Located in:
- Program-Specific Requirements for State Vocational Rehabilitation (Blind)
The Vocational Rehabilitation (VR) Services Portion of the Unified or Combined State Plan must include the following descriptions and estimates, as required by sections 101(a) and 606 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, as amended by title IV of WIOA.
- b. Comprehensive Statewide Needs Assessment (CSNA).
Section 101(a)(15), (17), and (23) of the Rehabilitation Act require VR agencies to provide an assessment of:
- b. Comprehensive Statewide Needs Assessment (CSNA).
b. 1. D. Youth with disabilities, including students with disabilities and their need for pre-employment transition services. Include an assessment of the needs of individuals with disabilities for transition career services and pre-employment transition services, and the extent to which such services are coordinated with transition services provided under IDEA.
Current Narrative:
The U.S Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) defines transition services for children as a coordinated set of activities for a child with a disability that
- • ... is focused on improving the academic and functional achievement of the child with a disability to facilitate the child’s movement from school to post-school activities, including postsecondary education, vocational education, integrated employment (including supported employment), continuing and adult education, adult services, independent living, or community participation.
The legislation goes on to state:
- •Transition services for children with disabilities may be special education, if provided as specially designed instruction, or a related service, if required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education.
There was some evidence that NYSCB staff and their VR providers are currently coordinating NYSCB services with schools (including special education students) and other educational supports for transition-aged students. However, the results of this NYSCB staff survey, in conjunction with the study 3a focus groups (with recipients of braille instruction) and the study 5 survey of past recipients of NYSCB services, revealed there is room for improvement.
While 82% of the NYSCB staff reported they regularly coordinate with colleges and universities, only 47%, or less than half of these staff, reported they regularly coordinate with primary and secondary schools. Similarly, just 45% regularly coordinate with vocational programs for youth, and 32% regularly coordinate with summer youth employment programs (Figure 2.8). This might suggest that more planning and coordination could occur for students while they are still in high school and youth employment settings to improve the transition process to college, vocational education, or adult employment.
Of the staff survey respondents who serve children or students, 46% indicated they obtain the IEP or 504 plan for accommodations (as required under IDEA) usually (38%) or always (8%). Similarly, 46% attend the IEP meetings usually (38%) or always (8%). These questions were asked because these school-based special education plans could provide important data and valuable insights for NYSCB staff when developing VR IPEs and/or recommending school-based IEP services to facilitate the transition out of high school.
Both the NYSCB staff survey respondents and the focus group participants in study 3a noted that many school systems are unaware of the NYSCB and the services it can offer to students who are visually impaired or blind. This is further evidence that additional outreach and coordination with school systems (elementary through high school) is warranted.
Focus group participants for study 3a touched on several other issues related to NYSCB coordination with the K–12 education system as well. They insisted that braille should be taught to all children and at the earliest age possible. They went on to suggest that the NYSCB emphasize this in their outreach and coordination with elementary schools and provide any support necessary for students to achieve proficiency in braille. The focus group participants also spoke at length about the importance of technology and adaptive equipment in achieving success in higher education or within the workforce. They shared numerous examples of their technology needs being addressed after a transition had occurred to college or a new job. This lag was often problematic for the student or employee, and it could be easily rectified with better coordination among systems as young people prepare to transition out of high school.
Study 5 of this needs assessment entailed a survey of past NYSCB participants, and they too touched upon the issue of transitions, specifically the role of coordination between NYSCB staff and school personnel. As summarized in Table 5.3, only 31% of these survey respondents felt they have enough support with school-related activities (i.e., advocating for educational needs, support during IEP meetings, computer training, assistive technology training) by their NYSCB assigned staff, and only 8% of them recalled participating in programs to support their efforts to select a college or career path.
Overall, there appears to be a need for clearer expectations and improved policies and procedures for NYSCB staff addressing regular communication and coordination with primary and secondary school systems. These policies should focus on creating smooth and seamless transitions for youth moving into post-secondary education, vocational education, or supported employment.
Virtual Services
During the COVID-19 pandemic, the NYSCB was forced to operate virtually. As services began to be offered in person again, the survey respondents were asked to reflect on whether anything they had done virtually in the last twelve to fifteen months should continue to be delivered in a virtual format. In response, 63% recommended continuing to offer some services virtually as they transition back to in-person services. There was some disagreement among these respondents about whether VR counseling should be done virtually. A few (3) noted the intake process should be done virtually:
The intake process should still be virtual. This gives time for the counselor to meet with more individuals in a day. Additionally, it works for the participant who may be newly blind and unable to travel. The participant will not have to clean up their house for the visitor.
Others felt it was important to meet in person for the intake process to establish rapport and that only VR counseling after the intake meeting should continue virtually:
VR counseling should continue to be offered virtually after the initial intake. In-person intakes are important in that they allow you to start the counseling relationship. You get more information about the participant (i.e., did they get to the intake on time, how are they dressed, etc.). If done in the participant’s home, you get a feel for the participant’s home environment. After the initial intake, meeting virtually, as needed, would allow the VRC to be more productive in completing other work-related tasks.
A few people commented that all services (except mobility) should be offered virtually if that best meets the needs of a particular participant. And one emphasized the point that offering virtual services is important for participants who are not ready to meet in person due to COVID-19 or other health issues.
- There were several other ideas and opinions mentioned for services that should continue virtually:
- Social work / social case work (7), especially for people living in rural areas.
- Team meetings, case conferences, and case meetings, as this allows participants to attend meetings when traveling is a difficulty.
- Conferences with vendors ... and staff meetings. They are easier to schedule and less time consuming if done remotely, but just as effective.
- Work readiness skills, some pre-vocational services (4), as participants could be part of things without the issue of travel. Some parents are reluctant to allow their children to travel in NYC by themselves.
- Assistive tech training because remote offerings can reach participants who cannot attend in person (for instance, those who live in rural areas, lack of transportation, etc.).
On-the-Job Technology Use and CIS
The survey ended with a series of questions probing staff proficiency and comfort using technology, as well as staff opinions on the state’s VR consumer information system (CIS). The responses are as follows:
- 94% reported they are proficient at using technology at work and in their day-to-day job (i.e., Microsoft Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Zoom, etc.).
- 98% reported they are proficient in using data for providing services to NYSCB participants (i.e., providing case management, making service referrals, and creating service authorization for NYSCB participants).
- 92% find the CIS useful for day-to-day work.
- 80% (46% frequently and 34% sometimes) consult the CIS to help them make case management decisions.
- 45% reported that when they have internet access in the field, using the CIS is more efficient than taking notes on paper.
The NYSCB offered a new training on WIOA changes and initiated several changes to the CIS system in the last three years.
Suggestions
Several individuals offered suggestions for improving CIS:
- Have prior case cycles readily available to refer back to (4).
- Add a feature to indicate a person is not progressing in their VR program
- Add features to allow electronic signatures.
- Add automatic reminders for outstanding authorizations.
- Provide counselors with laptops and improve access to Wi-Fi to enable access to CIS.
- Create ability to easily download forms and generate reports.
- Address accessibility issues.
Two surveys were completed with OCFS/NYSCB participants to gather data for the Needs Assessment of the State Plan that was conducted in 2021, but age data was not collected, and the surveys did not specifically target students. Surveys regarding Pre-ETS services specifically were not conducted but rather overall service delivery and satisfaction. OCFS/NYSCB will be including this as part of the Needs Assessment that will be conducted in 2024. Specific surveys targeting Pre-ETS students and services will be developed, conducted and reported on.