Located in:
- II. Strategic Elements
The Unified or Combined State Plan must include a Strategic Planning Elements section that analyzes the State’s current economic environment and identifies the State’s overall vision for its workforce development system. The required elements in this section allow the State to develop data-driven goals for preparing an educated and skilled workforce and to identify successful strategies for aligning workforce development programs. Unless otherwise noted, all Strategic Planning Elements apply to Combined State Plan partner programs included in the plan as well as to core programs.
- a. Economic, Workforce, and Workforce Development Activities Analysis
The Unified or Combined State Plan must include an analysis of the economic conditions, economic development strategies, and labor market in which the State’s workforce system and programs will operate.
- a. Economic, Workforce, and Workforce Development Activities Analysis
II. a. 1. B. Workforce Analysis (B.I - B.IV)
The Unified or Combined State Plan must include an analysis of the current workforce, including individuals with barriers to employment, as defined in section 3 of WIOA.* This population must include individuals with disabilities among other groups** in the State and across regions identified by the State. This includes: Individuals with barriers to employment include displaced homemakers; low-income individuals; Indians, Alaska Natives, and Native Hawaiians; individuals with disabilities, including youth who are individuals with disabilities; older individuals; ex-offenders; homeless individuals, or homeless children and youths; youth who are in or have aged out of the foster care system; individuals who are English language learners, individuals who have low levels of literacy, and individuals facing substantial cultural barriers; farmworkers (as defined at section 167(i) of WIOA and Training and Employment Guidance Letter No. 35-14); individuals within 2 years of exhausting lifetime eligibility under the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program; single parents (including single pregnant women); and long-term unemployed individuals. ** Veterans, unemployed workers, and youth, and others that the State may identify.
i. Employment and Unemployment
Provide an analysis of current employment and unemployment data, including labor force participation rates, and trends in the State.
ii. Labor Market Trends
Provide an analysis of key labor market trends, including across existing industries and occupations.iii. Education and Skill Levels of the Workforce
Provide an analysis of the educational and skill levels of the workforce.
iv. Skill Gaps
Describe apparent ‘skill gaps’.
Current Narrative:
Workforce Analysis
Employment and Unemployment
From the beginning of Governor Cuomo’s administration through August 2017, NYS’s economy has added more than a million private sector jobs, experienced employment growth in 68 of the past 80 months and added an average of 12,500 private sector jobs per month. Over this timeframe, the statewide unemployment rate has fallen from 8.4% to 4.8%.
Labor Market Trends
Three industry sectors - Educational and Health Services (+360,100), Professional and Business Services (+241,300), and Leisure and Hospitality (+224,800) - are responsible for more than 75% of the private sector jobs added in NYS since August 2010. The two private sector industry groups that lost the most jobs in August 2010-August 2017 include Manufacturing (-22,400) and Natural Resources and Mining (-200).
Of the state’s 10 labor market regions, New York City (+22.6%) is the only one that has added jobs at a faster pace than the nation as a whole (+15.1%) since August 2010. Other regions that have seen their private sector job counts grow by at least 5.0% since August 2010 include: Long Island (+11.9%), Hudson Valley (+11.2%), Capital (+10.1%), Finger Lakes (+5.7%) and Western New York (+5.2%). Regions adding private sector jobs at the slowest pace in August 2010 - August 2017 include: Central New York (+3.8%), Southern Tier (+2.3%), Mohawk Valley (+2.2%) and North Country (+2.0%).
In August 2017, the seasonally adjusted unemployment rate was 4.9% in New York City and 4.8% in the balance of the state (NYS-New York City). While the unemployment rate has increased in both New York City and the balance of the state since March 2017, the rates remain slightly below their pre-recession levels of 5.2% and 5.0%, respectively. In August 2010-August 2017, the rate in New York City dropped from 9.3% to 4.9%. This steep rate drop reflects, in part, the strong private sector job growth experienced in New York City over the past seven years. The rate decline in the balance of state’s unemployment rate has been more gradual, falling from 7.9% to 4.8% over the same seven-year timeframe.
The table below shows the change in unemployment rates by labor market region between August 2010 and August 2017. The rate in New York City has dropped the most (-4.4 percentage points) over the past seven years - from 9.5% to 5.1%. Most other regions in the state experienced rate drops in the range of 2.5-3.5 percentage points.
Unemployment Rates, New York State, by Region, August 2010 and August 2017
(not seasonally adjusted)
Region August 2010 August 2017 Change (in percentage points)
Capital 7.1% 4.2% -2.9
Central New York 8.1% 4.8% -3.3
Finger Lakes 7.6% 4.8% -2.8
Hudson Valley 7.4% 4.5% -2.9
Long Island 7.3% 4.4% -2.9
Mohawk Valley 7.7% 4.9% -2.8
New York City 9.5% 5.1% -4.4
North Country 8.7% 5.5% -3.2
Southern Tier 7.9% 4.9% -3.0
Western New York 8.2% 5.3% -2.9
Relative to other states, NYS’s economic recovery has been robust as it experienced the third largest net gain in private sector jobs in the country (calculated as jobs gained during the recovery/expansion minus jobs lost in the recession). However, the job gains have been uneven, with the New York City, Long Island and Hudson Valley regions adding private sector jobs at a much more rapid rate than other regions in the state.
In addition, New York City and the balance of the state experienced much different trends in their labor force participation rates since August 2010. In New York City, the participation rate has increased slightly, from 59.9% to 61.4%. Outside of New York City, the participation rate has decreased sharply, from 63.9% to 60.5%, over the same period. As a result, overall labor force levels in New York City are up by approximately 298,000 since August 2010, while they are down by almost 210,000 in NYS outside of New York City.
Businesses in a variety of industries in the state continue to report some level of difficulty in filling their job openings. Some of the most difficult-to-fill titles include various finance and accounting occupations, skilled trades occupations (e.g., HVAC technicians, plumbers, pipefitters and steamfitters, or sheet metal workers), retail salespersons, truck drivers, customer service representatives, advertising managers, various IT job titles (e.g., network architect, web developer), engineering job titles (e.g., biomedical engineer), health care practitioners (e.g., surgeon, optometrist), and health care support titles (e.g., home health aide, nursing assistant).
Education and Skill Levels of the Workforce
Educational Attainment for Population Age 25+: New York State and Labor Market Regions
Area Population Age 25+ (in 1000s) Less than high school diploma High school graduate (includes equivalency) Some college or Associate degree Bachelor degree Graduate or Professional degree
New York 13,435.8 14.4% 26.7% 24.7% 19.4% 14.8%
Capital 748.7 8.5% 29.3% 29.4% 18.1% 14.8%
Central NY 527.4 10.6% 30.3% 30.2% 16.3% 12.6%
Finger Lakes 828.7 10.3% 28.9% 30.0% 17.4% 13.5%
Hudson Valley 1,552.0 11.6% 24.5% 25.0% 20.7% 18.1%
Long Island 1,954.8 9.7% 26.9% 25.2% 21.1% 17.2%
Mohawk Valley 339.9 12.2% 34.9% 31.0% 12.7% 9.2%
New York City 5,801.3 19.7% 24.1% 20.6% 21.0% 14.6%
North Country 287.9 12.3% 35.7% 31.0% 11.2% 9.8%
Southern Tier 436.2 10.0% 33.4% 29.4% 14.2% 13.0%
Western NY 958.9 10.0% 31.1% 30.8% 15.6% 12.6%
Source: 2011-2015 ACS 5-Year Estimates Table B15002.
The above table presents information on the educational attainment of the state’s population age 25 and older. 59% of the state’s population (age 25+) have at least some college or an associate degree, including 19.4% who have a bachelor’s degree and another 14.8% who hold a graduate or professional (e.g.., medical or law) degree.
Looking at the state’s labor market regions, populations in the Hudson Valley (38.9%) and Long Island (38.2%) have the highest share with at least a bachelor’s degree. In contrast, the North Country (21.1%) and the Mohawk Valley (21.9%) have the smallest share.
Conversely, 19.7% of New York City’s population (age 25 and older) has less than a high school diploma. This reflects in large part the large share of the city’s population that is foreign born. The Capital (8.5%) and Long Island (9.7%) regions have the smallest share of population with less than a high school diploma.
Despite having a highly-educated population and a readily available talent pool, anecdotal accounts indicate that many businesses in the state are still having trouble finding workers with the skills they require. This suggests that local workforce boards need to continue working closely with businesses to develop the worker skills that are in demand.
Almost one in seven New Yorkers do not have a high school diploma. Anecdotal accounts suggest that many businesses will not consider a job applicant, even for the lowest-level positions, unless they have a high school degree.
Another barrier facing many workers in NYS, especially those without a high school diploma, is a lack of English proficiency. This can frequently be attributed to the large number of foreign-born residents in the state. Therefore, it is critical for any workforce development plan to implement a strategy to increase the percentage of potential workers with a high school diploma as well as provide English as a Second Language (ESL) programs.
School Status of Population Age 16-19 (levels in 1000s), New York State and Labor Market Regions
Area Population Age 16-19 Enrolled in School Not Enrolled in School High School Graduate Not High School Graduate % Not HS Graduate
New York 1,049.0 922.3 126.7 84.2 42.4 4.0%
Capital 61.0 53.4 7.6 4.9 2.7 4.4%
Central NY 51.0 45.8 5.2 3.4 1.8 3.5%
Finger Lakes 71.1 62.0 9.1 5.7 3.4 4.8%
Hudson Valley 135.2 119.7 15.5 10.5 5.0 3.7%
Long Island 158.5 143.3 15.3 11.8 3.4 2.2%
Mohawk 29.0 25.0 4.0 2.4 1.6 5.4%
New York City 393.6 342.6 51.1 32.1 19.0 4.8%
North Country 25.9 21.9 4.0 2.8 1.1 4.4%
Southern Tier 45.3 40.3 5.0 3.8 1.2 2.6%
Western NY 78.3 68.4 9.9 6.6 3.3 4.2%
Source: 2011-2015 ACS 5-Year Estimates Table B14005.
Among the more than 1 million New York youth aged 16-19, about 42,400, or 4.0%, are not enrolled in high school and have not graduated high school. Almost half of the youth (44.7%) in this category reside in New York City. As noted, in the discussion above, persons without a high school diploma are at a distinct disadvantage when it comes to finding a job in today’s competitive labor market. The share of this age group not in school and without a high school degree ranges from a high of 5.4% in Mohawk Valley to a low of 2.2% on Long Island.
Civilian Population with a Disability (in 1000s), New York State and Labor Market Regions
| Area | Total civilian population | With a disability | No disability | Percent with a disability |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York State | 19,427.3 | 2,159.4 | 17,267.9 | 11.1% |
| Capital | 1,065.6 | 132.8 | 932.9 | 12.5% |
| Central NY | 779.8 | 98.4 | 6881.4 | 12.6% |
| Finger Lakes | 1,197.4 | 155.5 | 1,041.9 | 13.0% |
| Hudson Valley | 2,277.2 | 241.9 | 2,035.3 | 10.6% |
| Long Island | 2,830.7 | 252.0 | 2,578.7 | 8.9% |
| Mohawk Valley | 484.5 | 73.0 | 411.5 | 15.1% |
| New York City | 8,364.7 | 869.1 | 7,495.6 | 10.4% |
| North Country | 406.6 | 59.9 | 346.8 | 14.7% |
| Southern Tier | 642.9 | 90.4 | 552.5 | 14.1% |
| Western NY | 1,377.9 | 186.6 | 1,191.3 | 13.5% |
Source: 2011-2015 ACS 5-Year Estimates, Table S1810.
The table above presents information on the number and share of the overall civilian population with a disability. Note that demographic information on the skill level of this population is not available. As shown, 11.1% of the overall civilian population has a disability. This means more than two million NYS residents have a disability. More than 40% of NYS residents with a disability live in New York City. Another 22.9% of NYS residents with disabilities reside in the Hudson Valley or Long Island.
Long Island (8.9%) is the only labor market region in which the disability rate is below 10%. In contrast, there are five regions in which the disability rate is at or exceeds 13%. The regions with the highest disability rates in the state are: Mohawk Valley (15.1%); North Country (14.7%); Southern Tier (14.1%); Western NY (13.5%); and the Finger Lakes (13.0%).
Share of Population in Poverty and Percent of Households Receiving Public Assistance, New York State and Labor Market Regions
Area % of Population with Income below poverty level % of Population Under 18 years with Income below poverty level % of Households with cash public assistance income % of Households with Food Stamp/SNAP benefits in the past 12 months
New York State 15.7% 22.2% 3.4% 15.4%
Capital 11.5% 16.2% 2.5% 11.0%
Central NY 15.3% 22.1% 3.6% 14.4%
Finger Lakes 14.3% 21.1% 4.0% 13.7%
Hudson Valley 11.1% 16.0% 2.4% 9.8%
Long Island 6.6% 8.5% 1.9% 5.9%
Mohawk Valley 16.8% 25.6% 3.2% 16.6%
New York City 20.6% 29.5% 4.1% 20.6%
North Country 16.4% 23.5% 3.5% 16.3%
Southern Tier 16.6% 22.1% 3.5% 14.2%
Western NY 15.4% 23.6% 3.2% 16.3%
Source: 2011-2015 ACS 5-Year Estimates, Tables DP03, S1701, B17001.
One of the major challenges facing the state’s population as it seeks to attain the education, skills, and training needed to obtain employment is achieving economic security. Data in the above table from the American Community Survey tell us about poverty rates as well as the percentage of NYS households receiving cash public assistance or Food Stamp/Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) benefits within the past 12 months.
About one in seven New Yorkers, or 15.7%, were living in poverty, per the American Community Survey. This figure, however, was much higher (22.2%) for those under the age of 18 in NYS.
These statewide figures mask wide variation in poverty rates across the different labor market regions. For example, less than 10% of residents in the Long Island (6.6%) region lived in poverty, while over 20% of New York City residents were in poverty.
The contrast in poverty rates is even greater for residents under the age of 18. For example, only 8.5% of Long Islanders under the age of 18 lived in poverty, while the comparable rate was three times higher (25.6%) in the Mohawk Valley and almost three and a half times higher (29.5%) in New York City.
Over 3% of households in NYS received cash public assistance income. As with the various poverty measures, discussed above, Long Island had the lowest rate (1.9%) of households receiving cash public assistance income, while New York City had the highest rate (4.1%). Similarly, Long Island had the lowest percentage share (5.9%) of households receiving Food Stamp/SNAP benefits in the past 12 months, while New York City topped the list (20.6%).
Description of Apparent Skill Gaps
In today’s global economy, industries in the United States, Europe and elsewhere are experiencing significant growth in “middle skill” occupations, which require more than a high school diploma, but less than a Bachelor’s degree. In NYS, average annual wages for middle skill occupations range from $20,180 to $146,280, with an average of $56,248 per year across all occupations. It is these jobs that many businesses in NYS, and the nation, are struggling to fill.
Occupational projections from the NYS Department of Labor indicate there will be 3.6 million job vacancies in New York between 2014 and 2024 as a result of new jobs (i.e., growth need) and openings from retirements and career changes (i.e., replacement need). Over a third of these available vacancies will require some type of formal education beyond high school, with 335,000 of these jobs available for those who fall into the “middle skill” category. This is approximately 10,000 more openings than those that will, in total, require a Bachelor’s, Master’s, or Doctoral/Professional degree.
Failure to address this gap will erode the state’s ability to strengthen middle class economic justice, and cause NYS businesses to be less competitive in the global economy due to losses in productivity.