U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.

Https

Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock () or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

2 Year Modification

Plan: Texas PYs 2022-2023 (Mod)
Combined Plan C

Section: Wagner-Peyser Act

Narrative: e. 2.

Published
Located in:

e. 2. An assessment of the agricultural activity in the State means: 1) Identifying the top five labor-intensive crops, the months of heavy activity, and the geographic area of prime activity; 2) Summarize the agricultural employers’ needs in the State (i.e. are they predominantly hiring local or foreign workers, are they expressing that there is a scarcity in the agricultural workforce); and 3) Identifying any economic, natural, or other factors that are affecting agriculture in the State or any projected factors that will affect agriculture in the State

Current Narrative:

Texas Agricultural Regions

Texas ranked sixth nationally in the value of agricultural exports in 2020 and 14th in fresh vegetable production, accounting for about 2 percent of US vegetable production. The leading counties for vegetable acres harvested were Hidalgo, Starr, and Cameron. Other important counties include Frio, Uvalde, Duval, Webb, Hale, Yoakum, and Zavala. Texas ranked ninth in fruit production and fifth in tree nut production, with combined fruit and nut production values at $148 million.

Land preparation, planting, irrigating, and harvesting are ongoing activities; therefore, agricultural employment occurs year-round at numerous locations. Usually, employment for farmworkers begins in the Lower Rio Grande Valley region, served by the Lower Rio Grande Valley and Cameron County Boards, and the Winter Garden and South/Central region, served by the Middle Rio Grande Board. Employment of migrant farmworkers moves northward to the Texas Panhandle as the agricultural season progresses. Workers who follow this crop pattern may migrate to other states as well.

Review of Previous Year’s Agricultural Activity in Texas

For the Program Year 2020 (PY’20) Agricultural Outreach Plan, TWC used the most recent available data. Although Texas regions support a wide variety of agricultural activities, data is not collected by a single entity using consistent time frames and methods. Data is limited for agricultural activities such as producing wheat, grain, and other labor-extensive crops and for labor-intensive production such as cotton ginning. Furthermore, available data sources do not collect production or forecast data based on the federal program year. For the purposes of this plan, calendar years are used when no other data is available. TWC is working with agricultural associations and other sources to improve the data available for planning.

Table 1 summarizes the agronomic crop production statistics for each of Texas’ primary growing regions for Calendar Years 2018–2020 (CY’18–20). Regional production statistics for horticultural crops are currently unavailable. For agronomic crops, the vast acreages of grain and row crops in the high plains and rolling plains make up most of the 8.59 million acres planted in the plain’s region. The eastern region of the state accounted for the majority of the remainder of agronomic crop production in Texas. Agronomic crops are typically less labor intensive because more capital machinery is used in planting and harvesting as compared to most horticultural crops.

It’s important to note that some inconsistencies can be observed during 2020 due to a lack of fully reported data from some regions. Most notably, there is a lack of reporting for cotton in all regions, which explains part of the large decrease in planted and harvested acres of the Far West region.

Table 1

RegionArea Planted (in acres) 2018Area Planted (in acres) 2019Area Planted (in acres)        2020Area Harvested (in acres) 2018Area Harvested (in acres) 2019Area Harvested (in acres) 2020Main Crops
Lower Rio Grande Valley506,200328,300302,300414,230339,100261,600corn, cotton, sorghum, sugar cane
Plains7,787,1808,587,1004,300,7003,960,6605,411,4102,116,060corn, cotton, peanuts, sorghum, wheat
Eastern2,844,3002,480,3001,962,0002,404,7102,212,.0501,518,060corn, cotton, rice, sorghum, soybean, wheat
Far West437,700522,60013,30046,100382,8002,430cotton, wheat
Winter Garden and South Central1,049,9001,120,900733,200654,290832,960369,530corn, cotton, sorghum, wheat
Texas Totals12,625,28013,039,2007,311,5007,479,9909,178,3204,267,670 

Source: Data is from the National Agricultural Statistics Service, USDA, and Center for North American Studies, Texas A&M AgriLife Extension Service.

Review of the Previous Year’s Agricultural Worker Activity in Texas

The Lower Rio Grande Valley has the most labor-intensive production, accounting for most of the horticultural crops in Texas. The top five labor intensive crops include onions, watermelons, citrus, sugar cane, and leafy greens, plus a variety of other produce including cabbage, carrots, potatoes, cucumbers, cilantro, and spinach. Peak harvest seasons typically run from mid-March through late June. The citrus harvest starts in early-to-mid-September and, depending on the quality of the crop, may run through early May. The harvest season in the Winter Garden and South/Central regions runs from mid-May through early July, with onions, melons, greens, squash, and corn as the top five labor intensive crops. Both regions grow winter crops year round. The South Plains harvest season typically runs from mid-July through October, with the top five crops including melons and gourds, greens, potatoes, peas, and beans. Additionally, this area is known for growing winter wheat, sorghum, and other seeds. The cotton ginning peak season typically runs from October through January, depending on the quality of the crop production. In the El Paso region, the peak harvest season runs from late September through early December or the first frost. Crops in this area include chili (jalapeño) peppers, onions, cabbage, pecans, bell peppers, cauliflower, eggplant, broccoli, and cotton. Horticultural crops also are grown throughout the state. Table 2 provides data on Texas vegetable production and average monthly labor, with crop information for CY’18–20. Fruit and vegetable production is typically the most labor intensive.

Table 2

CropCY’18 AcresCY’18 Labor Est.CY’18 MonthsCY’19 AcresCY’19 Labor Est.CY’19 MonthsCY’20 AcresCY’20 Labor Est.CY’20 Months
Citrus (1,000 Boxes)7,0004,14486,6403,32984,9602,9378
Peaches (Tons)12,4006132,4006132,400613
Pecans (1,000    Pounds)133,600101337,500113342,6001283
Bell Peppers1175295617529561752956
Cabbage5,0005105(D)N/A56,4006635
Cantaloupes12,00032122,00032122,0003212
Carrots11,4185831,4185831,418583
Chile Peppers12,5001,38552,5001,38552,5001,3855
Cucumbers4,9004,2885(D)N/A55,7004,9685
Honeydews1302342302342302342
Onions11,0001,58749001,296411,0001,5874
Potatoes17,500257414,800218415,3002254
Pumpkins4,8001834(D)N/A43,7001384
Spinach, Fresh2105044(D)N/A42,8006724
Squash11,50045561,50045561,5004556
Sweet Corn12,3297042,3297042,329704
Sweet Potatoes1622133622133622133
Tomatoes1706530770653077065307
Watermelons223,000711621,500664619,0005876
Total Acreage79,95215,506N/A56,8528,853N/A75,45215,135N/A

Source: National Agricultural Statistics Services, NASS/USDA

1 Production acreage is based on production data from the previous year.

2 Acreage is based on yearly yield per acre.

(D) Withheld to avoid disclosing data for individuals' operations

Projected Level of Agricultural Activity in Texas for the Coming Year

As seen nationally, some areas that historically have had high concentrations of agricultural work have experienced industry reduction relative to other types of work, such as employment in the oil and gas, construction, and retail industries. With that industry reduction, there has been a shift in the labor market. While some workers and their families who have long performed agricultural work are now being employed in nonagricultural industries, other workers are struggling to identify transferable skills that will allow them to obtain nonagricultural jobs. A good example is the Eagle Ford Shale boom in the Winter Garden region (in South Texas, north of Laredo and southwest of San Antonio) and the Cline Shale in West Texas. Although employers in the oil and gas industry have a relatively large demand for qualified employees, they find few qualified applicants, in part because the local migrant and seasonal farm worker (MSFW) population lacks the relevant transferable skills and training. The industrial shift has created a challenge for agricultural employers as well. Texas is designated as an agricultural supply state, yet many agricultural employers will have fewer laborers to meet demand. With other employment options available that may be less physically taxing, and fewer immigration controls in place, more workers seek nonagricultural jobs. The state’s major citrus growers’ associations have said that the labor shortage is one of their most critical issues.

In addition to the issues of labor moving to industries outside of agriculture, the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic has further decreased the number of farmworkers in Texas. Business disruptions and lockdowns diminished agricultural productivity throughout the course of the pandemic, resulting in fewer acres of planted products. Health concerns from workers to avoid exposure to the virus, as well as being at home to provide child care, also contributed to the shortage of farmworkers in the state.

Despite Texas being considered an agricultural supply state, the factors mentioned above continue to result in agricultural employers having fewer laborers to meet their needs. Major citrus growers’ associations in Texas have said that labor shortages have been one of their most challenging issues.

Projected Migrant and Seasonal Farm Workers (MSFW) in Texas

According to data from the National Agricultural Statistics Service, USDA, and Texas A&M AgriLife Extension Service, TWC estimates that 255,000 MSFWs will be active in Texas in the coming year. Although it is possible that jobs may be lost because of natural disasters and other adverse events, the number of MSFWs that reside in Texas is anticipated to decrease. Currently, there are more than 9,876 active agricultural employers in Texas, based on the North American Industry Classification System codes reported for each employer’s UI tax accounts.

Table 3

Agricultural Employers                                                                                                                                                     PY'192                        PY'203

Number of Job Postings11,0471,307
Number of Job Openings3,4333,049
Number of Job Openings Filled457105
Percentage of Job Openings Filled13.33.4

1 Number of job postings does not accurately reflect the number of employers because employers may file multiple postings within a year. Each posting may contain multiple job openings.

2PY’19 data represent the July 1, 2019–June 30, 2020 period.

3PY’20 data represent the July 1, 2020–June 30, 2021 period.

Table 4

Agricultural Employers (H-2A Only)                                                                                                                               PY'201                    PY'211

H-2A Job Orders Received739938
H-2A Job Orders Certified703827

1PY’20 and PY’21 data represents the October 1, 2019–September 30, 2020 period, and PY’21 represents the October 1, 2020–September 30, 2021 period. Data is from the USDOL/OFLC Disclosure Data page.

Several economic, natural, or other factors affect agricultural production in Texas. The COVID-19 pandemic has created uncertainty in production and the reliable need for labor, as well as a moderate increase of H-2A Job Orders certified. Moreover, according to PY’21 program statistics, Texas is now listed for the first time in the top 10 states for H-2A filings by number of workers certified. The following list does not assign these factors an order of importance, as more than one issue may exist at  any time:

  • COVID-19 pandemic and the uncertainty of migration for reliable labor
  • Increase of H-2A workers
  • MSFWs chosen to seek employment locally due to fear of the ongoing pandemic and other matters related to family income, social economic issues, and other factors
  • Lack of affordable housing and other risk factors in shared housing
  • Ongoing fears of the COVID-19 pandemic and unvaccinated workers and families
  • The cost of fuel
  • Secondary sources of income related to energy production
  • Varied weather patterns. Dry years interspersed with wet years has a critical effect on agricultural production. Because of the size of Texas—268,820 square miles (171,891,725 acres)—weather varies dramatically by geography
  • The amount of snowfall in midwestern states can have a negative effect on agricultural production in Texas in relation to the water allotment for irrigation methods along the Rio Grande River.
  • Tax policy as it relates to succession from generation to generation. The high average age of farmers—58 years of age—is part of this issue.
  • Environmental policies enforced by the Environmental Protection Agency and the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality
  • The policy requirements for the agricultural industry established by the Food Safety Modernization Act
  • Immigration law and enforcement, particularly as it affects the availability of labor for fruit and vegetable production but also in other agricultural sectors
  • Invasive species coming from other parts of the United States or from other countries, which can  negatively affect the agricultural production
  • The changing nature of US agriculture’s domestic policy to a more crop-insurance-based program
  • The conversion of agricultural land to developed land for housing and commercial uses
  • Water availability affected by weather, the increased need for urban water, and issues related to the 1944 US-Mexico Water Treaty (“Treaty Utilization of Waters of the Colorado and Tijuana Rivers and of the Rio Grande”)
  • Uncertainty of trade agreements with Mexico and the global economic impact of tariffs that affect agricultural imports and exports

Economic Impact of Imported Fresh Produce from Mexico

Produce imports from Mexico are a major source of economic activity in the Lower Rio Grande Valley. The United States imported $12.9 billion of produce and products from Mexico during 2017, including fresh, frozen, and processed fruits; vegetables; and nuts. About 98 percent of these imports entered the United States by land ports between Mexico and Texas, New Mexico, Arizona, and California. When considering only fresh fruits and vegetables, which comprise nearly 90 percent of the total, imports totaled $11.7 billion.

Based upon a forecasting approach that includes ongoing trends and input from industry, it is estimated that US produce that is imported from Mexico via truck will increase nearly 35 percent, as shown below in Figure 1. Most of this growth will occur through Texas ports, with imports expected to grow in Texas by 44 percent. By 2025, it is projected that imports to Texas will account for slightly more than half of US produce imports from Mexico. This growth in imports has implications throughout the border economy, and for the Texas economy especially.

The prognosis of continued expected growth in US imports of fresh produce in general and especially in Texas is based on several factors. One important factor is that US interest rates are beginning to rise, causing the dollar to appreciate, which will spur even more imports. Another important factor is the expanded use of Mexican Federal Highway 40 between Mazatlán and Reynosa for shipments of produce. Further, an expanded infrastructure of trade-services providers in the Lower Rio Grande Valley area has been built to accommodate recent and expected increases in imports, illustrating industry’s belief that increased shipments through Texas are likely to continue.

Figure 1: Texas Agricultural Economics Forecast

https://www.twc.texas.gov/files/partners/texas-agricultural-economics-forecast-twc.jpg

http://cnas.tamu.edu/Index/Mexican%20FFV%20Imports%20through%20US%20Land%20Borders%202025%20March%202018.pdf

Estimated Economic Impact

The economic impact of produce imports on agricultural and farmworker activity in the state is compelling. In 2017, direct economic activity attributed to the produce import industry was $401.1 million, requiring an additional $448.5 million in economic activity from supporting industries, resulting in a total economic impact of $849.6 million. By 2025, this economic effect is expected to grow to $577.5 million in direct activity and $645.7 million in supporting activity for a total of $1.2 billion in economic activity throughout the Texas economy. Truck transportation is anticipated to lead direct output at $169.4 million, to be followed by warehousing ($132.1 million); sorting, grading, and packing ($123.6 million); customs brokering ($91.5 million); and miscellaneous border services ($61.0 million).

During 2017, 7,836 jobs were required across Texas to support import operations. Sorting, grading, and packing required 2,021 jobs; customs broker services, 1,069 jobs; warehousing, 1,028 jobs; truck transportation, 779 jobs; and miscellaneous border services, 347 jobs. Another 2,592 jobs were required in supporting sectors. By 2025, 11,281 jobs will be required throughout the Texas economy to support these imports. Sorting, grading, and packing will require 2,910 jobs, followed by customs broker services (1,538 jobs); warehousing (1,479 jobs); truck transportation (1,121 jobs); and miscellaneous border services (500 jobs). Another 6,643 jobs will be required in supporting sectors by 2025.

Table 5.

Summary of Economic Activity from US Produce Imports from Mexico over Land Borders, 2017 and 2025 Forecast with Industry Input

Economic Activity Indicators                                                                                                            2017                                     2025 Forecast

Total Truckloads235,288338,716
Direct Economic OutputIn MillionsIn Millions
Truck Transportation$11.76$169.4
Warehousing$91.8$132.1
Sorting, Grading and Packing$85.8$123.6
Customs Brokering$63.5$91.5
Miscellaneous Border Services$42.5$61.0
Total Direct Economic Output$401.1$577.5
Economic Activity Indicators20172025F
Total Supporting Economic Output$448.5$645.7
Total Economic Output$849.6$1,223.2
Total Jobs Supporting Produce Imports7,83611,281

Source: Agricultural Marketing Service, USDA and Center for North American Studies, Department of Agricultural Economics, Texas A&M University/Texas A&M AgriLife Extension Service/Texas A&M AgriLife Research