U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.

Https

Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock () or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

2 Year Modification

Plan: Rhode Island PYs 2018-2019
Combined Plan C

Section: WIOA State Plan Common Elements

Narrative: II. a. 1. A.

Published
Located in:
  • II. Strategic Elements

    The Unified or Combined State Plan must include a Strategic Planning Elements section that analyzes the State’s current economic environment and identifies the State’s overall vision for its workforce development system. The required elements in this section allow the State to develop data-driven goals for preparing an educated and skilled workforce and to identify successful strategies for aligning workforce development programs. Unless otherwise noted, all Strategic Planning Elements apply to Combined State Plan partner programs included in the plan as well as to core programs.

II. a. 1. A. Economic Analysis (A.I -A.III)

The Unified or Combined State Plan must include an analysis of the economic conditions and trends in the State, including sub-State regions and any specific economic areas identified by the State. This must include-

  • i. Existing Demand Industry Sectors and Occupations

    Provide an analysis of the industries and occupations for which there is existing demand.

  • ii. Emerging Industry Sectors and Occupation

    Provide an analysis of the industries and occupations for which demand is emerging.

  • iii. Employers’ Employment Needs

    With regard to the industry sectors and occupations identified in 1 and 2 above, provide an assessment of the employment needs of employers, including a description of the knowledge, skills, and abilities required, including credentials and licenses.

Current Narrative:

The successful implementation of the strategies outlined above begins with a thorough understanding of the Rhode Island economy and existing workforce development activities. According to the study, Rhode Island Innovates: A Competitive Strategy for the Ocean State, conducted by the Battelle Technology Partnership Practice, Metropolitan Policy Program at Brookings, Monitor Deloitte, and TEConomy Partners, LLC (2016), Rhode Island’s economy is adrift. The State is 2.1% below its pre-recession employment level, and has lost momentum in many of its highest value export industries, leading to a lower rate of job production and business activity across the State’s economy. The unemployment level was higher and declined more slowly than the rest of New England. The deterioration of the State’s growth capacity has led to output and job growth numbers that are below the national average and an increase in income inequality.

Historically, Rhode Island’s economy relied heavily on manufacturing. Jewelry, toy and textile manufacturing that were only moderately advanced made up a large portion of the manufacturing base, and were vulnerable to offshoring. While total advanced industry employment has declined at the fastest rate in the nation from 1980 (134,500 jobs) to 2013 (68,600 jobs), Rhode Island’s advanced business service output and employment growth was the highest in New England from 2010 to 2013. Advanced business services include services modern corporations rely on for back-office and headquarter operations such as web services, data processing, marketing, client management, human resources, financial services, and strategy and product development support. However, growth in advanced business services has only partially offset the decline of the manufacturing base. Advanced business services has only added about 12,000 jobs since 1980, making up for a small fraction of the 50,000 jobs lost in manufacturing. It is a bleak picture, but one that can be changed if Rhode Island focuses on making sure workers have the skills they need to succeed in industries that will grow the economy.

In the first step of its analysis, the report finds that Rhode Island “possesses an intricate, interrelated array of detailed industries that can be rolled up into broader clusters of promising industries.” There are 33 groups of these interrelated industries that serve as building blocks for industry clusters, which have “sizeable economic potential.” These 33 groups were analyzed for their strength in three measures: high relative concentration compared to the national average, job creation, and relative employment growth compared to national trends.

The researchers then collapsed the 33 industry groups into eight broader industry clusters. The 33 groups, individually, did not have the scale needed to drive growth on their own. The median size of the industry groups is about 2,000 jobs. It is notable that the largest advanced industry group, computer systems and software, contained less than 7,000 workers, illustrating the lack of scale.

The eight industry clusters are: software systems and internet; instruments, electronics, and defense; advanced business services; health and life sciences; marine, materials, and machinery; design, consumer products, and food processing; arts, education, hospitality, and tourism; and, transportation, distribution, and logistics. Only two (marine, materials, and machinery and advanced business services) have outpaced national growth rates, while transportation, distribution, and logistics has kept pace with national growth. The remaining clusters were below national growth, or declined at a greater rate than the national level.

The Bureau of Labor Statistics projects that the eight industry clusters will experience significant economic output gains between 2013 and 2022, although projected employment growth is substantially lower. The researchers explain this by saying that output gains will come from high productivity gains.

Core Competencies

In the second step in the study, the researchers found “significant industry-based core competencies in eight areas relating to the state’s leading clusters.” Core competencies show where a state has the expertise and creative activity necessary to grow that industry. Battelle performed a “network analysis of forward patent citations” that “revealed a cohesive set of clusters arranged around a large volume of multidisciplinary ties across diverse groups of capabilities”. Eight industry-led core competencies were identified: advanced polymers, films, and composites; medical technology; data processing, e-commerce, and enterprise applications; semiconductors and electronic components; pharmaceuticals and supporting organic chemistry; games, toys, and gaming equipment; plastics packaging and containers; and, valves, piping and fluid systems.

Another analysis identified 17 research institution core competencies in areas corresponding to the state’s leading clusters by analyzing clusters of publication activity, areas of specialization in publications and research funding, presence of major funding, and national reputation. The majority of the core competencies stemmed from work at Brown University or the University of Rhode Island. Nine core competencies were identified in bioscience, a strong area for the State. Rhode Island also stands out nationally in math and ocean sciences, fine arts and design (led by the Rhode Island School of Design), and culinary arts (led by Johnson & Wales).

An additional analysis assessed Rhode Island’s position in relation to technology deployment across two measures: value added per employee and capacity to generate good jobs. Higher value added signify that an industry is more competitive, while a good job is defined as offering a livable wage with benefits for full-time workers who have less than a four-year degree. Five industry clusters exceeded the national level of value added per worker, which means that Brookings expects these five to expand their market share. These clusters are defense shipbuilding and maritime; design, materials, food, and custom manufacturing; advanced business services; transportation, shipping, and logistics; and, arts, education, hospitality, and tourism. Six of the clusters employ a significant share of their workforce in good jobs: marine, materials, and machinery; health and life sciences; instruments, electronics, and defense; advanced business services; software systems and internet; and, transportation, distribution, and logistics. In Rhode Island, 230 occupations are considered good jobs, accounting for 27% of employment in 2014.

In its third step, Brookings added a line of sight to the markets analysis of the industry clusters and core competency findings to find the industries that will most grow Rhode Island’s economy.

This analysis outlined five high-value advanced industry growth areas and two opportunity industry growth areas that produce larger numbers of good jobs to focus on to put Rhode Island’s economy back on course. The five advanced industry growth areas are: biomedical innovation; IT/software, cyber-physical systems and data analytics; defense shipbuilding and maritime; advanced business services; and, design, food and custom manufacturing. The two opportunity industry growth areas are transportation, distribution, and logistics; and, arts, education, hospitality and tourism.

Biomedical innovation accounted for 31,548 jobs in Rhode Island in 2013, with priority areas in biopharmaceuticals, medical devices and digital health. This industry growth area had a 31% higher industry concentration that the national rate, with a -0.2% job decline from 2009-2013. The study identified a broader range of opportunities in neuroscience-related therapeutics; medical devices for orthopedic, bio-sensing and neurological applications; and, health care informatics and digital innovations.

IT/software, cyber-physical systems and data analytics supported 12,538 jobs in 2013, with priority areas in data sciences and cyber-physical systems. The industry concentration was 18% higher than the nation, and saw a -3.2% job decline from 2009-2013. Opportunities are in the priority areas, as well as in autonomous underwater vehicles, remote medical device monitoring systems, environmental and energy monitoring, and smart grid infrastructure.

Defense shipbuilding and maritime was responsible for 19,107 jobs in 2013. Priority areas were submarine and boat building, ocean sciences and marine/coastal tourism. Rhode Island has an 86% higher industry concentration when compared to the nation, and saw 9.1% in jobs gains from 2009-2013.

There were 34,780 jobs in advanced business services in 2013, with back office operations as the priority area. This industry growth area has a 30% higher industry concentration than the nation, with 7.9% job growth from 2009-2013. Back office operations include web services, data processing, marketing, client management, human resources, financial services, and strategy and product development. These operations help firms improve their competitiveness in the megalopolis marketplace.

The fifth advanced industry growth area - design, materials, food and custom manufacturing - consisted of 11,045 jobs in 2013. This is a 128% higher industry concentration than the national rate, but saw a -9.4% job decline from 2009-2013. The priority areas are product design and food processing, with a growing interest in food manufacturing.

The two opportunity industry growth areas - transportation, distribution and logistics; and arts, education, hospitality and tourism - accounted for 21,322 and 42,801 jobs in 2013, respectively. Priority areas in transportation, distribution and logistics are grocery whole-sale and warehousing and storage, including ocean shipping, rail shipping and trucking. Priority areas in arts, education, hospitality and tourism are marine/coastal tourism and colleges and universities. Transportation, distribution and logistics was the only industry growth area with a lower industry concentration than the national rate at 27%, but saw a 5.3% job gain from 2009-2013. Arts, education, hospitality and tourism had a 38% higher industry concentration than the nation, and saw 5.2% in job gains from 2009-2013.

While these seven industries are identified as potential high growth areas, they are not individually large enough to support or justify a narrowly focused economic development strategy. The manufacturing base must move from low-end advanced manufacturing to higher-value, higher-tech production in niche markets. Increases in expenditures and production on medical equipment increase the demand for industry designers, which increases industry revenue across growth areas. To take advantage of this interconnectivity, the study recommends that Rhode Island use its network of interconnected industries to align core competencies and come up with broader growth opportunities. Specifically, the authors say, “To leverage its growth opportunities Rhode Island should pursue a focused strategy of investing in the most critical advanced industries growth drivers while improving its statewide platform for growth.”

The Governors Workforce Board’s Biennial plan also created a projection for other high employment industries such as health care and construction. According to the report, healthcare and social assistance services comprised almost one in five jobs . Healthcare is the largest industry in Rhode Island, employing over 80,000 people and is project to increase by nearly 13,000 jobs by 2020- which is a 16% increase over 10 years and has the largest job growth in any sector well about the state average of 10.7%. Of the 80,000 employed in the healthcare industry, 47,000 are patient care jobs ranging from entry level home care staff to surgeons and nurses. An additional 10,000 workers provide administrative support and 4,500 provide cleaning and food preparation .

Additionally, the construction industry at the time of the release of the Biennial plan employed 15,943 individuals or three percent of the total working population in Rhode Island. Construction jobs have declined 15 percent since 2008 when the Building Futures construction industry skills gap study reported 22,000 workers in the state . The growing occupation in this industry are carpenters and construction laborers. In addition, new workers entering the skilled technical trades are seeking much more competition for apprenticeship openings. In those trades more than 50 percent of candidates accepted as apprentices into the skilled trades have already completed two or more college courses or have a college degree in an unrelated field.

When it comes to the regional concentrations of labor throughout the state, almost half of Rhode Island’s jobs are concentrated in the Providence, Cranston and Warwick communities. One-quarter of the state’s employment is located in providence alone. Pawtucket and East Providence together contain another 10 percent of employment. This concentration of employment in a few communities points to the importance of accessible transportation to work for both employers and workers, especially for those with disabilities and significant barriers to unemployment.

Employer Needs

Educational Background

In all of these industries, the biggest need is a stable and secure workforce pipeline with individuals who have at least basic understandings of the work being performed, or at least individuals who are prepared and able to learn at work. In the Governor’s Workforce Board 2013 review; Bioscience: Identifying Employer Needs, Talent Gaps, & Strategies to Grow a Stronger Bio Science Workforce in Rhode Island, Tech Collective and other bio-medical companies from across the state expressed the same concerns. Employers look to find and retain employees who offer scientific as well as business/operations skill sets. In a highly regulated and complex industry, interdisciplinary knowledge and expertise can be a factor in whether a company achieves success and growth or it does not. Every respondent to Tech Collective’s Employer Survey indicated that the “Lack of skilled workers/candidates to hire” is the biggest workforce challenge at their company. Competition with other companies to hire qualified workers and retaining skilled workers were also concerns for 40% of companies. This is a direct effect of having an under-education population. According to Tech Collective, even jobs such as Computer user support require an associate’s degree. Occupations which do not require more than a high school diploma are Maintenance & repair workers, glass washers, and cleaning services.[1]


In the instance of construction trades and apprenticeship-able occupations, the main issue that employers face are directly tied to the demand of the economy. Since Rhode Island is still digging out of the recession, the demand that the state saw for construction and renovation projects has yet to fully rebound. The other biggest factor is the issue of recruitment. Most of the 360 registered apprenticeship programs have zero to one apprentice at any given time cannot mount an economically effective recruitment effort.

There are eight career and technical centers in RI that could be considered a pipeline to apprenticeships. However, most career centers offer construction programs focused only on home building cabinet making and, are geographically limited with just one center is located in Providence. Further, although five of these vocational centers offer programs to adults, none offer construction programs to adult students. Three sites in Rhode Island provide post-secondary training in construction, NEIT, MTTI, and Lincoln Technology Institute. These programs can cost up to $11,000 and are therefore not appropriate for the population that is seeking to join trade occupations.[2]


In the manufacturing industries, a number of challenges were outlined in “The Manufacturing Industry: Producing Rhode Island’s Future- A Report of the Manufacturing Industry Partners” produced by the Governor’s workforce board, the authors outlined a number of challenges that face manufacturers across the state. Focus group participants identified a need for manufacturing internships, apprenticeships and on the-job training opportunities for high school students. The study also cites issues such as the lack of educational institutions that focus on the skills necessary to carve a career pathway in the industry. However, this issue is disconnected due to many factors. Manufacturing Industry members pointed to the closing of four Community College of Rhode Island’s certificate programs in 2012 as an example. Educational institutions, in turn, cite lack of enrollments in those programs as the cause of those closures. Businesses recruit, instead, from educational and training programs outside of Rhode Island, but are competing with other markets on salary and cost of living, making it difficult to attract those workers. The biggest indicator of why manufacturing is struggling in Rhode Island is once again tied to an aging workforce. Boston College’s Center on Aging and Work found that in 2008 the median age of Rhode Island’s workers was 41.3. It was reported at that time that the manufacturing industry was among the most likely to be impacted, with several manufacturing sectors reporting more than one -quarter of their workforce between the ages of 50 and 59. Furthermore, 22.7% of production workers at the time were between the ages of 50 and 59.26 Manufacturing Industry Partner members described the aging workforce as a major workforce problem they face. They are losing qualified workers who possess industry know -how, and do not have qualified workers in the pipeline to replace them.

The common theme in all of these industries is the “skills gap”- that is the phenomena of younger workers who are looking to join the workforce not having the skills that employers are looking for. According to Rhode Island Defense Industry Skill Gap Study conducted by the Ninigret partners, this issue is the biggest for Rhode Island’s defense sector. Rhode Island Defense employers perceive skill gaps in applicant pools across all occupational categories in our survey: engineers, technicians, production workers, and business administration professionals. Searches for engineers and technicians are more likely to be difficult (many open positions unfilled) than searches for business administration. Fewer respondents have recently hired production workers or logisticians, but among those that did, 60% found it difficult or marginal to find candidates with the right skill sets in production and 76% for logisticians. Technical writing was rated as a critical skill gap by 60% of respondents for engineers, 59% for technicians, 28% for production workers, and 44% for business administration. A theme that emerged through employer interviews is that technical businesses need employees who can be a bridge between the business and technical worlds. For example, engineers need to be connected to the customers’ needs, the techniques of the production process, and the economics of production to design for manufacturability and affordability. Teamwork and ability to communicate with co-workers ranked as one of the most frequent critical skill gaps for employers hiring technicians (46%) and also for a large minority of employers hiring engineers (35%).

The best way to produce a workforce that meets the current and future needs of Rhode Island’s businesses and industries is to ensure that Rhode Island graduates an ever-increasing percentage of employees who have earned a degree from a four-year college or university, an associate’s degree, or a post-secondary, industry-recognized credential. By 2020, 71% of jobs in Rhode Island will require a post-secondary degree or certification. But currently, only about 40% of Rhode Islanders aged 25 or older have such a degree. In part this is due to the reality that far too many students are graduating with a high school diploma despite not being college or career-ready. We know this because two-thirds of the students who enter the Community College of Rhode Island require remediation before they can begin to take initial credit-bearing course. We know this because the four-year graduation rate at the University of Rhode Island is 42%. At Rhode Island College, the four-year graduation rate is 14%. At CCRI, the two-year graduation rate is a mere 2%.

This projected job growth through 2022 suggests that Rhode Island will have an economy in which only 36% of all jobs will require at least some college. However, research by Georgetown University’s Center on Education and the Workforce suggests that by 2020, 65% of all jobs nationwide will require at least some kind of post-secondary education or training. In other words, beyond the 36% of jobs requiring some college, another roughly 30% can be expected to require some other sort of post-secondary preparation. Only about one-third of the state’s workers will be able to get by with only a high school diploma - but Rhode Islanders without such post-secondary credentials will comprise 42% of the state’s workforce. United States Census data estimates of the most recent levels of educational attainment by Rhode Island’s workforce include: 38.6% of Rhode Islanders aged 25 or older have a college degree (associate’s, bachelor’s, graduate or professional degree) 18.4% of Rhode Islanders aged 25 or older have some college education but have not earned a college degree. 28.7% of Rhode Islanders aged 25 or older have a high school degree or equivalent. 14.2% of Rhode Islanders aged 25 or older have less than a high school diploma or equivalent.

Soft Skills

Following the theme of the “skills gap”, what has been called “soft skills” are also on the forefront of business challenges. Businesses want employees with particular education and skills, but what is most desired - and most often lacking, particularly in entry-level hires - are basic educational foundation and soft skills. Soft skills refer to various behaviors and qualities that help people work with others successfully in any field or occupation. For example, soft skills include communication skills (such as the ability to speak and listen well), professionalism (such as timeliness and appropriate attire), problem solving skills, the ability to collaborate, flexibility, and a strong work ethic.

If businesses can hire someone reliable with basic reading and math skills, and capable of problem solving, working with others, and coming to work on time ready and willing to work, they are often willing and able to provide the specific on-the-job training that person needs for that particular job. However, what businesses are finding is that many inexperienced workers who are hired for entry-level positions often fail basic reading and math tests and do not understand workplace norms and expectations. As a result, businesses put a premium on hiring people with work experience and particularly value those workforce programs that provide training (such as paid internships, apprenticeships, and on-the-job training) or retrain incumbent - and proven - workers for new positions. Small employers don’t have capacity for lots of training. They want to hire someone who is ready the first day. - GWB Industry Partners Focus Group 36 In some sectors, particularly information technology, employees with mid- and high-level skills are also difficult to find. For example, computer programming and other high-tech firms reported having to recruit from out-of-state for mid-level programmer positions.

Unfortunately, many businesses - particularly small businesses, which are prevalent in Rhode Island - lack human resource departments or other staff skilled in recruitment and hiring. They often fail to plan for turnover or growth, struggle to articulate the skills or competencies new hires need, and are not skilled at sorting through resumes, conducting interviews, or selecting new employees. As a result, businesses often cannot find the applicants they want, or end up making hires that do not meet their actual needs.


[1]Bioscience: Identifying Employer Needs, Talent Gaps, & Strategies to Grow a Stronger Bio Science Workforce in Rhode Island

[2] Building Futures: Skills Gap Study, Governor’s Workforce Board’s Construction Industry Partnership (2008)