U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.

Https

Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock () or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Plan: New York PYs 2024-2027
Combined Plan C

Section: WIOA State Plan Common Elements

Narrative: II. a. 1. B.

Published
Some content in this area is under revision.
Located in:
  • II. Strategic Elements

    The Unified or Combined State Plan must include a Strategic Planning Elements section that analyzes the State’s current economic environment and identifies the State’s overall vision for its workforce development system.  The required elements in this section allow the State to develop data-driven goals for preparing an educated and skilled workforce and to identify successful strategies for aligning workforce development programs to support economic growth.  Unless otherwise noted, all Strategic Planning Elements apply to Combined State Plan partner programs included in the plan as well as to core programs. Where requirements identify the term “populations”, these must include individuals with barriers to employment as defined at WIOA Section 3.  This  includes displaced homemakers; low-income individuals; Indians, Alaska Natives, and Native Hawaiians; individuals with disabilities, including youth who are individuals with disabilities; older individuals; ex-offenders; homeless individuals, or homeless children and youths; youth who are in or have aged out of the foster care system; individuals who are English language learners, individuals who have low levels of literacy, and individuals facing substantial cultural barriers; farmworkers (as defined at section 167(i) of WIOA and Training and Employment Guidance Letter No. 35-14); individuals within 2 years of exhausting lifetime eligibility under the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program; single parents (including single pregnant women); and long-term unemployed individuals.  Additional populations include veterans, unemployed workers, and youth, and others that the State may identify.

         

     

II. a. 1. B. Workforce Analysis

The Unified or Combined State Plan must include an analysis of the current workforce in the State and within various state regions. Provide key analytical conclusions in aggregate as well as disaggregated among populations to identify potential disparities in employment and educational attainment and understand labor force conditions for items (i)-(iii) below. Populations analyzed must include individuals with barriers to employment described in the first paragraph of Section II. Analysis must include—

  • i. Employment and Unemployment

    Provide an analysis of current employment and unemployment data, including labor force participation rates, and trends in the State.

  • ii. Labor Market Trends

    Provide an analysis of key labor market trends, including across existing industries and occupations.

  • iii. Education and Skill Levels of the Workforce

    Provide an analysis of the educational and skill levels of the workforce.

Current Narrative:

i. Employment and Unemployment

Between February and April 2020, NYS’s economy lost over 1.92M private sector jobs due to the COVID-19 pandemic. From April 2020 to August 2023, NYS added back nearly 1.84M private sector jobs, or about 96% of jobs lost in March and April 2020. Since reaching a record high unemployment rate of 16.6% in May 2020, the NYS unemployment rate has decreased by 12.7% to 3.9% as of August 2023.

Demographics of the Civilian Labor Force Ages 16+: NYS and Labor Market Regions
 New York StateCapital RegionCentral New YorkFinger LakesHudson ValleyLong Island
Total, 16 years and over:      
Population16,383,427919,050640,563999,8971,912,0742,369,873
Civilian Labor Force10,306,430582,620391,972624,5751,218,5621,551,547
Labor Force Participation Rate62.90%63.40%61.20%62.50%63.70%65.50%
Employed9,663,517553,669369,108593,3911,148,2691,479,114
Unemployed642,91328,95122,86431,18470,29372,433
Unemployment Rate6.20%5.00%5.80%5.00%5.80%4.70%
By gender:      
Male      
Population7,910,852452,121312,079487,750938,1941,157,605
Civilian Labor Force5,312,835299,729201,394320,051637,051822,073
Labor Force Participation Rate67.20%66.30%64.50%65.60%67.90%71.00%
Employed4,963,131284,541189,306302,466598,692782,215
Unemployed349,70415,18812,08817,58538,35939,858
Unemployment Rate6.60%5.10%6.00%5.50%6.00%4.80%
Female      
Population8,472,575466,929328,484512,147973,8801,212,268
Civilian Labor Force4,993,595282,891190,578304,524581,511729,474
Labor Force Participation Rate58.90%60.60%58.00%59.50%59.70%60.20%
Employed4,700,386269,128179,802290,925549,577696,899
Unemployed293,20913,76310,77613,59931,93432,575
Unemployment Rate5.90%4.90%5.70%4.50%5.50%4.50%
By race or ethnicity:      
White, Including Hispanics or Latinos      
Population10,183,073775,901549,562823,4621,324,9801,713,821
Civilian Labor Force6,404,956490,540339,551517,329825,7591,098,899
Labor Force Participation Rate62.90%63.20%61.80%62.80%62.30%64.10%
Employed6,085,658469,333321,922496,169781,6391,051,171
Unemployed319,29821,20717,62921,16044,12047,728
Unemployment Rate5.00%4.30%5.20%4.10%5.30%4.30%
Black or African American, Including Hispanics or Latinos      
Population2,457,62560,88243,88495,573228,814221,165
Civilian Labor Force1,498,06136,85823,61955,657148,160152,940
Labor Force Participation Rate61.00%60.50%53.80%58.20%64.80%69.20%
Employed1,360,11932,96520,70049,754137,670143,287
Unemployed137,9423,8932,9195,90310,4909,653
Unemployment Rate9.20%10.60%12.40%10.60%7.10%6.30%
Asian, Including Hispanics or Latinos      
Population1,434,31534,24316,50626,06289,839164,858
Civilian Labor Force919,64422,9079,33016,68759,576108,526
Labor Force Participation Rate64.10%66.90%56.50%64.00%66.30%65.80%
Employed867,45421,9628,62316,12656,574104,149
Unemployed52,1909457075613,0024,377
Unemployment Rate5.70%4.10%7.60%3.40%5.00%4.00%
Other Race, Including Hispanics or Latinos      
Population2,308,41448,02430,61154,800268,441270,029
Civilian Labor Force1,483,76932,31519,47234,902185,067191,182
Labor Force Participation Rate64.30%67.30%63.60%63.70%68.90%70.80%
Employed1,350,28629,40917,86331,342172,386180,507
Unemployed133,4832,9061,6093,56012,68110,675
Unemployment Rate9.00%9.00%8.30%10.20%6.90%5.60%
Hispanic or Latino      
Population2,948,29541,03222,75263,119357,419397,431
Civilian Labor Force1,888,48027,57413,72539,426247,594283,209
Labor Force Participation Rate64.10%67.20%60.30%62.50%69.30%71.30%
Employed1,731,55025,34012,45435,394230,330269,771
Unemployed156,9302,2341,2714,03217,26413,438
Unemployment Rate8.30%8.10%9.30%10.20%7.00%4.70%

Source: 2017-2021 ACS 5-Year Estimates, Tables B23001, C23002A, C23002B, C23002D, C23002I.

Demographics of the Civilian Labor Force Ages 16+: NYS and Labor Market Regions (Continued)
 Mohawk ValleyNew York CityNorth CountrySouthern TierWestern New York
Total, 16 years and over:     
Population396,8587,105,100346,595533,3981,160,019
Civilian Labor Force230,4114,501,766184,728308,929711,320
Labor Force Participation Rate58.10%63.40%53.30%57.90%61.30%
Employed218,4294,164,373174,346289,591673,227
Unemployed11,982337,39310,38219,33838,093
Unemployment Rate5.20%7.50%5.60%6.30%5.40%
By gender:     
Male     
Population196,8343,357,600181,333264,360562,976
Civilian Labor Force120,0632,289,14196,988161,523364,822
Labor Force Participation Rate61.00%68.20%53.50%61.10%64.80%
Employed113,0662,107,44691,444150,233343,722
Unemployed6,997181,6955,54411,29021,100
Unemployment Rate5.80%7.90%5.70%7.00%5.80%
Female     
Population200,0243,747,500165,262269,038597,043
Civilian Labor Force110,3482,212,62587,740147,406346,498
Labor Force Participation Rate55.20%59.00%53.10%54.80%58.00%
Employed105,3632,056,92782,902139,358329,505
Unemployed4,985155,6984,8388,04816,993
Unemployment Rate4.50%7.00%5.50%5.50%4.90%
By race or ethnicity:     
White, Including Hispanics or Latinos     
Population355,2122,899,527308,932472,280959,396
Civilian Labor Force207,6511,883,137171,623275,972594,495
Labor Force Participation Rate58.50%64.90%55.60%58.40%62.00%
Employed197,4971,779,036162,457259,815566,619
Unemployed10,154104,1019,16616,15727,876
Unemployment Rate4.90%5.50%5.30%5.90%4.70%
Black or African American, Including Hispanics or Latinos     
Population14,4131,650,63814,95518,178109,123
Civilian Labor Force6,516999,6423,2409,11262,317
Labor Force Participation Rate45.20%60.60%21.70%50.10%57.10%
Employed5,927902,9363,0017,73556,144
Unemployed58996,706n/a1,3776,173
Unemployment Rate9.00%9.70%n/a15.10%9.90%
Asian, Including Hispanics or Latinos     
Population8,2131,039,4124,12420,26530,793
Civilian Labor Force5,059666,7402,20010,97717,642
Labor Force Participation Rate61.60%64.10%53.30%54.20%57.30%
Employed4,902625,8622,02010,46416,772
Unemployedn/a40,878n/a513870
Unemployment Raten/a6.10%n/a4.70%4.90%
Other Race, Including Hispanics or Latinos     
Population19,0201,515,52318,58422,67560,707
Civilian Labor Force11,185952,2477,66512,86836,866
Labor Force Participation Rate58.80%62.80%41.20%56.70%60.70%
Employed10,103856,5396,86811,57733,692
Unemployed1,08295,7087971,2913,174
Unemployment Rate9.70%10.10%10.40%10.00%8.60%
Hispanic or Latino     
Population19,4461,965,22013,21817,44151,217
Civilian Labor Force11,4221,220,3984,4499,13831,545
Labor Force Participation Rate58.70%62.10%33.70%52.40%61.60%
Employed10,2281,106,3724,0988,26329,300
Unemployed1,194114,0263518752,245
Unemployment Rate10.50%9.30%7.90%9.60%7.10%

Source: 2017-2021 ACS 5-Year Estimates, Tables B23001, C23002A, C23002B, C23002D, C23002I.

The tables above show demographics of the civilian labor force by labor market region based on 2017-2021 5-year American Community Survey (ACS) estimates. 

Looking at the estimates by gender, the labor force participation rate for males in NYS is 67.2%, compared to 58.9% for females. The labor force participation rate is higher for males throughout all 10 regions of the NYS. The unemployment rate for males in NYS is 6.6%, compared to 5.9% for females.

Across race/ethnicity groups, the White group has the lowest unemployment rate (5.0%), while the Black or African American group has the highest unemployment rate (9.2%). Hispanic or Latinos have an unemployment rate of 8.3%. The Long Island region has the highest labor force participation rate among Black or African American and Hispanic or Latino groups. Note that race groups include those of Hispanic or Latino ethnicity and Hispanics and Latinos may be of any race so these groups may overlap.

ii. Labor Market Trends

Three (3) industries – Private Education and Health Services (+128,900), Leisure and Hospitality (+51,900), and Other Services (+14,200) – are responsible for more than 96% of the private sector job growth in NYS from August 2022 to August 2023. The private sector industry that lost the most jobs over the same period was Trade, Transportation, and Utilities (-28,900).

Of NYS’s ten (10) labor market regions, New York City (+2.9%), Western New York (2.3%), Capital Region (+2.2%) and Central New York (+2.1%) added jobs at a faster pace than both NYS (+1.6%) and the nation (+2.0%) since August 2022. Other regions that saw their private sector jobs grow by at least 1.0% since August 2022 include Hudson Valley (+1.4%), Southern Tier (+1.2%), and Finger Lakes (+1.2%). Over the same period, North Country gained jobs at the slowest pace of all the gaining regions (+0.3%). Long Island (-0.3%) and Mohawk Valley (-0.2%) lost private sector jobs.

In August 2023, the seasonally adjusted unemployment rate was 5.3% in New York City and 3.0% in the balance of NYS. The rate in the balance of NYS region was at a record low of 2.9% from April through July 2023, while New York City’s rate fluctuated between 5.3% and 5.4% throughout 2023. As of August 2023, New York City’s rate remained above its pre-pandemic level (4.3%) while the balance of NYS was below (4.0%). Between August 2022 and August 2023, the not seasonally adjusted unemployment rate in New York City increased from 5.2% to 5.6% and the balance of NYS was unchanged at 3.5% over the same timeframe.

The table below shows the change in unemployment rates by labor market region between August 2022 and August 2023 (not seasonally adjusted). Five (5) regions (Central New York, Finger Lakes, Mohawk Valley, North Country, and Western New York) tied for the biggest drop (-0.2%). Of the remaining five (5) regions, two (2) experienced a slightly smaller drop (Capital Region and Southern Tier), two (2) held constant (Hudson Valley and Long Island), and New York City’s unemployment went up (+0.4%).

Unemployment Rates, NYS, by Region, August 2022 and August 2023 (Not seasonally adjusted)
RegionAugust 2022August 2023Change

(Percentage Points)
Capital     3.23.1-0.1
Central New York  3.73.5-0.2
Finger Lakes    3.73.5-0.2
Hudson Valley    3.43.40.0
Long Island    3.43.40.0
Mohawk Valley    3.93.7-0.2
New York City  5.25.6+0.4
North Country  4.03.8-0.2
Southern Tier    3.73.6-0.1
Western New York    4.03.8-0.2

Source: Local Area Unemployment Statistics (LAUS)

Note: Data are not seasonally adjusted and reflect seasonal hiring patterns.

In addition, the not seasonally adjusted labor force participation rates in both New York City and the balance of NYS regions increased since August 2022. In New York City, the participation rate increased from 60.9% to 62.3%. Outside of New York City, the participation rate increased from 60.4% to 61.6% over the same period. Correspondingly, the size of the labor force is up in both areas (by over 45,300 in New York City and over 111,300 in the balance of NYS).

Businesses in a variety of industries in NYS continue to report some level of difficulty in filling their job openings. Some of the most in-demand titles include Registered Nurses; Retail Salespersons; Software Developers; Sales Representatives, Wholesale and Manufacturing, Except Technical and Scientific Products; Managers, All Other; and First-Line Supervisors of Retail Sales Workers.

iii. Education and Skill Levels of the Workforce

Veteran Status for Population Age 18+: NYS
 VeteranNon-Veteran
Population, Age 18+ (in 1000s)679.414,578.6
Gender  
Male87.7%46.2%
Female12.3%53.8%
Age  
18 to 34 Years10.0%29.4%
35 to 54 Years20.9%32.1%
55 Years and Over69.1%38.5%
Educational Attainment  
Less than High School3.9%9.9%
HS Diploma/GED33.6%27.4%
Some College or associate degree29.8%21.8%
Bachelor's Degree or Higher32.7%40.9%
Race/Ethnicity  
White, not Hispanic or Latino76.5%56.4%
Black, not Hispanic or Latino11.3%13.8%
Asian, not Hispanic or Latino2.2%11.3%
Other, not Hispanic or Latino1.3%1.2%
Hispanic or Latino8.7%17.4%

Source: 2022 Current Population Survey (CPS) Annual Average

Veterans in NYS are much more likely to be over the age of 55 compared to non-veterans.  They are more likely to have a high school diploma/GED or some college or an associate degree than the general population, but less likely to have a bachelor's degree or higher.  

Educational Attainment for Population Age 25+: NYS and Labor Market Regions
AreaPopulation Age 25+

(In 1000s)
Less Than High School DiplomaHigh School Graduate (Includes Equivalency)Some College or Associate DegreeBachelor’s DegreeGraduate or Professional Degree
NYS14,081.112.6%25.2%24.1%21.3%16.8%
     Capital781.17.9%26.2%28.4%20.1%17.3%
     Central NY537.39.2%29.1%30.4%17.4%13.9%
     Finger Lakes  854.39.2%26.8%29.3%19.3%15.4%
     Hudson Valley 1,625.210.3%23.1%24.2%22.1%20.2%
     Long Island2,035.29.0%23.9%24.4%23.3%19.4%
     Mohawk Valley337.810.5%33.2%31.7%13.9%10.8%
     New York City6,191.716.8%23.6%20.0%22.9%16.7%
     North Country 287.710.7%35.2%29.9%13.5%10.7%
     Southern Tier435.38.8%31.9%29.5%15.2%14.6%
     Western NY995.48.4%28.8%30.7%18.0%14.1%

Source: 2017-2021 ACS 5-Year Estimates Table B15002.

The above table presents information on the educational attainment of NYS’s population age 25 and older. 62.2% of NYS’s population (age 25+) have at least some college or an associate degree, including 21.3% who have a bachelor’s degree and another 16.8% who hold a Graduate or Professional (i.e., medical or law) degree.

Looking at NYS’s labor market regions, populations in the Hudson Valley (42.3%) and Long Island (42.7%) have the highest share with at least a bachelor’s degree. In contrast, the North Country (24.2%) and the Mohawk Valley (24.7%) have the smallest share.

Conversely, 16.8% of New York City’s population (age 25 and older) has less than a high school diploma. This reflects, in part, the large share of the New York City’s population that is foreign born. The Capital (7.9%) and Western NY (8.4%) regions have the smallest share of population with less than a high school diploma.

Despite having a highly educated population and a readily available talent pool, many businesses in NYS are still having trouble finding workers with the skills they require. This suggests that LWDBs need to continue working closely with businesses to develop the skills that are in demand.

Around one (1) in eight (8) New Yorkers do not have a high school diploma. Anecdotal accounts suggest that many businesses will not consider a job applicant, even for the lowest-level positions, unless the applicant has a high school degree.

Another barrier facing many workers in NYS, especially those without a high school diploma, is a lack of English proficiency. This can frequently be attributed to the large number of foreign-born residents in NYS. Therefore, it is critical for any workforce development plan to implement a strategy to increase the percentage of potential employees with a high school diploma, as well as provide English as a Second Language (ESL) programs.

School Status of Population Age 16-19 (in 1000s): NYS and Labor Market Regions
    Not Enrolled in SchoolNot Enrolled in SchoolNot Enrolled in School
AreaPopulation Age 16-19Enrolled in SchoolNot Enrolled in SchoolHigh School GraduateNot High School GraduateAge 16-19 Population Not Enrolled in School and Not a High School Graduate (%)
NYS1,004.70890114.781.233.53.30%
 Capital 59.452.17.34.92.54.20%
 Central NY48.643.84.83.21.53.10%
 Finger Lakes66.457.496.12.94.40%
 Hudson Valley133118.914.110.63.52.60%
 Long Island152136.515.511.93.52.30%
 Mohawk Valley26.823.43.42.11.34.90%
 New York City376.6335.441.228.2133.50%
 North Country2520.44.63.21.35.20%
 Southern Tier42.3375.33.81.53.50%
 Western NY74.765.19.67.12.53.30%

Source: 2017-2021 ACS 5-Year Estimates Table B14005.

Among the more than one (1) million NYS youth aged 16-19, about 33,500, or 3.3%, are not enrolled in school and did not graduate from high school. Almost 40% of the youth (38.8%) in this category reside in New York City. As noted in the discussion above, individuals without a high school diploma are at a distinct disadvantage when it comes to finding a job in today’s labor market. The share of this age group not in school and without a high school degree ranges from a high of 5.2% in the North Country to a low of 2.3% on Long Island.

Civilian Population with a Disability (in 1000s): NYS and Labor Market Regions
AreaTotal Civilian PopulationWith a DisabilityNo DisabilityPercent with a Disability
      NYS19,878.02,296.517,581.511.6%
     Capital1,087.2138.4948.812.7%
     Central NY774.2105.8668.313.7%
     Finger Lakes1,201.5169.31,032.214.1%
     Hudson Valley2,348.4250.12,098.210.7%
     Long Island2,894.4261.02,633.39.0%
     Mohawk Valley474.570.0404.414.8%
     New York City8,671.1944.47,726.710.9%
     North Country395.161.7333.415.6%
     Southern Tier632.195.7536.415.1%
     Western NY1,399.6199.91,199.714.3%

Source: 2017-2021 ACS 5-Year Estimates, Table S1810.

The table above presents information on the number and share of the overall civilian population with a disability. Note that demographic information on the skill level of this population is not available. As shown, 11.6% of the overall civilian population has a disability. This means more than two (2) million NYS residents have a disability, with more than 40% of those individuals residing in New York City.

Long Island (9.0%) is the only labor market region in which the disability rate is below 10%. In contrast, there are six (6) regions in which the disability rate exceeds 13%. The regions with the highest disability rates in NYS are the North Country (15.6%); Southern Tier (15.1%); Mohawk Valley (14.8%); Western New York (14.3%); Finger Lakes (14.1%); and Central New York (13.7%).

Share of Population in Poverty and Percent of Households Receiving Public Assistance, NYS and Labor Market Regions
AreaPopulation Below Poverty Level (%)Population Under 18 years Below Poverty Level (%)Households with Cash Public Assistance Income (%)Households with SNAP Benefits in the Past 12 Months (%)
     NYS13.61%18.14%3.89%14.64%
     Capital10.43%13.11%2.53%10.20%
     Central NY13.92%20.68%3.47%14.38%
     Finger Lakes12.51%17.12%3.37%12.93%
     Hudson Valley10.80%15.12%2.51%9.52%
     Long Island5.96%6.73%1.97%5.24%
     Mohawk Valley13.71%18.69%2.91%14.35%
     New York City17.20%23.05%5.37%19.60%
     North Country14.24%19.16%3.56%14.80%
     Southern Tier15.64%19.46%3.30%13.43%
     Western NY14.27%19.95%3.25%15.45%

 Source: 2018-2022 ACS 5-Year Estimates, Tables DP03 and S1701.