Located in:
- Program-specific Requirements for Adult, Dislocated Worker, and Youth Activities under Title I-B
The Unified or Combined State Plan must include the following with respect to activities carried out under subtitle B—
b. 3. Training Provider Eligibility Procedure
Provide the procedure, eligibility criteria, and information requirements for determining training provider initial and continued eligibility, including Registered Apprenticeship programs (WIOA Section 122).
Current Narrative:
Oklahoma Workforce Development Issuance 09-2020, released in October 2020, outlines the types of training authorized under WIOA, the requirements to become an eligible training provider (ETP), and the eligibility requirements for training programs. The policy also sets additional criteria for organizations applying for ETP approval, stresses the importance of required data reporting, and defines State, Local Workforce Development Board (LWDB), and Training Provider responsibilities in the state. Oklahoma’s eligible training provider list (ETPL) is designed to maximize customer choice and ensure all priority groups under WIOA are served. The ETPL is administered in a manner to ensure significant numbers of competent providers offering a wide variety of training programs and occupational choices are available to customers. Oklahoma’s ETPL is disseminated electronically through Oklahoma’s virtual case management system, OKJobMatch.com, which is also the system used by the state to receive, review and process applications for ETPL inclusion.
Eligible Training Provider List Procedure
Adding a program to the state’s Eligible Training Provider List is a two phase process. First, providers must apply to become approved by the state as Eligible Training Providers.
The current performance benchmarks for the initial eligibility of training providers, with the exception of Registered Apprenticeships, are based on the All Student population:
- The current performance benchmarks for the initial eligibility of training providers, with the exception of Registered Apprenticeships, are based on the All Student population:
- Number of students who completed training (must meet minimum 35%);
- Number of students that attained credentials – (must meet minimum 35%);
- Median Earnings: The median earnings of training program participants who are in unsubsidized employment during the second quarter after exit;
- Average Earnings in the 2nd quarter after exit; and
- Average Earnings in the 4th quarter after exit.
Then the provider must submit an additional application for each training program they wish to offer for initial program eligibility.
By creating an account in OKJobMatch, training providers may enter and edit information about their training institutions and the programs they offer. Once a provider applies online and is approved by the State, the local workforce board reviews the program entered by the provider and recommends approval to OOWD for programs that meet local criteria and the requirements stipulated in State policy.
Prior to beginning the application, an ETP applicant must assure their ability to provide training programs that are physically and programmatically accessible for individuals who are employed and individuals with barriers to employment, including individuals with disabilities. Assurances must be signed by each ETP that it and all of the provider’s employees responsible for providing training services will comply fully with all nondiscrimination and equal opportunity provisions of the laws, including WIOA Section 188, Title IV of The Civil Rights Act of 1964, Section 504 of The Rehabilitation Act of 1973, which prohibits discrimination against qualified individuals with disabilities, The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) of 1990, The Age Discrimination Act of 1975, Title IX of The Education Amendments of 1972, and The Oklahoma Act Against Discrimination. If the training provider does not check YES to all assurances above, they will not be able to complete the application for inclusion on the ETPL. With the exception of Registered Apprenticeship programs, training providers must comply with the criteria, information requirements, and procedures established under WIOA Section 122 to be included on the list of eligible providers of training services.
Initial Eligibility Criteria for Training Programs
All entities who have been approved as Eligible Training Providers must submit an additional application for each training program to be considered for inclusion on the ETP List. Training providers are encouraged to apply for program approval at least 60 days in advance of initial program offerings. Required information for initial approval include a complete description of the training program to be offered, including:
- Program cost,
- Occupation(s) for which the training prepares the individual;
- The number of participants enrolled in the program during the reporting period;
- The number of individuals who exited the program during the performance period. (defined as the total number of students who completed, withdrew, or transferred from the program of study in the reporting period.);
- Performance information pertaining to the training program’s All Student completion rate (defined as the aggregate number of all individuals, which includes both WIOA and non-WIOA, in the program of study/training program.)
- Performance information pertaining to the training program’s All Student credential attainment rate; and
- Information addressing the alignment of the training program with in-demand industry sectors and occupations.
An exception to the program specific performance requirement has been made for new programs that the ETP has never provided before. Initial eligibility for new training providers that have no history of providing training programs may be determined eligible for one year only, based on information such as: Whether they have attained the appropriate license, registration, accreditation, or approval to operate in Oklahoma; Whether have operated under another name(s); Whether they offer training aligned with in-demand occupations and industry sectors; and Information pertaining to operations in other states. Providers who fail to accurately submit all required initial eligibility information within 60 days from the date of the initial application will be denied.
Continued (Subsequent) Eligibility for Training Programs
After the initial year of eligibility, approved training programs must meet continued (subsequent) approval requirements to remain on the ETPL. Continued eligibility will then be reviewed at least every two years. Continued eligibility is based on information, reported by the ETP, for the All Student population of each program of training service (program of study) on the ETPL.
As required by WIOA, the state takes into account the following WIOA performance criteria for determining an ETP’s continued eligibility, based on the ETP’s All Student population:
- The number of the provider’s program participants who are in unsubsidized employment in the 2nd quarter after program exit;
- The number of the provider’s program participants who are in unsubsidized employment in the 4th quarter after program exit;
- The median earnings of the provider’s program participants during the 2nd quarter after exit from the program;
- The percentage of program participants who obtain a recognized postsecondary credential during participation in or within one year after exit from the program;
- The average earnings of individuals who are in unsubsidized employment during the 2nd quarter after exit; and
- The average earnings of individuals who are in unsubsidized employment during the 4th quarter after exit.
- Local coordinators are encouraged to contact the ETP within the 45 day period before the performance update is due as a courtesy reminder and to prevent removal of programs from the ETPL.
The All Student data is reviewed by the local area for a local determination, and then by the state for approval. The ETP receives an Eligibility Expiration Notice within 45 days of the date the previous program approval (or re-approval), provided that the contact information on the Training Providers Details page is current. ETP are strongly encouraged to update performance and cost information within the eligibility expiration period.
Additional factors that may be considered by local workforce boards prior to the electronic submission of training programs to the State for subsequent approval include:
- Specific economic, geographic and demographic factors in the workforce area in which the providers seeking eligibility are located;
- Characteristics of the population served by providers seeking eligibility, including the demonstrated difficulties in serving such populations;
- The degree to which training programs relate to in-demand industry sectors and occupations within the state;
- The performance of the provider’s training programs;
- The program’s cost of training;
- The involvement of employers in the establishment of skills requirements for the training program; and
- The impact provider performance will have on State-negotiated WIOA performance measures for all program participants.
Failure to provide the updated information after the updated performance request may result in the training program’s denial of continued eligibility. Repeated failures to update training program performance and cost information may result in the training provider’s removal from the ETPL.
Performance is still required to be entered biennially, at a minimum, by the training provider (or by their oversight agency through a data exchange process) for each training program. Local workforce boards cannot require training providers to update information more frequently than once per year, provided the information is accurately submitted. All Student and WIOA performance data will be captured through OKJobMatch and reported to ETA via the Workforce Integration Performance System (WIPS).
The state is in the process of re-evaluating the current performance benchmarks for ETPL eligibility, including continued eligibility. Oklahoma currently considers program completion rate and the credential attainment rate as the indicators of program performance used for ETPL eligibility determinations. However, the state is in the process of re-evaluating the current performance benchmarks for ETPL eligibility, including continued eligibility. With the aid of the State entities responsible for oversight of training providers, including ODCTE, OSRHE and the Oklahoma Board of Private Vocational Schools (OBPVS), and with input from the local workforce development boards, OOWD will determine a reasonable increase in the minimum performance standards for eligibility. This will ensure quality training providers and programs on the ETPL, as well as better performance outcomes.
Registered Apprenticeship Programs
Registered Apprenticeship Programs are automatically eligible to be included on the ETPL and are exempt from state and local ETP eligibility requirements. Due to the rigorous assessment RAPs have passed as part of the registration process with the U.S. Department of Labor’s Office of Apprenticeship (DOLETA/OA), additional information and performance requirements may not be required or requested of RAPs. If openings for new apprenticeships exist in the local area, the RA sponsor’s programs will automatically be considered in-demand training, and will be included and maintained on the ETPL as a statewide demand occupation for as long as the openings remain unfilled.
Each RAP sponsor must indicate whether they wish to be included on the ETPL. With the assistance of the State Office of Apprenticeship (OA), each RAP sponsor must be contacted to voice their willingness to be part of the ETPL. RAPs that opt for inclusion on the ETPL may request the State ETPL Administrator to add them to the ETPL with the provision of only the following basic information:
- Occupations included within the RAP;
- The name and address of the RAP sponsor;
- The name and address of the Related Technical Instruction (RTI) provider(s), and the location(s) of instruction if different from the program sponsor’s address;
- The method and length of instruction;
- The number of active apprentices; and
- The appropriate NAICS and SOC codes, as currently required by the State’s ETPL management system.
- RAPs will remain on the ETPL until:
- The RAP notifies the OOWD that it no longer wants to be included on the ETPL;
- The program becomes deregistered under the National Apprenticeship Act;
- The program is determined to have intentionally supplied inaccurate information; or
- A determination is made that the RAP substantially violated any provision of Title I of WIOA or the WIOA regulations, including 29 CFR part 38.
ETPs may voluntarily report performance outcomes, however local areas must not establish any RAP-specific reporting requirements. Unlike RAPs, Industry Recognized Apprenticeship Programs (IRAPs) seeking addition to the ETPL must follow the same process requirements as other training programs that are not RAPs, which are detailed in the sections below. IRAPs are required to be on the ETPL to receive WIOA training funds through an ITA.
The registration status of Registered Apprenticeship programs must be verified on a biennial basis. To accomplish this, continued registration status will be requested biennially from the State Office of Apprenticeship.
Intermediaries serving as RAPs who are employers using an outside instructional provider must identify their instructional provider in accordance with requirements established by their local board or the Oklahoma Office of Apprenticeship (OA).
Conditions for Removal from the ETPL
The State may remove a program or programs from the list for failing to meet the established criteria or for not providing all required performance information for subsequent eligibility. Removal is also appropriate if the program has failed to attain or has lost the accreditation required for professional licensure. A training provider that is removed from the list for reasons stated above may reapply for continued eligibility when they can demonstrate that they meet all requirements. Any providers that willfully supply false performance information, misrepresent costs or services, misrepresents their financial stability relating to the ability to provide training services, or violate requirements of WIOA law, including the provisions addressed in the Assurances section of the ETPL application regarding nondiscrimination, will be removed from the ETPL by the State for a period of not less than two years. Providers are liable to repay all adult, dislocated worker, and youth funds received during the period of non-compliance. No training provider debarred by the Federal Government may be permitted to be placed or remain on the ETPL. In the case of a training provider or a program of training services that is removed from the list while WIOA participants are enrolled, the participants may complete the program unless the provider or program has lost state licensing, certification, or authorization to operate by the appropriate state oversight agency. This section does not apply to Registered Apprenticeship programs, whose registration status is required to be assessed by the OOWD on a biennial basis at a minimum.
Appeal Process
Training providers can choose to appeal the rejection of their program for inclusion on the ETPL, or its subsequent termination of eligibility. The appeal must be submitted in writing via email to OOWD within 14 days after notification of the decision. The appeal must include the justification for the appeal in the request. The provider must also have the right to request a hearing to discuss their appeal. If a hearing is requested, a board will be convened consisting of OOWD management, the OOWD ETPL Administrator, and the LWDB Director. A decision will be made within 60 days of appeal. This will be a final decision and, if the removal is upheld, the program will be prohibited from reapplying for one year from the date of the final decision or for two years if the removal was for submittal of false information.
State ETPL Responsibilities
OOWD is responsible for the following:
- Develop, maintain, and disseminate the ETPL, including the list of training providers and their programs of study.
- Establish a minimally burdensome mechanism for adding Registered Apprenticeship programs (RAPs) to the list and verifying registration status at least every two years.
- Work with the State Board (the Governor’s Council) to develop procedures, information requirements, and criteria for determining eligibility, including clarifying state and local board responsibilities.
- Review and finalize the approval of providers and programs recommended by the LWDBs.
- Determine whether training providers submitted accurate information for the eligibility criteria and performance levels, and take enforcement actions as needed if the provider intentionally submitted inaccurate information or substantially violated WIOA requirements.
- Ensure that state-established minimal performance levels for initial and/or continued eligibility are met, including verifying the accuracy of the information.
- Establish procedures for removing a provider from the ETPL.8. Establish a procedure by which a provider can demonstrate that providing state-required additional performance and cost information would be unduly burdensome or costly.
Local Workforce Board ETPL Responsibilities
The LWDB is responsible for carrying out the following procedures assigned by the State:
- Ensuring that there are sufficient numbers and types of providers of training services (including eligible providers with expertise in assisting individuals with disabilities and eligible providers with expertise in assisting adults in need of adult education and literacy activities) serving the local area and providing the services involved in a manner that maximizes consumer choice and leads to competitive integrated employment for individuals with disabilities.
- Making recommendations to OOWD for approving training providers based on demand occupations in the local area.
- Establishing relationships with the ETPs in the local area to provide technical assistance, collect performance information as required by the State and determining whether the providers meet the state’s performance criteria, and locally approving or denying initial and continued eligibility applications based on said criteria.
- Recommending that the state remove ETPs that fail to meet local performance standards, in accordance with local policies and procedures.
- Ensuring that the state’s ETP list is disseminated publicly through the local one-stop system, including in formats accessible to individuals with disabilities, and its partner programs.
- Identifying in-demand sectors or occupations for the local area using relevant labor market information.
- Reviewing the accuracy of eligibility criteria and performance information for initial applications and applications for continued ETPL approval prior to submission to the State for final approval.
As mentioned in bullet 3, the responsibility of developing a relationship with training providers falls on the local area. The success of the ETP program is tied to each local area ETP coordinator’s working relationship with the trainers in their respective areas and serving as the linkage between the clients and the training providers, which leads both to better compliance with state ETP requirements and better outcomes. The state, therefore, is providing technical assistance to the local ETP coordinators to facilitate closer communication and collaboration between providers and local area staff.