Located in:
- II. Strategic Elements
The Unified or Combined State Plan must include a Strategic Planning Elements section that analyzes the State’s current economic environment and identifies the State’s overall vision for its workforce development system. The required elements in this section allow the State to develop data-driven goals for preparing an educated and skilled workforce and to identify successful strategies for aligning workforce development programs. Unless otherwise noted, all Strategic Planning Elements apply to Combined State Plan partner programs included in the plan as well as to core programs.
- a. Economic, Workforce, and Workforce Development Activities Analysis
The Unified or Combined State Plan must include an analysis of the economic conditions, economic development strategies, and labor market in which the State’s workforce system and programs will operate.
- 2. Workforce Development, Education and Training Activities AnalysisThe Unified or Combined State Plan must include an analysis of the workforce development activities, including education and training in the State, to address the education and skill needs of the workforce, as identified in Education and Skill Levels of the Workforce above, and the employment needs of employers, as identified in Employers' Employment Needs above. This must include an analysis of –
- 2. Workforce Development, Education and Training Activities Analysis
- a. Economic, Workforce, and Workforce Development Activities Analysis
II. a. 2. A. The State’s Workforce Development Activities
Provide an analysis of the State’s workforce development activities, including education and training activities of the core programs, Combined State Plan partner programs included in this plan, and required and optional one-stop delivery system partners.*
Current Narrative:
Workforce Development Activities in Rhode Island
Workforce Development Activity, Strength and Weaknesses
One of the state’s biggest workforce strengths is Rhode Island’s commitment to fulfilling WIOA’s foundational purpose of being innovative and creative, while creating meaningful links between all workforce development efforts within the state. On the forefront of these activities, which is pulling in a plethora of workforce organizations, economic organizations, and stakeholders from almost every major industry in the state is Governor Gina Raimondo’s Real Jobs Rhode Island Program. Rhode Island is transforming statewide workforce development into a demand driven strategy that ‘works backwards’ from employer need and aligns with the statewide economic development plan to ensure that demand for talented workers can be met across growing industries. Real Jobs RI serves as the cornerstone program of this transformation. As the state’s new workforce development initiative, Real Jobs RI leverages strategic regional and industry partnerships to train workers and build other workforce solutions on a timeline that keeps up with business need. Flexibility and innovation are defining characteristics of this program. The Department of Labor and Training has awarded 21 planning grants to recipient organizations in 11 industries, as well as 3 regions. Planning Grants represent the first stage of the Real Jobs RI rollout.
Partnerships are a collaboration of businesses within an industry that are brought to a discussion by an intermediary. Real job partnerships must have at least 5 employers and have a designated lead. These partnership can consist of a combination of the following;
|
|
|---|
Planning Grants provided seed funding of up to $25,000 to assemble a strategic partnership within a particular industry or region, identify the specific workforce challenges that employers within that particular industry face, identify the training, education, human resource, and other solutions that are necessary to address these challenges and develop a detailed strategic industry workforce training plan to implement those solutions. The grants were all awarded using funding from a multitude of funding streams that RIDLT braids together in order to meet each partnerships specific needs. The Department pulls in federal grant money, the Governor’s WIOA reserve, and state funding and then dispenses it in a way that allows the most flexibility for the partnerships while simultaneously breaking down unnecessary bureaucratic barriers.
The state has the ability to apply for, manage, and implement multiple workforce based grants. Federal grant dollars allows the Department to bring additional services and resources to diverse priority populations in addition to the core partner programs. The Department currently operates 8 separate grant programs. The programs and their target population are as follows:
| Program | Target Population | Participants Served | Program Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| SCSEP | Unemployed Seniors | 61 | $456,934 |
| JVSG | Veterans | 1621 | $569,021 |
| RESEA | UI Recipients | 8530 | $1,183,687 |
| TAA | Laid off Workers | 227 | $1,730,695 |
| RIWorks (tanf) | TANF Recipients | 792 | $953,279 |
| Rapid Response | Laid off Workers | NA | $968,662 |
| Foreign Labor cert | Migrant Workers | 58 | $88,956 |
| WOTC | At Risk Populations | 4543 | $121,044 |
| DEI | People w/ Disabilities | 242 | $3,455,592.00 |
Program Overviews
Wagner-Peyser: Wagner Peyser is the major funding source for the one-stop system. The WP act of 1933 established a nationwide system of employment offices known as Employment Service. The Employment Service provides employment-related labor exchange services including but not limited to job search assistance, job referral and placement assistance for job seekers, re-employment services to unemployment insurance claimants, and recruitment services to employers with job openings. Services are delivered in one of three modes including self-service, facilitated self-help services and staff-assisted service delivery approaches. Veterans receive priority referral to jobs and training as well as special employment services and assistance. The system provides specialized attention and service to individuals with disabilities, migrant and seasonal farm-workers, ex-offenders, youth, minorities and older workers.
The Federal Trade Act (TAA): Provides special benefits under the Trade Adjustment Assistance (TAA) program to those who were laid off or had hours reduced because their employer was adversely affected by increased imports from other countries. These benefits include paid training for a new job, financial help in making a job search in other areas, or relocation to an area where jobs are more plentiful. Those who qualify may be entitled to weekly TRA after their unemployment compensation is exhausted.
RI Works: This partnership between the RI Department of Labor and Training and the RI Department of Human Services provides intensive employment services to cash assistance beneficiaries under the TANF program. Under RI Works, participants engage in job search as a first and primary activity in their plan. Cash benefit and SNAP recipients must participate in approved job search activities.
Senior Community Services Employment Program (SCSEP): The Senior Community Service Employment Program (SCSEP) is a service and work-based program for low-income individuals aged 55 and older. DLT administers the program which includes recruitment and outreach, eligibility screening, enrollment assessment, Individual Employment Plans, follow-up, work site placement, monitoring and enrollee recertification. Through SCSEP, enrollees are placed at Host Agency sites for up to 30 hours per week and are compensated with wages commensurate with their occupation. Host Agency sites include faith-based organizations, senior centers, community action programs and community-based organizations. These agencies prepare and train participants for future unsubsidized employment. The program is a bridge leading to unsubsidized employment and works to reintegrate participants into the workforce. Eligible SCSEP applicants must reside in Rhode Island, be unemployed at the time of application and be a member of a family with an income not more than 125 percent of federal poverty guidelines. Priority is given to applicants over the age of 60, veterans and spouses of veterans. Preference is given to limited English-speaking, minority applicants.
JVSG: JVSG funds are provided to states to fund two staff positions; Local Veteran Employment Representative (LVER) and Disabled Veteran Outreach Program Specialist (DVOP) which are fully integration in each American Job Center (AJC). Our integration strategy includes a streamline referral process to all partner programs such as WIOA and other combined state plan partners. Furthermore, DVOP specialists provide intensive services and facilitates placements to meet the employment needs of veterans, prioritizing service to special disabled veterans, other disabled veterans, and other categories of veterans in accordance with priorities determined by the Secretary of Labor. DVOP Specialists refer eligible veterans and eligible persons to all partner programs as determined in their comprehensive assessment. Additionally, DVOP Specialist receive referrals from other state partner programs such as; WIOA Title 1B for those eligible veterans and eligible persons who have been determined to have one or more Significant Barriers to Employment (SBE) outline in Veteran Program Letter (VPL) No. 03-14, VPL 03-14 Change 1 &2, VPL No. 04-14 and VPL No. 08-14. In addition, LVER staff must perform only the duties outlined in 38 U.S.C. 4104(5), which are related to outreach to the employer community and facilitation within the state’s employment service delivery system. Therefore, LVERs must be assigned duties that promote to employers, employer associations, and business groups the advantages of hiring veterans. LVERs are also responsible for facilitating employment, training, and placement services furnished to veterans in the State under the applicable State employment service delivery system such as the delivery of training to other state plan partner staff with current employment initiatives and programs for veteran.
Foreign Labor Exchange and Migrant Workers (MSFW): The foreign labor certification process allows employers to hire foreign workers, who are temporarily authorized by the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Service to live and work in the United States on a temporary basis. A qualifying business must demonstrate its inability to fill the position with a qualified citizen at prevailing wages.
Disability Employment Initiative (DEI): This program provides an integrated service system that creates a “One-Stop” entry point for individuals with disabilities to gain entrance to competitive and/or self-employment. This is accomplished by improving coordination and collaboration among employment and training programs implemented at state and local levels, including the “Ticket to Work” program under the SSA that enables disabled individuals to access employment services at an employment network site and other effective community partnerships that leverage public and private resources to better serve individuals with disabilities and improve employment outcomes. The array of services provided to DEI participants include; placement in suitable jobs, job search workshops, counseling, core, intensive, and training services, referral to supportive services, outreach to employers, and outreach to individuals with disabilities by providing services at various locations around the state.
Reemployment and Eligibility Assessment Program (RESEA): The State has conducted the Reemployment Services and Eligibility Assessment (RESEA) program (previously REA) since 2005 and continues to do so. Currently under the program, all UCX claimants and UI claimants deemed most likely to exhaust benefits (based on profiling scores) are directed to report to the One-Stops for mandatory participation in RESEA. The program focuses on providing participants with an overview of and access to the services available at the One-Stop Centers as well as through the state’s Virtual One-Stop (EmployRI), a detailed review of the claimant’s responsibilities while collecting UI, and assistance accessing the resources necessary to lessen the time on unemployment and to return to work as quickly as possible
REXO- Corrections
Through the Office of Rehabilitative Services and Correctional Industries, the Department of Corrections provides a series of educational and training programs to inmates at the Adult Correctional Institution (ACI). Educational and training services include special education, adult education, GED, postsecondary classes and occupational skill development offered through a partnership with the Community College of Rhode Island (CCRI). These classes are funded primarily through state general revenue dollars. Outcomes range from standard ESL and ABE measures such as gains in educational functional levels to credentials such as GED and occupational skill certifications. Many of these programs place an emphasis on work-readiness and soft-skill development in preparation for those transitioning out of prison and into the workforce. DOC and its community partners work hard at developing relationships with employers willing to hire ex-offenders.
RIWORKS
Rhode Island Works is Rhode Island’s cash assistance program. The program provides cash assistance and employment support services to enable parents with children to support their families. Rhode Island Works (RIGL 40-5.2-5) replaced the Family Independence Program in 2008. Rhode Island Works is funded through the federal Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF) program. TANF was enacted in 1996, replacing the nation’s welfare program, Aid to Families with Dependent Children. As of the end of calendar year 2010, Rhode Island Works served 16,185 individuals, with an average monthly cost per person of $188.68, at a total monthly program cost of $3.1 million, all of which is federal funds. As a condition of eligibility, recipients must enter into an employment plan developed in coordination with the Department of Human Services (DHS) and the Department of Labor and Training (DLT). For most parents, the employment plan begins with a four week intensive job readiness and job search program operated by DLT at the One Stop Career centers. Single parents must work or prepare for work an average of 30 hours per week (20 hours if the household includes a child under age six). In two-parent families, one parent must work 35 hours per week; if the family uses a childcare subsidy, both parents must work a total of 55 hours per week. Receipt of cash benefits under Rhode Island Works is subject to time limits. A family can receive assistance for no more than 24 months (whether or not consecutive) in any 60- month period.
The goal of the Rhode Island Works Program (RI Works) is to help very low-income families meet their basic needs by providing cash assistance and work supports, including employment services, SNAP benefits, health insurance, and subsidized child care. Children and families qualify for cash assistance based on their income, resources, and the number of people in their families. RI Works cash assistance recipients must participate in an employment plan unless they meet specific criteria for an exemption. This employment plan must take into account the parent’s skills, education, and family responsibilities as well as local employment opportunities and should outline a process for helping the parent meet his or her employment goals. Parents should be informed about opportunities to seek additional education or training to improve their employability prospects. RI Works provides a safety net for some children whose parents are unable to work due to a disability and can function as an unemployment system for parents who do not have sufficient earnings or work experience to qualify for unemployment benefits. RI Works also provides time-limited supplementary cash assistance to very low-income working families.
In December 2014, the average hourly wage of working parents enrolled in RI Works was $9.81 per hour. RI Works connects families to the Office of Child Support Services, which assists families in establishing paternity (when applicable), identifying and locating non-custodial parents, and obtaining child support payments from non-custodial parents. In Rhode Island, the first $50 of child support paid on time each month on behalf of a child enrolled in RI Works goes to the custodial parent caring for the child. The balance is shared by the state and federal governments as reimbursement for assistance received through RI Works. The maximum monthly RI Works benefit for a family of three is $554 per month. Families receiving the maximum monthly cash benefit have incomes that are less than one-half the federal poverty level and are living in extreme poverty.
Summary
In total, aside from WIOA formula funding for the Dislocated Worker, Adult, and Youth services, WDS has been awarded and manages upwards of $8 million in grant funds. These funds helped to serve 48,126 participants in an array of services for PY15. These grant programs are a crucial complement to the core workforce activities as it allows the state to provide additional services such as familial support and individualized care to at risk populations that other funds do not allow for. Rhode Island is dedicated to leveraging every resource available to bring our workforce towards economic sustainability.
RI Dept. of Education
The Rhode Island Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (RIDE) is responsible for all K-12 education in the state, as well as those programs that serve out of school youth and adults working to improve literacy, numeracy, English language and workforce basic skills or to acquire a GED. The funds presented under this category are those for which the GWB has policy oversight: Carl Perkins Career and Technical Education (CTE) funds and adult education funds under Title II of the Workforce Investment Act. Both of these programs are a part of the Office of Multiple Pathways at RIDE.
The core mission of adult education is to provide adults with the basic academic knowledge and skills they need to participate in civic life and the workforce. Adult education programs serve students who have educational objectives such as learning to speak English; passing the oral and written exams for U.S. citizenship; earning a high school diploma; receiving job training; and obtaining proficiency in reading, writing, and mathematics to succeed in college, careers and community life. Adult education programs in Rhode Island are located in community-based organizations, public school districts, college campuses, libraries, correctional facilities, volunteer literacy organizations and a housing authority. Each of these is uniquely designed to include various combinations of the following components: basic academic skills instruction, work readiness, occupational skills training, structured work exposure activities, work experiences (such as internships or community service assignments), case management, wrap-around support services, and career coaching and job placement. These services may target welfare recipients; homeless adults; prisoners in reentry; unemployed or dislocated workers; incumbent workers in transition to new jobs and advancement in employment; and other eligible persons at all educational functioning levels including the lowest levels of literacy, numeracy, and English-language proficiency. Program offerings also include contextualized classes in specific industry sectors to prepare adults for employment and career pathways.
Collaboration among RIDE, the Governor’s Office and the Governor’s Workforce Board has led to the establishment of key investment priorities in the following outcome areas:
- Provision of comprehensive community-based classroom Adult Basic Education, Adult Secondary Education, and English as a Second Language (English for Speakers of Other Languages);
- Expansion of distance learning;
- Expansion of adult education that is contextualized and supports career pathways for youth and adults in Rhode Island’s critical and emerging industries;
- Integration of adult education and hands-on technical training leading to academic and industry credentials for low-skilled current and former welfare recipients and other unemployed low-skilled adults; · Integration of pre- and post-release adult education services for the incarcerated;
- Expansion of transition to postsecondary education and training/apprenticeship programs that use dual or concurrent enrollment including rigorous Adult Secondary Education for those preparing for postsecondary education based on internationally benchmarked college and career- readiness standards; and
- Support of the Department of Labor and Training Workforce On-Ramps pilot project at the state’s two netWORKri One-Stop Career Centers.
The following measures shows the number of learners who have advanced from one EFL to the next highest EFL, which is two to three grade level equivalents in K-12 system terms. Credentials in adult education include the number of GED and high school equivalent diplomas earned. Additional federal funds come from the DHS Project Opportunity Program, which funds adult education and job preparation service for individuals on Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF).
| Program | Target population | Participants served | Program cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Basic Adult Education | Adult learners | 1273 | $1936551 |
| English Literacy and civis | ESL Learners | 431 | $256603 |
| TANF | Low Income | 458 | $1,000,000 |
| General Revenue Adult Ed | Adult Learners | 1705 | $2,000,000 |
| GWB Job Devleopment | Job Seekers | 2764 | $3,500,000 |
As the eligible state agency and recipient of the Perkins funds, RIDE supports numerous career preparation programs across the state including aquaculture, cosmetology, pre-engineering/robotics, asbestos and lead paint removal, manufacturing, culinary arts, biotechnology, CAD, business/finance, automotive, construction and information technologies, the arts, health careers and more. Federally-mandated secondary student program outcomes include math, reading/language arts and technical skill attainment, and program completion, graduation, and placement in postsecondary education/training, work and/or the military. Postsecondary and adult student program outcomes include technical skill attainment; program retention, industry recognized credential and degree earning (as appropriate); and placement in advanced education/training, work and/or the military. The following technical programs are operated and funded by RIDE.
| Program | Target population | participants served | program cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| On Ramps | Unemployed and Underemployed | 95 | 31,700 |
| CTE Program | Unemployed and Underemployed | 7509 | 2,552,413 |
| Incarcerated programs | Incarcerated Individuals | 69 | 168,452 |
| Adult skills Training | Skills deficient adults | 631 | 300,000 |
| Post Secondary Programs | Skills deficient adults | 1759 | 271,023 |
| Secondary School Concentrators | Skills deficient adults | 10688 | 3,791,348 |
Dept. of Human Services, Executive Office of Health and Human Services
The Executive Office of Health & Human Services (EOHHS) fulfills the crucial function of serving as the Medicaid state agency in Rhode Island. It is also responsible for overseeing and managing publicly-funded health and human services in our state. In this capacity, the EOHHS coordinates the organization, finance and delivery of services and supports provided by the following agencies:
- Department of Behavioral Healthcare, Developmental Disabilities & Hospitals (BHDDH).
- Department of Children, Youth & Families (DCYF);
- Department of Health (HEALTH);
- Department of Human Services (DHS), including its divisions of Elderly Affairs and Veterans Affairs; and Office of Rehabilitative Services (ORS).
BHDDH partners with licensed Behavioral Health Organizations (BHO), which focus on mental health and/or substance abuse disorders, and Developmental Disabilities Organizations to provide supportive employment services to clients. Community based organizations (CBO) network with local businesses to develop relationships and build a referral/job pool. Depending on the needs of the individual, CBOs often provide on-site coaching and job retention services. BHDDH and its partner agencies work closely with the Business Leadership Network to help link individuals with disabilities to employers.
Developmental Disability Organizations (DDO): Individuals eligible for services through the Division of Developmental Disabilities are assessed and authorized a level of services and are able to choose from 34 licensed developmental disability organizations to provide these services or individuals may choose to “Self-Direct” services and hire employees to work directly for them to provide services. Supported Employment Services are included in an array of 24 services, specifically the services include job development, job coaching and job retention, as well as vocational assessments and training
Community Mental Health Center (CMHO) Employment Supports: Activities to support employment for Severely Mentally Ill (SMI) clients of the Community Mental Health Organizations include a variety of client-specific supports to prepare them for work, including coaching their job-search efforts and supporting job retention by helping individuals to overcome the barriers presented by the their illness. Services are delivered either by certified Supported Employment Specialists or by Certified Community Support (CSP) Case Managers. Although specific outcomes are not required as a condition for funding, and access to Supported Employment Services is just one of the variables determining whether CSP clients get and keep employment, the goal of the service is to increase the number of clients in competitive, gainful employment. In FY 14, of 7,024 CSP clients, 633 were gainfully employed.
Cookie Place: The Cookie Place training program is supported by a legislative grant to offer job training in the food service industry for individuals with severe mental illness. Because of their handicaps, many of these individuals have limited ability to find employment, and the program’s goal is to increase the number SMI individuals who are competitively employed. In addition to its job training program, Cookie Place also runs a wholesale bakery, a retail shop and a catering business, but only the training program is supported by this grant. The grant-funded program provides 10 weeks of hands-on training in Cookie Place’s commercial bakery. Kitchen skills, food handling safety, food preparation and menu planning are part of the curriculum, and coaching in job readiness and job application skills and assistance with job placement are also provided
New Leaf: New Leaf is a full-service, non-profit florist shop affiliated with the Providence Center that trains and employs individuals with severe mental illnesses in an integrated commercial business. The program aims to operate a business that trains and employs disabled workers alongside non-disabled workers who help to model acceptable workplace behavior. This kind of work setting is considered highly effective in helping psychiatrically disabled individuals prepare for competitive employment because it provides them with normative social interactions and realistic performance expectations. Disabled workers who have received on-the-job training may seek other competitive employment or remain as longer term employees of New Leaf.
| Program | participants served | program cost |
|---|---|---|
| Community HEalth Org | 95 | 294,125 |
| Behavioral Health Treatment | 7509 | 91,821 |
| Developmental Disabilities | 69 | 1,974,086 |
Dept. of Children, Youth, and Families
The Department of Children, Youth and Families (DCYF) was established by the RI Legislature in 1980 by margining children’s programs previously administered by four different state agencies. The director of DCYF is also a member of the RI Children’s Cabinet, which addresses cross-departmental issues relating to children’s needs and services. Rhode Island is one of a small group of states that integrates the three major public responsibilities for troubled children, youth and families in one agency: Child Welfare, Children’s Behavioral Health and Juvenile Corrections. The funds and activities presented in this report are those dedicated to workforce development for older youth.
The Department of Children, Youth and Families provides a series of educational and training programs to adjudicated youth at the Thomas C. Slater Training School. Educational services include special education, regular education, Adult Basic Education, training and post-secondary classes
Harvest Kitchen Project: The Harvest Kitchen Project is a culinary and job-readiness training program for youth within the Division of Juvenile Corrections both for youth on Probation and for youth at the Thomas C. Slater Training School. The youth will create a line of high-quality preserved foods using ingredients sourced from local farmers at a certified kitchen in Providence.
For youth on Probation: The Harvest Kitchen Project is a 15-week culinary and job-readiness training program followed by the opportunity for a 6 week paid internship in a professional kitchen with one of our partners. Classes for youth on Probation take place in the community at the Harvest Kitchen Training Kitchen located at 542 Pawtucket Ave Pawtucket, RI 02860.
For Youth at the Thomas C. Slater Training School: The Harvest Kitchen Project takes place on Monday evenings, Saturday mornings, and is one of the food stations inside of the facilities weekly Culinary Arts Program. The Harvest Kitchen Project inside of the Thomas C. Slater Training School utilizes the same recipes and procedures used in the community. The program is intended to introduce to youth detained at the Thomas C. Slater Training School to the Harvest Kitchen Project to better prepare them for the application and interview, as well as the training and internship opportunities the Harvest Kitchen has to offer in the community.
Barbering/Cosmetology Program: The RITS contracts with licensed personnel to provide classroom instruction and practicum sessions for residents. Residents begin the 1200 hours of classroom instruction and practicum required by the RI Department of Health while residing at the RITS but also have the opportunity to complete these hours in the community through our contracted instructors.
| Program | Participants served | Program cost |
|---|---|---|
| Adult Basic Education | 57 | 280,000 |
| Barbering, Cosmetology | 22 | 43,000 |
| CCRI Courses | 36 | 8,000 |
| Harvest kitchen | 38 | 21,244 |
| Culinary classes | 41 | 150,000 |
Department of Human Services
The Department of Human Services sponsors a variety of programs and activities with the goal of workforce development. For many DHS customers, the initial goal is to increase education or skills and employability, and then pursue the ultimate goal of gainful employment and financial independence. DHS considers “entered employment” at the time a participant begins work at any job. The following workforce development programs are available to DHS clients.
The REACH program at the Community College of Rhode Island - Customers attend CCRI programs, and are assigned to a coordinator to provide case management and support in order to successfully attain their educational goals. Participants must have a High School Diploma, or a GED and a minimum of 10th grade TABE scores. Outcomes vary based on the educational goals of each individual. At the end of the program, the participants are one step closer to employability than beforehand
SER/South Shore Center/DLT/OnRamps - Customers who receive cash assistance and are ready to look for work are referred to these four programs for assistance with job search and job readiness activities, including work experience, subsidized employment, and on-the-job training opportunities. Through OnRamps, in addition to the services listed, customers receive career coaching and can earn a National Career Readiness Certificate (NCRC+). The desired outcomes for participants in these programs are employment and job retention.
South Shore/Workforce Solutions of Providence-Cranston/Family Resources On-The-Job Training (OJT) - DHS sponsors three OJT programs for TANF recipients, during which they participate in work readiness activities and are then placed as employees into training with employers who are reimbursed for 50% of the participants’ wages. At the end of the training period, most participants are retained by the employers as unsubsidized employees. The desired outcome of OJT is full-time unsubsidized employment.
Project Opportunity - this program provides intensive adult education for customers at or below a fourth grade reading level. The program provides: English as a second language and/or literacy instruction; life skills, cultural adjustment, confidence building, leadership development; work readiness and work exposure activities; computer skills and financial literacy; job skills training modules; and life skills related case management. Participants receive certificates of progress for increased educational levels, computer skills, and financial literacy. The desired outcome of this program is to bring customers up to a level at which they are ready to look for work.
Pre-Certified Vendor Training - Rhode Island Works recipients are able to attend one appropriate training, from the list of pre-certified vendors, paid for by DHS. The types of training programs include CNA, Office Assistant, Auto Services, Bookkeeping and accounting, Building, Custodial, CDL, Computer Skills, Customer Service, Homemaker, Insurance Tech, Medical Billing and Coding, Recycling/Green services, Security, and Teachers’ Assistant training. Desired outcomes are completion or graduation, and ultimately employment and retention.
Youth Success - provides case management services to all pregnant and parenting teens requiring or requesting them. The objectives are to improve academic and other life skills including parenting skills, improve social skills/character development, and reduce repeat pregnancy. Also, Youth Success assists customers with establishing paternity, child support, finding adult-supervised living arrangements if necessary, and opportunities for career exploration, work experience and community service.
| Program | Participants served | Program cost |
|---|---|---|
| CCRI Reach | 2708 | 433534 |
| Job Search On Ramps | 5037 | 3015718 |
| On the job Training | 258 | 575140 |
| priject opporunity | 371 | 1,000,000 |
| Youth Success | 425 | 1,304,436 |
| SNAP E&T | 297 | 423,216 |
| supportive Services | 2694 | 1,222,333 |
The Office of Rehabilitation Services (ORS) consists of three distinct programs: Vocational Rehabilitation (VR) Program, Services for the Blind and Visually Impaired (SBVI), and Disability Determination Services (DDS). ORS has partnerships with the Governor’s Appointed State Rehabilitation Council (SRC), Governor’s Advisory Council for the Blind and Visually Impaired, the Statewide Independent Living Council (SILC) and the RI Council on Assistive Technology (RICAT). The Vocational Rehabilitation Program of ORS assists Rhode Islanders with disabilities to achieve quality employment outcomes and to increase self-sufficiency. ORS has several specialized programs that serve Rhode Islanders with disabilities: Supported Employment, Business Enterprises Program, Adaptive Telephone Equipment Loan (ATEL), Home and Vehicle Modification, Assistive Technology Access Partnership (ATAP) and Transition Services program for youth with disabilities. The Office of Rehabilitation Services (ORS) administers the Title I Federal/State funded Vocational Rehabilitation Program (VR), the Title VI Supported Employment Program, and the statewide
Transition program for youth with disabilities. The Rehabilitation Act of 1973, as amended via WIOA in 2014, authorizes a federal-state vocational rehabilitation program to provide services to eligible individuals with disabilities in order to prepare for and engage in employment. The “Act” requires states to match federal funds at a ratio of 78.7 percent federal to 21.3 percent state dollars. The Vocational Rehabilitation Program (VR) is the federal government’s largest and most successful employment program for individuals with disabilities. The agency assists Rhode Islanders with disabilities to select, prepare for, obtain and maintain competitive employment.
The VR Program has continued on an order of selection, which is a mandated system of prioritization that limits service provision to only individuals with the most significant disabilities. Few other programs offer a holistic approach that advances empowerment, informed choice as well as a full range of services and supports that individuals with disabilities need to fully participate in education, training and employment.
Services/Outcomes - The VR program helps individuals with disabilities to obtain an integrated competitive employment outcome at or above minimum wage. Masters level Vocational Rehabilitation Counselors tailor services to the individualized needs of the person with a disability. Services may include: evaluation and assessment, vocational counseling and guidance, training, assistive technology, job development and placement, including services that support individuals with disabilities to obtain and keep jobs. The objective of the program is to assist individuals with disabilities to become successfully employed in a job that matches the individual’s skills, abilities and interests.
Work Readiness/Job Preparation - VR provides several options for Work Readiness/Job Preparation. Through the general and supported employment components of VR, a 4 week job preparation program is tailored for customers to learn about the demands of employment, interviewing and job retention. In addition, the VR Work Force Development Supervisor conducts interviewing workshops for clients. In FY 2014, 37 participants attended of which 8 or 22% obtained employment. VR funds clients to attend training programs and educational institutions based on the employment goal of the client’s Individualized Plan for Employment (IPE). ORS has been funding and coordinating summer work program for in-school and out of school youth in the community since 2010. Last year ORS funded summer work experiences to 335 students with a range of disabilities
Employer Based skill Assessments (EBSA) - The VR Program partnered with 2 employers to conduct EBSA. These assessments are a unique opportunity for VR to assess an individual’s work skills and behaviors within a business environment. The employer provides feedback to VR and the client about their skills and potential. Some of these assessments have resulted in a job match while others have provided information to justify on-going education/training in the field or in some cases exploration of alternate careers. In addition, the VR Program partnered with 23 employers to provide on-the-job (OJT) training opportunities.
Training Participation - The VR program has a wide array of fee for service training options for clients that include but are not limited to: culinary arts, pet grooming, tractor trailer driver, green recycling, auto repair, pharmacy technician, etc. Client participation in these programs is based on an assessment of the client’s skills, interests and labor market need. As a component of career and employment plan development, clients are encouraged and supported to explore an array of job settings and career options. Such tools as informational interviewing, job shadowing and situational assessments are utilized to provide hands on experiences in different career areas to ensure informed client choice in selecting an occupation.
Interagency Collaboration - VR, Goodwill Industries of Rhode Island and the Department of Human Services (DHS) agreed to provide intensive support services with an expected employment outcome to RIWork’s clients who are also eligible for ORS services. This collaboration provided an array of intensive, coordinated services to assist RIWork clients with disabilities to achieve employment success and self-sufficiency. The Journey to Success Program began in 2013 and in FY 2014 had 17 participants of which 14 became employed.
| Program | Participants served | Program cost |
|---|---|---|
| On the job Training | 23 | 59,292 |
| College Assistance | 217 | 794,153 |
| Short Term Skills Training | 501 | 575,140 |
| Vocational Evaluation | 1009 | 1248331 |
| Job Prep | 46 | 44063 |
| Assessments | 346 | 423,216 |
| Summer Work | 243 | 476473 |
| LEAP | 141 | 166371 |
| Journey to Success | 28 | 101500 |
Workforce Development Weaknesses
The workforce programs and services that have been in place for many years in Rhode Island do not function as a “system,” because the term “system” implies a hierarchy, where one entity has the authority to articulate goals and hold a vast array of actors (government agencies, community partners, and others) accountable for progress toward those goals. To view the disparate workforce programs and services offered in Rhode Island as a system assumes that all involved parties are operating according to a pre-defined set of goals and principles and that they are strategically organized and connected in such a way as to meet those goals and principles. But this is not how workforce programming in Rhode Island operates. Symptoms of this situation can be seen in the following challenges and barriers:
- Workforce development services are highly fragmented in the absence of a single unified and comprehensive vision;
- Multiple state and federal workforce programs each have differing rules, regulations, and limitations and are not always the number one priority of their respective administering agency;
- A widely-held perception is that services are geared toward low to low-medium skilled positions, despite the fact that this is not where employer hiring challenges and, by extension, job opportunities, lie;
- There is a lack of consistent and dynamic marketing to create and maintain awareness among job seekers and employers of workforce development offerings;
- Multiple entry points exist for job seekers and employers that increase the risk of customer confusion and detachment;
- Demand continues to increase for adult basic education and English language training and services;
- There is a lack of robust connections to K-12 and higher education systems.
To address these and other barriers the GWB laid out a series of recommendations that will improve the delivery of workforce development services and maximize efficiencies throughout the state workforce network. Partnerships between Government agencies have key roles within the workforce development network, from developing policy to funding activities. Therefore, it is necessary to ensure the network connections between government agencies are maximized and able to support network solutions involving non-government agencies.
There are two main projects to pursue in the context of improving partnerships between government agencies: strengthening internal structures within agencies to better support interagency collaboration, and creating capacity within agencies to support interagency problem solving as part of daily operations. As agencies improve their internal supports for interagency collaboration, each agency must take steps to ensure the capacity to work with other agencies exists. Networked government allows problems found under specific circumstances to be articulated to key staff within an agency. Each individual agency must create clear procedures for evaluating those problems identified and determining if other agencies must be involved in developing the solution. Clear points of contacts should be developed to provide consistent interagency communication and to provide a clear method for follow up. By improving these partnerships within and between government agencies, Rhode Island will be better positioned to implement interagency projects that get included in the states forthcoming Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act (WIOA) plan and solve problems that are identified by Rhode Island businesses and partners. In addition to this partnership strengthening work, the state will:
• Establish common measures and definitions.
• Establish common information around individuals and service providers.
• Set up mechanisms to improve coordination at the agency level.
• Further strengthen the relationship of the two local workforce areas.
• Establish a mechanism for policy reform based on employer and job-seeker feedback.
• Consolidate planning efforts.
• Improve referral processes between programs.
Connecting employer demand to the supply of available workers in the state is the core challenge of each workforce development program. As demonstrated by persistent hiring challenges across all industries, the direct employer connection to a job seeker is insufficient to meet the workforce needs of employers throughout the economy. Employers rely on other actors in the workforce network to identify, and in some cases train, the individuals needed to fill vacant or new positions. Because no actor in the network can expect to have all the connections necessary to connect employers and jobseekers while ensuring all the needs of each group are met, it is important for each actor to determine what strengths they lend to the network and what purpose they want to serve. Actors then make connections with each other to provide more comprehensive interventions that lead people to employment opportunities.
Networked government allows entities that represent first contacts to build relationships with other entities in an effort to help the individual make subsequent connections. Rather than consolidate programs and try to reduce them to an ordered, sequential set of steps that an individual would follow like a technical manual, entities providing services should partner around common themes to create more effective connections around shared topics. Formal partnerships should emerge from this process and more comprehensive solutions that combine the strength of all engaged entities can be developed. This already has begun to occur through Real Jobs Rhode Island and will continue to expand. While government agencies can help support the convening of these partnerships, this approach requires substantial engagement by all entities within the workforce development and One Stop Job centers.
‘One-Stop Career Centers’ are intended to provide a full range of assistance to job seekers under one roof. With such unrealistic expectations placed upon the One Stop, the staff have been unable to focus on their greatest strength, career counseling, due to the need to attempt to make all network connections themselves. Furthermore, the barriers that some individuals face to becoming unemployed are excessively difficult for One Stop staff to address properly. The ability to provide supportive services for individuals with substance abuse and the homeless can be exhaustive for staff who are not trained to handle extensive mental disabilities and deficiencies. It can become increasingly difficult to properly case manage individuals who do not have the capacity to meet deadlines or are unable to meet with case councilors multiple times. In order for One Stop staff to fully assist the hardest to serve, NetworkRI centers will have to be reimagined under WIOA.
WIOA provides Rhode Island with the opportunity and flexibility to reimagine the role of One-Stops as a network connections facilitator, connecting jobseekers to the services or industry partnership based on the jobseeker’s specific needs and allowing the partnering entities to provide the services and help the individual make subsequent connections. An important part of reimagining the One Stops is retooling Network RI, Rhode Island’s Workforce IT platform and job bank, to produce a system that works to collect the data needed by state and local staff, jobseekers, service providers, and employers to make informed workforce development decisions. One key component will be the management of the WIOA Eligible Training Provider List, which will become a more useable and accurate list to catalogue training opportunities and provide performance data on training providers to the public. Accompanying the development of this web-based repository will be a network wide initiative focused on training career coaches, case managers, and guidance counselors on how to navigate the workforce development network (including the information contained in the training repository), aligning coaching with industry needs, and providing clearer and more refined guidance for job seekers. Career coaching plays a crucial role in all corners of the workforce development network.
The one stop will become a single point of collaboration for many of the WIOA core partners and their programs. The staff at the One Stops will be able to coalesce their efforts to provide training and education opportunities to their customers through rigorous alignment of the core programs. Seamless integration of referrals and intake procedures, coupled with data sharing positions the one stops to provide more services to the hardest to serve individuals of the state. The joint management of education and training participants will reduce duplicative efforts and create a customer work flow that will seem natural and easy to navigate. Co-locating the WIOA core partners along with optional partners like UI, TANF, and ReXO. Sharing infrastructure costs by co-locating will also ease the fiscal burden of each agency to deliver services to Rhode Island communities.
Workforce development funding can is also an area of difficulty for Rhode Island. About two-thirds of the state’s workforce funding comes from federal sources. Each federal funding stream mandates a particular set of services, has different eligibility thresholds and requirements, and places restrictions on how funds can be used. For example, Wagner Peyser mandates the use employment services and cannot be used for skills training while certain WIOA funds must include certain basic services to customers and cannot be used solely for training. In addition, each funding source requires particular outcomes. These outcomes and how they are measured are not consistent across all core partners. This complicates efforts to establish employer- or employee-centered programs that incorporate multiple funding streams while coordinating efforts with other agencies. Additionally, attaching funding to different target populations and determining eligibility can be burdensome on One Stop staff, especially when counselling the hardest to serve populations. Documentation requirements can cause individuals to come in to the job centers more than once, and some may not have documentation at all. In order to determine individuals eligible for training services, customers may need to report back to the one stops multiple times, they may become disinterested in the process and potentially can leave one stops without any meaningful intervention.
Although Rhode Island is a small state, the geographic locations of training services and delivering services to target populations can be challenging. Programs are concentrated in the north-south corridor between Woonsocket and Providence. For example, there are very few offerings in the western and southern regions of the state for adult education or case management, while occupational skills training is more broadly available. It also seems apparent that the same types of services are funded by multiple agencies. For example, the data suggests that adult education, occupational skills training, and work readiness/job search skills all are funded by agencies such as DLT, DHS, ORS, BHDDH, GWB, and RIDE. While there may be specialized programs to assist targeted populations, there could be value in consolidating and streamlining funding to fewer vendors - making the system easier for users to navigate and providing an opportunity to focus resources only on those providers producing the best outcomes. Additionally, many vendors receive funding from more than one state workforce agency. While in and of itself that practice is not problematic, it does suggest an opportunity for agencies to coordinate and collaborate to improve service delivery and potentially benefit from economies of scale.