Located in:
- Program-specific Requirements for Adult, Dislocated Worker, and Youth Activities under Title I-B
The Unified or Combined State Plan must include the following with respect to activities carried out under subtitle B—
b. 1. Work-Based Training Models
If the State is utilizing work-based training models (e.g. on-the-job training, incumbent worker training, transitional jobs, and customized training) as part of its training strategy and these strategies are not already discussed in other sections of the plan, describe the State’s strategies for how these models ensure high quality training for both the participant and the employer.
Current Narrative:
As discussed in detail throughout this Combined Plan, work-based training models are an integral component of the employment and training services offered in NYS. Adults, DWs, and Youth all benefit from the integration of education and hands-on work experience these programs provide.
The RA program is the gold standard of work-based training, integrating OJT and RI to meet the needs of businesses and jobseekers Statewide. Work-based training is also made available to participants through several employment and training program contracts awarded through competitive procurements.
There is value in examining NYS’s ongoing commitment to the RA program model. The timeline below, while not inclusive of every milestone, reflects how NYS continues to build on the success of RA programs year over year since the implementation of WIOA:
- 2016 – NYSDOL was awarded a $200,000 Apprenticeship State Accelerator Grant from USDOL, followed by $1.5M grant for State Apprenticeship Expansion (SAE).
- The funds from these grants allowed NYSDOL to expand RA throughout NYS in new and emerging occupations.
- 2017 – The 2017-2018 NYS budget included the Empire State Apprenticeship Tax Credit (ESATC) Program, which began January 1, 2018, and continues through 2026, providing up to $10M annually for expenditure.
- ESATC provides tax credits that start at $2,000 per qualified apprentice employed full-time for at least six (6) months during the year. Additional credits are available for each year the apprentice remains in the RA program. Enhanced credits are available to businesses that employ disadvantaged youth as apprentices.
- There are also credits available to businesses that provide apprentices with the support of a mentor for the full calendar year. This program is focused on in-demand occupations throughout NYS.
- 2018 – NYSDOL was awarded $1.8M under the SAE Continuation Funding Grant.
- The 2016 Apprenticeship State Accelerator Grant concluded and was a stepping-stone toward the goal of apprenticeship expansion.
- 2019 – NYS embarked on an ambitious plan to further expand RA by increasing the number of apprenticeships in high-demand fields, increasing the number of women and minorities in all apprenticeships, and simplifying and streamlining the program registration process.
- NYSDOL applied for and received approximately $4.4M under the PY 2018 Apprenticeship State Expansion (ASE) Grant, which ended on June 30, 2023.
- 2020 – NYSDOL was awarded a $450,000 SAE 2020 base grant, which also ended on June 30, 2023, to support new staff and marketing efforts, further allowing NYSDOL to sustain and expand apprenticeship throughout NYS.
- 2022 – Seven (7) RAEN centers created a regional apprenticeship network that continues to connect Adult Education programs with apprenticeship career pathways and opportunities.
- New trades in Dental Office Assistant, Teacher Assistant, Pharmacy Associate, Environmental Literacy Instructor, and Precision Imaging/Nanolithography Technician were developed and approved.
- March 2023 – NYSDOL released another round of the Apprenticeship Expansion Grant RFA (AEG-4), currently utilizing $3M in State Apprenticeship Expansion Formula (SAEF) grant funding) to support new and existing sponsors and signatories with a focus on high growth industries and other in-demand occupations identified by REDCs and LWDBs.
- Sponsors and signatories of NYS RA programs may apply for up to $300,000 in funds (up to $15,000 per apprentice) to cover costs associated with training, such as OJT, RI, books, and tools. The application deadline for funding is August 30, 2024. NYSDOL continues to receive applications and is reviewing them for eligibility.
- Prior rounds of AEG funding, AEG-1, AEG-2, and AEG-3 were very successful with a total of 48 programs funded.
- July 2023 – NYSDOL was awarded SAEF Base Formula Funding in the amount of $1.5M and $6M in Competitive Funding that will collectively create new, and expand existing RA Programs, while also driving system innovation and improvement.
- December 2023 – NYSDOL made $2M in SAEF funding available under the Direct Entry Pre-Apprenticeship Programs (DEPA) RFA.
- DEPA funding is intended to support 300 participants in Direct Entry pre-apprentice programs that lead to NYS RA programs and support entry into NYS RA programs for underrepresented populations including women, minorities, individuals with disabilities, and veterans.
- NYSDOL is particularly interested in supporting DEPA programs that provide participants with training and exposure to various trades and offer opportunities for entry into RA training programs. Targeted industries include, but are not limited to, Building and Construction, Manufacturing, and IT.
- This is part of the Governor’s comprehensive plan to strengthen NYS's workforce and help grow the economy by focusing on regional needs and creating and expanding access to career services and the jobs of tomorrow and identifying innovative ways to build the workforce of the future.
Since 2016, NYSDOL has approved almost 600 new programs and of those programs, almost 70% were in trades other than Construction. In 2022 and 2023, NYSDOL approved almost 130 new programs and of those programs, over 100 were in trades other than Construction. It is important to note that most programs were approved while competing against the economic difficulties of COVID-19.
As of June 2023, there were over 17,300 apprentices across over 900 programs with 619 sponsors. Of the over 17,000 apprentices, over 7,000 are minorities; 38% are in Building and Construction Trades and 54% are in trades other than Building and Construction. Women make up almost 12% of the active apprentices; 8% of women are in Building and Construction Trades; and 32% of women are in trades outside of Building and Construction. Over 1,000 apprentices are Veterans; 7% work in Building and Construction Trades; and 7% of Veterans are in trades outside of Building and Construction. The Building and Construction trades programs have just over 15,000 active apprentices enrolled, with 90% being in union programs and 10% in non-union programs. In trades other than Building and Construction, there are 2,366 active apprentices enrolled.
Traditionally, apprenticeship programs were only approved as time-based programs where apprentices had to complete a specific number of hours in each OJT task but did not have to demonstrate competency. However, NYS’s Apprenticeship Regulations permit the use of hybrid and competency-based approaches to training. The hybrid approach is a combination of the time-based and competency-based approaches and requires a minimum number of OJT hours for each skill prior to testing. NYSDOL is seeing in an increase in the number of trades approved to use hybrid and competency-based training approaches. For example, in 2023, the trade of Elevator/Escalator Constructor and Modernizer was approved with a hybrid training approach. NYSDOL has also approved a change of approach to time-based for the trades of Computer Support Technician; Software Developer; Project Manager; Network Administrator; Security Analyst; Network Engineer; and Systems Engineer; Human Resources Associate; Junior Accountant; Central Sterile Processing Technician; Certified Nursing Assistant; Home Health Aide; Cloud Engineer; and Teacher. Approval of hybrid and competency-based programs allows sponsors and apprentices additional flexibility in the length of time needed to complete a program. NYSDOL anticipates developing and moving additional trades into alternative training approaches, which allows for diversity and expansion into new and emerging industries.
In parallel to the expansion efforts, NYSDOL is looking into ways to enhance its data collection and management system to improve processes and transparency and to better align with USDOL’s grant reporting requirements through the Workforce Integrated Performance System (WIPS). An enhanced, more modernized system of collecting and managing data will allow for a more accurate and seamless method of tracking and reporting program and apprentice information.
RA programs are an important tool for economic mobility and growth. All NYS RA sponsors are required to complete an Affirmative Action Plan (AAP) or Non-Discrimination Plan, depending on the size of their program. These are approved by NYSDOL and are reviewed and updated as necessary through regular program monitoring. As an on-going process to assist RA sponsors with meeting Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO) goals and serving underrepresented communities, EEO reviews are conducted periodically to evaluate diversity in RA programs and provide technical assistance to Program Sponsors, with the goal of supporting and promoting a diverse and equitable workforce.
To further support EEO goals, Direct Entry may be used by sponsors to bring apprentices into their programs. Direct Entry is an effective tool to help sponsors reach underrepresented populations and to meet EEO goals. It provides individuals who successfully complete a direct entry apprenticeship preparation program, and who met the minimum requirements for a NYS RA program, with the direct opportunity for an interview with the sponsor of a RA program.
Additional goals for RA include prioritizing the expansion of apprenticeship through NYS’s OSWD; enhancing collaboration between NYS agencies, SUNY, workforce training providers, and the private sector; creating a marketing campaign to make parents and guidance counselors of middle and high school students, with and without disabilities, aware of the benefits of apprenticeships and work-based learning; expanding the Apprenticeship and Training Council to include more growth sectors; developing better linkages to educational institutions; and advising OSWD on ways to better connect with regional workforce intermediaries.