Located in:
- Program-Specific Requirements for State Vocational Rehabilitation (Blind)
The Vocational Rehabilitation (VR) Services Portion of the Unified or Combined State Plan must include the following descriptions and estimates, as required by sections 101(a) and 606 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, as amended by title IV of WIOA.
- b. Comprehensive Statewide Needs Assessment (CSNA).
Section 101(a)(15), (17), and (23) of the Rehabilitation Act require VR agencies to provide an assessment of:
- b. Comprehensive Statewide Needs Assessment (CSNA).
b. 2. Identify the need to establish, develop, or improve community rehabilitation programs within the State.
Current Narrative:
A&O designed a survey to gather perceptions and opinions from NYSCB VR staff across seven district offices. The questions were developed to explore barriers in providing services, efforts to collaborate with other providers of rehabilitation services, and attitudes regarding the level of satisfaction with the Consumer Information System (CIS).
The final survey instrument and protocol designed by A&O was reviewed and approved by NYSCB staff. The NYSCB then provided a contact list of sixty-seven VR staff members as potential survey recipients. The survey was administered electronically using Survey Monkey. After four reminders, fifty-one people responded, for a response rate of 76%.
Survey Respondents
Seventy-three percent (73%) of the fifty-one survey respondents were employed as Vocational Rehabilitation Counselors (VRCs), and 22% were VR supervisors. There were respondents from all three NYSCB regions, with the largest number (17) from the Upstate region, representing the Albany, Syracuse, and Buffalo offices. Seventy percent (70%) of the survey respondents have been employed by the NYSCB in their current title for six or more years. Approximately 20% indicated they were a person with a vison impairment or blindness themselves.
Caseload sizes ranged from fewer than 40 cases to more than 100 cases, with 80% of these staff carrying caseloads over 60. Over a quarter of VRCs carried caseloads on the high end of the range, with caseloads over 100. One counselor noted her caseload was over 320 individuals. The eleven supervisors who responded to this survey also carry caseloads, albeit much smaller, with eight of the eleven (73%) reporting caseloads of 20 or fewer.
Barriers to Success
VR staff were asked to reflect on whether caseloads, paperwork, travel time, VR system procedures, and available training were factors related to success or lack thereof for their participants. Fifty-seven percent cited the time required to complete their paperwork as a barrier for success, while approximately a third of the respondents reported caseload size, travel time, participant availability, and vague or restrictive policies as barriers as well.
VR Services and Providers
The survey asked staff if they believed the range, number, and quality of NYSCB VR services were well-matched with participant needs, and if their participants were equipped with enough information to have significant input in the development of their goals and service plans. Those responses and indicates a fairly high level of agreement that the range of services offered (86%) and the quality of VR service providers (79%) are sufficient to meet the needs of the participants. Most also agreed that their participants are well-informed (79%) and provide valuable input while developing goals and service plans. A relatively high percentage of respondents (51%) disagreed with the statement that the NYSCB has a sufficient number of VR service providers to meet the needs of their participants.
Professional Development
The VR staff were asked what additional training they would benefit from. Over half of these staff requested more training in serving individuals who have cognitive disabilities or are homeless. More than a third of these staff (36% to 43%) also requested further training on populations living in rural areas; those with low literacy or limited English language proficiency; individuals who have dropped out of high school; individuals living in poverty; and immigrant, migrant, and refugee populations.
Adaptive technology and conflict resolution skills led the list of most commonly identified skill related topics, with 58% and 52% respectively. Other topics with significant interest (25% to 40% of respondents) included learning more about NYSCB’s full menu of services, time management strategies, workplace safety for the visually impaired, career counseling, and legislation governing their work (i.e., the American with Disabilities Act).
When offered a chance to list any other populations or topics for additional training not listed as choices in the preceding two questions, the following topics/populations were identified:
- Adults involved in the criminal justice system (3)
- Individuals who are deaf-blind (2)
- Parents who are reluctant to help their children achieve greater independence (1)
- Career exploration/discovery (1)
- Technology (1)
- IEP and school regulations (1)
Collaboration
Collaboration with other service systems is deemed essential for providing high-quality VR counseling services. Therefore, the staff were asked to share who they regularly collaborate with. The vast majority (92%) of staff collaborate regularly with private agencies and community rehabilitation providers. Most (over 75%) also collaborate with medical professionals, higher education staff, and independent living centers. Fewer, but still over 50% of the respondents, collaborate regularly with Department of Labor (DOL) career centers, the NYS Office for People With Developmental Disabilities (OPWDD), and the NYS Education Department ACCESS-VR system.
Two other entities were mentioned by one respondent each when asked who they collaborate with:
- Criminal justice system / parole / probation Employers / human resources Public and private transportation services
In follow-up questions regarding professional collaborations with VR service providers:
- 78% reported there is an effective feedback loop or service update established when they encounter a problem with a vocational rehabilitation service provider.
- 86% reported they have enough time to develop and maintain good working relationships with vocational rehabilitation service providers.
The survey also asked the staff to list any additional resources or services they believe would allow them to better or more fully serve NYSCB VR participants. The following suggestions were shared:
Based on these findings, A&O offers the following recommendations.
1. Ensure that participant voice is emphasized at all levels of the NYSCB to inform service provision. NYSCB participants who participated in focus groups indicated a need to have a more impactful voice in their services, including an expanded ability to secure the services and technologies that align with their goals. NYSCB participants further indicated a desire for formal channels through which they can provided feedback to the NYSCB. Many expressed interest in providing insight, drawing from their lived experience, about how to better support braille utilization. The NYSCB may wish to consider, as a starting point, developing an advisory board on braille, comprised of participants at various levels and stages of braille proficiency and learning.
2. Hire staff and teachers with visual impairments and blindness to ensure representation and to benefit from the perspectives of those with lived experience. Of note, relatively few NYSCB staff members surveyed through the needs assessment indicated that they have a visual impairment or blindness. The NYSCB could benefit greatly from including those with lived experience throughout all levels of the organization. Staff with lived experience can inform service provision by applying a unique mix of professional and personal expertise.
3. Emphasize braille services for NYSCB participants and allocate funding necessary to expand braille services and supports. Research underscores the critical importance of braille for academic and vocational success among those with visual impairment and blindness. The needs assessment findings emphasized a need to recruit and hire TVIs/VRTs with strong braille proficiency. Further, the findings highlight a need for additional instructional time to support braille learning, with the goal of facilitating proficiency. Both teachers and participants noted the importance of prioritizing braille instruction for young children with visual impairment and blindness. Thus, efforts targeting parent/family engagement in teaching braille, as well as further outreach to promote strong partnerships with schools, are warranted.
4. Extend professional development regarding awareness of and proficiency with adaptive technology, and ensure that participants are supported in selecting technology that best suits their needs. Based on feedback from NYSCB staff and participants, the NYSCB may wish to consider providing professional development to its workforce to enhance knowledge of and proficiency with adaptive technologies. Participants indicated a need to better understand the full array of adaptive technologies available to them in order to make informed choices that best meet their academic, vocational, and personal needs.
5. Provide continued support to participants regarding the use of adaptive technology after they obtain employment. Given the learning curve associated with learning and becoming comfortable with adaptive technology, participants stressed a need for further support from the NSYCB following receipt of these devices. Many reported obtaining adaptive technology needed for a new job, but noted that they did not receive training from NYSCB on how to use it, leading some to feel overwhelmed and not positioned for success. Thus, the NYSCB may consider prioritizing training in adaptive technology, along with promoting continued follow-up with participants to assess the need for additional support to maintain vocational success.
6. Explore additional support for those with serious medical issues or multiple disabilities. Consider establishing new outreach efforts and communication protocols with medical providers and education systems to identify individuals more likely to experience barriers to service participation due to medical issues or multiple disabilities.
7. Consider models to reduce barriers to service provision faced by participants in rural areas. Ideas raised by NYSCB staff and participants, TVIs, and VRTs within this needs assessment include:
8. To support participant success, review the assessment and IPE development processes, and consider requiring more frequent contact with counselors. The needs assessment findings underscore the importance of individualized services to meet participant needs. Based on feedback from former participants with unsuccessful case closures and from focus group participants, the NYSCB should explore strategies to improve the assessment process and ensure that each participant has an authentic voice in the process. The VR staff responsibilities and requirements for contact with participants should also be reviewed to assure the frequency and duration allow sufficient time to monitor participant progress and identify emerging needs. This may entail more frequent meetings or check-ins, with participant feedback critical to determining the type of contact that is most helpful (e.g., in-person vs. virtual).
9. Develop mechanisms for participants to provide ongoing feedback on service provision, and develop a continuous quality improvement process to promote accountability. In the interest of reducing the number of unsuccessful case closures and improving service provision, the NYSCB may benefit significantly from developing a process for collecting participant feedback on an ongoing basis. Data may include participant feedback on the assigned counselor, exit surveys as people transition out of the VR system, and/or annual feedback and satisfaction ratings regarding the services and supports received. This information may increase success by ensuring that VR needs are being understood and addressed as well as possible.
10. Create a strategic plan to address the key barriers identified in this needs assessment, and consider extending the methods used in upcoming needs assessments. To create actionable solutions, the NYSCB can use these needs assessment findings to inform a strategic plan with clear goals, objectives, and indicators. In future needs assessments and/or evaluations, the NYSCB might consider applying additional methods to extend the rigor of the quantitative analysis, such as providing a larger dataset (e.g., more years/VR cycles) and considering service duration and dosage within the analysis. Additionally, qualitative study data collected through interviews and focus groups can shed light on aspects of service provision that may be promoting or impeding participant success. Interviews and/or focus groups with a broader array of stakeholders, including NYSCB administrative staff, VRTs and TVIs, and participants, may prove especially useful.
11. Conduct further research on cost outliers. Of note, the analysis found that a significant amount of money is spent on a small number of participants (i.e., outliers). Given the need for additional funding to support hiring TVIs/VRTs and to provide more braille instruction, the NYSCB may wish to more closely analyze the services and needs that are driving significant spending regarding these outliers in order to ensure the best use of available funds.
- Additional vendors, specifically more vendors and rehabilitation professionals in the Upstate area and in rural areas.
- VRC assistants to assist with paperwork.
- Specialists assigned to each NYSCB office including a certified assistive technology specialist, a teacher of the visually impaired (TVI), a vision rehabilitation therapist (VRT) and an orientation and mobility (O&M) specialist.
- More braille instruction.
- More options and access to safe, affordable transportation.
- More services for people who are deaf-blind.
- Services for elderly participants who still want to work.
- An electronic method for participants to sign documents.
- Orientation and mobility providers for children
- Loan closet with sufficient and updated computers, closed-circuit TVs, and assistive software and technology
- Cell phones for counselors with ability to text with participants.
- Community outreach, especially to schools.
- increasing the workforce in rural areas to support smaller caseloads,
- continuing and expanding opportunities for virtual meetings as appropriate,
- increase funding for transportation support.