U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.

Https

Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock () or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

2 Year Modification

Plan: New Jersey PYs 2022-2023 (Mod)
Combined Plan C

Section: Vocational Rehabilitation Program (Blind)

Narrative: j. 1. A.

Published
Located in:

j. 1. A. With the most significant disabilities, including their need for supported employment services;

Current Narrative:

The Commission for the Blind and Visually Impaired (CBVI) in collaboration with its State Rehabilitation Council (SRC) and the assistance of the Institute for Community Inclusion at the University of Massachusetts Boston, conducted a comprehensive statewide needs assessment to ascertain the rehabilitation needs of individuals who are blind, deaf-blind, and visually impaired, completed in 2021. The intent of the assessment was to obtain information on these needs, services gaps, and agency strengths/areas of improvement. The SRC was actively involved in the process, including the development of assessment methods and served as an active partner in conducting the assessment activities with the agency.

The assessment efforts yielded quantitative and qualitative data on the employment needs of this population from various sources. The information gleaned from these assessment activities was used by the agency to further develop goals, objectives, and strategies that will improve outcomes for those that receive vocational rehabilitation services from the agency and to improve outreach efforts to unserved or underserved populations.

The process that was developed for conducting the needs assessment involved six primary data-gathering approaches:

  • Focus groups conducted with consumer and stakeholder groups, including a focus on students and youth, deaf-blind consumers, and general VR consumers to be conducted at a range of locations across the state.
  • Electronic surveys conducted with the following stakeholder groups: consumers (including a focus on students and youth, deaf-blind consumers, and individuals with the most significant disabilities); CBVI staff; Community Rehabilitation Providers
  • Individual stakeholder interviews conducted with the following groups: Workforce partners, including One-Stops; Businesses
  • A Request for Information to solicit feedback from CRPs and Stakeholders on how to restructure and improve the range of employment services provided, including Pre-Placement Activities & Job Development, Time-Limited Job Coaching, Supported Employment Job Coaching, Services to Students and Youth, including Supported Employment.
  • Analysis of a variety of existing demographic and case service data relevant to blind, deaf-blind, and visually impaired individuals;
  • An assessment of the Joseph Kohn Training Center, including a physical assessment of the building for the identification of capital projects, and a strategic plan for programmatic improvement.

In addition to the formal assessment activities for the CSNA, CBVI has engaged consumers, the State Rehabilitation Council, stakeholders, and CRPs throughout this CSNA cycle, which has contributed to the identification of areas that warrant further exploration, improvement, and the development of additional programs and services.  

  • Through feedback from the SRC and stakeholders, as well as a review of the Youth Employment Solutions pilot (described further in Section (2) below), CBVI has identified that the current Supported Employment (SE) services do not fully meet the needs of individuals with the most significant disabilities, and do not facilitate successful employment outcomes at a desired rate. In comparing the agency’s outcome data with that of the YES program, the YES program demonstrated a higher rate of employment outcomes than seen through traditional SE services. Some characteristics unique to the YES program include more person-centered and customized employment approaches, increased collaboration between a consumer’s adult services providers (particularly those that are outside the VR program), activities that maintain consumer engagement, and a payment structure that focuses on outcomes and deliverables. The Request for Information, will be utilized to further obtain information that will guide the development of a new program structure and Request for Proposal to develop a new list of CRPs committed to providing SE services to CBVI consumers.
  • Through prior CSNAs, as well as feedback from stakeholders and staff, CBVI has identified that consumers who are minorities, as well as those who are economically disadvantaged, may face additional challenges in accessing services due to language and other non-disability related barriers. The agency has begun taking steps to address these barriers by hiring social workers (including those who are bilingual) to facilitate information and referral to appropriate local community and governmental agencies, and identifying and expanding the agency’s list of interpreting vendors.
  • Prior CSNAs, as well as SRC, consumer, and stakeholder feedback, have identified two primary groups believed to be underserved by CBVI: Deaf-Blind consumers and consumers with the most significant disabilities who require SE services. 1) To address the needs of Deaf-Blind consumers, CBVI has hired an additional VRC Deaf-Blind Specialist. Additional consumer feedback has highlighted the need to expand the agency’s Support Service Providers program, to be more flexible in addressing the support needs of Deaf-Blind consumers. Dedicated focus groups and outreach for feedback to the Deaf-Blind community and stakeholders were conducted to further identify how to better serve this population. 2) To address the needs of consumers with the most significant disabilities.
  • SRC, consumer, and stakeholder feedback has previously identified a need to enhance cooperation and collaboration with other workforce partners, as well as access for blind, deaf-blind, and visually impaired consumers. CBVI continues to work on this, as required under WIOA, and conducted informational interviews with the Local Workforce Development Boards and One-Stops as part of this CSNA cycle that contributed to CBVI’s proposed contributions within the local area MOUs and IFAs.
  • CBVI has struggled historically with obtaining feedback from students and their parents on the need to improve, enhance, or create additional Transition and Pre-Employment Transition Services. This challenge was also reflected in CBVI’s experience during the CSNA cycle. CBVI staff working with students and youth have identified the need for additional options for students with disabilities that may not be interested in the agency’s existing programs, either due to the residential component or time-commitment. CBVI plans on conducting focused outreach to transition-age youth and their families to increase future participation in the survey, as well as focus groups, to identify what areas are identified as a priority to our students and youth with disabilities and their families. The RFI referenced above, will also request feedback from stakeholders and CRPs on enhancing the provision of work-based learning experiences to students and youth with disabilities. Finally, CBVI will be issuing an RFP to identify additional vendors for the provision of short-term and targeted topic Pre-ETS services, to supplement our more comprehensive summer and year-round Pre-ETS programs.

COVID-19 Response

The onset of the COVID-19 pandemic greatly impacted the provision of, and efficacy of, NJCBVI services. The challenge in adjusting to this unprecedented health crisis was grounded both in the nature of converting services to a virtual platform, as well as the time frame required for such a change. As such, the pandemic forced a degree of isolation upon a population already prone to feelings of disconnection. labor market data has not yet been collected.

However, throughout the course of the adjustment, certain advantages were realized that CBVI hopes to continue to utilize as we move forward as an option to enhance access when appropriate. Virtual and remote learning provide for increased flexibility in meeting consumer needs, allowing for more frequent instruction and eliminating the costs of travel associated with in-person contact. Utilizing virtual learning in this way overcame certain previously encountered scheduling related barriers. Remote instruction also allowed for service provision in situations where in-person contact may not have been preferred due to other circumstances such as medical needs not associated with COVID-19, or in situations where an in-person meeting location may not have been convenient.

Though virtual learning was an option for many, there were those who were adversely impacted by this necessary alteration. The Deaf-Blind population were heavily impacted as denial of in-person service meant the elimination of tactile ASL essential for communication. As virtual learning requires a base-line of reliable technology and internet service, consumers from low-income households were more likely to encounter associated challenges with virtual instruction. Additionally, in order for remote learning to be effective, the consumer must possess foundational skills in the use of their technology, a skillset that would not necessarily be present in certain cases such as with newer referrals. Remote learning, by its very nature, tended to increase preexisting feelings of isolation and disconnection.

In order to overcome some of the challenges associated with isolation, communication, and technology, NJCBVI implemented a number of corrective measures. Frequent virtual outreach became a regular component of VR and IL service provision. An increase virtual presence allowed for the dissemination of information and provided additional methods to stay in regular contact with consumers. The agency saw to the provision of iPads to those consumers who would benefit from the technology for access, and the communication potential it represented. Alterations were made in instructional methods allowing for robust virtual curricula on a wide range of subject matter. Finally, as the COVID-19 guidance has evolved and allowed with the appropriate precautions, CBVI resumed in-person services for consumers when appropriate and desired by the consumer, while continuing virtual offerings, to be flexible to the unique needs of the wide range of individuals served.

Data Collection from National Databases

Data sources used for this report include:

  • 2017 Disability Status Report for New Jersey from Cornell University’s Employment and Disability Institute
  •  U.S. Census Bureau’s 2018 American Community Survey (ACS)
  •  2017 Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
  • The American Foundation for the Blind-Prevalence Rates of Visual Loss (January 2017)
  • The National Research and Training Center on Blindness & Low Vision at Mississippi State University

All Disabilities

Data Source: 2017 Cornell Disabilities Status Report New Jersey, 2017 Cornell Disabilities Status Report US, and 2018 American Community Survey (ACS).

Nationally, the prevalence rate for all types of disabilities across all age groups was 12.7 percent.  In New Jersey, the prevalence rate for all types of disabilities across all age groups was 10.2 percent.  Based on the prevalence rates for New Jersey of individuals with a wide range of disabilities, it is estimated that 908,699 New Jersey residents have some level of disability.  Of that population aged 18-64, 20.9 percent have income that is at or below the Federal poverty rate.  In addition, those individuals aged 21-64 with disabilities that are living in the community are employed at a rate of 37.3 percent nationally, and slightly higher in New Jersey at 39.2 percent.

Data Source: 2017 Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System – Disability and Health Data (DHDS) Systems Data, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

The prevalence rate for all types of disabilities among adults 18 years of age or older was 25.6 percent nationally, compared to a slightly lower 24.6 percent in New Jersey.  The prevalence rate for a visual disability among adults 18 years of age or older was 4.7 percent, both nationally and in New Jersey.

Blindness & Vision Impairment

Data Sources: AFB Prevalence Rates of Visual Loss (1/2017), and 2015 Disability Status Report for New Jersey

Recent survey data on overall prevalence rates of vision loss across all age groups was available at the American Foundation for the Blind (updated January 2017), and indicates that approximately 161,587 New Jersey residents are blind or visually impaired, a prevalence rate of 1.8 percent of the general population. This prevalence rate is slightly lower than the national rate of 2.3 percent.  For ages 21-64, all races and ethnicities, it is estimated that 74,300 New Jersey residents have vision impairments, a prevalence rate of 1.4 percent of the base population in the State.  It was also observed in the data review that the Black/African American population, regardless of ethnicity, living in New Jersey, has a slightly higher rate of vision loss, at 2.5 percent.  Individuals who identified their ethnicity as Hispanic, all racial groups, had a prevalence rate of vision impairment at 2 percent of the general population.

Data Source:  2017 Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance Systems

When defined more broadly to include functional disability, as defined as “blind or serious difficulty seeing, even when wearing glasses” in the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (2017) conducted by the CDC, 4.7 percent of adults of all ages, races and ethnicities reported having a functional visual disability, the same as the national average. When broken down by age, 2.8 percent of individuals 18-44 identify has having a vision disability, and 6.2 percent of individuals age 45-64 identify as having a vision disability. Individuals who identified as Black, non-Hispanic, (7.4 percent) and Hispanic (8.4 percent) reported having a vision disability at a much higher rate than those who identified as White, non-Hispanic (3.1 percent).

Deaf-Blindness

Data source: Mississippi State University National Research and Training Center on Blindness & Low Vision (NRTC) and U.S. Census Bureau Data

Data from the U.S. Census Bureau indicates that 0.77 percent of the U.S. population experiences both vision and hearing loss. The NRTC’s review of the data indicates that this population experiences an unemployment rate is more than twice that of the general population, 15.7 percent compared to 7.7 percent.