Located in:
- II. Strategic Elements
The Unified or Combined State Plan must include a Strategic Planning Elements section that analyzes the State’s current economic environment and identifies the State’s overall vision for its workforce development system. The required elements in this section allow the State to develop data-driven goals for preparing an educated and skilled workforce and to identify successful strategies for aligning workforce development programs. Unless otherwise noted, all Strategic Planning Elements apply to Combined State Plan partner programs included in the plan as well as to core programs.
- a. Economic, Workforce, and Workforce Development Activities Analysis
The Unified or Combined State Plan must include an analysis of the economic conditions, economic development strategies, and labor market in which the State’s workforce system and programs will operate.
- 2. Workforce Development, Education and Training Activities AnalysisThe Unified or Combined State Plan must include an analysis of the workforce development activities, including education and training in the State, to address the education and skill needs of the workforce, as identified in Education and Skill Levels of the Workforce above, and the employment needs of employers, as identified in Employers' Employment Needs above. This must include an analysis of –
- 2. Workforce Development, Education and Training Activities Analysis
- a. Economic, Workforce, and Workforce Development Activities Analysis
II. a. 2. B. The Strengths and Weaknesses of Workforce Development Activities
Current Narrative:
Oklahoma’s Workforce Development Activities have both strengths and weaknesses.
Initial analysis of the strengths and weaknesses of Oklahoma’s workforce development activities listed in section 2A, suggest that our workforce development system is well-suited for successful progress and change due to strong leadership as well as engaged and connected cross-sector partners, among other strengths.
The Core Partners, in consult with local workforce development area feedback, collaboratively identified strengths and weaknesses of the workforce development system, and the activities listed in 2A, including: Oklahoma Works Initiative outreach and planning through the 2015 Key Economic Network tour, the strategic plan development meetings and resulting objectives, the coordination of the Core Partners and required partners in system-building, the business-led and data-driven restructuring of the Governor’s Council for Workforce and Economic Development, and the commissioned study on non-completers to guide policy on increasing educational attainment.
Additionally, a Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats (SWOT) analysis of WIOA Core Partners was conducted in early 2018 to update the 2016 plan to 2018.
Oklahoma Works System Strengths
The 2016 plan described Oklahoma’s strengths as: strong leadership, workforce system partner engagement, unprecedented involvement from the business community, a strong postsecondary education system, and openness to regionalism.
1) Oklahoma benefits from having strong leadership to guide and push forward the state’s workforce development priorities through our state’s Governor and Cabinet Secretaries. Governor Mary Fallin chose workforce and closing the skills gap and increasing educational attainment as her key priority, as identified in her 2015 and 2016 State of the State addresses. Through her leadership, Oklahoma’s Workforce Partner Agency leadership, which includes Core Partner leadership and leadership from other partner agencies, meet once per month to discuss workforce issues and ways in which partnerships can be leveraged, and how to create a stronger state workforce system. These occur at the Office of the Governor each month. Each leader supports workforce development in the state by publicly promoting the initiative and workforce development activities in the state.
2) Also, as demonstrated by the cross-sector planning and teams under Oklahoma Works’ activities, Oklahoma boasts strong engagement and partnerships from our Core Partners and workforce system partners, and Workforce Development Boards. The State’s partners’ leadership are fully engaged in monthly meetings, mentioned above, where agencies provide updates regarding their education and training activities, and leverage partnerships with, and promotions of, training and education. Additionally, the System Oversight Subcommittee, the working arm of the Workforce System Oversight Committee of the Governor’s Council for Workforce and Economic Development is well represented of Core Partner staff and many required partner staff. This well-attended group meets approximately once per month to discuss system-level issues and provide system-level guidance and monitoring. This group is committed to collaborating on the state-level, with local-level guidance.
3) Additionally, Oklahoma has unprecedented involvement from the business community in workforce development efforts. Business leads the Governor’s Council for Workforce and Economic Development and Local Workforce Development Boards. Also, Business Champions in the Key Economic Networks (KENs), as a part of the Oklahoma Works initiative, and are engaged to vet and lead numerous Oklahoma Works efforts. Oklahoma is ensuring that business and labor market information is leading policy on the identification of skills needed, employment opportunities, and trends in industry is imperative for a responsive workforce development system. For example, the Governor’s Council for Workforce and Economic Development commissioned a yearly statewide labor market information report which will include real time data as well as education assets. This report will be vetted and used by existing state-level business advisory groups, such as the State Department of Education’s Business Advisory Group among others, to make institution-level policy, and disseminate among other business leaders not necessarily associated with the Governor’s Council and WIOA programs. This yearly document will guide Career Pathway efforts across the state.
4) Oklahoma boasts a robust and geographically diverse postsecondary education system with our Career and Technology Education System, and our higher education institutions, which includes our community colleges and four-year educational institutions. In particular, many local Career and Technology Education institutions have strong local ties to communities and are extremely responsive to local business’ needs. This robust system supports Oklahoma’s path to adopt and accomplish a statewide postsecondary attainment goal.
https://oklahomaworks.gov/docs/2018/02/5.png" alt="Asset Map." title="Line Chart" />
5) Oklahoma has embraced regionalism. Previously, Oklahoma was already working toward a system-approach to workforce development by implementing system-certification and broader coordinated efforts among partners and programs.
With the addition of WIOA required Planning Regions, Oklahoma encourages further cooperation and collaboration among local areas in order to be more strategic with resources and performance targets. Thus, our eight local workforce development areas in Oklahoma are now represented by four regional planning areas. The designation of these areas has opened up new opportunities as these areas consider joint strategies and additional partnerships. For example, the Northeast planning region is meeting regularly and as of June 2016, has elected a leadership team consisting of local elected officials from each of the local areas in their region.
6) The State is supporting a local pilot project on the development of an infrastructure and cost-sharing processes template. The pilot reports to the System Oversight Subcommittee to collect best practices and lessons learned in order to determine the state-level guidance. All core partners are represented on the committee.
In addition to the six strengths outlined in the 2016 WIOA State Plan, the SWOT analysis conducted in early 2018 identified additional strengths as a result of statewide efforts over the past two years, and center on data, partnerships, resources, and system-building and infrastructure.
7) The WIOA Core Partners have strengthened our data infrastructure and alignment over the past two years as federal joint guidance has been released, and prior to release. Oklahoma embodies the phrase, “enough is known for action” and has been as proactive as possible in convening state partners to create advancements in data sharing and performance collaboration and reporting. Information management systems have been procured and enhanced at ODCTE, OESC, DRS and OOWD. Also, the OklahomaWorks.gov website, the clearinghouse for the workforce development system across partners has been further developed thanks to a private grant. The new site drives traffic to the state’s top resources for labor market information, career exploration, career exposure, and education and training opportunities and job opportunities in the state. The State’s top resources include the OklahomaWorks.gov website, OKJobMatch.com, OKCareerGuide, OKCollegeStart, and Oklahoma Edge.
8) Partnerships continue to be a strength of the Oklahoma Works system. Throughout the implementation of WIOA, collaboration and cooperation among state core partners is at an all-time high. Each agency has strong leadership, which echoes the strong leadership of the Governor identifying workforce development as a state priority. Each partner director or high-level designee participates in regular WIOA Core Partner Director meetings, regular convenings of the Local Area Board Directors, and participates in the Oklahoma Workforce Association and Oklahoma Association of Workforce Development Boards.
9) Despite a lack of resources, the system has been adaptable by increasingly finding efficiencies, and responding to such a shortage with innovation and creativity. Funds across state programs are increasingly being blended as opportunities for collaboration and sharing of resources and capacity becomes the standard way of doing business. For example, multiple pilot projects are requiring cross-agency funds and participation, and agency directors are often eager and willing to share the financial and capacity burdens, as well as successes.
10) Finally, the SWOT analysis revealed a strength in the system-building and infrastructure development over the past two years. Internal processes and procedures and investments into creating a strong infrastructure have yielded a strong foundation on which to build future programs. The past two years, Core Partners have united on a customer-centered vision with a strong focus on businesses and job seekers. Advancements being made consistently focus on this vision. Also, processes and procedures across agencies with regard to data sharing for performance, access for targeted populations, accountability across partners for components of the workforce system, and coordination have been developed, and are continuing to be developed. Such a framework has established a strong foundation for future developments over the next two years of the State Plan.
Oklahoma Works System Weaknesses
Oklahoma’s Workforce Development Activities also have weaknesses that hinder us in realizing our State’s vision for economic prosperity for all of our citizens. The 2016 development of the State Plan revealed weaknesses centered on the decreasing state budget, limited capacity to deliver on the increased priority of workforce development, rising unemployment, challenges of creating a longitudinal data system, information systems, and common intake processes and procedures and technology.
1) In the 2016 legislative session, Oklahoma experienced a budget shortfall of $900 million before the legislative session began, which then grew to more than $1 billion by the end of the session. Many state agencies, including some of our Core Partners, were required to offer voluntary buyouts and layoff staff. Also, postsecondary institutions were required to increase tuition to cover losing state appropriations. Thus, any mention of limited resources and fund sharing elicits anxiety and protection of already limited resources. However, in order to fully realize the vision and strategic priorities of the State, the Partners must work hard to overcome these tendencies to better deliver education and training services to Oklahomans.
2) Limited resources continue to be a weakness both at the state and federal level. Oklahoma continues to not have a legislature-approved budget that identifies new revenue to supplement cuts to state agencies over the past few years. Similarly, federal budget discussions centering on the cuts to workforce investment programs of our WIOA core partners requires leadership to continue to move forward to resource-sharing conversations, but tread carefully as budgets may be further cut, or even eliminated. Such resource woes have negatively impacted MOU agreements, Infrastructure Funding Agreements, and Cost Sharing of the Oklahoma Works American Job Center system. Until funding availability, instability, and uncertainty can be addressed both at the state and federal levels, resource sharing conversations will continue to be difficult and will require even more efficiency and innovation.
3) Also, Oklahoma runs the risk of limited capacity to deliver on the ambitious strategies we’ve set forth. Due to the state’s revamped efforts in and leadership for workforce development activities, there are numerous workforce development initiatives, new and revived, across the state that are requiring engagement from partner staff and the business communities. Thus, partner staff are engaged in numerous workforce related efforts, running the risk of duplication of efforts and burn-out due to a lack of capacity to sustain the efforts with the current amount of staff available at each agency to devote to the efforts. Similarly, the business community may be exhausted in a short amount of time due to the numerous requests for engagement from a variety of partners and initiatives.
4) Although Oklahoma has had lower than the national average of unemployment for years, Oklahoma’s unemployment rate rose steadily for most of 2016. In January 2016, the state posted an unemployment rate of 4.1%. This increased to a high of 5.3% in September 2016. By December 2016, the rate had decreased by one-half of a percentage point to 4.8%. This decline continued between January (4.7%) and March 2017 (4.3%) before leveling off, remaining at 4.3% through June 2017. In July, the state unemployment rate surpassed the national rate - 4.4% versus 4.3%, respectively - and has remained above the national rate since that time. Between July and October, unemployment fluctuated between 4.4% and 4.5% before declining once again in November and reaching a low of 4.1% in December 2017.
5) Although a major goal under Oklahoma Works is for a fully functional state longitudinal data system to better track the workforce development successes of the state and provide better data to inform policy and resource distribution, the State does not yet have a fully functional system. Further resources and continued commitment of Partners to implement this system is required in order for it to be successful.
6) The State’s Education and Training Provider List (ETPL), Online Case Management System, and Labor Exchange System is not as functional nor fully dynamic as necessary to ensure a seamless system. The State must select a new vendor to ensure all new WIOA reporting requirements are met, the ETPL is fully functional to prevent barriers to identifying and securing education and training for participants, and the labor exchange system is accurate and practical for both job seekers and employers.
7) Oklahoma lacks a common intake or common registration system for citizens to better access programs for which they are eligible. All core partners have their own data systems and there is limited data sharing, which results in participant duplication, and tracking shared performance is difficult. Common intake is needed in order to get participants’ the services they need, quicker, and more seamlessly, and get them education, training, and/or employment as efficiently as possible.
Despite two years into the State Plan, many of the weaknesses listed above require long-term vision and sustainable resources to improve. Though the state has implemented a new case management system for OESC and OOWD, challenges still exist as federal performance requirements continue to change two years into WIOA implementation. Similarly, vendor foci continue to be on adapting to constant federal performance changes requiring constant remapping of the system, and advancements to the ETPL part of the system have yet to be made. We anticipate those advancements to be made in fall 2018. Although efforts have been made to overcome system weaknesses, a few additional challenges were identified in a 2018 SWOT analysis. Such weaknesses focus on Resources, Alignment and Partnerships.
8) Despite efforts to be proactive on alignment using the motto “enough is known for action”, slow federal guidance and support has required the WIOA Core Partners to be more reactive than desired. The state’s hope is that federal administrative leadership and staff capacity will be restored in the coming months, and as such, the timeliness of guidance will be released with more frequency and with more advance notice. Such delay on guidance has created friction between the state and local areas, as local areas are required to implement processes and procedures across programs to serve businesses and job seekers daily. They are doing so with state interpretation when possible, but the federal lack-of-capacity is further adding liability to local and state administrations. Similarly, knowledge of services and activities across federal programs continues to be a barrier to address as the new federal law requires local and state staff to be generalists across programs in addition to subject matter experts. To account for this, the state must continue to foster cross-program training and exposure, as well as relationship building, to successfully implement WIOA.
9) Finally, although partnerships are one of Oklahoma’s biggest strengths, the interconnectedness of WIOA tests the breadth and depth of those partnerships on a daily basis. For example, despite efforts of state agency staff to meet and participate in convenings across state agencies at the state level, and with local area staff and leadership, communication across the state level and vertically to--and from-- the local level continues to be a challenge. Messaging of state level advancements and contributions to the system in the form of policies, processes, and infrastructure as required in the implementation of a new federal law, fail to provide tangible benefits to front-line staff providing services in the local area. Better communication and messaging between state agencies and between the state and local areas is necessary to appreciate each others’ advancements and progress, and ensure each is responsive to the others’ immediate and long-term needs.