U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.

Https

Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock () or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Plan: New York PYs 2024-2027
Combined Plan C

Section: WIOA State Plan Common Elements

Narrative: III. a. 2. C.

Published
Some content in this area is under revision.
Located in:
  • III. Operational Planning Elements

    The Unified or Combined State Plan must include an Operational Planning Elements section that supports the State’s strategy and the system-wide vision described in Section II(c) above.  Unless otherwise noted, all Operational Planning Elements apply to Combined State Plan partner programs included in the plan as well as to core programs.  This section must include—

    • a. State Strategy Implementation

      The Unified or Combined State Plan must include–

      • 2. Implementation of State Strategy

        Describe how the lead State agency with responsibility for the administration of each core program or a Combined Plan partner program included in this plan will implement the State’s Strategies identified in Section II(c). above. This must include a description of—

III. a. 2. C. Coordination, Alignment and Provision of Services to Individuals

Describe how the entities carrying out the respective core programs, Combined State Plan partner programs included in this plan, and required and optional one-stop partner programs will coordinate activities and resources to provide comprehensive, high-quality, customer-centered services, including supportive services (e.g. transportation), to individuals, including those populations identified in section II(a)(1)(B), and individuals in remote areas. The activities described shall conform to the statutory requirements of each program.   

Current Narrative:

To provide comprehensive, high-quality, customer-centered services, including supportive services to individuals, it is imperative to understand their needs and desires from their perspective, including how they currently interact with the System. To gather real-time feedback, NYSDOL issues annual Statewide Business and Job Seeker Surveys.

A portion of the narrative that follows includes a summary of these survey results and how the NYS System is providing comprehensive, high-quality services to individuals and businesses based on their direct feedback and in the context of NYS’s broader strategy to address complex, system-wide issues. The summary applies to III.a.2.C. Coordination, Alignment and Provision of Services to Individuals as well as the III.a.2.D. Coordination, Alignment and Provision of Services to Businesses sections of this Combined Plan.

NYSDOL Statewide Workforce Surveys

In 2021, NYSDOL and The Business Council of New York State (Business Council) partnered to conduct a comprehensive survey of NYS businesses focused on workforce development. As a follow-up to that survey, NYSDOL also launched a Statewide Job Seeker Survey the same year. The results of these surveys continue to shape workforce development practices and policy from the P-12 system to higher education and among training providers across NYS.

In 2022 and 2023, NYSDOL again worked to gather real-time feedback on the state of the workforce from job seekers, with 8,200 individuals responding to the 2023 Survey.  

The NYS AFL-CIO, NYATEP, The Business Council and the Workforce Development Institute (WDI) assisted in shaping the Job Seeker Survey questions. As with the previous surveys, survey questions were optional, but job seekers were encouraged to answer as many as possible. Percentages listed represent a percentage of the total participants for that individual question, not all survey participants.

Main takeaways from the 2023 Job Seeker Survey:

  • Workers’ needs and expectations have shifted;
  • There is significant need for training and upskilling; and
  • A lack of professional networks, experience, and credentials limit growth.

As in years past, businesses’ top challenge in 2023 was attracting new workers, with inflation and retaining current workers second and third, respectively. Lack of experience continues to be a major barrier that prevents a business from hiring a job candidate and prevents the candidate from taking a job. Businesses consistently identified both technical and non-technical skills to be lacking among job applicants and new employees, as shown in the tables below.

Non-Technical Skills Lacking (Statewide, All industries)202120222023
Self-motivation64%70%61%
Communication 66%52%56%
Problem-solving/critical thinking63%48%52%
Timeliness/attendance 51%55%51%
Attention to detail 58%50%46%
Technical Skills Lacking (Statewide, All industries)202120222023
Basic computer use/computer literacy 47%44%48%
Software proficiency in Excel 39%32%34%
Email proficiency19%19%22%
Mechanical technical/engineering 23%19%22%
Software proficiency in Word 23%17%19%

Survey results also reflected the incentives and services job seekers said would be most beneficial to them:

Incentive (Statewide)2023
Ability to work remotely full-time36%
Paid time off35%
Higher pay/higher starting pay33%
Health insurance33%
Ability to work remotely some of the time33%
Services (Statewide)2023
Access to good online training courses44%
Virtual workshops44%
In-person workshops37%
Virtual job fairs34%
In-person job fairs33%

Teacher and CDL driver were top-ranked hard-to-fill positions. In line with this, job seekers identified CDL training as a specific skill training that would be of high interest if it were available, affordable/at no cost and worked with their schedule. Initiatives are underway to connect these job seekers with training and help employers fill these positions. NYSDOL has procured four (4) truck driving simulators that will be stationed in Career Centers around NYS, providing career exploration and training opportunities for this high-demand, high-paying career. In regions where the simulators are not permanently stationed, a similar experience with a traveling simulator will be offered, through a partnership with the Trucking Association of New York (TANY). LWDBs have been directly connected with the independent vendor offering this service and are encouraged to host community events around it as the program rolls out in 2024.

Likewise, the teacher shortage is being addressed on multiple fronts in collaboration with various agencies. The NYSDOL TRP, for example, is an innovative program working to combat the teacher shortage. The TRP provides funding for NYS public school districts and/or Boards of Cooperative Educational Services (BOCES) to create residency opportunities for graduate-level PK-12 teacher candidates. The program will provide $30M in funding to fund master’s degrees partially or fully for teacher residents enrolled in a residency program registered with NYSED.

Childcare, transportation, and mental health support were the top services businesses desired to offer but were unable to. Likewise, job seekers said childcare was a barrier keeping them from pursuing additional education to advance their careers. The childcare crisis is a widely known barrier to education and quality jobs – not unique to NYS – that disproportionately affects women and low-wage earners who typically bear the brunt of family care and do not have access to paid time off. The crisis is further exacerbated because childcare workers themselves are underpaid and the industry’s contributions to a healthy economy and functioning society are grossly undervalued.

Governor Hochul has made addressing this crisis a priority with wide-reaching initiatives, including tackling the specific barrier to education cited in the 2023 survey, with the availability of 200 more childcare spots at 12 high-demand SUNY campus childcare centers.  

As part of a historic investment in families and childcare, the FY 2024 Budget includes:

  • The Workforce Retention Grant Program, which will make $500M in underutilized federal funds available as grants for eligible childcare programs. Funding can be used to provide bonus payments ranging from $2,300 to $3,000 to staff in caregiving roles, as well as to recruit new staff, offer sign-on and referral bonuses and more;
  • A $4.8M investment in a new Employer-Sponsored Child Care Pilot Program. Participating employers, NYS and employees will split the cost of childcare. Families must fall between 85 percent and 100 percent of the State median income to qualify;
  • A new Employer Child Care Tax Credit available to businesses that create new childcare seats (and expand existing options) for workers. The $25M annual credit will be administered through the NYS Department of Taxation and Finance (DTF) and the NYS Office of Children and Family Services (OCFS);
  • A $1M Budget allocation to create a Statewide business navigator program in each of the ten (10) REDC regions to help interested businesses identify options to support employees’ childcare needs and develop a Statewide employer childcare guidebook; and
  • Expansion of the Empire State Child Credit (ESCC) to include children under four (4) years of age. This expansion will provide $179M in total support for over 525,000 low and middle-income taxpayers thanks to the inclusion of nearly 630,000 additional children. The ESCC, which has excluded children under four (4) since its inception in 2006, will now provide an additional average benefit of $340 per affected taxpayer and $284 per newly included child.

The national childcare crisis was temporarily stabilized with the one-time infusion of American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) stabilization grants. At the time of this writing, those funds are set to expire without a long-term solution in place. Continued investments, public-private partnerships and community-based services are necessary to fully stabilize the childcare industry.

The CHIPS Act requires semiconductor manufacturers to commit to providing affordable, reliable childcare for the communities where they build; this is currently happening in NYS, where semiconductor is an emerging industry. As part of its agreement with NYS, Micron Technology, a global leader in semiconductors, has purchased land in Central New York to develop a childcare facility alongside its cutting-edge semiconductor facility there.

NYSDOL’s Workforce Forward Project: This Syracuse-based infrastructure project to redesign sections of the I-81 Viaduct in and around the City of Syracuse will provide comprehensive supportive services, particularly assistance with childcare and transportation to and from training and work to all participants. The project also targets businesses within the infrastructure-related sector including advanced manufacturing, construction, communications, logistics, transportation, and distribution, and includes those in the care economy sector who were disproportionately and adversely affected during the pandemic and continue to struggle to rebound having faced significant worker shortages, increased layoffs, and resignations.

Job seekers said other barriers to education include not knowing where to start and not knowing what they need to do to obtain education. These two (2) common obstacles can be overcome in part through NYSDOL’s partnerships with Coursera and Northstar Digital Literacy. Additionally, better System-wide evaluation and data systems are needed as accessible resources for Career Center staff and job seekers. The NYSDOL Regional Training Assessment program is one such program working to compile an inventory of all trainings provided in local areas throughout NYS, outside of what is already listed on the ETPL.

Beyond training inventory, more robust evaluation and data systems are imperative to ensure accountability for our workforce System to contribute to an inclusive economy. Economists, educators and public policy analysts have recently called for increased federal funding and support for improved labor market skill needs data and those on WIOA training providers and outcomes.[1]

Recognizing this need, OSWD established uniform metrics for all grants and a common database to measure impact across programs. This robust set of metrics will evaluate the impact of OSWD’s grantmaking, including job placement, wages before and after program participation, hiring barriers faced, and supportive services utilized. Grantees are required to collect and report data at regular intervals throughout the grant period, and all data is stored and tracked through a new dashboard within OSOS, the same case management system used by NYSDOL and other NYS agencies. Using this existing tool helps to standardize Statewide tracking and makes it easier to evaluate outcomes across Statewide programs. OSWD continues to work closely with sister agencies to align metrics and grant reporting across programs through OSOS.

[1]https://www.brookings.edu/articles/should-the-federal-government-spend-more-on-workforce-development/

Identification of Customer Needs

NYS workforce policy was established to enable job-seeking participants to receive an initial assessment as their first staff-assisted service to identify their employment and training needs and determine what services they may need.  This determination is based on a one-to-one initial assessment interview with the participant, where the career advisor takes into consideration the participant’s occupational goals; existing skills and strengths, including literacy; English language proficiency and skill gaps; work search readiness and any potential barriers to employment; local labor market conditions; and desire for skills upgrading and/or training.  

Expeditious Entry into the Workforce System

NYS agencies participating in NYS OMH/NYESS have a shared case management system and WIOA combined enrollment process.  This allows for streamlined services to participants, coordination of services, the ability to provide real time referrals, and delivery of comprehensive service to participants.  

Development of the interagency release of information form, as well as issuance of TA #19-1 and training on the use of the form provided across NYS, has better enabled the partner programs to provide timely services to common participants of the System.  With the re-engagement of the Release and Referral workgroup in 2023, an enhanced focus has been placed on partners making direct linkages and meaningful referrals to ensure duplication of services is avoided and customers are able to move seamlessly through the System.

NYSED/ACCES-VR has 15 district offices and ten (10) satellite offices located throughout NYS.  In addition, counselors are available at Career Centers and schools.  NYSED/ACCES-VR encourages individuals to participate in an orientation, which is an overview of the VR program.  This can help determine if they wish to seek service and can speed the process as eligibility requirements are clarified.  To best support youth applying for services, a group orientation specific to this population is available. 

OCFS/NYSCB provides services to individuals who are legally blind through seven (7) district offices as well as several outstations located throughout NYS.  Counselors arrange to meet with an individual at a convenient location to discuss the array of services provided by OCFS/NYSCB.  If the individual is interested in participating in VR services, the counselor will gather information from the individual to assist in determining their eligibility for services.  Once a determination of eligibility is made, the counselor and the individual will work together to identify a vocational goal and the services required to enable them to meet that goal.  The goal and planned services are documented on the Individualized Plan for Employment (IPE).

Coordination of Services and Development of Individual Service Plans

A quality initial assessment provides information, like that found on a resume, to be recorded in participant case files and submitted into NYSDOL’s JobZone and VCC. Job matching and referral takes place on multiple levels, from automated VCC emails sent directly to participants, to staff making referrals during interviews at the Career Center.  The VCC platform uses artificial intelligence to read participant profiles and recommend jobs that match their skills and experience. Participants can opt in to receive emails of job matches, including job referrals sent by staff. NYSDOL staff can work with participants to update their profiles, review matched jobs, and visit career exploration features that are available on the platform.

Career Center staff work with all job seekers to plan the services best suited to their individual needs.  Those requiring career development assistance or seeking training receive a written IEP that helps guide participants as they work toward their employment goals.  Participants identified as having barriers to employment such as language proficiency, disability, skills gaps, and justice system involvement, are provided services directly at the Career Centers by workforce experts.  They may also be referred to supportive services and/or other agencies to work through perceived barriers and provide coordinated services via case management. 

For example, DRC staff hired under DEI and NY SCION model collaborative interventions such as IRTs to leverage existing WIOA partnerships to blend and braid funding and improve mutual outcomes. Reentry Employment Specialists (RES), as well as some Employment Counselors have received training to help them address the unique needs of individuals with legal history such as understanding RAP sheets and Certificates of Rehabilitation, legal protections for those with criminal convictions in NYS, the Federal Bonding Program and disclosing legal history during the employment process. 

Trade Act eligible individuals who access services via the Career Centers are co-enrolled in the WIOA DW Program and receive all applicable and available basic services and individualized career services.  Co-enrollment allows the process of needs and skills assessment to begin immediately, even before these workers may become eligible for TAA, giving them more time to consider all the options available to them.  Local career planners record the co-enrollment in OSOS, and NYSDOL’s State-level TAA Unit staff confirms that co-enrollment is documented in the record when approving training programs at the State level.

OCFS/NYSCB provides services to eligible individuals in accordance with an IPE.  VR counselors coordinate service provision and work with participants to assess progress in meeting their objectives and goal.  OCFS/NYSCB works with students, families, and school districts to facilitate the coordination of transition services for students who are legally blind and transitioning from school to the world of adult responsibilities and work.  OCFS/NYSCB recognizes these efforts are critical to enable students to achieve maximum success in employment, postsecondary education, independent living, and community participation, and is committed to being an active partner in the transition process. OCFS/NYSCB also maintains relationships with other NYS agencies involved in workforce development, including OPWDD, OMH, OASAS, and NYSDOL.  

NYSED/ACCES-VR has a strong infrastructure and provides a wide range of services to eligible individuals.  Counselors work directly with individuals to develop an IPE that identifies the services and strategies necessary for achieving the plan’s employment goal.  The IPE is the foundation of service for the participant.  The employment goal is established based upon the individual’s choice and LMI.  Often, achievement of the goal requires services obtained from postsecondary educational institutions, vocational training, or contracted vendors.  

In addition to contracts with service vendors, NYSED/ACCES-VR has several agreements in place with other entities, including sister State agencies, to guide cooperative work.  Further, under NY SCION, NYSED/ACCES-VR and OCFS/NYSCB staff work collaboratively with DRCs to minimize duplicative services through coordination, such as through IRTs.

Initiatives and Infrastructure

OCFS/NYSCB entered into a Partnership Plus Agreement, which enables participants with a Social Security Ticket to Work (TTW) to obtain VR services from OCFS/NYSCB, as well as broad access to community providers to assist in the coordination of Social Security payments and other benefits and services.

Eleven (11) nonprofit organizations across NYS were approved as vendors to provide benefits advisement and support the development of economic self-sufficiency.   The increased access to DRCs and other Employment Networks (ENs) increases support in maintaining employment regardless of whether the individual is an active participant with any State workforce agency.

OCFS/NYSCB uses funds to contract with two (2) private agencies for individuals who are blind to provide pre-college programs for OCFS/NYSCB participants entering their senior year of high school.  The program goal is to provide students the opportunity to refine their academic, social, and independent living skills before beginning college.

Work Experience Training services are provided to a wide range of VR services recipients.  This service provides employment experiences and resume building for youth transitioning from school to employment and for adults with minimal work histories.  

OCFS/NYSCB continues to work closely with community rehabilitation providers to create new pre-vocational and vocational training programs for both adults and transitioning youth.  In addition, OCFS/NYSCB district offices engage new providers when specialized training is required for a participant to reach their vocational goal.  OCFS/NYSCB reviews curriculum for all pre-vocational programs for transition-age youth to evaluate the nature and quality of the program with the goal of providing quality programming preparing youth to enter the 21st century workforce.

OCFS/NYSCB continues to encourage development of vocational training programs that meet the requirements of business and will work with providers to create and approve curricula, especially in fields with in-demand jobs where vocational training was not previously available.

OCFS/NYSCB Children’s Consultants and VR Counselors (VRCs) will continue to emphasize to school district personnel the importance of integrating the Expanded Core Curriculum (ECC) into standard academic instruction and routine daily tasks and encourage school staff to work closely with itinerant vision teachers and staff from local private agencies for individuals who are blind to provide comprehensive services needed by students.

OCFS/NYSCB also provides assistive technology services and devices to individuals during each stage of the rehabilitation process through Assistive Technology Center (ATC) contracts and private vendors.  The outcome-based services of ATC Readiness Evaluation, ATC Assessment, and ATC Training provide a comprehensive and rigorous array of assessments and training with the goal of preparing students for success in school and employment.  ATC Centers and a network of more than 30 private assistive technology trainers provide on-site needs evaluation and training for those whose needs require intervention at their education or employment site.

In addition, OCFS/NYSCB provides assistive technology devices and training to current managers and manager trainees in the Randolph-Sheppard Business Enterprise Program, enabling them to manage their newsstands and food service operations in accordance with industry standards.

Continuous Engagement

NYS strives to keep job-seeking participants engaged with all partners in the System until they are successful in achieving their employment goals.  Continuous engagement strategies include participation in career services, individual counseling, assessments, provision of LMI, job referrals, job clubs, workshops, virtual services, and business recruitment events. NY SCION DRCs can also provide benefits advisement to social security disability beneficiaries long after they achieve their employment goals, creating a continuous, ongoing relationship that creates stability for our customers.

Continuous engagement and individualized case management allow staff to provide the necessary services to participants while giving them multiple opportunities to provide feedback, which leads to participant satisfaction.  In some instances, staff are evaluated on the services provided to their participants and through the use of individual level performance data to provide consistent feedback.  This ensures participants receive the necessary services to help them reach their employment and training goals.  Beginning in 2024, NYSDOL will also release customer satisfaction surveys each Spring to ensure NYS is capturing participant feedback on the effectiveness, physical and programmatic accessibility, and continuous improvement of the System.

Staff Development

NYS values staff training and recognizes the importance of having a strong capacity building program to train workforce staff on serving participants, providing resources, and understanding and complying with policies and procedures to meet changing workforce needs.  NYSDOL staff development opportunities are offered weekly and trainings are continuously developed to support frontline Career Center staff in providing high quality participant-centered services.  

Specialized training and technical assistance are provided to staff by RESs and DRCs, who build staff capacity to serve individuals with involvement in the criminal justice system, and people with disabilities, respectively. Likewise, OCFS/NYSCB continues to provide training for staff on participant’s potential eligibility for the use of Blind Work Expenses (BWE) as well as other work incentives to support participant financial independence.  

NYSED/ACCES-VR has a cadre of trainings available that support VRCs in their professional development. These trainings are made available through contracted vendors, conferences or through federal partners. Internal trainings on eligibility, IPE development, pre-employment transition services, and policy and procedure updates are regularly completed by NYSED/ACCES-VR staff. Trainings that provide credential opportunities for VRCs are also shared with OCFS/NYSCB. 

These trainings are shared on a quarterly basis with the interagency TAAG workgroup , which works to ensure all training and skill building that occurs in the System is consistent across all partner programs.

NYSDOL also partners with the TAAG workgroup to offer virtual Statewide workshops, and NYSED/ACCES, OCFS/NYSCB and OTDA regularly present workshops to job seeking New Yorkers on topics such as:

  • Seeing Your Disability as an Asset: How to Use LinkedIn to Market Yourself to Potential Employers, presented by OCFS/NYSCB;
  • SNAP Overview, presented by OTDA;
  • Overview of NYSED/ACCES-VR, presented by NYSED/ACCES-VR; 
  • About Reasonable Accommodations, It’s Easier Than You Think, presented by NYSED/ACCES-VR; 
  • Disclosure: Talking to Employers About Your Disability, presented by NYSED/ACCES-VR; and
  • Employment Incentives for Government Jobs:  What Job Seekers with Disabilities Need to Know, presented by NYSED/ACCES-VR.

The virtual workshops have proven to be a successful way to reach New Yorkers to aid in preparing them for their job search.  In addition, agency staff and partners are encouraged to attend these sessions to learn about partner services. The recordings are available to staff to refer to if unable to view the live sessions and the monthly schedule of workshops is shared amongst the group.  In 2022, over 630 workshops were delivered to over 37,000 attendees.  Partners plan to continue expanding the offerings and topics in the coming years.

Regional Training Assessment Program

This program will create an inventory of all trainings provided in local areas; help avoid overlap, duplication, and/or fragmentation of programs and services; and streamline how these resources are deployed to the end users. The training inventory is not meant to recreate the ETPL, but to instead be a complement to the ETPL by providing a repository of other ongoing training programs in the local areas, including classroom, customized, OJT, community college, those offered by labor unions, Northstar Digital Literacy, and Coursera.

NYSDOL worked with one LWDB to pilot the program and develop a process to compile the information and is now in the process of working with the other LWDBs in that region to compile a full regional repository. The goal is to have a fully accessible database sharable throughout NYS where participants are able to obtain all available trainings they may be interested in. Conversations are ongoing with all LWDBs about how we can use this information, once fully compiled, to distinguish quality programs with good performance outcomes.