U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.

Https

Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock () or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

2 Year Modification

Plan: Rhode Island PYs 2018-2019
Combined Plan C

Section: WIOA State Plan Common Elements

Narrative: II. a. 1. B.

Published
Located in:
  • II. Strategic Elements

    The Unified or Combined State Plan must include a Strategic Planning Elements section that analyzes the State’s current economic environment and identifies the State’s overall vision for its workforce development system. The required elements in this section allow the State to develop data-driven goals for preparing an educated and skilled workforce and to identify successful strategies for aligning workforce development programs. Unless otherwise noted, all Strategic Planning Elements apply to Combined State Plan partner programs included in the plan as well as to core programs.

II. a. 1. B. Workforce Analysis (B.I - B.IV)

The Unified or Combined State Plan must include an analysis of the current workforce, including individuals with barriers to employment, as defined in section 3 of WIOA.* This population must include individuals with disabilities among other groups** in the State and across regions identified by the State. This includes: Individuals with barriers to employment include displaced homemakers; low-income individuals; Indians, Alaska Natives, and Native Hawaiians; individuals with disabilities, including youth who are individuals with disabilities; older individuals; ex-offenders; homeless individuals, or homeless children and youths; youth who are in or have aged out of the foster care system; individuals who are English language learners, individuals who have low levels of literacy, and individuals facing substantial cultural barriers; farmworkers (as defined at section 167(i) of WIOA and Training and Employment Guidance Letter No. 35-14); individuals within 2 years of exhausting lifetime eligibility under the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program; single parents (including single pregnant women); and long-term unemployed individuals. ** Veterans, unemployed workers, and youth, and others that the State may identify.

  • i. Employment and Unemployment

    Provide an analysis of current employment and unemployment data, including labor force participation rates, and trends in the State.

  • ii. Labor Market Trends

    Provide an analysis of key labor market trends, including across existing industries and occupations.
  • iii. Education and Skill Levels of the Workforce

    Provide an analysis of the educational and skill levels of the workforce.

  • iv. Skill Gaps

    Describe apparent ‘skill gaps’.

Current Narrative:

Workforce Analysis

In Rhode Island Innovates: A Competitive Strategy for the Ocean State, the researchers find that Rhode Island “will face near- and longer-term challenges in mobilizing the kinds of technical skills needed to grow its advanced industries”.[1] In the Comprehensive System Improvement Plan, the Governor’s Workforce Board states, “The state’s workforce system is not consistently meeting the needs of businesses and workers- and ultimately all its residents - by not creating the dynamic workforce needed for the 21st Century”.[2]

In order to be successful, particularly to grow the advanced business services industry, it will be critical within the next five years for Rhode Island to ensure that its “underserved populations have access to these growth opportunities.”[3]

Lack of Education Necessary for Employment in the High-Growth Industries

The current working-age population is nationally competitive, but is behind that of the New England educational attainment rate. Rhode Island ranks sixth of six states in New England with regard to percentage of population with a bachelor’s degree and fifth on number of people with a graduate or professional degree. The State has strong job growth in high-skill jobs requiring at least a bachelor’s degree and middle-skill jobs requiring some postsecondary credential/associate’s degree. Analysis by the Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce found that, by 2020, over seven out of ten jobs in Rhode Island will require some form of postsecondary education. Yet Rhode Island, when compared to the national average, has struggled to maintain and grow the educational attainment of its residents. “In sum, Rhode Island’s residents were barely more educated in 2014 than they were in 2009, and actually less educated in terms of the share of the population with only a bachelor’s degree.”[4]. This will create a shortage of labor supply for Rhode Island businesses. This is particularly acute in computer programming and coding jobs, which have seen thousands of openings each year in Rhode Island. The number of occupations requiring STEAM degrees is growing in the state, but Rhode Island produces the lowest or almost lowest number of STEAM degrees among its benchmark states and in the region.

The study by Battelle et al. (2016) also finds that Rhode Island does not have the near-term or future talent pool necessary to fill jobs in technical fields in identified growth areas. Students are not prepared to enter STEAM careers, showing a lack of proficiency in science and math. Students are not being introduced to computer science and coding, which offer pathways to jobs in high-value advanced industries. Only 72 students took the AP computer science exam in 2014-2015, with many students only taking a basic computer literacy class to fulfill the technology graduation requirement.

The Battelle et al. (2016) report uses blunt statistics to illustrate how Rhode Island is divided by racial, ethnic, gender, and income lines in preparing people of color and low-income communities for employment its advanced and opportunity industries:

For Rhode Island’s students of color and those from low-income households, math proficiency challenges are especially acute. Among eighth graders, 41 percent of white students but just 13 percent of Hispanic students, 14 percent of black students, and 15 percent of low-income students scored at proficiency on the math portion of the NAEP in 2015. Among fourth graders, 48 percent of white children were proficient, compared to 18 percent of Hispanic students, 17 percent of black students, and 21 percent of low-income students. These are disturbing numbers for the state’s economic future given that 30 percent of the state’s PK-12 population is Hispanic or black and 46 percent are low income. As Baby Boomers retire it is far from clear that the state’s future workforce will be ready to fill their jobs in critical advanced industries, let alone support sector expansion. (p. 101-102)

Rhode Island will need enough workers to replace the retiring Baby Boomers and fill additional growth in high- and middle-skill jobs. As shown in the economic analysis section and the data presented above, Rhode Island must bring all of its citizens into the new economy in order to succeed.

According to Rhode Island census data Rhode Island’s workforce population is aging at an alarming rate. When it comes to working age citizens, in 2010 Rhode Islander’s aged 15-34 constituted 27.5% of Rhode Island’s population, while people aged 35-64 made up 40.8% of the population. From 2000 to 2010 children age 10-14 declined 10.1%, children 5-9 declined 15.9% and children under 5 declined 10%. In comparison, between 2000 and 2010 the percentage of Rhode Islanders age 55-64 increased 95%.

When analyzing Rhode Island’s workforce it is crucial to pay attention to immigrant population trends. According to the American Immigration Council, almost 1 in 8 Rhode Islanders are “new Americans”, comprised of foreign born residents and their children. In 1990 Rhode Island’s immigrants made up 9.5% of the population as a whole, by 2000 it increased to 11.4% and in 2013 it further increased to 12.9%. Immigrants in the state comprised 15.2% of the workforce population.

The trends of immigration in Rhode Island are represented in overall census demographic data. In 2000 the population of Rhode Island was 1,048,319; in 2010 this increased to 1,052,567- a relatively small change but there is a larger story to be told about this sum. Between 2000 and 2010 white/Caucasian residents declined 3.9 percent, from 891,191 in 2000 to 856,869 while African American and Latino populations increased dramatically. The African American population rose from 46,908 to 60,189- a 28.3% increase. Additionally, Latinos saw an even larger increase than African Americans; the population of Latinos and/or Hispanics in Rhode Island jumped from 90,820 to 130,655- an overall increase of 43.9%. Asian populations also saw a 28.7% increase, while other minorities such as Native Americans (+18% increase) also saw boosts in numbers.


Through the Office of Vocational Rehabilitation services and programs, Rhode Island’s disability population is also a crucial segment of our workforce that will be included in WIOA implementation and the execution of programs. According to the most recent available data from the Census Bureau, there are 63,400 working age Rhode Islanders with disabilities between the ages of 21 and 64. It is critical to distinguish between working age people and those that acquire disabilities due to the aging process. Of those working age citizens with disabilities, 33.9% of people with disabilities aged 18 to 64 are employed in juxtaposition with people who do not have disabilities who employed at a rate of 77.7%. Rhode Island currently ranks 32nd in the nation in terms of jobs for people with disabilities..

The Vocational Rehabilitation Program continues to serve Rhode Islanders with disabilities in increasing numbers. In FFY 2013, the VR Program provided services to over 7,500 individuals with disabilities. Additionally, 2,851 individuals completed applications for services; and 603 individual’s successfully obtained and maintained employment consistent with their abilities, interests and informed choice. In addition to serving increased numbers of individuals with significant disabilities, the VR Program continues to outreach to un-served and underserved populations. In particular, this includes individuals from linguistically and culturally diverse backgrounds; veterans returning from war; and individuals with learning disabilities served through the federal Temporary Aid to Needy Families (TANF) program (in Rhode Island, the Rhode Island Works Program (RIWorks)). The VR Program is strongly focused on outreach and services for youth that are in transition from school to self-sufficiency in adult life through employment, develop advocacy and leadership skills for high school juniors and seniors with disabilities in Rhode Island. ORS is looking to expand services to eligible individuals with disabilities through Innovation and Expansion (I & E) activities.

In addition to the usual employment issues surrounding those with disabilities its important within this plan and in the broader scope of workforce development to breakdown the social stigmas and stereotypes that follow disabled citizens. Individuals with disabilities represent an untapped labor resource that can meet diverse talent needs of our state’s growing job sectors, but unless we change the culture and perception of people with disabilities within said sectors Rhode Island will continue to fail in its effort to include this untapped labor resource. It is important to understand that the barriers to gaining employment are not only physical. Attitudinal barriers can be just as detrimental as physical inaccessibility. The stigmas and misconceptions about Rhode Islanders with disabilities are serious barriers that our workforce system needs to address. The best method to challenge stigmas is to introduce employers to other employers who are already succeeding by hiring individuals with disabilities. The state will achieve this through our sector strategy work in programs such as Real Jobs Rhode Island in conjunction with the Office of Rehabilitation. As industries come together and work to identify best practices for hiring different populations the state will encourage businesses who employ workers with disabilities to share their experiences with their industry partners, we believe this will be the most efficient and effective way to incorporate this population into the work that is already underway for our sector strategy.

The comprehensive system improvement plan created by the Governor’s Workforce Board reinforces the need for preparing and upskilling workers. Projected job growth in Rhode Island through 2022 suggests that 36% of all jobs in the state will require at least some college, and another 30% of jobs will require some type of post-secondary education. However, 42% of Rhode Islanders will not have any type of post-secondary education - and there will only be about 33% of jobs available to workers with only a high school diploma.[5]

Current Unemployment Data, Projected Future Employment, and Labor Market Trends

Rhode Island’s December 2015 unemployment rate dropped to 5.1%, down from 6.8% in December 2014 and from a peak of 11.3% during the Recession in summer 2009.[6] This decrease in the unemployment rate moves Rhode Island closer to the national average, but this is not just due to job gains. Rhode Island’s workforce is shrinking, partly due to retiring Baby Boomers.

A report by the Economic Progress Institute (2015) found that Rhode Island must add 12,700 additional jobs to regain jobs that were lost during the recession and keep up with population growth. The state is close to prerecession levels - 1,600 jobs short - but needs to continue to grow to keep up with projected population growth.[7]

The Economic Progress Institute (2015) breaks down unemployment data by race and ethnicity, painting a different overall picture of the unemployment rate in Rhode Island. In 2014, the average unemployment rate was 7.7%, which was tied for the highest overall unemployment rate in the nation. When the unemployment rate is looked at by demographics that number changes drastically. In 2014, the White unemployment rate was 6.2%, compared to 11.5% for Black workers and 16.2% for Latino workers. The highest White unemployment rate, 9.7% in 2009, was almost lower than the lowest minority unemployment rates. The data shows that Latino workers had a lower unemployment rate than 9.7% prior to 2008.

The report also looks at unemployment data by age. Younger workers, age 16-24, were particularly hard hit with an unemployment rate of 14.9% in 2014. Among the 14.9% who were unemployed, 26% were considered long-term unemployed.

According to the RIDLT Labor Market Information’s 2022 industry Outlook Report Rhode Island employment is expected to increase by more than 51,000 jobs during the 2012-2022 projection period as the state’s economy continues to recover from recessionary losses. Employment in 2022 is projected to reach 545,550 an increase of 51,420 (10.4%) job from the 2012 employment level. Much of this growth is attributed to the increased demand for the products and services provided by the Health Care & Social Assistance; Accommodation & Food Services; Professional, Scientific and Technical Services; Administrative & Waste Services; Construction and Manufacturing sectors. Nationally employment is projected to increase by 10.8 percent. The largest numeric gains will continue to occur in the Health Care & Social Assistance sector. This sector is expected to account for 17 percent of the new job growth expected in the state during the 2012-2022 projection period. Increasing coverage, medical advances along with an aging population will result in an increase of 13,852 (+17.2%) jobs. The Construction sector is projected to grow at the fastest rate (26.6 %) during the 2012 -2022 projection period. Prior to the recession, employment in this sector averaged 22,000 jobs. The projected growth of over 4,000 jobs will bring our construction industry close to its pre-recession levels.

Rhode Island’s Consent Decree

In 2014, the U.S. Department of Justice and the State of Rhode Island entered into an agreement to give 3,250 individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities (IDD) the option of integrated day and employment services. Prior to the agreement, only 12% of individuals were in individualized, integrated employment. In the latest court monitor report, the State has not met its benchmarks for fulfilling the agreement (Moseley, 2015). According to data from A. Anthony Antosh from the Sherlock Center on Disabilities at Rhode Island College, 21.2% of individuals with IDD were in integrated, paid employment in 2015.[8]

The state of RI recently negotiated a Consent Decree (CD) and Interim Settlement Agreement (ISA) with the Department of Justice (DOJ) to ensure that Employment First Principles and practices are utilized in planning and service delivery to adults, in-school youth and out-school youth with significant intellectual disabilities (I/DD) who need access to the continuum of Supported Employment Services in order to work. The DOJ court order requires three state agencies: (1) Office of Rehabilitation Services or ORS, (2) the Rhode Island Department of Education or RIDE and (3) the Behavioral Health, Developmental Disabilities and Hospitals or BHDDH to develop and implement a service delivery system that ensures individuals, adults and youth, with I/DD have access to integrated competitive employment opportunities in order to make fully informed choices about work. The three state agencies are developing Cooperative Agreements, Data Exchange Agreements, and joint Continuous Quality Improvement efforts as elements/requirements of the CD and ISA.

While the consent decree represents one instance of deficiency in providing adequate training and employment opportunities to populations with disabilities, in the future Rhode Island will ensure that this issue is addressed more broadly beyond the consent decree. The state recognizes its short comings with respect to the consent decree and is actively working to address the needs of those with physical, emotional, developmental or other disabilities. The DOJ settlement with the state created an opportunity for Governor Chaffee to proclaim RI as an Employment First state. This proclamation clearly articulated a commitment to all individuals, regardless of type of disability, to have the same access to integrated competitive employment opportunities afforded to non-disabled adults and youths.

The Rhode Island employment rate of individuals with disabilities has improved in recent years; it remains one of the highest in the nation at 9% and is the highest among the New England region. Information obtained from the Disability Employment Policy Resource by Topic in January of 2013; 16-19 year olds with a disability were employed at a rate of 12.7% in comparison to non-disabled youth which were employed at a rate of 24.9%. Additionally, for youth ages 20-24 with a disability the rate of employment was 25.7% compared to non-disabled youth who were employed at a rate of 60.6%.

Workforce Development Activities in Rhode Island

The Comprehensive System Improvement Plan, developed by the Governor’s Workforce Board, included an interactive map of all workforce development activities that shows resource allocation and a geographic distribution of vendors. The map can be viewed here: http://www.gwb.ri.gov/WFDdata.htm. In this report and accompanying map, more than $58.3 million in funding is illustrated. Of those funds, 66% are federal and 34% are state funds. This map also shows that workforce programs in Rhode Island serve a limited amount of people - out of 61 programs, 43% served fewer than 300 people and 23% served fewer than 100.

Expenditures per program vary widely, and do not paint an accurate picture of what it costs to train an individual and place them into meaningful employment. There are 340 unique vendors that receive funding from state agencies whose data was collected. Of those 340, the researchers point out that programs that cost more tend to provide more individualized or intensive services, yielding better long-term results for the individual, and therefore the State.[9]

The researchers suggest that the large number of programs is causing the State to spread its resources too widely, and should fund fewer programs with greater success rates. This could result in the workforce network becoming more cohesive and manageable for all involved, particularly in cases where vendors receive funding from more than one state agency. Increased coordination among agencies and targeted funding to more successful programs could lead to more effective service for job seekers and more growth opportunities for the identified high-growth advanced industry clusters.

However, work is currently underway in Rhode Island to develop sector based strategies to connect employers to the workers they need and addressing the state’s “skills gap”. The industry partnerships of the GWB started many years ago, and have now been integrated into the Real Jobs Rhode Island program. RJRI aims to allow industry partners to be the leaders in their own training programs. In the past, communication between the public and private sectors has not produced programs that have been exactly what businesses need. By creating a “demand driven” program which is led by the businesses and industries the state can help facilitate accurate training programs that exactly match business needs. Partnerships range across many sectors, including the Healthcare industry which employs over 80,000 people in Rhode Island.[10] Giving industry leaders a key role in creating these programs will help the workforce network become more cohesive while facilitating seamless cooperation between agencies.

The same organizing principle that is the foundation of demand-driven workforce development nationally, and Real Jobs RI locally - namely, the idea that employers and industries know better than the government what their needs are; has been extended to the supply-side in Rhode Island through the state-funded Real Pathways RI. Real Pathways is an associate program to Real Jobs RI, and supports partnerships between and among public, private, and nonprofit agencies, education and training providers, and others, that focus on serving populations with traditional barriers to employment (ex. veterans, homeless individuals) or on serving regions of the state with above average concentrations of poverty or unemployment. These partnerships collaborate and strategize how to best serve clients through cooperative or collaborative workforce development programming that is demand-driven, linked to the larger workforce development network, and designed to maximize the opportunities for middle class employment. From a WIOA perspective, these partnerships provide ‘reinforcements’ and enhanced capacity to the system at a time of limited resources.


[1] Battelle Et Al. (2016) P. 97

[2] Rhode Island Governor’s Workforce Board. (2016, January). Comprehensive System Improvement Plan For Workforce Development in Rhode Island.

[3] Battelle Et Al. (2016) Page 68

[4] Battelle Et al. (2016) page 99

[5] Governor’s Workforce Board. (2016). Comprehensive System Improvement Plan. Cranston, RI: Governor’s Workforce Board.

[6] RI Department of Labor and Training. (2016). Rhode Island-Based Jobs Up 1,100 from November; December Unemployment Rate Drops to 5.1 Percent [Press release]. Retrieved from http://www.dlt.ri.gov/News_Releases/NR012116.htm.

[7] Economic Progress Institute. (2015, December). The State of Working Rhode Island 2015: Workers of Color, page 6 figure 6; Providence, RI: Author.

[8] Antosh, Anthony A. (2016). RI Senate Committee on Health and Human Services Briefing on the Consent Decree. Providence, RI.

[9] Governor’s Workforce Board. (2016). Comprehensive System Improvement Plan. Cranston, RI: Governor’s Workforce Board.

[10] Governor’s Workforce Board Rhode Island ( 2014), Biennial Employment & Training Plan

FY2014 and FY2015