Located in:
- II. Strategic Elements
The Unified or Combined State Plan must include a Strategic Planning Elements section that analyzes the State’s current economic environment and identifies the State’s overall vision for its workforce development system. The required elements in this section allow the State to develop data-driven goals for preparing an educated and skilled workforce and to identify successful strategies for aligning workforce development programs. Unless otherwise noted, all Strategic Planning Elements apply to Combined State Plan partner programs included in the plan as well as to core programs.
- a. Economic, Workforce, and Workforce Development Activities Analysis
The Unified or Combined State Plan must include an analysis of the economic conditions, economic development strategies, and labor market in which the State’s workforce system and programs will operate.
- 2. Workforce Development, Education and Training Activities AnalysisThe Unified or Combined State Plan must include an analysis of the workforce development activities, including education and training in the State, to address the education and skill needs of the workforce, as identified in Education and Skill Levels of the Workforce above, and the employment needs of employers, as identified in Employers' Employment Needs above. This must include an analysis of –
- 2. Workforce Development, Education and Training Activities Analysis
- a. Economic, Workforce, and Workforce Development Activities Analysis
II. a. 2. B. The Strengths and Weaknesses of Workforce Development Activities
Current Narrative:
1. Strengths
a. Wide-ranging Education and Training Programs
NYS places a priority on ensuring the secondary education system, the postsecondary education system, and certificate training programs are of high quality and offer a wide-range of curricula and attendance options to ensure a diverse workforce is prepared to meet the evolving needs of a 21st century labor market. Multiple pathways for students and adults have been developed to ensure full participation of all students and adults.
The NYS Career Center System serves as the center of the system by:
- Linking directly to the education/training systems for specific purposes;
- Connecting workforce system participants to training options;
- Providing career pathway opportunities; and
- Providing support to assure that participants are successful in both completing training and subsequently achieving employment.
b. High-quality Services to Students and Youth
WIOA requires partners to provide services to both in-school and out-of-school youth, ages 14-24. NYSCB has maintained a commitment to serving transition age youth as young as 10 through the VR program and has done so since 2011, leading to a focus on increasing programs and services available for this age group statewide. Collaboration across all NYS partners in serving students and youth has led to increased business engagement, stronger linkages with secondary and postsecondary systems, and additional employment opportunities for youth with various barriers to employment.
Work experience is an essential part of youth programs in NYS, and most programs are spending more than the 20% required funding on youth activities. The programs have developed innovative ways to help build work readiness skills, business relations, and work-site mentoring options via the work experience. Youth programs are engaged with Regional Business Services Teams, many of which include partner staff, to further their skills and knowledge of developing work experience and employment opportunities with businesses for youth. Continual promotion of the NY Youth Jobs Program (a tax credit for hiring youth) and the Work Opportunity Tax Credit (WOTC) program has facilitated business engagement.
NYSED/ACCES-VR is housed within NYSED, which has made the partnership and linkages between the NYS VR programs and the special education system stronger and more seamless. The VR programs are working collaboratively on agreements with education officials so that students are provided with pre-employment transition services (as appropriate), transition services, and other VR services that may be required for youth in school settings. Both the NYS VR programs are working closely with the secondary and postsecondary systems, and workforce system partners to develop additional opportunities for the provision of pre-employment transition services for students with disabilities. Specifically, NYSED/ACCES-VR will be executing new contracted services for pre-employment transition services for students with disabilities in 2018. These services were identified as critical for establishing a solid foundation for in-school youth with disabilities, ages 14-21. The providers will be expected to build partnerships with the local Career Centers, school districts, and businesses. The VR programs also work closely with System partners to develop work experience opportunities and facilitate the integration of youth needs into local planning.
NYSCB and NYSED/ACCES-VR collaborate to implement new requirements for students and youth consistently. Together, the agencies are committed to providing pre-employment transition services for students and for providing additional VR services for transition age youth statewide. The VR agencies will continue to develop, implement, and assess programs and services that prepare NYS youth with disabilities for entering the workforce.
In many local areas, core program staff is working together and receiving cross training to improve skills associated with serving youth with disabilities. Most programs are spending more than 75% of their funds to serve out-of-school youth. To meet the needs of out-of-school youth, they are building collaboration with core programs, Youth Bureaus, alternative schools, and not-for-profit organizations to make all 14 program elements available to youth.
The Summer Youth Employment Program (SYEP) serves to introduce youth into the labor market, helping them acquire skills that can be used to improve school performance and become responsible adults. All youth are paid at least the current NYS minimum wage and receive supportive and educational services including financial literacy training. Worksites are public, private or non-profit and include employment at day care centers, summer camps, senior citizen centers, school districts and community-based organizations, and county government. The NYS Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance (OTDA) allocates SYEP funds to all Social Services Districts, and many districts opted to transfer their allocations to their LWDBs for program operation in 2017.
In an effort to further collaboration across System Partners, NYSDOL is in contact with the OCFS Bureau of Youth Development, OTDA Employment and Income Support Programs, and NYSED/ACCES-VR to collaborate on issues and initiatives pertaining to youth in NYS. A series of bi-monthly meetings are planned to explore opportunities for greater System alignment of service delivery to youth, and to share best practices in combatting the high youth unemployment rate. NYSDOL continues to engage NYSED on issues related to aligning the CareerZone website with NYS learning standards, promoting the use of the Career Development and Occupational Standards (CDOS) Commencement Credential as a measure of work readiness for youth, and to provide clarity to youth program providers on appropriate pathways to High School Equivalency (HSE) diplomas in NYS.
In 2017, NYSDOL Youth Office staff offered training for OCFS Youth Bureau directors to understand the changes in WIOA youth program eligibility and started exploring ways to collaborate at the NYS level. The NYSDOL Youth Office is also exploring ways to collaborate with the Youth and Workforce Development Unit of OCFS, which focuses on youth in facilities and their transition back to communities after release.
c. Collaboration between the NYS Partners
NYS agencies including NYSDOL, NYSED, OCFS/NYSCB, OTDA, and the NYS Office for the Aging (SOFA) have a strong history of collaboration that has served as a foundation for the successful implementation of WIOA strategies.
1. WIOA Implementation
Beginning in late 2016, partners obtained One-Stop Operator and MOU assistance from a renowned national consultant. The consultant presented to NYS partner program staff, LWDB Directors and Board members, Career Center staff, and MOU negotiators and signatories on infrastructure funding expectations, options, and partnering opportunities.
Partner Program and Counsel staff also worked together to develop and approve guidance for the One-Stop Operator and MOU processes, which were released to the Career Center System. Local Workforce Development Boards (LWDBs) are using MOU planning as an opportunity to review service offerings and availability to leverage resources and reduce duplication, and to establish effective referral systems, career services offerings, and co-location of partners where appropriate. A joint technical assistance document regarding the MOU will be released by partner programs participating on the Interagency Team.
In addition to discussions on the One-Stop Operator and MOU process, the national consultant discussed:
- Building a collaborative workforce development system through identification of career services to be offered and methods of shared service delivery;
- Serving youth; and
- Business collaboration and performance accountability.
Furthermore, in a webinar targeted for VR field staff, the consultant focused discussion on performance and the role of the VR program as a partner of the workforce system, expected to meet and contribute to achieving NYS’s performance measures.
2. Joint Presentations
Together the program partners have presented to a number of different organizations in NYS, including the NYS Rehabilitation Association (NYSRA), the New York Association of Training and Employment Professionals (NYATEP), and the NYS Association for Continuing and Community Education (NYACCE).
3. WIOA Local Planning
NYSDOL staff worked with Title II Adult Education staff on the Title II component of the WIOA Local Plan, meeting a new federal requirement that all WIOA Title II competitive applications be reviewed by the LWDB for alignment with dedicated plans to serve Title II populations. Title II information is posted to the NYSDOL website for assistance in developing the remainder of the Plan.
Through the statewide business engagement team, all program partners are committed to understanding regional and local business needs and developing statewide strategies that can link to and/or guide regional and local efforts.
There are also examples of NYS partner collaboration affecting local service provision. For example, One-Stop Career Centers and Social Services Districts in many local areas have longstanding working relationships, coordinating workforce resources to maximize their funding streams, meet the specific needs of the locality, and improve outcomes for their shared customers. These relationships have strengthened due to collaboration between NYSDOL and OTDA at the NYS level since the implementation of WIOA.
2. Challenges
a. Funding
Federal appropriations for WIOA are flat funded at best, with significant cuts being proposed by the President and Congress, making it impossible to meet the full potential of the statute. Even now, funding reaches only a fraction of the need.
b. Fragmented Federal Guidance
Federal policy guidance and requirements are delivered to each partner individually. This results in:
- Conflicting information;
- Necessary front-line staff training;
- Essential cross-training for all System partners on cross-program knowledge and requirements;
- Reduction of staff availability to focus on collaborative efforts;
- The need for new processes, forms, and policies; and
- Significant modification to data collection systems.
c. Data Integration
The previously mentioned Data Integration Workgroup has also identified several barriers that need to be addressed before further progress can be made:
- Changes in reporting requirements make it difficult to commit to a solution;
- No targeted date has been provided for joint reporting; and
- No estimate has been provided for the funding required for this project.