U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.

Https

Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock () or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Plan: Washington PYs 2020-2023
Combined Plan C

Section: Vocational Rehabilitation Program (Blind)

Narrative: j. 1. A.

Published
Located in:

j. 1. A. With the most significant disabilities, including their need for supported employment services;

Current Narrative:

Agency response (j):

  • The Department of Services for the Blind (DSB) utilized data derived from comprehensive needs assessment efforts conducted throughout 2019, and has built upon that assessment data through meetings, audits, reviews, surveys and public forums with DSB agency participants, employees, partners, service providers, Rehabilitation Council members, the Client Assistance Program (CAP), tribal program representatives, school representatives and other community members.
  • The State Rehabilitation Council co-sponsored four public forums in the past year, where a call-in phone line allowed for statewide input from Washington State residents and agency participants.
  • DSB staff met with the State Rehabilitation Council to solicit discussion, engagement and feedback on the content of the combined state plan and the agency’s VR supplemental attachments.
  • A strategic planning refresh process in February 2019 provided perspective in reviewing our performance as a VR agency, and revised strategic initiatives.
  • Analysis of customer satisfaction surveys and performance data was considered.
  • Demographic data for the agency was compared to general Washington state demographics through tools such as the American Community Survey
  • The ACS data highlighted the progress that the agency had made in the previously underserved communities for agency services – the Hispanic/Latinx and Asian communities.
  • Workforce partner activities such as data gathered by the Barriers and Access Solutions Committee have highlighted areas of focus for underserved communities.
  • The Division of Vocational Rehabilitation CSNA report was useful in further understanding the needs of underserved communities and Worksource partner challenges.
  • The Center for Studying Disability Policy research brief on provision of Pre-Employment Transition Services provided insight to the comparison of state program activities to those of this agency.
  • Survey data from youth participating in Pre-Employment Transition Service career exploration and work experience programs were utilized to understand how Pre-ETS services are being received by users.

 

Demographic Profile:

The American Community Survey (ACS) compiled 5 year data (2013 – 2017) showed there are approximately 155,000 individuals of all ages who experience a visual disability. This represents about 2.2% of the general population, and about 10% of individuals with disabilities within the state.

 Traditional working age individuals (ages 18 - 64) represent the primary segment (52%) of the state’s population with visual disabilities. This represents about 1.8% of the general population in the same age group. About 60% of the caseload is represented by this age range.

 Approximately 41% of those in the state with visual disability are age 65 and older. This represents about 6.3% of the general population in the same age group.

 A large segment of the agency vocational rehabilitation participants is older than age 55, representing a shift in traditional notions of working and retirement age. About 20% of the caseload is over age 55, and 6% of the caseload is over age 65. In fact, the agency has assisted individuals in their 90’s to retain their job - a man age 91 retained his job as a psychologist in 2019.

 Youth with a visual disability, age birth to 18, represent approximately 7% of the state's population of individuals with a visual disability. This represents about 0.7% of the general population in the same age group.

While the ACS shows an estimated 11,000 youth with a visual disability, the Office of Superintendent for Public Instruction (OSPI) documents only around 400 IEP students with a visual disability. The OSPI count does not indicate a student with a visual disability when it aggregates the category “students with multiple disabilities”; thus an accurate count can’t be obtained from the state’s IEP data. As well, the OSPI does not document the number of students with an accommodation 504 plan. The Washington Sensory Disabilities Services (WSDS) manages the Washington Deaf Blind Project, which lists a count of 287 Deaf Blind youth in the state under age 18.

The Center for Change in Transition Services has tracked engagement of Washington State students with a disability after the first year exited from high school. The trend for engagement after high school has improved slightly for students with all disabilities from 2012 to 2017, steadily improving from 34.8% no engagement in 2012 to 27.8% no engagement in 2017.

Washingtonians with a visual disability age 16 - 64 are employed at lower rates than the total population, but at higher rates than the demographic group for all disabilities.

The employment rate for all Washington residents age 18 - 64 is 70.0%; for all individuals with a disability in that age group 40.7%; and for all individuals with a visual disability 47.2%.

In order to close the employment gap between those with a visual disability and population as a whole in Washington and to match the 70.0% employment rate, an approximate additional 18,000 blind, low vision or deaf blind individuals would need to become employed. The agency serves approximately less than 10% of the potential need in any given year.

All of those individuals exiting DSB’s VR program with employment earned greater than or equal to the state and/or local minimum wage. In FFY 2019 the average hourly wage earned by those who exited services with integrated and competitive employment was $24.29.

All eligible DSB participants have a visual disability. Many participants also have multiple disabilities.

In FFY2019, five of the 88 cases exiting with employment outcomes were integrated employment outcomes requiring long term supports; this represents 5.6% of all employment outcomes for that year.

Where other disability expertise is needed, we readily collaborate with partner agencies such as Division of Vocational Rehabilitation, Office of Deaf & Hard of Hearing, and the Developmental Disabilities Administration.

When an applicant presents no functional visual disability and therefore does not meet eligibility for DSB services, information & referral services to Workforce partner and other community resources is provided as appropriate.

For those participants who exited the program with employment outcomes in FFY2019, the average participant age at closure was 45.6 years old. The eldest participant with an employment outcome in that time period was age 91 (Self-employed Psychologist) and the youngest age 20 (Electromechanical Equipment Assemblers).

Social Security Administration estimates show that approximately 134,000 of Washington residents with a visual or other disability receive SSI/SSDI benefits. For FFY2019, 21% of the agency’s active participants rely on SSA financial and medical benefits (211 out of total 1009 active participants in January 2020).

Of those individuals who exited in FFY2019 with an employment outcome and had listed public assistance as their primary support at plan, 25% were able to rely on their earned income, and no longer require any public assistance at case closure.

In the previous state plan, the Asian community was identified to be under-represented among the customer base in comparison to general demographics. Targeted areas for outreach for increasing Asian participation in DSB services included these counties: King, Snohomish, Kitsap, Thurston, and Pierce; and the following linguistic communities: Chinese, Filipino, Vietnamese, and Korean. The agency's efforts have increased representation to be at par with the general population demographics. State demographics expect 7% of the state's population to identify with an Asian background, the agency's representation has consistently mirrored the state demographics with a 7% representation.

The Hispanic/Latinx community had also been identified as under-represented in the last state plan, but outreach and service provision efforts have brought parity of the percentage of the DSB Hispanic participant base and the state’s Hispanic/Latino demographic data. Washington State shows a representation of 13.9% Hispanic/Latino, and DSB now shows a representation of 14.3% among the participant base. Targeted areas of outreach for increasing Hispanic participation have included the following counties: King, Snohomish, Franklin, Grant, Skagit, Kitsap, Whatcom, and Walla Walla.

All other races and ethnicities are represented in the agency participant base in equal or higher ratios as the general Washington State demographics. All counties in the state are served.

As race/ethnicity are no longer identified as underserved communities for the VR program, the agency has identified other groups for whom obstacles to access to services exist. The agency and Workforce partners collected feedback and data, in particular showing the need to address the homeless crisis in the state, the needs of ex-offenders, and rural residents.

The Governor has listed homelessness as a statewide agenda for state agencies to coordinate efforts. As of January 2018, Washington had an estimated 22,304 experiencing homelessness on any given day, as reported by Continuums of Care to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). Of that total, 1,800 were family households, 1,636 were Veterans, 2,184 were unaccompanied young adults (aged 18-24), and 6,158 were individuals experiencing chronic homelessness.

Public school data reported to the U.S. Department of Education during the 2016-2017 school year shows that an estimated 39,127 public school students experienced homelessness over the course of the year. Youth and young adults experience homelessness in every region of Washington State. Despite what many people assume, rates of youth homelessness are similar in rural and urban areas. Yet while there are youth experiencing homelessness in all communities of the state, the resources to help them are not. There are no beds for homeless youth in half of the 39 counties in Washington. The homeless population includes individuals with visual disabilities; in the past year about 2% of our participants were experiencing homelessness. The barriers to individuals with disabilities who are also experiencing homelessness have been challenging to overcome, and require agency attention for improvement.

In SFY 2019, there were 63 DSB participants (out of 1165 served FFY2019) who received services through other components of the statewide workforce development system.

DSB identifies and qualifies Community Rehabilitation Program (CRP) and other service providers across the state to provide specialized Supported Employment and other job readiness, development, job customization, coaching, and work experience services, including Pre-Employment Transition services for students with a disability.

The agency provides on-going training and technical assistance related to issues of blindness to all CRPs who express an interest. Many CRPs are more familiar with supporting the needs for individuals with an intellectual disability, and there is often need for a much different approach in supporting the agency blind participants. Training is often needed to be refreshed as turn-over among CRP businesses is high. It is a challenge for this agency to secure skilled and effective CRP service providers across the state.

Participants have provided their feedback formally at exit from services; all individuals who exit services are surveyed within a month of exit. For FFY2019 many comments appeared to share some patterns:

  • Responsiveness is critically important to VR participants. There were many comments expressing gratitude for highly responsive services an individual received by agency staff, and a number of comments expressing frustrations at staff contact that wasn’t as frequent or rapid as the individual preferred. Responsiveness was one of the most cited comments, equally in both positive and negative lights.
  • Participants found the attitude and knowledge of staff a meaningful aspect of their VR experience, with predominantly positive comments about their interactions and progression. They commented that staff were respectful, patient, sensitive, thoughtful, upbeat, knowledgeable, cheerful, attentive, and demonstrated a belief in the participant.
  • Participants found the skills training the received through the agency staff life changing, and equated a greater sense of value and self-worth through gaining confidence in the adaptive skills of blindness. Technology, mobility, on-the-job training, tools for glare reduction, information on community resources like assistance with utilities, education, and counseling services were highlighted as providing a greater sense of independence, confidence, and a return to feeling like oneself.
  • While adaptive skills of blindness almost unanimously received strongly positive comments, the vocational services provided by the agency and through contracted service providers showed room for improvement in some comments. Job readiness, cover letters and resumes, identifying a good career fit and lack of skilled community resources were cited as frustrations for some.

 Staff and stakeholders gave feedback in a variety of forums. Some shared patterns include:

  • Gratitude for diversity and quality of employment outcomes
  • Appreciation for the need for improved internal and external communications; outreach; sharing of information
  • Strong concern about the agency achieving fiscal stability and to serve all eligible individuals immediately
  • Acknowledgement of wave of retirements and many new staff coming into the agency without a strong background in the specialized skills and needs of blindness
  • Challenge of understanding how the blind agency fits into the broader Workforce system – are the needs of our population base being met through the system?
  • Does the agency represent diversity, equity and inclusion to its highest capacity?
  • How can the agency reduce the administrative burden that WIOA has placed on agency staff?
  • How can the agency refocus on the core values of the Rehab Act to maximize the comprehensive and individualized services through frequent interaction and counseling and guidance?
  • Can the agency promote and advocate for a priority in state procurement for Disability-owned businesses?
  • How can the agency connect to apprenticeships, and the state’s new Career Connect programs?

Students have provided feedback at the end of Pre-Employment Transition workshops they have attended. Some patterns in the comments include:

  • Students enjoyed challenges of independence to include making adult choices during career exploration activities
  • Most felt that the academic prep workshops helped prepare for college and offered increased self-confidence
  • Many who attended work experience and academic prep workshop felt comfortable with program peers as well as formed professional relationships with co-workers at work experience.
  • Students felt trusted to have the responsibility of having their own living space and responsible for own daily living and chores.
  • Transportation was a major obstacle for many to attending Pre-ETS activities, particularly in the rural areas of the state.
  • Summertime is crowded for additional programs, hard to choose among offerings.
  • Hands-on work experience and workplace cultural navigation skills are a critical need for students with a visual disability