prominently in this particular zone, signaling a possible need for managerial and leadership skills.
Chart 20 Potential Skill Gaps in Medium Preparation Occupations February to July 2015
| Occupation | Feb–July 2015 Claims | Feb–July 2015 Job Postings | Job Count | Job Count as % of full employment | Claimants per 100 | Entry Wage | Median Wage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Web Developers | 164 | 7,133 | 3,960 | 64% | 2 | $48,210 | $74,080 |
| Merchandise Displayers and Window Trimmers | 144 | 1,798 | 1,470 | 55% | 8 | $19,260 | $27,210 |
| Real Estate Sales Agents | 27 | 1,533 | 2,600 | 37% | 2 | $33,370 | $55,680 |
| Computer User Support Specialists | 787 | 6,854 | 16,490 | 29% | 11 | $39,230 | $58,430 |
| Executive Secretaries and Executive Administrative Assistants | 1,583 | 10,328 | 26,670 | 28% | 15 | $39,810 | $54,800 |
| First–Line Supervisors of Construction Trades and Extraction Workers | 1,517 | 3,285 | 8,860 | 27% | 46 | $50,280 | $72,400 |
| Bus and Truck Mechanics and Diesel Engine Specialists | 111 | 1,179 | 3,210 | 27% | 9 | $38,510 | $50,020 |
| First–Line Supervisors of Mechanics, Installers, and Repairers | 367 | 2,246 | 9,120 | 20% | 16 | $48,220 | $69,860 |
| Dental Assistants | 309 | 1,534 | 7,200 | 18% | 20 | $31,260 | $41,480 |
| Preschool Teachers, Except Special Education | 1,056 | 2,819 | 13,400 | 17% | 37 | $24,410 | $32,430 |
| Maintenance and Repair Workers, General | 1,246 | 4,617 | 22,430 | 17% | 27 | $29,430 | $42,530 |
| First–Line Supervisors of Office and Administrative Support Workers | 821 | 7,304 | 35,820 | 17% | 11 | $39,470 | $57,020 |
| Registered Nurses | 1,065 | 14,322 | 79,910 | 15% | 7 | $59,080 | $81,380 |
| Hairdressers, Hairstylists, and Cosmetologists | 196 | 1,752 | 10,750 | 14% | 11 | $18,850 | $28,490 |
| Medical Secretaries | 737 | 3,195 | 20,880 | 13% | 23 | $30,840 | $38,290 |
| Licensed Practical and Licensed Vocational Nurses | 467 | 2,258 | 16,100 | 12% | 21 | $43,150 | $53,640 |
| Bookkeeping, Accounting, and Auditing Clerks | 1,127 | 5,341 | 38,870 | 12% | 21 | $29,590 | $42,190 |
| Medical Assistants | 714 | 1,795 | 16,100 | 10% | 40 | $29,260 | $36,000 |
| Secretaries and Administrative Assistants, Except Legal, Medical, and Executive | 1,061 | 3,565 | 45,310 | 7% | 30 | $29,980 | $41,920 |
| Teacher Assistants | 788 | 2,228 | 35,070 | 6% | 35 | $20,040 | $28,350 |
Source: DUA Unemployment Insurance Claimant Data, Conference Board Help Wanted Online Data Series® real–time job vacancies
While there are few occupations in the Higher Demand, Higher Gap quadrant overall, Web Developers are clearly a critical area. This occupation has highest demand in relation to current employment of any occupation included in the analysis and indicates only two available claimants for every 100 posted vacancies. At $74,080 annually web developer pays well above other occupations in this job zone.
Merchandise Displayer is an interesting and likely under–considered occupation that requires a unique combination of skills that includes the use of crafting tools, digital literacy and management skills. However, median wages for this are below average at $27,210 annually and probably reflect this more as part time work.
Nursing occupations along with other health professions figure prominently in the Lower Demand, Higher Gap quadrant and should continue to be areas of focus for training, despite the higher percentages of current employment.
When considering occupations that may have potential skill gaps overall without excluding professions by job zones or wages, we do see several Job Zone 2 occupations in the chart below. While there may be limited supply of UI claimants in these occupations, again it is probably due to the fact they offer lower wages or that these are more likely to be part time opportunities.
Chart 21 Occupations with Overall Higher Demand and Higher skill gaps Occupation
| Occupation | Feb to July 2015 Claims | Feb to July 2015 Job Postings | Employment Count | Demand as % of full employment | Claimants per 100 Postings | Entry Wage | Median Wage | Job Zone |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Software Developers, Applications | 734 | 13,169 | 26,900 | 33% | 5.6 | $71,770 | $104,460 | 4 |
| Web Developers | 164 | 7,133 | 3,960 | 64% | 2.3 | $48,210 | $74,080 | 3 |
| Network and Computer Systems Administrators | 393 | 6,781 | 9,730 | 41% | 5.8 | $58,950 | $81,390 | 4 |
| Social and Human Service Assistants | 678 | 6,856 | 17,790 | 28% | 9.9 | $23,350 | $31,110 | 4 |
| Computer Systems Analysts | 453 | 6,597 | 15,850 | 29% | 6.9 | $59,550 | $85,180 | 4 |
| Medical Scientists, Except Epidemiologists | 309 | 5,327 | 10,000 | 35% | 5.8 | $47,900 | $87,000 | 5 |
| Industrial Engineers | 117 | 4,951 | 7,150 | 41% | 2.4 | $64,310 | $90,160 | 4 |
| Public Relations Specialists | 133 | 3,097 | 7,000 | 31% | 4.3 | $38,380 | $57,170 | 4 |
| Demonstrators and Product Promoters | 51 | 2,710 | 1,480 | 65% | 1.9 | $20,900 | $32,870 | 2 |
| First–Line Supervisors of Non–Retail Sales Workers | 112 | 2,620 | 5,740 | 31% | 4.3 | $51,900 | $86,240 | 4 |
| Physical Therapists | 47 | 2,429 | 7,300 | 25% | 1.9 | $64,860 | $82,540 | 5 |
| Computer Programmers | 194 | 2,575 | 8,440 | 23% | 7.5 | $57,490 | $85,870 | 4 |
| Speech–Language Pathologists | 44 | 1,875 | 3,660 | 34% | 2.3 | $56,270 | $76,910 | 5 |
| Merchandise Displayers and Window Trimmers | 144 | 1,798 | 1,470 | 55% | 8.0 | $19,260 | $27,210 | 3 |
| Information Security Analysts | 37 | 1,684 | 2,630 | 39% | 2.2 | $50,790 | $84,800 | 4 |
| Telemarketers | 127 | 1,718 | 3,690 | 32% | 7.4 | $20,820 | $27,710 | 2 |
| Real Estate Sales Agents | 27 | 1,533 | 2,600 | 37% | 1.8 | $33,370 | $55,680 | 3 |
| Database Administrators | 119 | 1,550 | 3,730 | 29% | 7.7 | $53,520 | $79,560 | 4 |
| Occupational Therapists | 34 | 1,314 | 4,490 | 23% | 2.6 | $57,840 | $80,420 | 5 |
| Bus and Truck Mechanics and Diesel Engine Specialists | 111 | 1,179 | 3,210 | 27% | 9.4 | $38,510 | $50,020 | 3 |
Source: DUA Unemployment Insurance Claimant Data, Conference Board Help Wanted Online Data Series® real–time job vacancies
Regional Differences
There are some minor variations across the Commonwealth in skill gap indicators. The Greater Boston Region demonstrates a higher demand and higher gap for Social and Human Service Assistants in Job Zone 4. Approximate annual median wages in the Boston area for this occupation are $30,070. A relative low annual wage and high level of experience required combined with high level of preparation may contribute to a gap between supply and demand in this occupation. Outside of Web Developers, this region does not display the higher demand and higher skill gap for IT professions compared to the state as a whole, possibly due to the high concentration of the Professional and Technical Services industry in Greater Boston.
There are indicators of a potential skill gaps needed in education professions in the Cape and Islands region, where Elementary and Secondary Teachers are showing the highest concentration of relative demand with a lack of available claimants that are not seen elsewhere in the Commonwealth.
The Metro South West region has some of the same critical IT occupational skill gaps seen statewide and additionally has the highest relative demand for IT Security Analysts, a newly emerging occupation in demand, with little in the way of potential talent available.
Overall the cursory indications are that IT and health care occupation clusters, and to a lesser extent management, are areas of concern in regard to a potential skills gap in the Commonwealth. Across the three higher preparation job zones, these occupational areas concentrate heavily in STEM–related fields, more so than other occupations in Massachusetts.
Overall Labor Market and Workforce Indications
Statewide, and in varying degrees among local workforce areas, the Commonwealth’s labor markets are exhibiting unprecedented tightness between employer demands for labor and the supplies of unemployed jobseekers and employed potential job changers.
Massachusetts’s population projections and educational attainment rates portend a potential shortfall in the supply of labor needed to sustain the state’s leading industries, in particular Health Care and Education, and Professional, Scientific, & Technical Services industries which are critical to the statewide economy. Regional differentiation in employment, demographic and job growth trends call out additional priority industries/occupations for specific regions. At the same time, while not concentrated in any specific industry, anticipated Computer and IT labor shortfalls will have a wide impact on the economy given their distribution across industries.
The existing and projected demographic patterns for the Massachusetts workforce will not solve the workforce gaps emerging in the post–recession economy. The Massachusetts workforce currently has the highest concentration of 4–year degreed workers in the nation, but that trend is predicted to change based on the expected outflow of the labor force (baby boomers) and the size of college graduation cohorts. The Massachusetts population is only growing due to the inflow of immigrants, which may not be able to replace the skill loss of the baby boomers. Instead, it presents a significant need to build capacity in ESOL and “credentialing” focused on high–demand career pathways.
These trends signal the need to focus on three major challenges:
1) Talent retention of the existing workforce, especially individuals with STEM related credentials
2) Creating career pathways for those individuals who are not currently in the workforce for a number of reasons, from difficulty accessing adequate childcare, barriers to employment, or lack of education and skill related to the job market.
3) Maximizing the existing labor force by accurately matching talent, training dollars, and new education and training options aligned with business demands. Workforce strategies need to align with demand in order to bolster talent pipelines, especially in STEM related areas.