U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.

Https

Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock () or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

2 Year Modification

Plan: New York PYs 2018-2019
Combined Plan C

Section: WIOA State Plan Common Elements

Narrative: III. a. 2. D.

Published
Located in:
  • III. Operational Planning Elements
    The Unified or Combined State Plan must include an Operational Planning Elements section that support the State’s strategy and the system-wide vision described in Section II.(c) above. Unless otherwise noted, all Operational Planning Elements apply to Combined State Plan partner programs included in the plan as well as to core programs. This section must include—
    • a. State Strategy Implementation
      The Unified or Combined State Plan must include—
      • 2. Implementation of State Strategy
        Describe how the lead State agency with responsibility for the administration of each core program or a Combined Plan partner program included in this plan will implement the State’s Strategies identified in Section II(c). above. This must include a description of—

III. a. 2. D. Coordination, Alignment and Provision of Services to Employers

Describe how the entities carrying out the respective core programs, any Combined State Plan partner program included in this plan, required and optional one-stop partner programs will coordinate activities and resources to provide comprehensive, high-quality services to employers to meet their current and projected workforce needs. The activities described shall conform to the statutory requirements of each program.

Current Narrative:

Coordination, Alignment, and Provision of Services to Businesses

Mission

The mission of New York Works Business Services is to provide business customers with a competitive advantage in the labor market. This mission is executed through a holistic business-centric understanding of the customer, rather than the compliance-centric employer view of a business (i.e., how can we help the business versus how can the employer help us).

Business Engagement Framework

The New York Works business engagement framework begins with referring to the customer as a “business” rather than “employer” and continues with understanding the business customer’s needs relative to its health. Figure 1 illustrates NYS’s business engagement framework, and how the “health” of the business determines service strategy and service type. Understanding where a business is on a “business health” spectrum allows targeted outreach with meaningful services.

For emerging, growing, and stable businesses, Business Services provides Job Development services such as customized recruitment assistance, hiring and training incentives, and/or other services in the Business Services toolkit. For businesses classified as retention, the Shared Work program reduces the need for layoffs by reducing staff work hours and supplementing wages with partial unemployment insurance benefits.

Rapid Response focuses on reemployment services for any workers impacted by layoffs.

Figure 1 - Business Engagement Framework

Strategy, Goals, and Implementation of the Business Engagement Framework

The Business Services strategy is to continuously increase exposure within the business community and the number of businesses receiving services to advance job development. This requires setting goals that support far-reaching and sustainable engagement with the business community, deploying resources to achieve these goals, and setting metrics to measure success. These goals include:

• Increasing visibility within the business community;

• Increasing the number of businesses listing jobs with the NYS Job Bank/Jobs Express;

• Increasing the number of job seeker resumes available for search in NYTalent;

• Increasing the amount and efficacy of job matching; and

• Generating positive reciprocal messaging with the business community.

The operational strategy for business-centric service delivery is to build business relationships that will generate a conduit for future services, and ultimately produce job seeker placements.

The resources used to support this strategy include:

• Conducting an outreach campaign, targeting various business associations, that provides presentations on Business Services and Rapid Response services with a customized regional approach;

• Expanding existing lead generation methods through development of a business survey that gauges interest in services and utilizes lead generation tools such as business intelligence from business associates, Dun & Bradstreet data, and current events/media; and

• Expanding the Business Services staff role as account executives servicing business accounts, monitoring services received, and engaging with businesses to ensure job openings are matched to qualified candidates.

Cultivating relationships with businesses is a multi-stage process beginning with an initial contact to identify business needs and evolving to meet specific business needs. Three elements central to building and forging these connections are daily staff outreach goals, the Priority Jobs Initiative, and regional performance measures.

The NYS Department of Labor’s Business Services unit continues to expand the network of businesses by requiring staff to engage five businesses each day with the goal of providing a quality service. Each day, staff reviews the new job openings on Jobs Express to identify which hiring business have not recently been serviced. This has proven to be an effective way for staff to foster positive relationships with businesses, and connect job seekers to employment opportunities. Staff connected over 54,000 times with more than 24,000 unique businesses in calendar years 2014 and 2015, resulting in an increase in the number of businesses receiving services. In calendar year 2016 staff engaged 17,536 businesses; and 13,802 in 2017.

The Priority Jobs Initiative is a concentrated effort by staff to build ongoing relationships with businesses to provide job seeking customers with a competitive advantage in obtaining employment.

Priority jobs are generally defined as:

• In-demand and quality jobs;

• Job openings that need to be filled immediately;

• Job openings that align with the Career Center talent pool; and/or

• Job openings from businesses with existing relationships.

Job orders that meet this definition are shared with a Career Center Match Team responsible for identifying candidates and securing resumes from those who are interested. Business Services then shares the resumes with the businesses for consideration.

The Priority Jobs model engages the Career Center staff to take a larger role in the front-end matching process of job order fulfillment. This shift enables Business Services staff to function as account executives focused on building relationships with businesses to provide more intensive services and capture placement data, and to follow-up at regular intervals to ensure customer satisfaction.

Beginning in PY2015, NYSDOL established a new Business Services Customer Service Indicator (CSI) for the combined WIOA/Wagner-Peyser program. Specifically, the measure was to effect that 95% of businesses who receive referrals on staff entered job orders receive a follow up contact. The new measure was designed to ensure that the needs of business customers are met and to help build the NYS’s business customer base. This business customer follow-up has now become a regular, integral part of NYSDOL's business engagement. It continues to be important for ensuring the quality of services we provide and for fostering long-term, reciprocal relationships with businesses.

Regional Sector Based Approaches

All regions developed successful, long-standing, informal relationships between NYSDOL and LWDA Business Services staff. NYS sought to build on these partnerships by creating Regional Business Service Teams (RBST) to align services with regional strategies across all levels of the workforce system. A number of the REDCs already have sectoral workforce strategies in place and NYS has embarked upon specific regional sector strategies for the health care workforce in NYC and Central regions. The State has also utilized sector strategies in advanced manufacturing in Southern Tier and Western regions. Regional strategies were also utilized when developing the Unemployment Strikeforce Initiative to meet the need for a coordinated inter-agency plan to link unemployed individuals to jobs, while piloting a sector-based approach.

The RBSTs convene regularly to develop regional strategies for Business Services; share business intelligence, labor market information, and information on new programs; and co-host career fairs and customized recruiting events. The RBSTs opened lines of communication that are important when navigating logistical issues due to new policy; collaborating to meet performance measures; and expanding and rolling out new initiatives, including OJT programs.

It is important to note that the Regional Business Services Team:

• Is not a policy-making body, but rather is intended to help align business services provided at the local level with regional sector initiatives/strategies and regional labor market information;

• Does not supersede existing partnerships and/or business relationships that are working effectively, but rather is intended to build upon them;

• Does not preclude an LWDA from partnering with entities in other regions to address specific workforce needs (e.g., Transformational Sector Strategy Projects under Grant 13N); and

• Does not provide direct services to business in the region, but rather is intended to identify and disseminate information regarding services that will benefit businesses.

Regional Business Services Team membership is as follows:

• In regions comprised of more than one LWDA, membership includes:

o The NYSDOL Business Services Associate Representative and Occupational Analyst assigned to the region; and

o One representative from each LWDA in the region designated by the area’s LWDB. The LWDA representative can be LWDB or Career Center staff, and must have specific responsibility for providing services to businesses in the LWDA; and

o Steps are being taken to expand the RBSTs to include all core programs of WIOA as regular members of the team.

• In regions comprised of a single LWDA (i.e., New York City), membership includes:

o To be determined - Executive staff from NYSDOL and the New York City LWDA will meet to determine appropriate representation.

Other one-stop system partners are not formal members of the RBST, but may participate on team projects/tasks requiring their expertise and resources.

RBSTs are responsible for developing and implementing guidelines which, at minimum, must address:

• The team’s purpose, goals, and key functions;

• Convening of regular meetings, including structured agendas and meeting notes;

• Facilitating consensus based decision-making among team members; and

• Communicating team activities with LWDBs and Career Center managers.

The Unemployment Strikeforce employs a sector-based model that relies on a network of partnerships among business intermediaries, government, educational institutions, training providers, economic developers, and labor and community organizations. This type of model requires active staff engagement in job development (business demand) and customer case management (worker supply) with intensive referral and job brokering.

The Strikeforce model implemented a ‘gold standard’ of intensive job placement services connecting the unemployed to jobs while providing those services in convenient community locations with the assistance of community partners. Career Centers and Business Services worked seamlessly as a team to ensure job seekers became employed by:

• Stationing Career Center staff in convenient community locations to provide case management of customers; ensure each had a quality resume able to be sent to businesses; receive multiple job leads and referrals; and supply interview preparation assistance and follow-up for further assistance; and

• Stationing Business Services staff at the Bronx Overall Economic Development Corporation to engage local businesses to develop job openings; post and match the orders to the Strikeforce customers; and refer qualified candidates. Staff developed customized recruitments and career fair events to facilitate hiring; advocated on behalf of customers with the hiring business; and followed-up to ensure customer satisfaction.

Bronx County, NY was selected as an Unemployment Strikeforce pilot beginning on May 1, 2014. This was based on several years of the borough suffering with one of the highest unemployment rates in the state. In May 2014, the unemployment rate in the Bronx was 10.6% and the statewide rate was 6.2%. By May 2015, those unemployment rates were 8.0% and 5.3% respectively.

In 2014 and 2015, the initiative was rolled out to nine other counties in NYS. The counties added (Jefferson, Lewis, Kings, St. Lawrence, Oswego, Orleans, Montgomery, Franklin and Steuben) had the highest unemployment rates in the state at the time of selection.

In 2016, the initiative was further expanded into Western New York to provide intensive placement services to specific parts of Buffalo, Lackawanna, and Niagara County.

Competitive Advantage Assets

New York Works Business Services deploys a number of services and a network of partnerships to enable businesses to meet their needs. The nine key assets listed below are designed to provide a competitive advantage in the labor market to New York Works Career Center business customers, and are described in greater detail in the narrative that follows.

• Inter-Agency Collaboration

• NYS Job Bank and Jobs Express

• Customized Recruiting Assistance

• Focus Talent

• On-the-Job Training, Existing Worker and Unemployed Worker Training

• Tax Credits

• Virtual Career Fairs

• Ensuring Business Integrity

Business Services built a network of partnerships used to attract businesses, develop funding opportunities, and create talent pipelines for businesses. This includes collaboration with NYS agencies including NYSED/ACCES-VR, ESD, OTDA, and the NYS Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA).

The mission of Business Services is aligned with the ESD goal of encouraging job creation and economic opportunities. Accordingly, Business Services collaborates with ESD to provide information and services to businesses considering developing new sites in NYS. This partnership was evident in the effort to attract United Natural Foods, Inc. to the Hudson Valley region. Local, regional, and state economic development and workforce development entities created a package of labor market and talent pool information, as well as available hiring and training incentives to encourage the development of a 525,000 square foot distribution center that will employ 400 individuals.

Business Services promoted and connected job seekers to the NYSERDA-funded Clean Energy OJT program, and partnered with OTDA for the Green Jobs/Green NY effort. OTDA provided more than $1 million in funding and worked as a referral partner of candidates for green career opportunities in residential and commercial weatherization retrofits. Community based organizations (CBOs) were selected by a competitive procurement process to train candidates.

Business Services also partners with higher education on multiple levels, including utilizing colleges, universities, and training providers as strategic partners for regional growth; as referral sources for qualified job seekers; and as business customers when they need to fill job openings.

Business Services acted as an intermediary between the business community and community colleges in the Next Generation New York Job Linkage Program. This program provides incentives to SUNY and City University of New York (CUNY) community colleges for certificate or degree programs that prepare students for current and future in-demand employment opportunities.

Other community college partnerships have been sector or business specific. Hudson Valley Community College developed its TEC-SMART facility and corresponding curricula that seek to provide students with the skills for careers in the burgeoning semiconductor and clean and renewable energy industries in the Capital Region. Similarly, collaboration between Schenectady County Community College (SCCC) and General Electric (GE) developed a program that provides training to work in the renewable energy field as required by the GE Energy Transportation Energy Storage Technologies division that neighbors the SCCC campus. In recruiting for these businesses, Business Services promoted the training programs to applicants looking for training to make them marketable to these in-demand occupations.

Business Services works closely with many high-profile businesses on large projects of significant jobs impacts. These include coordinating with the business to create a customized recruitment plan and application process, followed by matching, referring and/or assessing qualified candidates in our talent bank or the job seeking public. A sampling of recent top projects includes:

  • Maximus - Finger Lakes Region - 600+ Customers Hired

In 2016, Maximus contracted with NYS to administer its health insurance exchange, i.e., Medicaid and Child Health Plus and a need to fill 2,000 related openings. NYSDOL Business Services worked with the business to develop job descriptions; post and match job orders; and contact qualified candidates. Business Services developed and staffed customized recruitment and interview events that saw 3,546 applicants assessed and advanced to interviews.

  • NYS Office for People With Developmental Disabilities (OPWDD) - North Country Region - 164 Customers Hired

In June of 2015, the OPWDD requested assistance with hosting Civil Service Tests for Direct Support Professionals needed to staff their Tupper Lake location. An ongoing series of exams was scheduled, advertised, and staffed at four career centers in the North Country. As of September 2017, 28 exams have been hosted at 4 North Country Career Centers resulting in 240 customers attending and 164 hires recorded. The partnership between OPWDD and NYSDOL has helped in maintaining OPWDD’s staffing levels to the point where they no longer need to implement mandatory overtime.

  • Nassau Coliseum - Long Island Region - 1,052 Customers Hired

This landmark Long Island entertainment center reopened in 2017 after a year of reconstruction with a need to fill 1,000 positions. NYSDOL staff worked hand-in-glove with AEG Worldwide and Levy Restaurants (event and food and beverage providers) to develop a coordinated application process, and to identify, match, contact, and schedule 3,546 applicants for assessment. Staff staged and staffed assessment and recruitment events for what was our largest recruitment project to date.

  • Barclay’s Center - New York City Region - Hires Pending

Spawned off a successful partnership with AEG Worldwide and Levy Restaurants (event and food and beverage provider) around the Nassau Coliseum project, New York City’s Business Services supported the recruitment needs of the Barclays Center in Brooklyn. Barclay’s Center is a multi-purpose indoor arena in Brooklyn, NY currently home to the Brooklyn Nets and New York Islanders. Staff worked hand-in glove to develop a coordinated application process and assist with preliminary candidate assessments. In total, 400 positions needed to be filled for the 2017-2018 season. Approximately 1,000 candidates were assessed and multiple hiring events were staged and staffed.

  • Commercial Casino Projects - 1,280 Customers Hired

In 2016, four commercial casino projects awarded licenses in NYS with a combined impact of 6,500 expected openings. To date, three of the projects have come to fruition: Rivers Casino, del Lago, Tioga Casino. A fourth project, Resorts World Catskills, is beginning to ramp up. NYSDOL staff worked closely with project HR staff to provide customized recruitment assistance. Staff developed job orders; posted and matched job orders; contacted candidates; and developed and staffing of information sessions, interview sessions and new employee orientations. To date, 1,280 customers have been hired.

The NYS Job Bank provides a great value to business customers, allowing them the opportunity to post jobs at no cost and save thousands of dollars a year in fees from Internet job boards and print media.

Businesses have several options of how to post jobs:

• Send job listings directly to Business Services to be posted;

• Post jobs themselves manually; or

• “Index” jobs directly from their own corporate websites. By choosing to index jobs, all jobs that are posted on the business site are automatically uploaded to the NYS Job Bank. This method provides the convenience of entering the job only once, with any changes to the job order on the corporate site also reflected in the posting on the Job Bank.

There are currently more than 210,000 jobs from more than 8,000 businesses on the NYS Job Bank. There are approximately 15,000 unique page views by job seekers on a weekly basis.

Jobs Express is a subset of the NYS Job Bank that sorts all of the job openings in NYS by region and occupation in a user friendly website (www.jobs.ny.gov). There are approximately 130,000 jobs listed on the Jobs Express website each day on average (over the last three months). This enables businesses and job seekers the ability to search jobs based on zip code and travel distance, and also serves as a critical lead source for business service outreach.

Customized recruiting assistance is core to the Business Services strategy and is promoted to all businesses with current job openings. NYSDOL, partnering with WIOA staff, facilitates recruiting events, including providing space in Career Centers and providing staff to assist at the direction of the business. This service creates connections for job seekers while fostering relationships with business customers. It also helps Business Services staff better understand the needs of the business to make enhanced matches and referrals in the future. NYSDOL seeks to adopt promising practices to ensure continuity across regions and increase the number of quality outcomes (i.e. placements) from these events.

Business Services works with Career Center partners to create and expand the Talent Bank with a wide variety of qualified and capable workers to fit the needs of business customers. The Talent Bank is an online collection of customer resumes made available for business search. It is currently hosted through the Job Bank, and customers are encouraged to post their resume online to be viewed by businesses and notified when new openings become available.

Adding to our available self-service tools for business, Focus Talent, allows businesses to search the Talent Bank for qualified candidates. It also assists businesses with developing quality job postings for the Job Bank.

OJT has become one of the principal tools to make connections between businesses and job seekers. The value of these training incentives is demonstrated by the large percentage of businesses that hired job seekers using OJT, and used the program for multiple hires. Local WIA OJT was utilized effectively throughout the state, with particular success in the Mohawk Valley, Southern Tier, and Western regions. These three regions were responsible for more than 50% of the total statewide local OJT hires.

National Emergency Grants (NEGs) with an OJT focus have also proved successful in providing training to dislocated workers and the long-term unemployed. The OJT-NEG produced a significant number of hires, all of whom are dislocated workers who experienced prolonged unemployment. The Dislocated Worker Training NEG was available to businesses to provide occupational training to dislocated workers, with an emphasis on long-term unemployed. The Jobs Driven OJT-NEG was available to businesses looking to expand their workforce and included On-the-Job, Apprenticeship, or Customized training, depending on the individual needs of the business. in 2017, the Sector Partnership National Emergency Grant became available to provide opportunities for sector approaches to reconnect Dislocated Workers to the workforce through work-based training such as OJT, Apprenticeships, or unpaid occupational skill-based training.

While the programs are administered at the local level, NYSDOL and LWDA staff promotes these programs interchangeably. All staff is active in business and participant identification, development of training plans, and monitoring of contracts.

Business Services staff promotes tax credits to all businesses to incentivize hiring certain eligible populations. This includes the Work Opportunity Tax Credit (WOTC), the Hire-a-Veteran Tax Credit, and the Urban Youth Jobs (UYJP) Program.

When promoting hiring and training incentives, WOTC has traditionally been a key tool in the Business Services toolkit. Business Services staff continues to promote awareness of the program to ensure businesses are positioned to take advantage of the credit. The Hire-a-Veteran Tax Credit encourages businesses to hire Post-9/11 Veterans who have not been employed in full-time (35+ hours/week) employment for at least 180 days. A business can receive up to $5,000 by hiring and retaining an eligible veteran or $15,000 if the veteran is disabled. This program became active on January 1, 2014. The UYJP program (formally New York Youth Works) is currently active and widely promoted to encourage businesses to hire unemployed, disadvantaged youth, 16 to 24 years of age, who reside in 13 specific targeted areas in eight regions of the state. Businesses utilizing this program can earn up to $5,000 in tax credits. The UYJP has helped 1,541 NYS businesses place youth participants in 27,133 jobs across targeted urban communities with high youth unemployment.

Business Services employs multiple methods to capture placement data. These include leveraging relationships that provide a flow-through of placement information from business customers as well as accessing data from New Hire Reports.

The initiatives previously mentioned (i.e., Business Outreach, Priority Jobs, Customized Recruitment) were designed to build the type of solid and trustworthy relationships with businesses that naturally lead to the sharing of placement data. Through these initiatives, staff provides the quality service that becomes the foundation of strong relationships and open dialogue, which are then leveraged to glean hire information.

Business Services works closely with NYSDOL’s R&S Division to retrieve data from New Hire Reports, identifying candidates from OSOS that attained employment with business customers. This enables staff to capture supplemental placement data outside of the direct relationships with businesses.

Ultimately, it is only at the point of placement where the business customer and job seeker come together to validate the vision of Business Services and its execution. Together these methods provide a means to assess the number of placements occurring as a result of Business Services efforts and an understanding of which strategies produce the greatest successes.

Last, monitoring staff activities plays a large role in the success of Business Services operations by ensuring staff provides quality services and document their activities. Outreach to businesses is tracked on a weekly basis to capture data and report on the daily outreach activities, services, and number of businesses served by Business Services staff across the state. This is done through multiple reports, and sent to supervisors and staff so individuals are held to standards for outreach goals and the quality of their work. Data is compiled and analyzed by staff; region; industry sector; type of outreach; and services offered.

Like NYSDOL, OCFS/NYSCB and NYSED/ACCES-VR offer workforce development services to businesses, monitor the activities of business outreach staff, and provide linkages between businesses and job seekers.

OCFS/NYSCB monitors contract compliance with comprehensive services contracts, vocational evaluation/job placement services contracts, and assistive technology services contracts through a centralized Quality Assurance process. Each contractor is evaluated at least once during the contract period through an internal review of randomly selected consumer cases. The review evaluates the contractor’s adherence to contract guidelines and the quality of services delivered. The review team includes staff from OCFS/NYSCB home office and district offices. A final report is submitted to the contractor, and additional follow-up monitoring is conducted if corrective actions are needed.

In addition, on-going monitoring of eligibility, plan development, services provision, and case closure takes place through checks built into the OCFS/NYSCB consumer caseload management system and through supervisory review of consumer cases.

NYSED/ACCES-VR has a workforce development and business relations team, including a statewide coordinator, who develops relationships with businesses to ensure a statewide presence; five regional business coordinators who develop relationships with regional companies based on labor market demand; and 15 local workforce development and business relations staff, who develop local business relations and work with the regional and statewide coordinators and other core partners to implement activities on a broader scale.

The whole team works directly with businesses to understand their employment needs and to find candidates who are appropriate matches. Team members also work closely with job seekers, discovering their skills and placing them in On-the-Job Training (OTJ) and work tryouts. NYSED/ACCES-VR reimburses 100% of an employee’s wages for up to 480 hours for OTJ and work tryouts. Recently, the team met with the Workforce Development Committee of the NYSED/ACCES-VR State Rehabilitation Council and partnered with a member to roll-out Champions of Change events. These events were designed to link businesses to information about hiring individuals with disabilities.

The NYSED/ACCES-VR team also provides job coaches, who work with the business and the employee to understand the needs of both. Team members offer assistance on accommodations, financial incentives, accessibility, and diversity training. They provide publications about hiring people with disabilities, and celebrate National Disability Awareness month by giving awards to businesses that are committed to hiring people with disabilities in their communities. Staff attends business-related events, including job fairs, to provide information about NYSED/ACCES-VR services to business and to link specific job applicants to business needs.

The ACCES workforce development and business relations team is aligned with the CSAVR national employment team.