Located in:
- Unemployment Insurance (UI)
The Jobs for Veterans’ State Grants (JVSG) are mandatory, formula-based staffing grants to (including DC, PR, VI and Guam). The JVSG is funded annually in accordance with a funding formula defined in the statute (38 U.S.C. 4102A (c) (2) (B) and regulation and operates on a fiscal year (not program year) basis, however, performance metrics are collected and reported (VETS-200 Series Reports) quarterly (using four “rolling quarters”) on a Program Year basis (as with the ETA- 9002 Series). Currently, VETS JVSG operates on a five-year (FY 2015-2019), multi-year grant approval cycle modified and funded annually.
In accordance with 38 U.S.C. § 4102A(b)(5) and § 4102A(c), the Assistant Secretary for Veterans' Employment and Training (ASVET) makes grant funds available for use in each State to support Disabled Veterans' Outreach Program (DVOP) specialists and Local Veterans' Employment Representatives (LVER) staff. As a condition to receive funding, 38 U.S.C. § 4102A(c)(2) requires States to submit an application for a grant that contains a State Plan narrative, which includes:
- a. Contents of a Complete Ui Sqsp Package
A complete UI SQSP package includes the following documents, as described in Chapter 1, ETA Handbook 336, 18th Edition:
- a. Contents of a Complete Ui Sqsp Package
a. 3. The State Plan Narrative
The State Plan Narrative is a vital element of the SQSP that provides a vehicle for sharing with the Federal partner State-specific efforts that affect the administration of the UI Program. The State Plan Narrative allows the State to describe in a single narrative: a) State performance in comparison to the Government Performance Review Act goals; b) actions planned to correct deficiencies regarding UI programs, UI program reviews and reporting requirements; and c) results of customer satisfaction surveys (optional).
Current Narrative:
UPDATED 10/30/2018
STATE PLAN NARRATIVE
(Washington - Fiscal Years 2019 and 2020)
Overview
Economic Outlook
The Washington Economic & Revenue Forecast Council’s (ERFC) June 2018 quarterly economic forecast assumes the Washington economy will continue to expand at a good pace. However, major threats to the U.S. and Washington economies remain, including international trade concerns, geopolitical risks and a maturing economic expansion. The forecast calls for growth in employment to be 2.5 percent this year, but is expected to gradually decelerate as the recovery matures. We expect employment growth to average 1.1% per year in 2019 through 2023. Nominal personal income growth this year is expected to be 5.8%, due mainly to stronger growth in the first quarter, and to average 5.1 percent per year. Our new forecast for nominal personal income growth in 2019 through 2023 averages 5.1% per year.
Basic Operations Funding Shortfall
No discussion concerning the state climate and issues affecting the administration of the UI Program would be complete without an acknowledgement that our state does not receive sufficient UI administrative funds to run this complex program in the way that our citizens deserve, commensurate with what employers have paid through their FUTA taxes. The funding mechanism at the national level continues to calculate total funds available at a lower-than-sustainable rate, which sets up continual competition among the states for funding. This “spiral down” system rewards low cost states without regard to quality or the complexity of individual state UI laws.
Following years of reducing staff, investing in technology and working to achieve maximum value from our federal funding, we were disappointed to see this year’s significant reduction in FFY 2019 appropriations. We will continue to perform as best we can within funding limits, but will likely experience significant challenges in such a funding environment.
State priorities and the strategic direction the state has adopted to ensure continuous improvement.
Vision, Mission and Objectives
ESD continues to use Lean strategic planning processes to update its mission statement and set new objectives. Please see the attached Strategy Map for a high-level view of our current objectives.
Vision: The right job for each person, every time.
Mission: We partner to connect employers and job seekers -- supporting transitions to new jobs and empowering careers.
Values:
Serving customers
Strengthening partnerships
Acting with integrity
Empowering people
Anticipating future needs
Achieving goals
Technology Enhancements
Over the last several years, Washington pursued several major technology enhancements as a main strategy to improving and stabilizing our UI program in the face of downsizing and spending reductions. These systems included a new UI tax computer system, a new UI benefits computer system, and a new job-matching and case management system for workforce development staff.
One challenge of undertaking so many enhancements simultaneously was to stretch our staff capacity to its limits. As an example, for our UI benefit system replacement, over a third of our adjudication and intake staff were assigned to the project as business analysts and subject matter experts, or took temporary assignments with the project as system testers. These efforts to ensure the success of the new system directly impacted our ability to complete day-to-day operations and meet acceptable levels of performance. This strategy of embedding line staff in the projects had the additional result of giving those staff new skills and opportunities to move into new career paths, and many did not return to their prior positions. While this is a net positive and reflective of our values, it represents a significant loss of institutional knowledge to the program. That continues to affect every aspect of the program, and contributes to lower-than-acceptable performance levels.
Assessment of past performance and expected future performance. Includes, at state discretion, a discussion of external factors that may have performance implications.
Core Measures and Secretary’s Standards: Washington met or exceeded U.S. Department of Labor Core Measures and Secretary Standards in seven of 20 categories. This is a substantial departure from prior years, and reflects a number of factors including our focus on stabilizing technology implementation, reduced funding and staffing, and loss of institutional knowledge through attrition and retirements. We have also, within the past year, experienced nearly complete turnover of the executive leadership involved in the UI program and supporting divisions within the agency.
We cannot continue to do business in this fashion and expect improvement without significant change. Many of those changes are already in progress, to include rebuilding the human side of our program workflows, new partnerships within and among our units, and a commitment to address problem areas. We also greatly appreciated the technical assistance offered by USDOL staff and the National Association of State Workforce Agencies (NASWA) Integrity Center, and will continue to reach out and request their assistance as we work toward wholesale improvement.
Coordination with other plans.
The Employment Security Department is an integral partner in the WIOA State Plan. We collaborate with state and local agencies that participate in the workforce system and serve UI claimants, job seekers, and businesses. We are increasing our collaboration between UI and workforce divisions within the agency, using our Lean methodologies, to better promote UI benefits as the bridge between jobs, and to assist employers with skilled workers to fit their needs.
Federal emphasis (GPRA goals)
State performance compared to the GPRA goals.
Government Performance and Results Act (GPRA) -- Washington’s results for the year ending 3/31/18 have not met USDOL goals for timely benefit payments, nor prompt establishment of tax accounts.
Make Timely Benefit Payments - Washington 69.87%
Target: 87.5% of intrastate first payments for full weeks of unemployment compensation will be made within 14/21 days from the week ending date of the first compensable week.
Establish Tax Accounts Promptly - Washington 86.5%
Target: 89.0% of status determinations for new employers will be made within 90 days of the end of the first quarter in which liability occurred.
Detect Benefit Overpayments - Washington 129.7%
Target: Overpayments established will be at least 54.5% of the estimated detectable, recoverable overpayments.
Washington’s results for detection of overpayments for the three year period ending 3/31/18 are higher than expected for federal review purposes because of its work search-related overpayments and how they interact with the federal performance formula. Washington does not believe the results indicate a systemic problem with detection of overpayments.
Actions planned to achieve GPRA goals and targets.
National Priorities
Improving State Capacity to Administer and Operate the UI Program Effectively
Washington’s challenges maintaining high-quality programs in our current environment of substantially-reduced resources are well documented throughout this narrative. We are working to stabilize and improve our new technology solutions as we manage with fewer, newer staff. We are working to reduce backlogs in several areas while we lose substantial subject-matter expertise to retirement and attrition. These staff losses continue to jostle work units and create inefficiencies as staff learn their new work. We have proactively worked to introduce and expand the use of Lean methodologies throughout the agency to identify opportunities for improvement, streamline and standardize workflows, and improve performance.
In the past several months, we began work to streamline our program organization, such as recombining the benefits and tax operations under a single division and improving partnerships across policy, performance management and operational divisions as well as across agencies, namely our department and the Office of Administrative Hearings. We also accepted technical assistance offered by the U.S. Department of Labor, the UI Information Technology Support Center (ITSC), and the UI Integrity Center of Excellence. Having fresh eyes examine our organization and provide suggestions and encouragement to line staff is exceptionally helpful.
Improving Prevention, Detection, and Recovery of UI Improper Payments
As noted in our previous SQSP, staffing reductions due to technology investments negatively affected claims quality and timeliness as measured by BTQ reviews. This also put Lean process improvement efforts at UI Claims Centers, which are critical to preventing overpayments, behind schedule. The agency continues to focus its efforts on process improvement, but with an eye toward balancing those efforts with the need to maintain day-to-day excellence in operations. As predicted, it was challenging to meet BTQ standards in this environment. Washington remains committed to national integrity efforts and is developing its Integrity Action Plan with technical assistance from NASWA Integrity Center staff in the coming weeks.
Improving Program Performance Nationally
Washington extensively uses Lean principles and practices as its main business process analysis tool. In many cases, it yielded excellent results, and we are learning by experience where it is successful, and where it is less so. In the past several months we expanded our toolbox to include methods such as Human Centered Design, which shares many basic principles with Lean but provides a different approach. ESD believes tools such as these could be used by any state to help improve system performance.
Additionally, ESD staff are taking active leadership roles in several national groups, including NASWA and its several committees, and participating in several national workgroups. Through these efforts we seek to advocate for best practices across the country, and learn from our colleagues’ different ways we can serve our customers.
Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act (WIOA)
The Employment Security Department is an integral partner in the WIOA State Plan and elected to submit this State Quality Service Plan as part of a WIOA Combined State Plan. Additionally, we are working internally to further integrate our UI Tax, UI Benefits, and Labor Exchange programs to more fully support UI claimants and job-seeking customers throughout their experience. We are accomplishing this through a careful look at the roles and responsibilities of the units within our department, seamless integration of our main customer technology systems in a single web portal and careful integration of UI elements into our WorkSource programs in the one-stop centers.
Reemployment of UI Claimants
ESD works diligently to closely integrate unemployment compensation and workforce services. The agency’s vision of UI benefits as a support bridge between jobs directly aligns with USDOL’s emphasis on claimant reemployment. Agency strategic plan success measures include reduced duration of UI claims and reduced time to find employment. The action plan includes working more successfully to meet employer needs, which will also result in better access to job opportunities for UI claimants and other WorkSource clients.
As reflected in our strategic plan, we are actively searching for additional ways to integrate our unemployment insurance program with labor exchange programs, and increasing visibility of UI in one-stop centers across the state. We have a strong Reemployment Services and Eligibility Assessments (RESEA) program centered in the one-stops, and are pursuing full integration of our new UI benefits and job-matching computer systems in one customer portal in order to provide job-seekers with a seamless experience as they search for employment and collect unemployment benefits.
Improving Data Validation and Federal Reporting
New technology systems across our enterprise have necessitated a fresh look at data validation and its inherent impact on our federal reports. With technical assistance from USDOL staff, we have made progress identifying issues with data validation in our systems, and are working with programmers to address those issues. We have also invested more staff resources in this area, both to bring more talent to bear on the issues and to ensure continuity as key retirements approach.
Addressing Worker Misclassification
ESD’s efforts to address worker misclassification are part of joint efforts to combat the underground economy with the Department of Labor & Industries (L&I) and the Department of Revenue (DOR). Particular emphasis is placed on data sharing between the agencies and other areas where the agencies have partnered to uncover and take action on tax misreporting or fraud.
Staff from these three agencies meet quarterly in a cross-agency referral committee to share information on tax discovery, fraud prevention, new technology and data sharing opportunities, audit data and findings, and unregistered businesses that were involuntarily registered.
On-going efforts of the committee focus on new cross-match scenarios and how to refine existing queries. Members continue to discuss and focus on 1) using technology to the best advantage, 2) data analysis best practices software, and 3) how to refine and share leads. In addition to the work of the committee and the automated exchange of data, staff at all levels in the three agencies continue informal sharing of information on individual cases, special projects, or other items of interest.
Program review deficiencies - Washington has completed program reviews as required.
Program deficiencies
Detection of Overpayments: Three Year Aggregate: ALP 50% - 95%, Washington 106.6%.
Washington’s results for detection of overpayments for the three year period ending 3/31/18 are higher than expected for federal review purposes because of its work search-related overpayments and how they interact with the federal performance formula. Washington has very strong work-search requirements in state law, mandating a progression to an “all weeks” review if the one week review uncovers eligibility or work-search errors. This results in a number of “all weeks” denials due to work-search errors, which create large overpayments.
The Benefit Accuracy Measurement (BAM) Operational Rate, the denominator of the overpayment detection ratio, excludes work search related overpayments. The numerator, overpayments established, includes work search related overpayments. Washington establishes a very high proportion of work search related overpayments in relation to total overpayments. Given the legal structure in Washington regarding work search overpayments, it is mathematically impossible for the state to meet the 95% acceptable level of performance for overpayments established to overpayments detected ratio by virtue of how the ratio is calculated.
Washington is addressing work-search overpayments from a number of angles. We are in the midst of a review of administrative rules regarding work search, with the goal to create opportunities for coaching and corrective action before creating overpayments when errors are minor or inadvertent. We also built better tools in our new UI Benefits system to provide quicker visibility to work-search related errors on claims. These measures, partnered with expanded RESEA encounters and our existing work on cross-matches, should continue to bring the overall measure down toward the ALP. However, we may not ever be within the 50-95% parameter established due to our structural impediments.
There are also concerns that the combination of struggles in the BAM program and issues with Data Validation in certain benefits populations (see CAPs) may be affecting the underlying data to calculate the overpayment detection ratio. Washington will be continuing corrective actions in both these areas during the period, and will consider where there may be hidden effects on the ETA 227 data that require correction. These efforts will be tracked and reported through appropriate CAP milestones.
Lower Authority Appeals
With the launch of our new UI Benefits system in January 2017, claimants were given substantially greater access to file appeals independent of agents via our e-services interface. This led to a significant increase in the number of appeals filed, and placed great demand on existing staff at the claims centers and the Office of Administrative Hearings. Additionally, the new system required different processes and workflows to assemble appeals packages for submittal to OAH. We are continuing to actively collaborate with the Office of Administrative Hearings to improve our joint and individual processes, and are working through the large backlog of cases that exists.
We expect to see improvement in this measure in short order, and will be reporting our progress via the attached CAP.
Reporting deficiencies
Washington submitted its ar227 report late for the periods ending 6/30/2017, 9/30/2017, and 12/31/2017 due to the need to manually correct errors found in the reports as produced by our new UI benefits system. Staff are carefully reviewing the data produced by the system, then making small corrections to ensure the amounts balance across the report. We have also submitted several solution requests to the system programmers to correct the errors, and those are being worked. Until the report can be consistently and correctly produced by the system, we will continue to correct the report manually before submittal.
In addition to technology challenges in our main UI computer systems, the department had unexpected staff turnover in key roles. The department is reviewing all reports required for the various programs, and working to ensure that they are produced correctly and in a timely fashion moving forward. Several of these efforts are documented in change requests to our new UI benefits and tax systems, however, customer-facing corrections are prioritized over back-end operations. We are working diligently to increase the priority of these fixes to more quickly and reliably produce the necessary data for these reports.
Customer service surveys (optional) - not applicable
Other (e.g., approach to maintaining solvency, requests for technical assistance)
Trust Fund Solvency
Over the past 10 years, Washington’s governor and legislature worked together in a bipartisan manner to develop a stable unemployment insurance tax and benefit system to sustain the state through difficult economic times. As a result, Washington’s trust fund remained solvent while 36 other states exhausted their trust funds and were forced to secure loans from the federal government to maintain unemployment insurance benefits.
As of January 1, 2018, Washington’s trust fund was ranked 14th among states, based on Average High Cost Multiple. And Washington’s average unemployment tax rate dropped from 2nd-highest in the nation in 2007 to 23rd-highest in 2017. As of June 30, 2018, Washington had $4.47 billion (approximately 16.8 months of benefits) in the unemployment trust fund.
Assurances:
The State will comply with the following assurances:
Assurance of Equal Opportunity (EO).
Assurance of Administrative Requirements and Allowable Cost Standards.
Assurance of Management Systems, Reporting, and Recordkeeping.
Assurance of Program Quality.
Assurance on Use of Unobligated Funds.
Assurance of Prohibition of Lobbying Costs (29 CFR Part 93).
Drug-Free Workplace (29 CFR Part 98).
Assurance of Contingency Planning.
Provide the most recent dates for the following:
Information Technology (IT) Contingency Plan Implemented: __October 2016__
IT Contingency Plan Reviewed/Updated: ___April 2018___
IT Contingency Plan Tested: __March 2017___
Assurance of Conformity and Compliance.
Assurance of Automated Information Systems Security.
Provide the most recent dates for the following:
Risk Assessment Conducted: __August 2018__
System Security Plan Reviewed/Updated: __August 2018__
Assurance of Confidentiality.