Located in:
- III. Operational Planning ElementsThe Unified or Combined State Plan must include an Operational Planning Elements section that support the State’s strategy and the system-wide vision described in Section II.(c) above. Unless otherwise noted, all Operational Planning Elements apply to Combined State Plan partner programs included in the plan as well as to core programs. This section must include—
- b. State Operating Systems and PoliciesThe Unified or Combined State Plan must include a description of the State operating systems and policies that will support the implementation of the State strategy described in Section II Strategic Elements . This includes—
- b. State Operating Systems and Policies
III. b. 6. C. Use of Unemployment Insurance (ui) Wage Record Data
Current Narrative:
Wage records, despite the time lag associated with using them, remain the best, most objective source of information for determining employment-related outcomes. Measures that use wage records are also far more efficient and less costly than those that depend on administrative data. States, for example, could match to UI wage records to verify program-specific, customer-level data furnished by providers of training services. In addition, TWC encourages the Secretary of Labor—in consultation with the Workforce Information Advisory Council, federal agencies, and states—to develop standardized definitions for the data elements composing wage records as well as improved processes and systems for the collection and reporting of such records.
In light of the discussion on adding data elements to the quarterly wage reports (preamble to NPRM §652.302), TWC recommends serious consideration of the costs and additional burden of any change to wage record reporting. Employer input is certainly fundamental to any changes or additions. TWC estimates it may cost $2 million to modify its reporting systems to incorporate a new data element on the employer wage reports. This estimate excludes the cost to employers. Costs attributable to audits and delinquent reporting reviews will also increase if additional elements are added to the reporting process.
TWC currently makes extensive use of quarterly UI wage records as part of its common data systems both for required and ad hoc reporting and makes the data available to the Boards, other state agencies, and various researchers either directly or by performing matches to seed records provided by the external entity.
While TWC and the local Boards generally operate Texas Workforce Solutions as an integrated system that focuses on customer outcomes rather than program outcomes, there is often interest in program-specific outcomes. TWC is committed to providing consistent, reliable, and comparable performance data to partners, stakeholders, and the public. Therefore, TWC calculates performance at the customer-level across programs and then aggregates the results by sublevel, such as by program or for customers with given characteristics.
Historically, TWC’s ability to provide consistent, reliable, and comparable data was negatively impacted when a customer was served through a DOL program such as WIA Adult and another program such as SNAP E&T, and the person was found to be working in another state through data obtained through WRIS. Language in the WRIS agreement limited use of this data to DOL programs, which meant that when reporting a customer such as the one in this example, the customer would count positively in the WIA Adult performance but count negatively in the SNAP E&T performance. This undermines the idea of an integrated system where the focus should first be on how well the system served the customer; each program that helped support the outcome should be able to report that success.
In addition, while WIOA provides for a set of performance measures, they are by no means the only such method to measure success. Indeed, with their extensive lag, states need the ability to develop and use leading indicators to improve program monitoring and management. In addition, states need the ability to evaluate employment/wage data to measure system and program impact and return on investment. Heretofore, the WRIS agreement’s language prohibited this extremely important activity as well.
However, WIOA §116(i)(2) provides that the Secretary of Labor shall provide access to wage data from other states to the extent that this data is necessary to carry out the state plan or the annual report prescribed by WIOA §116(d), and WIOA §116(e) requires the state in coordination with the Boards to conduct ongoing evaluations of activities carried out by the state. Therefore, as noted, TWC intends to use data obtained through WRIS to evaluate system and program performance through a variety of federal and state-developed performance measures, as well as to evaluate system and program impact and return on investment.